The New York Times 2024-07-27 12:10:55


Opening Ceremony Highlights: Celine Dion Caps Celebration Along Seine Hours After Rail Chaos

Don’t miss a moment at the Paris Olympics.  Sign up for our daily email to receive the biggest highlights, the latest medal count and the stories you won’t see on TV.
Pinned

Andrew Keh

Reporting from Paris

The Paris Games, after a night of rain and drama, are open.

The Paris Olympics opened under tight security and rainy skies on Friday, only hours after a coordinated arson attack brought France’s national rail system to a standstill and rattled nerves in a city already on edge.

French organizers have spent years planning the country’s showcase moment, and it was a masterpiece of history and surprise, kitsch and sports, art and fashion — all highlighted by a sprawling boat parade that ferried nearly 7,000 athletes along a route almost four miles long and that was book ended by performances by Lady Gaga and Celine Dion.

The route, past monuments and under bridges, celebrated the city itself as an Olympic venue, and helped France cap a day of celebration that had begun ominously: with fires that the authorities said were deliberately set to disrupt the start of the Games — a reminder of the limits of years of preparations and more than 50,000 policemen.

Here’s what else to know:

  • NBC and Peacock aired the ceremony live and will show it again at 7:30 p.m. Eastern. For the first time, it was held not inside the barricaded confines of a stadium but on the Seine. The N.B.A. star LeBron James of the Los Angeles Lakers and the tennis star Coco Gauff served as flag bearers for the United States. Gojira, a leading French heavy metal band, became the first hard rock act to perform in an Olympics opening ceremony when it did a metal version of “Ah! Ça Ira,” a song that was popular during the French Revolution.

  • A series of arson attacks on France’s rail network on Friday disrupted service on three high-speed rail lines — the Atlantic, Northern and Eastern lines — with many trains canceled, the railway company, S.N.C.F., said in a statement. The fires, which were set in pipes carrying cables used for signaling and have been described as “criminal,” were all detected around 4 a.m. local time, according to Patrice Vergriete, France’s transportation minister.

  • No one was killed or reported injured, but the damage to France’s high-speed train lines caused major delays as thousands of local and international travelers were headed to Paris for the ceremony and the Games.

    Amélie Oudéa-Castera, France’s minister for sports and the Olympics, said the authorities were still evaluating whether athletes’ transportation would be affected over the weekend. Train service is expected to be affected through Monday, interrupting plans for more than a million people, including French vacationers, Olympic athletes and tourists. The S.N.C.F. advised travelers to postpone their trips if possible.

Aurelien Breeden, Andrew Das, Catherine Porter and Ségolène Le Stradic contributed reporting.

Gaga and Celine, Eurodisco and ballroom voguers, drag queens posed like the apostles in the Last Supper, the quays of the Seine covered in pink, and a throuple cruising one another in the national library: Thomas Jolly’s ceremony promised to be grandiose, but it was also a festival of queer Paris, looking fabulous in the rain. Politicians from the far right denounced the ceremony before it even began. And in the midst of an ongoing political crisis, this ceremony made clear what sort of France it believes in.

Gérald Darmanin, France’s interior minister, exulted on X that “WE DID IT!” Organizing the opening ceremony was a huge logistical challenge and security headache, and many critics had questioned its feasibility. Darmanin and other top officials can celebrate now that it went off without a major hitch. But on Saturday the Games start in earnest — and with them the possibility of other things going wrong.


Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

“I can’t talk,” says the NBC commentator Kelly Clarkson, shaken up with emotion at Celine Dion’s performance. And this is indeed one of those moments when the music — and the images of Paris glowing by night — say all that needs to be said.

French TV presenter Daphné Bürki, who worked on the show with Thomas Jolly overseeing the costumes, has been in tears through much of the show, as a commentator on France 2 television. She ended the show in a puddle.

Is that hot-air balloon anchored somewhere, or is someone piloting it? At first it looked like it would just float away, but it appears to now be stationary

It does in fact look like the hot-air balloon is tethered to the ground.

Celine Dion closes the opening ceremony with a triumphant return to stage.

The stakes could not have been higher for Celine Dion’s first public performance since 2020. After canceling tour dates, in 2022 she announced that she was suffering from a rare neurological disorder known as stiff person syndrome, which causes muscle spasms, including constrictions of her vocal cords. “I Am: Celine Dion,” the documentary released this year, showed her struggling to sing at a recording session.

Her performance at the Olympics opening ceremony was a song from Edith Piaf, the petite, tangy-voiced, dramatic and quintessentially French chanson singer who was nicknamed “the Little Sparrow.” The song, “Hymne à l’amour,” envisions a love that outlasts the end of the world, and it’s the kind of soaring, swelling, long-breathed anthem that Dion used to belt to the rafters.

Like sports, singing has a demanding physicality of its own. Dion faced a live, real-time test with a worldwide audience.

And in a long, white glittering dress, she seized her moment. She relied on subtlety along with lung power. Perhaps her voice was a little scratchier, at times, than before her illness. But the drama of the moment was matched by the dynamics of her performance, rising to an unaccompanied peak before a triumphant final phrase. Yes, she nailed the landing.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Celine Dion brings it all to a close in a Dior dress covered in “thousands of pearls and more than 500 meters of fringing.” She looks like a sort of angelic showgirl, glowing from the innards of the Eiffel Tower.

Teddy Riner, a judoka seeking a medal at his fifth straight Olympics, and Marie-José Pérec, a three-time gold medalist in track and field, get the honors for lighting the cauldron.

The group of runners is now headed by three French Paralympians, trailed now by Amélie Mauresmo and Tony Parker in the darkness and spotlights as they pass from the Louvre to the Tuileries. Two French handball athletes take the torch from them. The group keeps getting bigger, and the emptiness and the wet path and the growing group of legends make this really a terrific presentation.

I like this as an advertisement for running in Paris. Fantastic running city.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

In France, people are so proud of French players in the N.B.A. that they referred to the San Antonio Spurs as “Tony Parker’s team,” just like the Minnesota Timberwolves are now “Rudy Gobert’s team.”

There is something strangely poetic about Tony Parker, the French former N.B.A. player, and Amélie Mauresmo running alone in a near-empty Louvre courtyard.

The speedboat legends hand off to Amélie Mauresmo, a French former tennis champion.

That boat is going FAST. Serena Williams and Nadia Comaneci almost fell over and caught each other.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

One more serving of disco fromage: Cerrone’s 1977 hit “Supernature” accompanies the torch’s boat ride. It’s a song about nature taking revenge on mankind for wrecking the environment. But it pumps!

Nadal to Serena to Nadia Comaneci to Carl Lewis. This is a boat of legends.

I have to say, the life jacket Serena Williams is wearing on the motor boat is important — safety first! — but it’s kind of ruining her dress effect.

The producers proving an old rule of entertainment: If you’ve got an Eiffel Tower, flaunt it.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Zidane hands on off to Rafael Nadal, the Spanish tennis champion. This all has the feel of a relay of great athletes.

Zinedine Zidane, a French-Algerian soccer star and World Cup winner, strolls out to cheers and — gasp! — takes the torch from the masked figure we’ve been following all night.

President Emmanuel Macron officially declares the Games open.

Thomas Bach, the International Olympic Committee president: “Vive les Jeux Olympique, vive la France.”

Wet athletes: “Let’s gooooo.”

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

A few hours into the ceremony, as the cameras cut from the speeches to tight shots of the drenched athletes, you get the sense that braving this rain has been an endurance event for everyone.

“The most beautiful treasures of our national heritage will be your playground,” Tony Estanguet says, referring to the fact that some of the most famous monuments and areas in the French capital, like the Grand Palais or the Eiffel Tower, have become staging areas for Olympic events.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Sunny recorded scenes peek through the rainy festivities.

If you are looking for clues as to what was recorded before the opening ceremony, look for the rain.

