The New York Times 2024-07-20 00:10:23


Middle East Crisis: Global Court Says Israel’s Occupation of Territories Violates International Law

Israel’s occupation has been a subject of U.N. debate for decades.

The International Court of Justice said on Friday that Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem, and its settlements there, violated international law — the most sweeping stance laid out by the world’s highest court on an issue that has been the subject of debates and resolutions at the United Nations for decades.

The court was issuing an advisory opinion that, while not binding, carries authority and legal weight. It is unlikely to affect Israeli policy but could shape international opinion.

“The Israeli settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem and the regime associated with them have been established and are being maintained in violation of international law,” the court’s president, Nawaf Salam, said as he issued the opinion at the Peace Palace in The Hague.

The court also said that Israel’s presence in the territories should come to an end “as rapidly as possible” and that Israel was “under an obligation to provide full reparation for the damage caused by its internationally wrongful acts to all natural or legal persons concerned.”

Friday’s pronouncement received heightened attention because of the war in Gaza, which began more than nine months ago, and because of a separate genocide case brought in the same court by South Africa against Israel in December over its conduct in the war.

In an initial ruling on the genocide case in January, the court ordered Israel to restrain its attacks in Gaza, and in May it ordered the country to immediately halt its military offensive in the city of Rafah, in southern Gaza.

The U.N. General Assembly in 2022 asked the court for its opinion on the legal consequences of Israel’s “prolonged occupation, settlement and annexation” of territories captured in the 1967 Middle East war, including the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel called the decision “mendacious” and said that Israeli settlement in all parts of its land was legal.

“The Jewish people is not an occupier in its land — not in our eternal capital Jerusalem and not in the tracks of our forefathers in Judea and Samaria,” he said, using the Israeli designation for the territories that make up the West Bank.

In his response, Israel’s far-right finance minister, Bezalel Smotrich, posted an Israeli flag emoji on social media and added: “The answer to The Hague — sovereignty now.” The comment reflected the view of many Israeli religious nationalists and settlers that the government should declare the occupied lands part of Israel.

Many Palestinians were likely to welcome the court’s opinion as a vindication and the Palestinian Authority said in a statement that it was a “victory for justice” as it “affirmed that the Israeli occupation is illegal.”

Israel annexed East Jerusalem decades ago, in a move that did not garner widespread international recognition.

The country regards the occupied West Bank as disputed territory and wants the future status of it to be decided in negotiations, but it has allowed hundreds of thousands of Jews to settle there, on land envisioned by Palestinians — and many of Israel’s allies — as part of a future Palestinian state. Critics say the settlements carve the West Bank into a patchwork that make a potential state increasingly untenable, while many settlement advocates oppose Palestinian statehood and support annexation by Israel.

Israel withdrew from Gaza and dismantled its settlements there in 2005 but partly blockaded the territory, along with Egypt, for 17 years after Hamas seized control of it in 2007. Now much of Gaza is once again under Israeli military control.

The international court held hearings in February at the Peace Palace. Israel did not appear at that session but filed a submission rejecting the validity of the proceedings as biased. The Palestinian Authority’s foreign minister, Riyad al-Maliki, told the court that Israel had subjected Palestinians to decades of discrimination, leaving them with the choice of “displacement, subjugation or death.”

Over the course of several days, representatives of more than 50 countries, an unusually high number for the court, addressed the hearings. Most sided with the Palestinian representatives. But a few speakers at the court, including those from the United States, Britain and Hungary — among Israel’s traditional allies — sided with Israel.

A U.S. State Department official argued before the court that Israel’s policies toward the Palestinians were determined by its “very real security needs.”

Two focal points of Friday’s case were Israel’s settlement policy in the West Bank and East Jerusalem as well as the government’s tolerance of violent land grabs by Jewish settlers.

Every Israeli government has allowed some Israeli construction in the territories, but the Netanyahu government has expanded the program and announced plans for thousands of new housing units. More than 500,000 Israelis have settled in the West Bank since 1967.

Israel’s military says it’s investigating why it missed the drone that hit Tel Aviv.

The Iran-backed Houthi militia claimed responsibility for a rare drone attack in central Tel Aviv that crashed into a building near the United States Embassy branch office early Friday, killing at least one person and wounding eight others.

Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, the Israeli military spokesman, told reporters that Israel’s defense systems had apparently picked up the drone but failed to register it as a threat. No air-raid sirens were activated to warn civilians of the attack, despite Israel’s extensive aerial defense system.

“We are investigating why we did not identify it, attack it and intercept it,” Admiral Hagari said.

The Israeli military said the drone had likely flown from Yemen, where the Houthis are based, before approaching Tel Aviv from the coast. Video posted on X and verified by The New York Times shows what appears to be a unmanned aerial vehicle approaching west of Tel Aviv, followed by a blast at the location of the strike.

The two sides offered differing accounts of the type of drone used in the attack.

Nasruddin Amer, a Houthi spokesman, said in an interview that the drone, called Yaffa, had been fully manufactured in Yemen and that it had not previously been used for direct operational purposes. He said the drone bore technologies that made it difficult to detect.

But Admiral Hagari told reporters that the drone was a Samad-3, an Iranian model, that had been adapted for long-distance flight. He denied that it had stealth capabilities that enabled it to evade Israeli surveillance.

Mr. Amer said that the attack was a response to “an escalation in massacres against the Palestinian people in Gaza,” and that the Houthis would halt their assaults only when the war in Gaza ends and Israel’s blockade of the enclave is lifted. He added that Iran was not involved in the decision to carry out the attack on Tel Aviv, but he said the Houthis had updated the Iranians afterward.

Asked whether Israel would respond to Friday’s attack, Admiral Hagari said it would first work to fully assess the situation.

Iran-backed militants across the Middle East have fired masses of rockets and drones at Israel since Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack triggered Israel’s devastating campaign in Gaza. Israel has intercepted most of them, leaving central Israel mostly unscathed in recent months — until Friday, when the explosive-laden drone struck the building just after 3 a.m.

Since November, the Houthis have also been attacking ships along a vital route in the Red Sea in what they have described as a campaign in solidarity with Palestinians in Gaza. Admiral Hagari said that dozens of drones had been launched at Israel from Yemen since the war with Hamas began in October, most of which were intercepted by American or Israeli forces.

Hezbollah, based in Lebanon, has launched thousands of strikes on northern Israel since the start of the war, many of which Israel’s antimissile defenses have thwarted. Israel has also launched thousands of strikes on Lebanon in that period. Over 150,000 people have fled border towns in both countries, with little prospect of returning home.

Ron Huldai, the mayor of Tel Aviv, said the city was on heightened alert.

“The war is still here, and it is hard and painful,” he said on social media, referring to Israel’s war with Hamas in the Gaza Strip.

Matthew Mpoke Bigg and Ronen Bergman contributed reporting.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Residents in the drone strike area describe ‘a crazy reality.’

When a Houthi drone crashed into a building in a residential area of Tel Aviv early Friday, the explosion reverberated through the city blocks, jolting residents out of their sleep, shattering windows and leaving shrapnel scattered on the streets.

The noise woke Yochai Afek, 35, with a start at a little after 3 a.m. He looked out his bedroom window and saw, just yards away, that his car was in flames.

Thinking that maybe an air-conditioning unit had fallen onto it, he and his wife ran out with a fire extinguisher and a hose. They were confused to see so many other onlookers there, too.

“We didn’t understand why the whole neighborhood came out to the streets because of a fallen AC unit,” Mr. Afek said. “But slowly, we began to hear buzz about a drone strike.”

The attack killed at least one person and wounded several others, the authorities said. The body of a 50-year-old man was found in a nearby apartment building as emergency workers combed through the area, Zaki Heller, a spokesman for Israel’s national emergency service, said in a statement. The man was found in his apartment and had shrapnel injuries, according to the Tel Aviv police.

The police described the wounded as “lightly injured.”

By late morning, the glass shards and debris had mostly been cleaned up from the streets.

Holding a roll of tape, Naor Vilner, 32, the manager of a nearby CrossFit studio, was busy taping plastic sheets over its shattered windows.

He recounted hearing a loud explosion from his apartment and tried to go back to sleep. But when he saw a photo sent around in neighborhood WhatsApp groups of a drone’s wing, he determined there had been a strike and went to the studio to inspect the damage.

“Hopefully we’ll be open on Sunday with this behind us,” Mr. Vilner said, “but of course it can’t completely be behind us. It’s a crazy reality.”

Shahar Dubb, 20, a displaced resident from Kiryat Shmona, a town near Israel’s northern border with Lebanon, expressed frustration over people’s reaction to the strike in Tel Aviv.

“I see people in a hubbub, but I ask myself: What’s the uproar?” said Ms. Dubb, who lives with her mother in a cramped hotel room less than a mile from the strike zone. “This happens every day.”

Ms. Dubb’s hometown has been evacuated for nine months and regularly comes under Hezbollah drone and rocket fire.

“People here live in a bubble,” she said of Tel Aviv. “They don’t realize what’s happening in the north.”

Britain says it’s restoring funding to the U.N. agency that aids Palestinians.

Britain said on Friday that it would restore funding to the United Nations agency for Palestinians, a major vote of confidence in the embattled aid group by the country’s new Labour government in its first significant move on the Israel-Gaza conflict.

The British foreign secretary, David Lammy, told Parliament that the agency, UNRWA, had taken steps to make sure that it meets “the highest standards of neutrality,” and he confirmed that Britain would transfer 21 million pounds, or $27 million, to the agency, which processes much of the humanitarian aid flowing into Gaza.

The previous Conservative government had suspended funding after Israel accused a dozen employees of UNRWA of being involved in the Hamas-led attacks that killed about 1,200 Israeli civilians last October. Israel claimed that many other workers at the agency were members of terrorist groups, but has not produced evidence to support those broader charges.

“I was appalled by the allegations that UNRWA staff were involved in the Oct. 7 attacks, but the U.N. took these allegations seriously,” said Mr. Lammy, who was appointed foreign secretary on July 5, a day after the Labour Party’s landslide election victory over the Conservatives.

After an independent review, Mr. Lammy said that Britain had been “reassured” that UNRWA was “strengthening its procedures, including on vetting.”

Britain had joined the United States and a dozen other countries in suspending the funding. But the humanitarian situation in Gaza has become ever more dire, and last week 118 countries publicly declared their support for the agency at the United Nations, with the secretary general, Antonio Guterres, declaring, “There is no alternative to UNRWA.”

Mr. Lammy, who recently returned from a visit to Israel, repeated his demand for an immediate cease-fire and criticized Israel over the shortage of aid entering Gaza. “Israel promised a flood of aid back in April but imposes impossible and unacceptable restrictions,” he said. But his statement captured the political pressures that his government is likely to face regarding the conflict.

He did not signal that Britain would drop the previous government’s objection to arrest warrants sought by the International Criminal Court for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel and for the Israeli defense minister, Yoav Gallant. Mr. Lammy said his government would not act on the matter before the results of the court’s legal review on whether Israel was complying with international human rights law.

That reluctance has drawn criticism from many members of the Labour Party, who want tougher action against Israel. Some Labour politicians were damaged in the election by the party’s cautious approach to the conflict. Jonathan Ashworth, a Labour figure who would probably have been named to a cabinet post, unexpectedly lost his seat to a pro-Palestinian activist.

Mr. Lammy’s support of UNRWA was widely welcomed in Parliament, though one senior Conservative lawmaker voiced opposition. “UNRWA schools have been repeatedly used by terrorists to both store weapons and launch attacks,” said Richard Holden, a former deputy chairman of the party, “and over 100 UNRWA staff have had links to terrorist groups in the region.”

Juliette Touma, an UNRWA spokeswoman, called the decision to resume funding a “very positive and welcome announcement,” adding that the agency “needs every penny as part of its humanitarian response in Gaza.”

She said that UNRWA had no way to verify accusations about the use of its facilities by armed groups but said it had denounced the reports and called for investigations. U.N. investigators are still examining Israel’s accusations that some UNRWA employees participated in the Oct. 7 attacks, she added.

Aaron Boxerman contributed reporting from Jerusalem.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

U.S. Treasury sanctions seek to financially cripple the Yemeni rebels attacking Red Sea shipping.

The United States on Thursday imposed new sanctions on about a dozen people, businesses and vessels that it said were part of a financial network enabling Yemen’s Houthi militia to continue striking ships in the Red Sea, driving a spike in commercial shipping costs.