It’s pretty slippery in Paris, and many of the taped segments were shot on a clear day, when dancers did not need to work as diligently to stay balanced as they did Friday.

Also keep an eye on the character identified only as “the mysterious torchbearer,” the masked person leading us through some unusual scenes in an attempt to weave a story that will make the most sense to the opening ceremony organizers.

He’s based on a number of masked characters who have “left their mark on French culture,” according to the program for the opening ceremony. They include Ezio from the Assassin’s Creed video game in addition to Belphégor, the Iron Mask, the Phantom of the Opera and Fantomas.

There are dancers, there’s art, there’s some black-and-white footage, and there are minions. Yes, minions. (Pierre Coffin, a French Indonesian animator, helped invent the yellow animated creatures and has supplied their voices for nearly 15 years.)

A few more examples of scenes that were filmed before it started pouring in Paris: parts of a segment titled “Synchronicity,” written by Victor le Masne, showed dancers performing in the scaffolding of Notre-Dame. That gold medal welding? Taped, until we were taken back to real time as a suitcase — with the medals, of course — was taken down a set of stairs in the rain. That scene in the library with a possible ménage a trois? That was taped, too.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

fashion review

Team U.S.A. is wearing navy blazers — again.

What does it mean to dress to represent the United States?

As far as Ralph Lauren is concerned, it appears to mean wearing a navy blazer.

Yes, the Americans will be wearing navy blazers yet again as they make their Olympic entrance. This is the fifth Summer Games for which Ralph Lauren has been the official outfitter of the American delegation, and the fifth time he has designed a navy blazer for the Summer Games. Plus ça change and all that.

In 2008, the blazer was single-breasted, with white buttons to match the white newsboy caps and white trousers (very “Brideshead Revisited” with an American twist). In 2012, the blazer was double- or single-breasted, worn with matching navy berets, white pants or skirts and, for women, a red, white and blue scarf that gave the look a sort of regimental air.

By 2016, the blazer was single-breasted again, with skinny white jeans and a red, white and blue striped T-shirt that inspired unfortunate comparisons to the Russian flag. And for the last Summer Games, in Tokyo in 2021, the navy blazer was worn with sneakers, a nautical blue-and-white striped tee and dark blue denim pegged-leg jeans, some cuffed at the ankle.

This time around, the jacket is single-breasted, with red-and-white grosgrain ribbon trim. The shirt is a blue-and-white striped oxford, the jeans are faded and relaxed, and the shoes are white bucks. (Men also have a navy tie.)

In the pantheon of navy blazers, it is less yacht club, more private-school boy with a naughty streak — but still suffused with somewhat outmoded prepster déjà vu.

Tradition and consistency have always been part of the Ralph Lauren sell, whether it is on the runway or in stores. So have the uniforms of WASP fantasy. But at this point, especially given the criticism that the navy blazer attracted during the Tokyo Games and the complicated associations with exclusion and privilege it can evoke — viewers compared the athletes to a team of Karens or people “on vacation in Newport” — you’d think the company would have tried a new approach.

Instead, it doubled down on the old one. America is a bigger, more chaotic place than the country club. Why default to banality?

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Middle East Crisis: Harris Expresses Support for Israel but Says She ‘Will Not Be Silent’ About Palestinian Suffering

Harris offers support for Israel but calls out Palestinians’ plight after Netanyahu meeting.

Vice President Kamala Harris offered Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu strong support for Israel’s right to defend itself from terrorism on Thursday but declared that “far too many innocent civilians” had died in Gaza and that “I will not be silent” about their suffering.

In what amounted to her debut on the world stage since her rapid ascension as the presumptive Democratic nominee for president, Ms. Harris sought to strike a balance and capture what she called “the complexity” of the strife in the Middle East. But while she did not stray from President Biden on policy, she struck a stronger tone on the plight of Palestinians.

“What has happened in Gaza over the past nine months is devastating,” she told reporters after meeting with Mr. Netanyahu at the White House complex. “The images of dead children and desperate, hungry people fleeing for safety, sometimes displaced for the second, third or fourth time — we cannot look away in the face of these tragedies, we cannot allow ourselves to become numb to the suffering, and I will not be silent.”

She noted that she had also met with the families of Israeli hostages held by Hamas since its Oct. 7 terrorist attack and expressed distress for their anguish, making a point of reciting the names of each of the hostages with U.S. citizenship. “I’ve told them each time they are not alone, and I stand with them,” she said. “And President Biden and I are working every day to bring them home.”

In a sign of the changing order in Washington since Mr. Biden withdrew from the presidential race on Sunday, Ms. Harris offered the only substantive comments after Mr. Netanyahu met separately with each of them. She pressed for the conclusion of a long-delayed cease-fire deal to end the war and bring the hostages home.

Many were watching Ms. Harris, given her new role. Over the nine months since the Hamas attack, she has largely stuck close to the president’s position, although at times she has sounded more empathetic about the suffering in Gaza, leading some to conclude that she might not be as supportive of Mr. Netanyahu’s war as Mr. Biden has been.

Republicans criticized Ms. Harris for not attending the prime minister’s address to Congress on Wednesday while keeping a previously scheduled out-of-town commitment, although they had no criticism for Senator JD Vance of Ohio, their own Republican vice-presidential nominee, for also skipping the speech, citing a scheduling conflict.

Clearly determined not to let herself be painted into a corner, Ms. Harris made a point of denouncing the “despicable acts by unpatriotic protesters” who burned a flag and defaced statues with anti-Israel slogans outside the Capitol on Wednesday.

“I condemn any individuals associating with the brutal terrorist organization Hamas, which has vowed to annihilate the State of Israel and kill Jews,” she said in a written statement issued hours before her meeting with Mr. Netanyahu. “Pro-Hamas graffiti and rhetoric is abhorrent, and we must not tolerate it in our nation.”

The administration’s support of Israel’s war effort, even with the qualms Mr. Biden has expressed about the civilian toll and his suspension of a shipment of munitions, had been a thorny issue for his re-election campaign. He has faced criticism from some Democrats for not exerting more pressure on Mr. Netanyahu to limit the carnage and end the fighting.

The contrast between the prime minister’s meetings with Ms. Harris and Mr. Biden on Thursday was striking. The president greeted Mr. Netanyahu cordially in the Oval Office. “Well, welcome back, Mr. Prime Minister,” Mr. Biden said as the two sat down for what would be a 90-minute meeting. “We’ve got a lot to talk about. I think we should get to it.”

While the two have been at odds over the conduct of the war for months, Mr. Biden offered no thoughts about the situation on the ground while reporters were in the room and instead turned the floor over to Mr. Netanyahu, who used the opportunity to express gratitude now that the president is winding up his long political career.

“Mr. President, we’ve known each other for 40 years, and you’ve known every Israeli prime minister for 50 years, from Golda Meir,” Mr. Netanyahu told him. “So from a proud Jewish Zionist to a proud Irish American Zionist, I want to thank you for 50 years of public service and 50 years of support for the state of Israel. And I look forward to discussing with you today and working with you in the months ahead on the great issues before us.”

Mr. Biden grinned at the reference to him as an “Irish American Zionist” and then said he looked forward to their discussions as well. “By the way, that first meeting with Prime Minister Golda Meir, and she had an assistant sitting next to me, a guy named Rabin,” he said, referring to Yitzhak Rabin, who would later become prime minister. “That’s how far back it goes. I was only 12 then.”

Ms. Harris, by contrast, was polite but businesslike in greeting Mr. Netanyahu in her ceremonial office in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building next to the White House, and the two offered no statements in front of the cameras as they began their 40-minute meeting. When she emerged afterward to make her comments, she did so by herself, and the Israelis were surprised by her tone.

She expressed solidarity with Israel, reiterating her “unwavering commitment” to its existence and its security, and she condemned Hamas as a “brutal terrorist organization” that had started the war when it “massacred 1,200 innocent people, including 44 Americans” and “committed horrific acts of sexual violence.”