The Houthis, who are allied with Hamas as part of an Iran-backed network known as the Axis of Resistance, have said the attacks are a show of support for the Palestinian cause in Gaza.

Brian Nelson, under secretary of the Treasury for terrorism and financial intelligence, said in a statement that the new sanctions were intended to undermine the Houthis’ “ability to further destabilize the region and threaten international commerce.”

“Today’s action underscores our focus on disrupting the Houthis’ sprawling network of financial facilitators, shell companies and vessels that enables the primary source of funding for the group’s destabilizing activities,” he said.

The sanctions are being imposed on a far-flung group of individuals and businesses, reflecting the Houthis’ global ties. Among the targeted individuals are a Malaysian and Singaporean national and a Chinese national who the United States said have “facilitated illicit shipments and engaged in money laundering” for the Houthi network.

Commercial shipping companies have been struggling to contend with the effects of the Houthi strikes, which have been rippling across the industry. On Wednesday, the shipping company Maersk said disruptions had extended far beyond the trade routes directly affected by the attacks, which lie between Asia and Europe, with shippers’ forced reroutings leading to congestion, backlogs and delays at ports on alternate routes.

The Houthi attacks have significantly raised shipping costs worldwide. While container costs have not reached pandemic highs, when supply chains were snarled across the globe, the average price to ship a 40-foot container across eight major East-West trade routes has risen more than 285 percent since last year, according to Drewry, a British maritime consultancy that tracks container costs.

The Treasury last month imposed sanctions on Sa’id al-Jamal, identifying him as a Houthi financier based in Iran who directed “a network of front companies and vessels that smuggle Iranian fuel, petroleum products and other commodities to customers throughout the Middle East, Africa and Asia” to fund the Houthis.

On Thursday, the Treasury added sanctions against what it called “seemingly innocuous” companies forming part of the same matrix — including an insurer, an energy trading company and a ship manager, as well as vessels under its management — saying the network continued “to provide tens of millions of dollars in revenue to the Houthis in Yemen.” The designated entities, based in Thailand, Singapore and the United Arab Emirates, operate around the world.

The Houthis on Tuesday released a video that they said showed an attack on a commercial ship in the Red Sea the previous day. The rebel group targeted two vessels on Monday, according to the United States Central Command.

In a post on social media, the Central Command said on Monday that it had destroyed five Houthi drones in the previous 24 hours, citing a rationale repeated across such announcements: that the targets “presented an imminent threat to U.S., coalition forces, and merchant vessels in the region.”

Pressure Builds on Netanyahu as Visit to Washington Nears

World leaders are pushing for a cease-fire agreement. Protesters are taking to the streets across Israel. And families of hostages are pleading with their country’s leader to just make a deal for their release.

The pressures are piling up on Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ahead of his scheduled visit to Washington next week. His speech before a divided Congress figures to be contentious, particularly if he cannot close a deal with Hamas to end the war before he travels.

On Thursday, Mr. Netanyahu visited Israeli troops in Gaza, near the border with Egypt, and told them that continued military pressure on Hamas was “helping us, together with the steadfast insistence on our just demands, to advance the hostages deal.”

Yair Lapid, the leader of Israel’s parliamentary opposition, has called on Mr. Netanyahu to cancel his speech to Congress on July 24 unless he planed to announce an agreement.

“He needs to declare a hostage deal without inventing conditions or raising obstacles every 10 minutes,” Mr. Lapid said on Israeli news radio, alluding to reports that Mr. Netanyahu had complicated the negotiations by adding conditions that Hamas would most likely resist.

Mediators in Qatar and Egypt have been negotiating over a framework for a deal that would stop the fighting and return about 120 people — it is not clear how many are alive — taken hostage in the Oct. 7 Hamas-led attack on Israel, among other terms.

But on Wednesday, Mr. Netanyahu told the Knesset, Israel’s Parliament, that applying more military pressure on Hamas would yield more concessions in negotiations, suggesting that a deal was not imminent.

The Hostages Families Forum, which represents relatives of the abductees, organized rallies at 30 locations across Israel on Wednesday, urging Mr. Netanyahu to close a deal.

“Bring everyone back before you fly off for political tours in other countries,” Ella Ben-Ami, whose father, Ohad Ben-Ami, is a hostage, said at the rally in Tel Aviv, video released by the family group showed.

Mr. Ben-Ami is a dual Israeli and German citizen who was taken from Kibbutz Be’eri on Oct. 7 with his wife, Raz Ben-Ami, who was released as part of a temporary cease-fire deal in November.

“Start here at home,” Ella Ben-Ami said. “Earn your citizens’ trust and make this deal happen.”

Yoav Gallant, Israel’s defense minister, told some families of hostages on Monday that no security considerations stood in the way of an agreement and that it was crucial to “exhaust all efforts” before Mr. Netanyahu’s trip to Washington, according to the Hostages Families Forum. “Afterward, it will be much more difficult and complicated,” Mr. Gallant told the families.

Some in Mr. Netanyahu’s governing coalition have urged him to oppose a deal with Hamas.

On Thursday, one coalition member, Itamar Ben-Gvir, the far-right national security minister, pressed his opposition to a deal during a visit to Jerusalem’s most contested holy site. The hilltop, revered by Muslims as the Aqsa Mosque compound and by Jews as the Temple Mount, has long been a tinderbox for Israeli-Palestinian tensions. Several states, among them France, Turkey and Jordan, which called it “a provocative act.”

Mr. Ben-Gvir said he had gone to the site to pray for the hostages to return home “without a bad deal, without surrender” to Hamas, and called on the government “to add more military pressure” and bar shipments of fuel to Gaza “until victory.”

Mr. Netanyahu’s grip on power relies on the support of two far-right parties, including Mr. Ben-Gvir’s, that oppose any agreement that would leave Hamas in power in Gaza. Critics say this has made him wary of committing to a deal that might lead to the collapse of his government and early elections that polling suggests he would lose.

Others in Mr. Netanyahu’s governing bloc have called on him to resist the political pressures against a cease-fire agreement. The ultra-Orthodox Shas party sent a letter to Mr. Netanyahu on Wednesday telling him “not to fear the voices within the coalition who oppose the deal.”

Some of the most persistent pressure for a cease-fire deal has come from world leaders, health organizations and human rights groups, which have condemned Israel’s prosecution of the war in Gaza. The conflict has killed tens of thousands of people and led to widespread hunger and disease, according to the Gazan health authorities.

At a briefing in Washington on Wednesday, a State Department spokesman, Matthew Miller, told reporters that, given the scale of Palestinian suffering in Gaza, reaching a cease-fire agreement was an “urgent priority.”

Some Democratic lawmakers have said they plan to skip Mr. Netanyahu’s speech in Congress to signal discontent with his government. And the speech has highlighted the divides over Mr. Netanyahu’s leadership at home.

A group of 500 Israeli academics sent the speaker of the House, Mike Johnson, the Louisiana Republican who had invited Mr. Netanyahu, a letter this week asking him to disinvite the prime minister, saying he “has demonstrated his indifference to the ongoing hell endured by the hostages.” And while some relatives of the hostages planned to travel to the United States to protest the address to Congress, others are expected to accompany the prime minister.

Dani Elgarat, whose brother, Itzik, was kidnapped from his home in Kibbutz Nir Oz, urged one rescued hostage, Noa Argamani, not to go forward with her reported plans to join Mr. Netanyahu in Washington. Mr. Elgarat said her presence might undermine the chances of bringing home more hostages.

Mr. Elgarat said he hoped that he and other relatives traveling to the United States to protest Mr. Netanyahu would not find themselves in the “absurd situation” of also being in conflict with a freed hostage accompanying him.

Many countries, including the United States, have argued that any hope for a lasting peace in the region depends on the creation of an independent Palestinian state alongside Israel.

But on Thursday, lawmakers in the Knesset approved a resolution declaring that a Palestinian state would pose an “existential threat” to Israel, embracing Mr. Netanyahu’s position on the issue. The resolution passed with 68 votes in the 120-member body. Benny Gantz, an opposition leader who quit Mr. Netanyahu’s emergency cabinet in June, citing disagreements over the conduct of the war, backed the measure.

Aaron Boxerman contributed reporting.

Is She the Oldest Person in the Amazon?

Jack Nicas and Victor Moriyama hiked 50 miles through the Amazon rainforest to reach remote Marubo villages, where they met Varî Vãti Marubo.

Ler em português

After more than 100 years in the rainforest, Varî Vãti Marubo walks with a stick and, as she always has, barefoot.

So when her Indigenous tribe, the Marubo, gathered for meetings this year in a village that would require a 13-mile hike across streams, fallen logs and dense forest to reach, everyone knew it would be difficult for her to attend.

But, as she has for a century, Varî Vãti dealt with the elements. She caught a ride on the only transportation available: her son’s back.

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.

A Border Crossing Shuttered for Months Traps the Sick and Wounded in Gaza

After months of waiting, Fida Ghanem was granted a permit by Israel and Egypt to leave Gaza for urgent lymphoma treatment in the spring. But the next morning, Israeli forces seized the only border crossing from Gaza to Egypt, in Rafah, as part of a military offensive against Hamas in the area.

Ms. Ghanem, 42, died one month later in early June. The border was still shut.

“She should have been allowed to leave as soon as they found the cancer,” said her husband, Maher Ghanem. “But it was delay after delay.”

For nearly all Gazans, the southern Rafah crossing has been the only way out since the war began nine months ago. But since Israel captured it in early May, it has been closed to all civilians and Israeli, Egyptian and Palestinian officials have been unable to agree on the terms to reopen it.

Aid workers and doctors have warned that the prolonged closure is endangering some of Gaza’s most defenseless, including children with severe burns, cancer patients and people needing heart surgery. More than 10,000 people need immediate medical treatment outside the enclave, according to the World Health Organization.

“The most vulnerable residents of Gaza — its children, sick, and elderly — are paying the highest price,” said Tania Hary, who directs Gisha, an Israeli human rights group that advocates freedom of movement for the more than two million Palestinians in Gaza.

The closure also severed a vital route for humanitarian aid into Gaza, and at least for a time, significantly reduced the quantities going in to a population already struggling with widespread hunger.

The Gaza side of the Rafah crossing had been administered by Hamas since the group took full control of the territory in 2007 and until Israel captured it in May. Egypt, which closely coordinates with Israel on security, often used the crossing to exert pressure on Hamas, including by enforcing a joint blockade of Gaza with Israel for 17 years.

To address the aid disruption after the crossing was shut down, Egypt agreed to divert some trucks ferrying food and medicine into the enclave via a different route, through Kerem Shalom, an Israeli-controlled gateway.

Ordinary Gazans are often forced to pay thousands of dollars to go-betweens to obtain permission to cross the border. Dual nationals, whose exit is arranged by their embassies in Cairo, and the critically ill, who leave in coordination with the Egyptian authorities, generally do not have to pay.

Israel controls all other routes out of Gaza.

The Kerem Shalom crossing connects Gaza only to Israel, but there is a separate border point with Egypt about 25 miles south, outside the Israeli village of Nitzana. Last month, Israel and Egypt allowed about 20 sick and wounded children from Gaza to leave through Kerem Shalom and enter Egypt at Nitzana to test the feasibility of that route.

But thousands more who desperately need treatment are still stuck in Gaza.

Muna Abu Holi, a college professor from central Gaza, said she survived explosions that killed one of her daughters and left two others with deep shrapnel wounds. The surviving daughters, Lama and Malak, need surgery and obtained permits to leave through Rafah on May 7. But they are still waiting to get out.

“We’re grasping for any possible hope,” Ms. Abu Holi said. “Every piece of news we hear, we cling to.”

The United States has pressured Egypt, Israel and the Palestinian Authority, which administers parts of the West Bank and administered Gaza before the Hamas takeover in 2007, to reopen the Rafah crossing.

But Israeli, Egyptian and Palestinian officials cannot agree on how to do that.

Egypt demands a full Israeli withdrawal, according to Egyptian state media. Israel says it will not allow Hamas to control the crossing again, charging that it used Rafah to smuggle arms into Gaza.

In private, Israeli officials have sought to persuade the Palestinian Authority to send employees to informally run the crossing under Israeli security control, according to Palestinian officials and diplomats who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to comment publicly.

The Palestinian Authority rejected the idea, refusing to take over the border unless it was part of a broader push for full Palestinian sovereignty over Gaza — which Israel opposes. Israel similarly approached a mission of European Union border observers who were present at the crossing until 2007, but they refused to work there without the Palestinian Authority, diplomats said.