“Israel has a right to defend itself,” she said, then added pointedly, “and how it does so matters.”

John F. Kirby, a White House spokesman, played down any differences between the president and vice president on Gaza. “She’s been a full partner in our policies in the Middle East,” he told reporters before either meeting.

Mr. Biden and Mr. Netanyahu met with families of hostages held by Hamas amid renewed confidence about prospects for a cease-fire deal that would release their loved ones. Some of the hostage relatives said as they left the White House that they were convinced the American and Israeli leaders both felt urgency to bring the war to an end so that those captured during the Oct. 7 attack could come home.

“We feel probably more optimistic than we have since the first round of releases in late November, early December,” said Jonathan Dekel-Chen, the father of Sagui Dekel-Chen, who lived on the kibbutz Nir Oz.

“We got an absolute commitment from the Biden administration and from Prime Minister Netanyahu that they understand the urgency of this moment now to waste no time and to complete this deal, as it currently stands with as little change as humanly possible within,” he added.

Rachel Goldberg-Polin, whose son Hersh Goldberg-Polin was grievously injured during the attack but seen in a video released in April, said Mr. Biden’s decision to give up his re-election bid would not diminish his ability to influence events in the region.

“On the contrary, I actually think it allows the president to be laser focused on the things that are true priorities to him,” she said. “And saving human beings, cherished human beings, 115 of them, eight of whom are U.S. citizens, is one paramount issue for him.”

Mr. Kirby said that the negotiators “are closer now, we believe, than we’ve been before” but that there were still gaps. He did not blame Israel in particular for resisting. “The Israelis already have made many compromises to get us to this point,” he said. “Hamas through their interlocutors have made compromises to get us to this point. And yet we’re still not there. So there’s still a need for compromise.”

The White House meeting came a day after Mr. Netanyahu used his address to a joint meeting of Congress to denounce critics of Israel, particularly left-wing protesters he termed “useful idiots.” Police used pepper spray outside the Capitol to push back thousands of protesters, some of whom burned an American flag and marred statues with slogans like “Hamas is coming.” On Thursday, protesters were kept at a distance from the White House by a new wall of fencing beyond the normal gates as they shouted upon Mr. Netanyahu’s arrival.

Mr. Netanyahu planned to hedge his bets by making a trip to Florida to visit former President Donald J. Trump at his Mar-a-Lago estate on Friday. But Mr. Trump, who has soured on Mr. Netanyahu after their initially strong alliance, may not offer the message the prime minister wants to hear.

In an interview on Fox News on Thursday, the former president said that Israel should wrap up the war soon because it has yielded bad public relations for the country. Israel should “finish up and get it done quickly,” Mr. Trump said, “because they are getting decimated with this publicity.”

Zach Montague contributed reporting.

Trump urges Netanyahu to end the war in Gaza ahead of Friday meeting.

Republicans in Congress applauded often when Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, spoke at the Capitol on Wednesday. But the Republican nominee for president, Donald J. Trump, appeared less impressed with Israel’s messaging the next day.

Israel must end the war in Gaza “and get it done quickly,” Mr. Trump said in an interview on Fox News on Thursday. He argued that Israel was “getting decimated” by negative publicity over its conduct of the war, set off by the Oct. 7 Hamas-led attack on Israel. Since then, more than 39,000 Palestinians have been killed, according to Gazan health authorities, and the war has wreaked widespread disease, hunger and destruction.

“Israel is not very good at public relations,” Mr. Trump said.

The comments came a day before a scheduled meeting on Friday between the former president and Mr. Netanyahu at Mar-a-Lago, Mr. Trump’s private residence and club in Palm Beach, Fla. But it is not clear that the Israeli prime minister — who praised the former president in his congressional address — would agree with Mr. Trump about wrapping up the conflict.

In his speech to U.S. lawmakers, Mr. Netanyahu vowed that Israel would fight until Hamas was eradicated. He did not say what many Israelis, especially the relatives of hostages in Gaza, wanted to hear: that he would close a cease-fire deal with Hamas to end the war and return about 115 people taken from Israel on Oct. 7 who remain in Gaza, several dozen of whom are believed to be dead.

On Monday, the Israeli military announced that two of the remaining hostages were dead. On Thursday, the Israeli military announced that five hostages’ bodies had been found in tunnels in an operation in Khan Younis and returned to Israel from Gaza.

The steady drumbeat of bad news about the captives underscores the urgency of a deal for the hostages’ relatives, some of whom met with Mr. Netanyahu in Washington this week, including at a gathering with President Biden at the White House on Thursday. They expressed optimism about the possibility of a deal when they emerged from the meeting, and told reporters in a briefing that Mr. Netanyahu understood the urgency of the need for a cease-fire.

It is a point that Mr. Trump may make at Mar-a-Lago, too, telling Mr. Netanyahu what he told Fox News: “Finish up.”

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Israeli forces have retrieved from Gaza the bodies of 5 people killed on Oct. 7.

Israeli forces retrieved the bodies of five Israelis held in Gaza, the Israeli military said on Thursday, amid growing international pressure for a cease-fire deal that would involve the release of the remaining captives.

The bodies were found on Wednesday in a tunnel shaft in a Khan Younis zone that Israel previously designated as a humanitarian area where Gazan civilians could go to avoid the fighting and to receive aid, the Israeli military said. The shaft was nearly 220 yards long and more than 20 yards underground, with several rooms, the military said.

Israel has said that Hamas has exploited the “humanitarian zone” to launch rockets at Israel, as well as use it for other military purposes. Aid groups have lamented that Israel has occasionally struck the area, despite telling Gazans they would be safer there. There was no immediate response from Hamas.

Israel has been carrying out a new operation in Khan Younis this week, using tanks and fighter jets to strike what it has described as Hamas infrastructure in the southern Gaza city. Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, the Israeli military spokesman, told reporters the renewed offensive aimed in part to “enable the operation” to retrieve the bodies.

Dozens of people have been killed during the Israeli assault on Khan Younis, the Gazan Health Ministry has reported. Many also fled their homes as the Israeli bombardment intensified, while others elected to stay, hoping they would be safer in their houses than in tents. Admiral Hagari said that Israeli forces had killed “many terrorists.”

The five people whose bodies were recovered — Maya Goren, 56; Tomer Ahimas, 20; Kiril Brodski, 19; Oren Goldin, 33; and Ravid Katz, 51 — were killed during the Hamas-led attacks on Oct. 7 and were taken back to Gaza to be held as bargaining chips, Israeli officials said. They are considered hostages by the Israeli government.

Mr. Brodski and Mr. Ahimas were soldiers who fell during the attacks, while the other three were civilians.

Ms. Goren was a teacher from Nir Oz, one of the hardest-hit communities near the Gaza border; her husband was also killed on Oct. 7. Mr. Katz, also from Nir Oz, was a father of three children. The body of Mr. Goldin, a member of a nearby village’s civil response squad, was taken, along with that of his brother-in-law Tal Haimi, whose body is still in Gaza.

The Israeli military said that intelligence — including information from detained Palestinian militants — had guided forces to the tunnel.

More than 250 people were abducted during the Hamas-led attack on Oct. 7, according to Israel, and 105 were released during a brief cease-fire in November. Israeli officials say 115 hostages remain in Gaza, including roughly 40 who are presumed dead.

The return home of the hostages’ remains in body bags added to the domestic political pressure on Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to end the war, even as he was visiting Washington and in a speech to Congress gave a full-throated defense of Israel’s military operations in Gaza.

“The war in Gaza could end tomorrow if Hamas surrenders, disarms and returns all the hostages,” Mr. Netanyahu said during his address to Congress on Wednesday. “But if they don’t, Israel will fight until we destroy Hamas’s military capabilities and its rule in Gaza and bring all our hostages home.”

Mr. Netanyahu did not refer to the current proposal backed by the Biden administration and the United Nations Security Council. Under that deal, Israel would ultimately agree to a permanent cease-fire with Hamas and withdraw its forces from Gaza in exchange for the release of all hostages.