By late June, photos revealed that much of the Rafah crossing had been destroyed, another obstacle to any speedy reopening.

Israel’s government has mostly rebuffed taking responsibility for the sick and wounded Gazans. This week, Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, shot down a proposal by his defense minister, Yoav Gallant, to build a field hospital for Gazan children along the border with the enclave.

Even before the war, the Israeli-Egyptian blockade of Hamas-ruled Gaza crippled the enclave’s health sector, forcing many to seek treatment in Israel or the West Bank. Basic equipment such as X-ray machines could take years to arrive, if at all, and the toll led some doctors to emigrate.

After the Oct. 7 Hamas-led attack that triggered the war, Israel stopped allowing Gazans to enter for medical care. Gaza’s hospitals were overwhelmed by the mass deaths and wounded, as well as by tens of thousands seeking safety from the Israeli offensive.

Already underequipped doctors struggled to cope amid shortages of medicine and of fuel for hospital generators. And Israeli forces stormed some medical facilities that they said Hamas used for military purposes, including in tunnels underneath some hospitals. Hamas and Gaza health officials denied those claims.

In November, Egypt, in coordination with Israel, began allowing a handful of urgent cases, such as those of children with cancer, to leave through Rafah. Most of the evacuees were ferried to Egyptian hospitals; others were sent to Qatar, the United Arab Emirates or several European countries. A few were treated in the United States.

Early in the war, just 10 sick and wounded Gazans were permitted to leave daily, which expanded to roughly 50 by early May, before the crossing closed, said Dr. Shannon Barkley, a senior World Health Organization official for Gaza and the West Bank who is based in Jerusalem.

But demand has always outstripped those limits.


According to W.H.O. figures, Gaza officials have submitted at least 12,760 requests for people to leave for medical care since the war started. About 46 percent were approved, many after delays of weeks or months.

Both Israeli and Egyptian security agencies vet the lists of those who can leave, according to Dr. Barkley. They rarely approve requests to transfer sick or wounded men aged 19 to 60, according to the W.H.O.

“The medical need is enormous because the health system has been decimated,” Dr. Barkley said.

Mr. Ghanem, a former officer in the Palestinian Authority security forces, said he buried his wife in June without a proper funeral because there was an Israeli offensive in central Gaza. She, too, was a victim of the war, he said.

For one Gaza boy, even an unusual opportunity to circumvent the border closure came too late.

Nabil Kuheil, 5, was diagnosed with acute leukemia in mid-April, with the war in full swing, as his once well-to-do family was living in a camp for displaced Palestinians in Rafah.

“We were living in tents, flies descending in the daytime and mosquitoes at night,” said his mother, Aya Kuheil, 28. “Suddenly, he was covered in bruises that turned first red, then purple. His stomach swelled; they told me there was growth in his spleen and liver.”

On May 6, Nabil’s name appeared on a list of evacuees who could leave the following day alongside a note indicating that his case was urgent. But by the next morning, Israel had launched its offensive in Rafah and seized the crossing.

For weeks, the family waited.

In late May, Ms. Kuheil received surprising news: Israel had approved Nabil for treatment at Augusta Victoria, a Palestinian-run hospital in East Jerusalem — a rare occurrence during this war.

The next morning, feverish and quaking, he was taken in an ambulance to the Kerem Shalom crossing, said his mother, who accompanied him.

Israel never publicized his evacuation, possibly fearing backlash at home. Some Jewish Israelis, including members of the governing coalition, have voiced opposition to humanitarian aid for Gazans.

Nabil “was in severe pain, with a high fever, dirty and covered in blue discolorations,” said Dr. Khadra Salami, the pediatric oncologist who treated him in Jerusalem.

“It was clear that the leukemia had infiltrated all his organs,” she said.

Two days later, Nabil died from a drug-resistant infection he had picked up in Gaza. Dr. Salami said the three-week wait after the closure of Rafah probably cost him his life.

“Every day of the delay mattered,” she said.

Live Updates: Flights and Businesses Are Struggling to Recover After Microsoft Windows Outage

Pinned

Here’s what to know about the outages.

Airlines, health care, banks and scores of other businesses and services began slowly to recover on Friday from severe disruptions caused by a global technology outage. But issues continued to cascade throughout the day, affecting package delivery, hospitals, courthouses and various other sectors in the United States and worldwide.

The outage was attributed to a software update issued by CrowdStrike, a cybersecurity firm whose software is used by myriad industries around the world. The disruption, which reached what some experts called “historic” proportions, was a stunning example of the global economy’s fragile dependence on certain software, and the cascading effect it can have when things go wrong.

A software update issued by CrowdStrike resulted in crashes of machines running the Microsoft Windows operating system. George Kurtz, the company’s chief executive, said it was not a security incident or cyberattack. He said a fix had been sent out, but warned it could take some time to implement.

“We’re deeply sorry for the impact that we’ve caused,” Mr. Kurtz said on NBC’s “Today” show.

Here’s how the spillover effects are being felt all over the world:

  • Flights disrupted: U.S. airlines began restoring service on Friday morning. At least five U.S. airlines — Allegiant Air, American, Delta, Spirit and United — had grounded all flights for a time, according to the Federal Aviation Administration. More than 1,500 flights across the country were canceled on Friday, according to FlightAware. The issues were also being felt at airports around the world, including in Hong Kong, Sydney, Berlin and Amsterdam. In Britain, check-in machines were not working.

  • Basic services: The United Parcel Service and FedEx both reported disruptions, which could effect deliveries in the U.S. and Europe. Customers with TD Bank, one of the biggest banks in the U.S., reported issues accessing their online accounts, and several state and municipal court systems closed for the day because of the outage.

  • Emergency care: The outage crippled health-care systems across the globe, leading hospitals to cancel noncritical surgeries and complicating emergency response systems in the U.S., where 911 lines were down in multiple states, the U.S. Emergency Alert System said on social media. Most if not all of the 911 problems appeared to be resolving themselves by midmorning.

  • Federal response: President Biden had been briefed on the CrowdStrike outage, White House officials said. Administration officials were “in touch with CrowdStrike and impacted entities” and “engaged across the interagency to get sector by sector updates.”