Nissim Kalderon, whose brother Ofer was abducted on Oct. 7, accused Mr. Netanyahu of hesitating to reach a deal for political reasons. Mr. Netanyahu’s coalition government depends on hard-line parties who support permanent Israeli control of Gaza, effectively ruling out a cease-fire with Hamas.

“I expected, hoped, wished that you would open your speech with ‘We have a signed deal.’ But again and again, you’re not doing what you should have done 292 days ago,” Mr. Kalderon said at a rally in Tel Aviv on Wednesday night. “Bring your citizens home.”

At least six Israeli relatives of hostages were arrested in the House gallery by Capitol Police during Mr. Netanyahu’s speech as they wore bright yellow T-shirts calling on him to reach an agreement to free their loved ones.

“Benjamin Netanyahu spoke for 54 minutes and he did not mention once the need to seal the deal,” said Gil Dickmann, whose cousin Carmel Gat was abducted from the Israeli border community of Be’eri. “That’s what he needs to do, sign the deal and release all the hostages now.”

Rawan Sheikh Ahmad contributed reporting.

The U.S. has sent thousands of bombs and missiles to Israel, a report found.

In his address to Congress on Wednesday, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel asked for the speedy delivery of more American weapons to help his country prevail over Hamas in the war in Gaza. “Give us the tools faster, and we’ll finish the job faster,” he said.

The prime minister’s plea for more weapons, faster, comes despite enormous transfers of American military hardware over the last 10 months.

A tally of publicly known deliveries, as compiled this week by the Jewish Institute for National Security of America, show that more than 20,000 unguided bombs, an estimated 2,600 guided bombs and 3,000 precision missiles — as well as aircraft, ammunition and air defenses — are among the American weapons that already have been shipped since Oct. 7.

Many of the arms shipments that the United States has sent to Israel since the war began in October are classified or have been otherwise kept secret. Nonetheless, what had been delivered by March alone amounts to “an enormous number and variety of weapons, which have played a vital role in helping Israel defend itself,” an analysis by the Foundation for Defense of Democracies found this past spring.

With Americans divided over U.S. support for the war, and the domestic defense industry already stretched thin by the war in Ukraine, some defense officials and weapons experts have predicted that arms shipments to Israel could soon level off, or be phased out over the next decade.

Human rights groups and some U.S. lawmakers have demanded that the United States stop supplying weapons that could be used by Israel in potential war crimes, though security experts and some members of Congress have argued that ending American military aid would make Israel more vulnerable to attacks by Iran and its regional proxies.

In May, the State Department concluded that Israel had most likely violated humanitarian standards by failing to protect civilians in Gaza, but it did not find specific instances that would justify withholding American military aid.

Earlier this year, the Biden administration halted the shipment of 1,800 2,000-pound bombs to Israel after concerns swelled that such explosives had killed thousands of Palestinian civilians in southern Gaza. President Biden said in May that he would block the delivery of weapons that could be fired into densely populated areas of Rafah, in southern Gaza, where more than a million Palestinians were sheltering.

But this month, Mr. Biden loosened some of the restrictions to allow the delivery of 1,700 500-pound bombs that were part of the paused shipment of 2,000-pound bombs.

The seeming inconsistency has prompted some weapons experts to explore how — or whether — Israel can become less reliant on the United States, in part by building up its own weapons industry. Such development would cost Israel tens of billions of dollars, the defense foundation’s analysis said, for a country that already spends around 4.5 percent of its gross domestic product on defense — more than any NATO country.

“It seems unlikely that Israel could attain across-the-board weapons and munitions self-sufficiency anytime soon (and some say ever),” the analysis said.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Israelis contrast Netanyahu’s speech in Congress with the grim reality at home.

For many Israelis, it wasn’t what Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said, it was what he didn’t say.

In his speech to Congress on Wednesday, Mr. Netanyahu cast the war in Gaza as a battle for the survival of the Jewish state, a view widely shared across Israel.

But many Israelis want the their leader to agree to a cease-fire that would allow for the release of the 115 remaining hostages in Gaza, at any cost. While Mr. Netanyahu spoke of “intensive efforts” to secure the release of the captives, he did not publicly embrace a proposed truce deal being negotiated.

In Israel, the dissonance between the repeated applause from U.S. lawmakers during his address and a grimmer domestic reality was apparent on the front pages of Thursday’s Hebrew-language newspapers, which were dominated by news that the military had recovered the bodies of several hostages from the Palestinian enclave.

Yedioth Ahronoth, a popular mainstream daily, split its front page horizontally, devoting the top half to portraits of four captives whose bodies were recovered, and the bottom half to the speech. A fifth body was subsequently identified by the Israeli authorities, who said all five had been killed on Oct. 7, during the Hamas-led assault on southern Israel that prompted the war.

The visit to Washington by Mr. Netanyahu, who arrived at the White House on Thursday afternoon for meetings with President Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris, was intended to shore up support for the war both at home and abroad.

But there is a widespread sense of government failure in Israel as the war has dragged on, with the fighting having expanded to multiple fronts and the leadership offering little vision for what comes next.

“It was a speech devoid of disappointments or good tidings,” wrote Ben-Dror Yemini in Thursday’s Yedioth Ahronoth. “Never, ever was there such a large chasm between high words and contradictory actions.”

In Israel, critics of Mr. Netanyahu have accused him of putting his political survival above the fate of the hostages. Two far-right parties that he relies on for his governing coalition have threatened to quit should he agree to a deal on terms that they would deem a surrender to Hamas.

Seeking better terms, Mr. Netanyahu has delayed the departure of an Israeli negotiating team that was meant to set out from Israel on Thursday for talks with mediators in Qatar. An Israeli official with knowledge of the talks said only that the team would depart for Qatar sometime after Mr. Netanyahu’s meeting with Mr. Biden, without specifying a new date.

The Hostages Families Forum, a grass-roots organization advocating for the captives’ release, declared a “crisis of trust” in a statement on Thursday, accusing Mr. Netanyahu of obstructing a deal.

“This foot-dragging is a deliberate sabotage of the chance to bring our loved ones back,” the forum said in its statement, adding, “It effectively undermines the negotiations and indicates a serious moral failure.”

Gaza’s death toll was largely accurate in the early days of the war, a study finds.

A new study analyzing the first 17 days of Israel’s bombardment in the Gaza Strip found that the Gaza Ministry of Health’s death toll, a subject of debate at the time, was reliable.

The study, conducted by Airwars, a British organization that assesses claims of civilian harm in conflicts, added to previous research suggesting that the Health Ministry’s figures in the early days of the war were credible.

In late October, the Health Ministry published the names of about 7,000 people who had been killed in the first 17 days of the war. Of the thousands of Israeli airstrikes and other explosions during that time period, only a fraction — 350 events — were analyzed by Airwars for the study released Wednesday. Airwars said it was able to independently identify 3,000 names, most of which matched the ministry’s list.

As a result, Airwars said, it felt confident the ministry’s casualty reporting system at the beginning of the war was reliable and that it was working to analyze additional strikes and explosions.

Airwars reported that more recent ministry figures had become less accurate after the destruction of the territory’s health system.

The war has, however, clearly devastated the civilian population in Gaza. On Wednesday, the ministry, whose death toll does not distinguish between civilians and combatants, said that more than 39,000 people had been killed.

The ministry is ultimately overseen by Hamas, and Israeli officials have expressed skepticism about its accuracy. Early in the war, before the Health Ministry released its list, President Biden said he had “no confidence in the number that the Palestinians are using,” though he and other American officials have since expressed more confidence in them, urging Israel to do more to protect civilians.

Israel says that it tries to avoid civilian casualties, but notes that Hamas often bases its forces in densely populated urban areas.

Airwars focused its research only on the early days of the conflict. It said that there were many other strikes and explosions apart from the nearly 350 it documented during the period.

About 75 percent of the names documented by Airwars appeared on the Health Ministry’s October list, a rate that showed that “both capture a large fraction of the underlying reality,” said Mike Spagat, a professor at Royal Holloway College at the University of London who reviewed the findings and advised on the research process.

Many international officials and experts familiar with the way the Health Ministry verifies deaths in Gaza — drawing on information from morgues and hospitals across the territory — say its numbers are generally reliable. But there is evidence that the quality of the data has declined, as infrastructure has collapsed in many parts of the territory. In December, after many hospitals had closed, the Health Ministry announced it was supplementing its hospital and morgue-based tally with “reliable media sources.”

In its analysis, Airwars verified that at least some militants were included on the list of those killed in the first three weeks of the war. Israel’s military said in July that it had killed or captured around 14,000 combatants in Gaza since the war began, a number that cannot be independently confirmed.

In one instance, an Israeli airstrike on Oct. 19 targeted and killed Maj. Gen. Jihad Muheisan, commander of the Hamas-run National Security Forces, along with 18 members of his family, including nine children and six women, Airwars found. General Muheisan and all but one of the 18 were included on the Health Ministry’s list.

Because Airwars only analyzed incidents in which civilians were reportedly harmed, researchers said they could not estimate how many militants were included on the Health Ministry’s list.

Other studies have also backed the reliability of the ministry’s early death toll.

Johns Hopkins researchers found that there was no evidence that it was inflated through early November. And researchers from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine who analyzed ID numbers from the October list found there was “no obvious reason” to doubt the data.

Airwars used the same methodology in its Gaza analysis as it has for conflicts in Iraq, Syria, Ukraine, Libya and others, said Emily Tripp, the group’s director.

The pace of those killed in Gaza in October stands out, she said. Airwars tracked more allegations of harm to civilians in October than in any month in its decade of monitoring, according to the report, including the U.S.-led fight against Islamic State and Russia’s bombardment of Syria. About a quarter of those included at least 10 civilians reportedly killed, which is much higher than other conflicts it has monitored.

“We have, per incident, more people dying than we’ve seen in any other campaign,” Ms. Tripp said. “The intensity is greater than anything else we’ve documented.”

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

This was the message that Netanyahu took to Congress.

Israel’s leader traveled some 5,000 miles and did not give an inch.

Addressing a joint meeting of Congress on Wednesday, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pushed back on condemnations of Israel’s prosecution of the war in Gaza and lavished praise and thanks on the United States for its support.

He offered a retort to harsh international criticism that Israel had done far too little to protect civilian lives in Gaza and was starving the population there. And he remained defiant in the face of the global pressure over a conflict that has killed tens of thousands of Palestinians, giving little hint that Israel would back down from the fight anytime soon.

Here are some of the highlights.

He name-checked both Biden and Trump.

Mr. Netanyahu was careful to walk a middle path, thanking both Democrats and Republicans, including President Biden and the Republican presidential nominee, Donald J. Trump, for their support.

“I know that America has our back,” he said. “And I thank you for it. All sides of the aisle. Thank you, my friends.”

He expressed particular appreciation for Mr. Biden’s “heartfelt support for Israel after the savage attack” led by Hamas on Oct. 7. But he also made a point of praising Mr. Trump, who as president was more receptive to some of his expansionist policies.

He denied that Israel was starving Gazans.

The prosecutor of the International Criminal Court has requested arrest warrants for war crimes and crimes against humanity for Mr. Netanyahu and the leaders of Hamas. But Mr. Netanyahu rejected accusations by the court’s prosecutor that Israel was deliberately cutting off food to Gazans.

“Utter, complete nonsense, a complete fabrication,” he declared.

Israel, he said, has enabled more than 40,000 aid trucks to enter Gaza during the war.

However, U.N. aid officials say Israel is responsible for most obstacles to getting aid to desperate Palestinians. Mr. Netanyahu said members of Hamas were stealing the goods.

He rejected blame for the heavy civilian loss.

More than 39,000 people have been killed in Gaza during the war, according to the Gaza health authorities, who do not distinguish between combatants and civilians. But Mr. Netanyahu again rejected Israeli responsibility. He denied deliberately targeting noncombatants and said the Israel Defense Forces had worked hard to protect them.

“The I.D.F. has dropped millions of fliers, sent millions of text messages and hundreds of thousands of phone calls to get Palestinian civilians out of harm’s way,” he said.

But those directives often confuse Gaza civilians who struggle to find any safe place to shelter amid the incessant airstrikes and bombardments that have lasted for more than nine months.

Mr. Netanyahu again blamed Hamas, saying it “does everything in its power to put Palestinian civilians in harm’s way” by using schools, hospitals and mosques for military operations.

International law requires combatants to avoid using such “civilian objects” for military objectives. But Israel’s critics say that Hamas’s use of civilian sites does not absolve Israel of its obligations under international law to protect civilians, nor does it explain the scale of death and destruction.

He played up diversity in Israeli society.

During the speech, Mr. Netanyahu called on a few Israeli soldiers in the audience to stand up, including one of Ethiopian descent and another who is Bedouin, citing their heroism and their important role in the Israeli military. It appeared to be an effort to convey that Israel and its military are not homogenous.

“The Muslim soldiers of the I.D.F. fought alongside their Jewish, Christian and other comrades in arms with tremendous bravery,” Mr. Netanyahu said.

Ethiopian Jews and Bedouins in Israel are often marginalized, but the prime minister offered a different portrayal.

He sketched out a vague vision of peace.

The Israeli prime minister has been accused by critics in Israel and some diplomats of dragging his feet in reaching a cease-fire deal with Hamas to end the bloodshed, possibly to preserve his own political longevity.

But Mr. Netanyahu said “a new Gaza could emerge” if Hamas was defeated and Gaza “demilitarized and de-radicalized,” adding that Israel “does not seek to resettle Gaza.”

He turned to past world conflicts to make his case, noting that the approach of demilitarization and de-radicalization was used in Germany and Japan after World War II.

There is broad concern, however, that in Gaza the trauma of the war will yield a new generation of radicalization.

The common enemy? Iran, he said.

“If you remember one thing, one thing from this speech, remember this: Our enemies are your enemies,” Mr. Netanyahu said. “Our fight is your fight. And our victory will be your victory.”

Iran, he said, wants to impose “radical Islam” on the world and sees the United States as its greatest enemy because it is “the guardian of Western civilization and the world’s greatest power.”

He argued that Iran-backed militias like Hamas, Hezbollah in Lebanon and the Houthis in Yemen, whatever their aggression against Israel, are actually fighting a different war.

“Israel is merely a tool,” Mr. Netanyahu said. “The main war, the real war, is with America.”

Israeli forces press forward in Khan Younis. At least 30 people are reported killed in 24 hours.

At least 30 people were killed and dozens more injured over a 24-hour period on Wednesday and Thursday in the Gaza Strip, local health officials said, as the Israeli military pushed deeper into parts of Khan Younis that it had previously designated as humanitarian zones for civilians fleeing the fighting.

The Israeli military, which began a renewed offensive in the southern Gaza city of Khan Younis earlier this week, said it was targeting Hamas forces whom it accused of embedding fighters among civilians.

Many of the victims were taken to the Nasser Medical Complex in Khan Younis, where photos taken by a photographer for Agence France-Presse showed bloodied children being rushed in for care.

Mohammad Saqer, the director of nursing at Nasser Hospital, said he had treated three children for severe blast wounds, which he said were most likely from bombardment. Dr. Saqer, who has worked at the medical center for 18 years, said few shipments of medicine and fuel were arriving at the hospital, making treatment difficult.

“So many dead, so many wounded, not enough beds,” Dr. Saqer said. “The situation’s disastrous. We’re rationing electricity, turning off air conditioning, trying to save what we can.”