  • Largely unaffected: Some basic services, including major grocery store chains and public transit systems, appeared largely unaffected by the outages, at least in the U.S. Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud, the other major cloud-computing platforms besides Microsoft Azure, said that by and large, their services were operating normally.

Airlines began the day by saying they didn’t owe stranded passengers anything more than rebooked flights with waived fees. But the Transportation Department said that the software outage is considered within the airlines’ control. This means they must follow through on their commitments to travelers, which fluctuate but could include paying for hotel rooms, ground transportation and meal vouchers.

The outage led to a very busy 16 minutes for the San Francisco Fire Department. Between 2:34 and 2:50 a.m., forefighters responded to 20 fire alarms in buildings around the city. The alarms were all false and all apparently caused by the outage, a fire department spokesperson said.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

TD Bank, the 10th largest in the U.S., confirmed it had been impacted by the outage. The bank’s customers have filled social media with complaints that they cannot access their online accounts. “Teams are working hard to restore all online banking and other impacted systems,” a spokeswoman said in a statement.

Court systems across the country are temporarily closing their doors to the public due to the outage. In Philadelphia, city courts and the First Judicial District were closed while the entire Maryland Judiciary system announced it would only be open for “emergency matters.”

The Oregon Department of Emergency Management has received reports of major impacts on some of the state’s 911 centers, hospitals, airports, and public safety and emergency management agencies, said Erin Zysett, a spokeswoman for the department. “Our IT teams are working very fast to apply the fixes that CrowdStrike has provided, and those impacts are being mitigated quickly,” she said, adding that statewide alert systems and public safety incident tracking systems have been mostly unaffected.

“This is historic – we haven’t had an incident like this,” said Mikko Hypponen, a security expert and chief research officer at WithSecure, a cybersecurity company. Cybersecurity software like CrowdStrike’s tools operate quietly in the background to defend computers against attacks and affect their basic operations. They are also frequently updated with new defenses as hackers develop fresh methods of attack.

“The normal software that you run on your Windows computer, at the worst it can crash itself, but security software can crash the whole system,” Mr. Hypponen said. “This is made worse by the fact that no other software updates as frequently because of the frequent attacks.”

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

The world’s biggest logistics companies are reporting disruptions, which could mean delivery delays in some regions. A spokesman for United Parcel Service said the company’s computer systems in the United States and Europe have been affected by the outage, and customers might experience service delays as a result. FedEx said it has put in place contingency plans to mitigate impacts from the outage and is working “​​diligently” to reduce service disruptions.

It’s not just 75 flights that have been cancelled at San Francisco International Airport. Mayor London Breed and Representative Nancy Pelosi were due this morning in Terminal 3 for a groundbreaking event signifying the start of a $2.6 billion modernization project including seismic retrofitting and an expanded security checkpoint. That, too, has been grounded as the airport works to recover from the overnight meltdown.

Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud, the other major cloud-computing platforms besides Microsoft Azure, said that by and large, their services were operating normally after the outage. It affected a subset of their corporate customers, who use their clouds to access Windows virtual machines — digital versions of a physical computer used to run applications. Amazon said there were three paths to recovery, including relaunching the service.

The Federal Aviation Administration said in a statement that it was continuing to work closely with airlines as they work to resume normal operations. “Ground stops and delays will be intermittent at various airports as the airlines work through residual technology issues.”

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Janno Lieber, the head of New York City’s transit system, said there was no impact to subway and bus service, though some customer-facing services were down, including countdown clocks on the lettered train lines and information about arrival times. “New York City’s public transit is going full speed,” he said.

Mayor Eric Adams of New York City held a news conference at City Hall to make clear that the tech outage was not a cyber attack. He said that there were no impacts to critical services, and that the 911 call system, traffic signals and water systems were all fine.

President Biden has been briefed on the CrowdStrike outage, according to the White House. Administration officials are “in touch with CrowdStrike and impacted entities. His team is engaged across the interagency to get sector by sector updates throughout the day and is standing by to provide assistance as needed.”

In California, “all 911, public safety communications and critical infrastructure is functioning as expected,” said Chris Dargan, a spokesman for the California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services. Mr. Dargan said the office was looking into initial reports of minor state system outages.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Microsoft said that its customers should follow instructions from CrowdStrike to fix the outage. “We are aware of a scenario in which customers experience issues with their machines causing a bug check (blue screen) due to a recent CrowdStrike update. We recommend customers to follow guidance provided by CrowdStrike,” a Microsoft spokesperson said.

A White House official said President Biden had been briefed on the outage. The White House team is working with government agencies to get updates from different industries during the day, the official said.

The outage hit as many of the U.S. government’s top cybersecurity officials are mingling with the industry’s chiefs at the Aspen Security Forum, a weeklong conference in Colorado. Anne Neuberger, the deputy national security advisor, and Jake Sullivan, the assistant to the president on national security affairs, are both scheduled to speak today.

I had plans on Friday to fly on American Airlines from Albany, N.Y., to Ft Lauderdale, Fla., through Charlotte, N.C., but awoke to find a major change of plans: The flight from Albany to Charlotte had been rescheduled, and the connection to Ft. Lauderdale was gone. The airline rebooked me on a route from Albany to Charlotte, then to Raleigh-Durham, then to a new final destination: Miami.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

This news is bad timing for tech stocks, which have driven the broader stock market higher this year, most notably among companies tied to artificial intelligence. Microsoft, one of the beneficiaries of A.I. enthusiasm, is down more than 1 percent so far this morning.

It’s not a huge move, but the size of the company means it could still have a big impact on the market today, and it comes after it had already dropped nearly 6 percent from its high earlier this month. CrowdStrike had also already fallen more than 12 percent this month prior to today’s news.

CrowdStrike’s stock price plummeted in early morning trading, falling roughly 12.5 percent and putting it on course for its worst day since November 2022. Despite the widespread impact of the outage, it has yet to contaminate the broader stock market, with futures on the S&P 500, which allow investors to bet on the market before the official start of trading, up 0.1 percent.

Patients at the Perlmutter Cancer Center in Midtown Manhattan experienced long wait times as they arrived for treatment. Joan Jubett, a patient, said patients began to wonder if their treatments would be pushed to Monday. In a statement on Friday, a spokesperson for NYU Langone, which operates the center, said that all the system’s facilities were open and “patient care remains our top priority.”