Patients at the facility have been forced to share beds, and the hospital was “under enormous strain as the killing, wounding and maiming of people continues relentlessly in southern Gaza,” the aid group Doctors Without Borders wrote on social media earlier in the week.

The United Nations said that 150,000 people fled Khan Younis on Monday alone, the day the renewed Israeli offensive began, and that “large-scale displacement” from the area was ongoing.

In Al-Mawasi, the coastal town where the Israeli military ordered Khan Younis residents to go, there is “no space for even a single tent due to the overwhelming number of people desperate for safety,” the Palestinian Red Crescent said. The group said that one of its ambulances came under fire on Thursday as medics were trying assisting injured civilians.

Fighting in recent days has centered around three towns near the city of Khan Younis — Bani Suaila, Al Zanna and Al Qarara. On Wednesday, the Israeli military discovered the bodies of five Israelis in Al Qarara who had been killed in Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack on Israel. The bodies were found in a tunnel used by militants.

“Hamas exploited the humanitarian area and used it to hold our hostages captive,” the military said in a statement on social media. Hamas did not issue a response on its social media channels.

Israeli officials say 115 hostages remain in Gaza, including roughly 40 who are presumed dead.

The military said on Thursday that Hamas had launched several rockets toward Israel from the humanitarian area in Khan Younis earlier in the day. But the strike did not reach Israel and at least one rocket hit a U.N.-run school in Al Qarara, killing two people and injuring several others, the military said.

Schools have not been operating during the war and most of them have become shelters for displaced people. UNRWA, the United Nations’ main relief group for Palestinians that runs schools, did not confirm the attack.

The Israeli military said its forces operating in Khan Younis had killed dozens of Hamas militants over the past day and struck more than 60 terror targets.

Gaza’s health ministry said Israeli military strikes on areas in eastern Khan Younis killed at least 14 people early Thursday, with airstrikes reported in southern Gaza and tanks advancing in central Rafah.

Mahmoud Basal, a spokesman for the Palestinian Civil Defense, said Israeli forces had killed at least 17 people on Thursday in Deir al-Balah, in central Gaza, and in Khan Younis, Israeli snipers shot and killed at least one person while he was moving down Salah al-Din Street, Gaza’s main north-south route, he said. The Israeli military did not immediately respond to a request for comment about the incident.

Anushka Patil and Aaron Boxerman contributed reporting.

Battling Inflation, Russia Raises Key Interest Rate to 18 Percent

Russia’s central bank raised its key interest rate to 18 percent on Friday, the highest level in more than two years, in a sign of mounting concern in Moscow that the country’s wartime economy risked producing runaway inflation.

Elvira Nabiullina, the Russian central bank’s chairwoman, said the bank raised the rate by two full percentage points because “overheating in the economy has remained considerable.”

The increase, the first since December, lifts rates to more than double where they were a year ago and close to the high of 20 percent, which the central bank pushed through as an emergency measure just after Russia launched its invasion of Ukraine in early 2022.

Annual inflation in Russia stood at 9 percent this month, far higher than the 4 percent the country’s financial authorities had been targeting. Ms. Nabiullina said Friday that the scale of “overheating” in the first half of the year was the greatest the Russian economy had seen in 16 years. The central bank is now forecasting inflation of as much as 7 percent for the full year.

Dmitri S. Peskov, the Kremlin spokesman, said in a call with journalists on Friday that President Vladimir V. Putin remained satisfied with the work of the central bank. He said that Russia’s overall economic development indicators were “very, very positive,” but that nonetheless problems can arise.

“No economy in the world is free from the current problems,” Mr. Peskov said. He said “certain regulatory measures” are taken to address those problems, and “the same is being done in our country.”

Russia’s economy has adapted to international sanctions and the demands of the war far better than Western officials had predicted. But Ms. Nabiullina’s move on Friday underscored the risks, as the government pumps enormous sums of money into the Russian economy to finance the military operation. Facing a tight labor market, made worse by the number of men drafted to fight at the front, Russian firms have been forced to raise wages, driving up inflation.

“Labor force and production-capacity reserves have been almost exhausted,” Ms. Nabiullina said.

A further cause for stubborn inflation, she added, were “risks related to external conditions,” saying that Russian companies were passing on the burden of sanctions to consumers in the form of price increases.

Russian military spending accounted for almost a third of all expenditures in the country’s 2024 budget. The level has more than tripled since the invasion of Ukraine in 2022. The Russian government has yet to propose a budget for next year, which would be an indicator of the economy’s future trajectory. Some economists are not ruling out a further hike in the key interest rate in September.

Paul Sonne contributed from Berlin and Ivan Nechepurenko from Tbilisi, Georgia.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

Town Famous for Royal and Hollywood Guests Is Ravaged by Wildfires

Queen Elizabeth II vacationed there, as did her parents before her. Hollywood’s royalty were regular visitors, too. Marilyn Monroe filmed scenes for “River of No Return” there, and “The Emperor Waltz” brought Bing Crosby and Joan Fontaine to its golf courses and tennis courts. The mountains of Jasper, Alberta, have also stood in for peaks around the world in other movies.

Above all, Jasper National Park represented Canada both to the world and for many Canadians for over a century.

Now, tens of thousands of acres of the park and its mountain town of Jasper are either burning in an inferno or have been reduced to rubble and ash. Parks Canada, the national agency, said that since two large-scale wildfires, which sent up a wall of flame more than 300 feet high, were whisked into the community on ferocious winds earlier in the week, 358 of its 1,113 buildings have been destroyed.

“The nature of this fire was such that it humbled the humans on the ground,” Richard Ireland, the mayor of Jasper, told reporters in Hinton, Alberta, on Friday. He added that he believed that nothing could have stopped the destruction and that all necessary preparations had been taken.

“We want to be in the mountains,” he said. “We want to be in nature. And that means our community is exposed to the threat of wildfire. There are lots of forested communities in Alberta that are exposed.”

The cause of the wildfires is still unclear.

In the vast mountain park, which attracts about 2.5 million visitors each year, the fire has consumed more than 140 square miles, Parks Canada said. About 20,000 park visitors and 5,000 Jasper residents were evacuated late Monday as ash began raining on the town in advance of the flames.

A team of researchers said last year that climate change has increased the risk of large wildfires in Canada, where the fire season typically runs from March to October. Earlier this year, Canadian wildfires also prompted air quality warnings in places including Minnesota and Wisconsin.

While Mr. Ireland said that he was “prepared for the worst” before he returned for a tour of the town, where the fire was still very much active, there were some glimmers of positive news on Friday.

Wildfire fighters from South Africa, Australia and New Zealand are expected to arrive over the weekend to help battle the 577 active blazes in Alberta and neighboring British Columbia. They will join crews that have flown in from other parts of Canada where wildfires have been relatively scarce this summer.

The Canadian National Railway restarted freight train service through Jasper on Friday, reopening an economically vital corridor between the Pacific Coast and the rest of North America.

Officials said that rain and cooler temperatures had allowed 158 firefighters who remained in Jasper to at least halt the fire’s advance, although no one had any opinion on when it might be brought under control there (hot and dry weather is expected to return on the weekend). And all the town’s water-treatment facilities, its schools, hospital and other important infrastructure have been saved, according to Parks Canada.

“It is a better day,” the mayor said. “I don’t want to say a brighter day, because I want it to get dark and thunder and lightning, rain like crazy.”

The worst-hit areas are largely residential neighborhoods on the west and south sides of the town, according to the parks agency. No one has died or been seriously injured because of the fires.

Mr. Ireland cautioned that when residents returned — still several weeks away, officials said — they might find that even if their homes or business buildings had been untouched by fire, they might nevertheless be severely damaged by smoke or water.

“It’s going to be difficult,” he said of the day when the town reopened to its citizens. “The pain that will be felt almost defies description. It is beyond comprehension.”

Jeff Morris, a driver and guide for a tour company in Jasper, told the CBC, Canada’s public broadcaster, that posts on social media suggested that his house had been saved, while the rest of his subdivision had been destroyed.