Ms. Jubbett reported that by 9 a.m., the system appeared to be back up and running and patients were being admitted.

Some banks were hit by the outage.

Financial transactions around the world were affected by a tech outage on Friday, hampering operations as workers at several firms struggled to log into their corporate systems.

Employees at companies including JPMorgan Chase and Instinet, a brokerage firm owned by the Japanese bank Nomura, have had trouble gaining access to their work stations, according to people with knowledge of the matter who spoke on condition of anonymity.

That has led to delays in some trades, though the companies have been working on workarounds, the people said.

The London Stock Exchange said that its RNS corporate news service was unable to publish, citing a “third-party global technical issue” that it was investigating. The exchange operator added that the matter was not affecting securities trading and other services.

Norway’s central bank said that it had suffered disruptions when conducting a securities auction on Friday, with participants having been asked to submit bids by phone or email. It later said that the system was operating normally.

Other central banks, including the Bank of England and the European Central Bank, said they were not experiencing any technical issues.

A representative for Nasdaq said in a statement that the exchange operator’s European and American pre-market trading businesses were working, and that its U.S. market would open for business as normal.

And a representative for the New York Stock Exchange said that its market was fully operational and expected to open normally.

Eshe Nelson contributed reporting from London, and Claire Fahy from New York.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

George Kurtz, the chief executive of CrowdStrike, said the company took responsibility for the software bug that caused the outage. He said a fix had been sent out, but warned it could take some time to implement. “We’re deeply sorry for the impact that we’ve caused,” Mr. Kurtz said on NBC’s “Today” show.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

The global outage has led to long lines and delays at airports around the world.

Long lines formed at airports from Hong Kong to Amsterdam to Baltimore on Friday, as a global technology outage disrupted services, including check-in, boarding and baggage software, causing delays and frustration.

At Taiwan’s largest airport, Taoyuan International, and Hong Kong International Airport officials were manually checking in passengers, and in India, some handwritten boarding passes were issued.

About a quarter of the flights departing from Amsterdam Airport Schiphol were delayed, according to FlightAware, a flight tracking website.

Joe Lebrato, an executive who was on his way from Dubai to a family vacation in Michigan, said that shortly before his flight from Amsterdam to Detroit was to take off, passengers were told it would be delayed by at least an hour. He said they waited on the tarmac for three hours before the flight, operated by the Dutch carrier KLM, was canceled. He said that he was hoping to rebook a flight to Detroit departing on Saturday.

“The world is not going to end, but it’s a pain, definitely,” Mr. Lebrato said. He said the passengers remained calm, understanding that the issue was out of the airline’s hands.

Louise Slyth, a consultant and freelance writer, said she had to wait on the tarmac for hours after landing in Edinburgh from Dublin. At the airport in Edinburgh, there were lines everywhere. “People were quite fractious,” Ms. Slyth said. “There seems to be very little knowledge of what’s going to happen next.”

In other European cities, including Zurich, Paris and Berlin, hundreds of flights were delayed or canceled. At Berlin’s Brandenburg Airport, Germany’s third busiest, flights were canceled for three hours, from 7 a.m. to 10 a.m., before they started to resume. About 15 percent of flights departing from Brandenburg Airport had been canceled, according to FlightAware. At Manchester Airport in England, there were long lines in the departures area and only a few of a dozen or so check-in computers were working. Announcements broadcast over the public address system said “worldwide” outages had caused the delays.

The outage was expected to effect later flights around the world. At Narita International Airport in Japan, some passengers said they were disappointed and frustrated to receive automated texts from United Airlines that their flights were boarding, when instead they were delayed.

In South Korea, Jeju Air, which flies to dozens of destinations in the Asia-Pacific, said on its website that a number of services, including flight reservations, were affected. Air Premia said its reservations and online check-in systems were affected and urged passengers with flights to San Francisco and Newark to arrive at Seoul’s Incheon airport as soon as possible.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

What is CrowdStrike?

On Friday morning, flights were canceled, broadcasters went off air, trains didn’t run and medical procedures were delayed around the world. Frustrated workers were confronted with blue computer screens and no obvious way to get back online.

The root of the problem? CrowdStrike, a cybersecurity company dedicated to preventing exactly this sort of global outage.

CrowdStrike, which was founded in 2011, is a cloud-based cybersecurity platform whose software is used by scores of industries around the world to protect against hackers and outside breaches.

Its software secures computers at many Fortune 500 companies, and the company has built a reputation over the years as one that can solve even the toughest security problems. CrowdStrike was tapped to investigate the hack of Sony Pictures in 2014, which resulted in the release of confidential data from the movie studio, and the hack of the Democratic National Committee in 2016, which exposed Hillary Clinton’s emails. CrowdStrike serves about 29,000 customers and has about $4 billion in annual sales.

Cybersecurity software like CrowdStrike’s has broad privileges to run across a computer system, including into sensitive areas. That means when errors occur, the ripple effect can be significant.

CrowdStrike updates its security software automatically and silently. A flawed update on Friday morning, of its Falcon Sensor software, resulted in crashes of machines running Microsoft Windows operating system and caused the worldwide chaos.

We’re deeply sorry for the impact that we’ve caused to customers,” George Kurtz, the chief executive of CrowdStrike, said in an interview on the “Today” show. “We know what the issue is. We’re resolving and have resolved the issue now.”

Mr. Kurtz said the outages were not the result of a security incident or cyberattack.

An updated fix of the software has been sent to computers, but experts said outages would most likely persist as CrowdStrike customers worked to reboot computers that had already been affected. Some systems were able to automatically install the fix, Mr. Kurtz said, while others would require manual intervention from I.T. specialists.

CrowdStrike, which went public in 2019, is worth about $76 billion. Its stock fell dramatically on Friday after news of the outage, and remained down about eight percent that morning.

“This is an unprecedented event and not something we or anyone had in their cards,” analysts for Evercore, an investment banking firm, wrote in a note to investors. “This event clearly proves that cyber needs to be diversified and the idea of relying on one or two vendors will come under scrutiny.”

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

What caused such a widespread tech meltdown?

A flawed software update sent out by a little-known cybersecurity company caused major computer outages around the world on Friday, affecting airlines, hospitals, emergency responders and scores of other businesses and services. How could that happen?