It looks like almost an “apocalyptic nightmare,” he told the broadcaster, adding that he was already preparing to help neighbors sort through the remains of their homes. “I’ll help, wherever, wherever my hands are needed. We’ll put the town back together.”

Along with the neighboring Banff National Park, Jasper was made a park in large part to promote tourist travel by train, which was initially the only way to reach the community. Claire Campbell, who edited and contributed to a scholarly history about what is now Parks Canada, said that the striking mountain scenery soon became an international symbol of the then young nation.

“Both at the founding of the original Rocky Mountain parks right through to the present day, images of these parks have been exported internationally as representative of Canada by the federal government,” said Professor Campbell, who is Canadian and teaches Canadian history at Bucknell University in Pennsylvania. “In some ways, we see how the world sees us, and then we adopt that image, as well.”

Both parks dislodged Indigenous people from their lands and, until recently, shut them out of their operations.

Professor Campbell said that Jasper, where Canadian National built a wood lodge surrounded by wooden cabins, always had a different reputation from Banff, where the Canadian Pacific Railway built an enormous, stone-clad hotel in the style of a French château.

“Jasper was the more rustic of the two and offered a more romantic, back-to-nature atmosphere,” she said.

The original Jasper Park Lodge burned down in the early 1950s. Its replacement, which opened in 1952 and is now known as the Fairmont Jasper Park Lodge, survived the current fire, but four other buildings in the complex have been lost, the hotel chain said.

Mr. Ireland, the mayor of Jasper, said that he had no doubt that his town would rebuild.

“The mountains are still there,” he said. “They will be there and so will our community.”

Eve Sampson contributed reporting.

Vintage of War

In One Image Vintage of War By Nanna Heitmann and Eric Nagourney

Russian forces in a bloody battle to occupy eastern Ukraine set up a field hospital for wounded fighters in an old winery.

This soldier had just arrived. Medics quickly transferred him to a stretcher, cutting off his clothes to assess his wounds and start an IV.

Before the war, tourists would wander through tunnels decorated with carvings and taste the sparkling wine that Bakhmut was known for.

Now the Russians, who rarely see sunlight, take what cheer they can from other decorations, like the tree still there after Christmas had passed.

The cards and drawings on the wall were sent to recuperating soldiers by children back home.

Bacchus once reigned here. Now Mars does.

Tunnels have long wended through the earth beneath Bakhmut, in eastern Ukraine. Until the 1960s, they were used by the mining industry. The vintners came next. Then, after Russia invaded the country in 2022, the tunnels were repurposed yet again.

As fighting between Russian and Ukrainian forces raged, Moscow set up a stabilization point, bringing in medical equipment and installing it near racks still bearing tens of thousands of bottles of wine.

Though Russian forces captured the city of Bakhmut last year, the fighting around it can still be pitched. Many of the soldiers who end up at the field hospital were hurt in Klishchiivka, a bloody frontline point on the outskirts of the city.

The room above, near the entrance to an old decanting chamber that is still decorated with Romanesque statuary, once echoed with the sounds of festivity. Now it is the sounds of pain and lament.

The days underground are long. Venturing outside, where drones are often on the prowl, is too risky. A medic on the night shift photographed above was killed by one a month earlier.

This is what we know about the patient:

He is Russian. He did not die. He was transferred to a hospital farther from the front line — but not before an arm and a leg were amputated.

Full Stands, Full Volume: The Olympics You Remember Are Back

New

Listen to this article · 6:58 min Learn more

Andrew Keh

Reporting from Paris

Leer en español

Tara Davis-Woodhall, a long jumper by trade and an entertainer at heart, gazed into the stands at Tokyo’s 68,000-seat Olympic stadium and decided she needed some noise. In a quixotic bid to inject even a small dose of spirit into a pandemic-stricken Summer Games, she began clapping her hands theatrically.

Tens of people, give or take, clapped back.

“It was awful,” Davis-Woodhall said last month about the enforced emptiness of the Olympics three summers ago. “It was my first Olympics, and I was like, ‘What the heck? This is weird!’ I’m glad it’s over, and I’m glad that I’m going to Paris to actually experience an Olympics.”

Countless athletes like Davis-Woodhall — those who have competed in an Olympics but not truly experienced one — have arrived in Paris this month in search of the same thing: normal Games.

Because normalcy, at the Olympics, is grandeur. It is the distinct cocktail of sound and color produced by the gathering of more than 200 national teams and millions of fans. It is athletes climbing into the stands to celebrate with family and friends, or to be consoled by them. It is crowds cheering for sports they do not typically watch.

All of this was missing at the coronavirus-delayed Summer Games in Tokyo in 2021 and the Winter Games in Beijing a year later. Both were sequestered from society and almost entirely denuded of life and fervor.

The International Olympic Committee and its member nations keenly understood all that was lost. They have sensed an opportunity in Paris to restore that Olympic feeling, to re-establish how the Games should look and feel and to welcome back commercial partners and fans.

“The tone is completely different,” said Sarah Hirshland, the chief executive of the United States Olympic and Paralympic Committee. “We now have permission to have fun.”

The merrymaking had a head start on Wednesday, two days before the opening ceremony, with the Games’ soft opening: a small slate of soccer and rugby matches around the country.

It was merely an appetizer, but in a single sun-splashed afternoon at the Stade de France, just north of the capital, the Paris Games became everything the Tokyo Olympics were not.

The stands were jammed and rippling with energy, particularly when the host, France, grappled to a draw with the United States in a rugby sevens match. Flags were waved. Slogans were chanted: “Allez les Bleus!”

Stephen Tomasin, 29, a member of the U.S. team, was one of many athletes on Wednesday who were awe-struck by the atmosphere in the stadium, which holds more than 80,000 spectators.

“It’s what you dream about: a packed stadium in an Olympic opener,” he said. “It doesn’t get much better than this.”

It has been almost a decade since this sort of pomp was seen at the Summer Games. The Tokyo Olympics were a shell of the normal spectacle, with eerily quiet venues and muted celebrations. The Winter Games in Beijing several months later unfolded largely behind barbed wire, in what Chinese organizers called a “closed loop” and one athlete called “sports prison.” The biggest sporting event in the world had never felt so small.

But competitors at those pandemic Games were just as rueful about missing the subtle elements, like the spontaneous camaraderie of the athletes’ village or the presence of family to celebrate or commiserate in some of the most emotional moments of the athletes’ careers.

“The cafeteria in Tokyo was humongous,” said Luis Grijalva, 25, a Guatemalan long-distance runner competing in Paris. “Sitting there, when it was empty, it felt like eating in a warehouse.”

The American weight lifter Jourdan Delacruz, 26, described the Tokyo Games in one word: isolating. She recalled falling far short of her expectations in competition and finding no one to lean on. Her favorite memory of that summer, she said, was seeing her friends and family at the airport after a lonely flight back to the United States.

“I got to still have a good Olympic experience,” she said of the reunion, “just not at the Olympics.”

She wants to perform better in Paris, of course, but she also wants to experience the Olympics as they are meant to be experienced. She wants to wave to screaming fans at the opening and closing ceremonies. She wants to attend other events and befriend athletes from different sports and far-flung nations. She wants to linger and explore the city — and not alone.

“I have a lot of friends and family coming to Paris ,” she said. “Like, a lot.”

Paris organizers announced this month that 8.6 million tickets had been sold, breaking the record of 8.3 million set at the Atlanta Games in 1996. They expect that figure to rise before the Games end on Aug. 11.

After the alienation of two pandemic Games, the Paris Olympics will be woven into the very fabric of the city, with a grandiose opening ceremony that will snake along the Seine on Friday and events at iconic sites like the Eiffel Tower, the Grand Palais and the Palace of Versailles.

“Paris 2024 is a reset for the Olympic brand,” said Terrence Burns, a longtime Olympic marketing consultant.

Even before the pandemic, Mr. Burns said, the image of the Games had faltered, plagued by political tensions, doping scandals and less-than-inspiring locales.

Television ratings for the Games have slumped in the United States since the 2016 Olympics in Rio de Janeiro. Burns said one had to look back to London in 2012 to find “the last truly globally successful Summer Games in a destination city.”

Paris could be the next one, and Olympic leaders do not want to squander the opportunity.

Hirshland, the president of the U.S.O.P.C., said there were serious implications this summer for every national Olympic committee but particularly for her own: The next Summer Games will be in Los Angeles in 2028. She said the resumption of a normal Olympic cycle would translate directly to revenue.

“Interest and engagement from the consumer drives every dollar we make in some capacity, whether it’s a commercial sponsor, a broadcast-rights deal or even a philanthropic donor,” she said. “And as a result, the stakes are higher for us.”

But Hirshland was just as focused on reviving the experience for fans and athletes.

Among the most enthusiastic will be Davis-Woodhall, 25, the long jumper, who said the Paris Games had been on her “dream board” since the misery of her time in Tokyo.

When she claps on the purple track this summer at the Stade de France, she hopes tens of thousands of people in the crowd will clap back. When she jumps, she wants to give them a reason to roar. And afterward, she will change into her signature cowboy boots, strut around the track and, if all goes well, luxuriate in their love.

“Now I get to live out my moment,” she said.

Rory Smith and Talya Minsberg contributed reporting.

In Japan, Turning the Tables on Rude Customers

The guests arrived 30 minutes before check-in time at a traditional hot springs inn a couple of hours north of Tokyo. When they saw a sign asking that customers wait in their cars, they demanded to know why they could not get their room key early.

The exchange, captured on a security camera, quickly exploded into angry shouting. Eventually it ended on the pavement out front — with the inn’s managing director down on his knees, bowing deeply and apologizing.

The incident was an extreme example of what has increasingly come to be known in Japan as “kasuhara,” an Anglicized abbreviation of “customer harassment.”

While no country is immune to such behavior, expectations for service — and the potential for dissatisfaction — are especially high in Japan, where a famous expression exalts the customer as a god. The tradition of hospitality is such that retail clerks in upscale stores bow to customers on their way out the door, and waiters, baristas and hotel clerks use honorific Japanese when serving.

Whether the abusive incidents are actually increasing is difficult to assess. But after the pandemic’s upheavals, company officials, labor unions and even the government are focusing on the perceived scourge of customer harassment. The push is all the more urgent as labor shortages have given workers more options to walk away if they feel mistreated.

“The mind-set has changed,” said Mami Tamura, a member of Parliament who is pressing for a law that would hold employers accountable for protecting their workers from customer abuse. “Now fewer business operators think the customer is a god.”

Examples that have shown up in the Japanese media have given rise to a sense that customers have finally gone too far.

A diner at a ramen shop northeast of Tokyo dumped 500 toothpicks into his noodles in protest when the owner could not keep up with constant demands for fresh toppings. The customer proceeded to deluge another branch of the restaurant with so many crank calls that the owner called the police, and a court fined the caller.

A viral video showed an enraged bus rider who caused a 25-minute delay as he berated the driver as an “idiot” because he was dissatisfied with seating options. A dashcam video, posted by a taxi company, showed a passenger ordering a driver to apologize repeatedly for slightly overshooting a destination, making her cry.

Based on surveys by the Labor Ministry and one of Japan’s largest labor unions, anywhere from one in 10 to as many as half of workers have experienced some form of harassment by a customer.

In response to such behavior, some companies and service providers have started posting signs warning customers against mistreating workers. They are drawing up rules to guide staff on what is considered a legitimate complaint and what is simply unacceptable behavior that can be rebuffed.

Some employers have removed surnames from name tags to protect employees from doxxing on social media. SoftBank, the technology giant, is developing an “emotion canceling” voice alteration service that call centers can use to tone down the blast of anger from incoming complaints.

Customers believe “they deserve higher-quality service,” said Shino Naito, an associate professor of labor law and a member of an expert panel advising the Tokyo Metropolitan Government on an ordinance that would officially ban customer harassment. “Their expectation level needs to be lowered.”

Defining — much less prohibiting — customer harassment can be difficult in Japan, where service staff have traditionally been expected to tolerate any interaction with customers, even indignant ones. Workers are quick to apologize for any perceived transgression, such as when conductors beg forgiveness if a train is late, or even if it leaves a few seconds early.

Such standards of service can come with a rigidity that frustrates customers.

“The Japanese have the attention to detail, and it’s the envy of the tourism and hospitality world,” said Benjamin Altschuler, an associate professor of sport, tourism and hospitality management who is currently teaching at Temple University’s campus in Tokyo. “But there’s an inflexibility as well.”

Customers may harass employees because they themselves have been abused by bosses or clients in Japan’s often harsh work environments. They need to “take it out on someone,” said Masayuki Kiriu, a professor of sociology at Toyo University who has studied customer harassment.

Workers for JR East, which operates commuter train lines around Tokyo, say they regularly experience verbal abuse from drunk late-night passengers confused about where to transfer or angry that their fare passes or cellphone apps aren’t working.

“I feel like if they don’t get their complaints out with us,” said Takami Matsumoto, who works at a ticket gate, “then they will have to carry them home.”

Until recently, he said, managers told workers that any complaints were their fault.

“The company would just believe the customer when they said I had done something bad,” Mr. Matsumoto said.

JR East said in an emailed statement that it provided “support” for workers suffering from mental health issues through “workplace managers and industrial physicians” and was considering guidelines on “how to deal with customer harassment in the future.”

In 2022, the labor ministry issued a manual describing what qualifies as customer harassment. Examples include “threatening with hints of exposure on social media or the mass media,” “screaming loudly in the store” and “excessive demands for equipment” — such as requesting 10 toothbrushes at a hotel. At the end of last year, the government revised a 1948 law so that lodging operators can now refuse customers who harass hotel employees.

UA Zensen, a union that represents textile, chemical, food and general services workers, has lobbied the government to develop regulations requiring all employers to protect staff from customer harassment. Such a law would be similar to those that make employers responsible for safeguarding workers from sexual harassment or managerial abuse.

Some employers, facing difficulties hiring and retaining young workers, have already taken action.

“Younger workers have learned that they no longer have to tolerate certain behaviors,” said Naoki Ishikawa, a crisis management chief at city hall in Utsunomiya, about 80 miles north of Tokyo. Visitors there are barred from taking photos or videos inside the building, and starting this summer, only the surnames of staff appear on name tags.

Yuji Tanaka, the managing director at Yumori Tanakaya, the traditional Japanese inn where the early arrivals verbally abused the staff, said he wanted to preserve Japan’s “unique” service culture.

But after the recent incident, he took the security camera footage and reported the couple to the police, who told him there was not much they could do. He says he has flashbacks to the moment where he got down on his knees to apologize. Viewers who saw clips of the episode on the news have called to badger him about the size of his lobby or to protest the rule asking guests to wait in their cars.

People “just assume that service workers should do whatever they want,” Mr. Tanaka said. But there are limits: “I also want the other person to respect the service workers.”

Kiuko Notoya contributed reporting from Tokyo.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

Scandal Hits U.K.’s ‘Strictly Come Dancing,’ the Original ‘Dancing With the Stars’

For almost two decades, viewers in Britain have watched celebrities jive, waltz and cha-cha-cha on “Strictly Come Dancing,” a BBC reality television show that inspired the international “Dancing With the Stars” franchise.

The format, which has been licensed to 61 other territories including the U.S., pairs professional ballroom dancers with people who are famous in other fields, from athletics and acting to politics and journalism. The amateur dancers then train intensively with their professional partners and compete in weekly live performances.

Introduced in 2004, the show quickly became one of the BBC’s most popular programs, widely loved as a glitzy, family-friendly watch on weekends.

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.