The chaos stemmed from an update sent by CrowdStrike, a cybersecurity company based in Austin, Texas, to businesses that use its software to protect against hackers and online intruders. But when CrowdStrike’s new code reached computers that run Microsoft Windows software, the machines began to crash.

The fallout was immediate and harmful. CrowdStrike and Microsoft underpin many major businesses. Airlines canceled flights and airports fell into chaos in the United States, Europe and Asia. In the United States, operators of 911 lines in multiple states could not respond to emergencies. Parts of Britain’s National Health Service reported problems. New driver’s licenses could not be issued in some areas. Some television broadcasters could not go on the air.

The cascading effects highlighted the world’s reliance on Microsoft and a handful of cybersecurity firms like CrowdStrike that provide the world’s technological backbone. When a single flawed piece of software is released over the internet, it can almost instantly damage countless companies and organizations that depend on those software providers to conduct everyday business.

“This is a very, very uncomfortable illustration of the fragility of the world’s core internet infrastructure,” said Ciaran Martin, the former chief executive of Britain’s National Cyber Security Center and a professor at the Blavatnik School of Government at Oxford University.

A cyberattack did not cause the widespread outage, but the issues on Friday raised broader questions about what repercussions software firms should face when flaws in their code cause major disruptions.

George Kurtz, CrowdStrike’s chief executive, said that the company took responsibility for the mistake and that a software fix had been released. He warned that it could be some time before everything was restored and tech systems returned to normal.

“We’re deeply sorry for the impact that we’ve caused to customers, to travelers, to anyone affected by this,” Mr. Kurtz said in an interview on Friday on NBC’s “Today” show.

Microsoft blamed CrowdStrike for the problem and said it expected that “a resolution is forthcoming.” Apple and Linux machines were not affected by the flawed CrowdStrike software.

How quickly such a fix can be implemented remains an open question because of the number of computers that have been affected.

The issues appeared to originate with an update to CrowdStrike software called Falcon Sensor, said Lukasz Olejnik, an independent cybersecurity researcher and consultant. Falcon Sensor scans a computer for intrusions and signs of hacking.

Mr. Olejnik said outages would probably take time to resolve because the suggested solution involved rebooting each computer manually into safe mode, deleting a specific file and then restarting the computer. While it is a relatively straightforward process, security experts say, it may not be easy to automate at scale. Those with organized and well-staffed information technology teams could potentially fix the issues more quickly, Mr. Olejnik said.

Unlike the iPhone software updates that Apple sends to customers, the incident involved information technology systems in the background that people typically don’t see businesses use. Companies rely on many other companies to make the software that underpins their operations.

A major problem with the CrowdStrike issues was that the software being updated performed critical cybersecurity tasks, giving it access to scan a computer to look for viruses and other malicious attacks.

“One of the tricky parts of security software is it needs to have absolute privileges over your entire computer in order to do its job,” said Thomas Parenty, a cybersecurity consultant and a former U.S. National Security Agency analyst.

“So if there’s something wrong with it, the consequences are vastly greater than if your spreadsheet doesn’t work,” he added.

The CrowdStrike flaw was not the only problem facing Microsoft. On Thursday, some Microsoft clients in the central United States, including some airlines, were affected by an outage on its cloud service system, Azure. Microsoft’s cloud service status page indicated that it had identified a preliminary cause, though some users may still be unable to access certain Microsoft 365 apps and services, including Teams video conferencing.

Microsoft said that the issue was not related to the CrowdStrike outage, but that it was “working to restore services for those still experiencing disruptions as quickly as possible.”

The outages underscored an uncomfortable reality that software companies face few liabilities for major disruptions and cybersecurity incidents. The economic and legal penalties for such significant outages can be so minimal that companies are not motivated to make more fundamental changes. While a car manufacturer would face stiff penalties for faulty breaks, a software provider can often issue another update and move on.

“Until software companies have to pay a price for faulty products, we will be no safer tomorrow than we are today,” Mr. Parenty said.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Health services were experiencing difficulties in several countries.

Health-care systems across the globe were hobbled by the Microsoft outage. It caused chaos for patients checking in for appointments across Britain, forced the cancellation of some elective procedures in German hospitals and complicated some emergency response systems in the United States.

In Britain, the National Health Service was crippled throughout the morning on Friday, as a number of hospitals and doctors offices lost access to their computer systems. But health-care providers stressed that there was no impact on emergency services, or the ability to provide care.

The National Health Service in Britain largely relies on a common internal information technology system, so the problems were widespread. In a statement, the health service said the outage had affected its appointment and patient record systems. It still advised patients to attend appointments unless they heard otherwise.

“The N.H.S. has longstanding measures in place to manage the disruption, including using paper patient records and handwritten prescriptions, and the usual phone systems to contact your G.P.,” the health service said in a statement, referring to general practitioners, the first point of contact for most patients.

Still, some patients reported being turned away at doctor’s offices for non-urgent appointments.

“Entire clinical system is down 20 mins before hundreds of people call for an appointment that we can’t book,” Liam Barker, a London-based doctor, wrote in a social-media post.

The British government held an emergency response on Friday to assess the situation, according to Pat McFadden, a Cabinet minister, who said the government was working with industry experts on the issue.

At least one large medical care center in Germany, the University Hospital Schleswig-Holstein, said that it would cancel elective procedures on Friday.

In the United States, the CrowdStrike outage downed the I.T. systems at Seattle’s Children Hospital in Washington State, the hospital said on social media, with most of them still out early Friday morning.

Rachel Nostrant contributed reporting.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Rebuilt Monastery, Aided by Beer Sales, Gives Hope to a Quake-Struck Region

Sign up for Your Places: Global Update.   All the latest news for any part of the world you select.

They may have chosen a contemplative life of prayer, detached from world affairs, but last month a small community of Benedictine monks threw a very big bash for the opening of their new monastery on a hill overlooking the central Italian town of Norcia, where St. Benedict was born.

After a Mass and a seated dinner for 1,000 — about half of them Norcia residents — the monks officially settled in, eight years after a devastating earthquake upended a sizable part of Norcia and destroyed their previous space.

At the festivities, they served “Nursia,” their craft beer whose sales supported the restoration of the 16th-century capuchin monastery that the community had bought after returning to Norcia 25 years ago, following a two-century hiatus. The celebration was also a moment of hope for an area struggling to revive itself after the earthquake compounded years of depopulation.

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.