The New York Times 2024-08-29 00:10:33


Live Updates: At Least 10 Killed as Israel Begins Major Military Operation in West Bank

Pinned

Aaron Boxerman

Reporting from Jerusalem

Here are the latest developments.

Hundreds of Israeli troops mounted major overnight raids in the occupied West Bank, Israeli officials said Wednesday, targeting Palestinian militants after what they called months of rising attacks. At least 10 people were killed, and an Israeli military official said the operation was continuing.

The operation was concentrated in Jenin and Tulkarm, two cities that have become militant strongholds, Lt. Col. Nadav Shoshani, an Israeli military spokesman, told reporters. A Palestinian armed group based in Jenin said that it had fired on Israeli forces in two villages on the city’s outskirts, and Palestinian residents in both cities described hearing intermittent gunfire.

The operation followed months of escalating Israeli raids in the occupied territory, where nearly three million Palestinians live under Israeli military rule. Israel has arrested thousands of Palestinians suspected of involvement in armed groups since the Hamas-led Oct. 7 attacks, an increasingly deadly campaign that has unfolded alongside its war against Hamas in Gaza.

Despite the toll in the West Bank — more than 580 Palestinians have been killed since Oct. 7, according to the United Nations, in violence involving both the Israeli military and extremist Jewish settlers — the raids have failed to tamp down the armed groups. They have also further immiserated Palestinian civilians in the territory, who saw Israeli bulldozers tear up roads early Wednesday and feared being caught in the crossfire.

The raids on Wednesday appeared to be the largest since July 2023, when about 1,000 Israeli soldiers carried out a 48-hour incursion in Jenin that killed 12 Palestinians, at least nine of whom militant groups claimed as members.

Palestinian officials said the Israeli operation included drone strikes. Troops also operated farther east in the Far’a neighborhood, conducting an aerial strike that killed four militants, the Israeli authorities said.

Here is what else to know:

  • Gunfire and explosions: Kamal Abu al-Rub, the Palestinian governor of Jenin, said the Israeli incursion was unusually fierce, with the sounds of gunfire and blasts intermittently resounding through the city. Israeli officials had informed their Palestinian counterparts that they were imposing a formal curfew on parts of the city and that soldiers had surrounded Jenin’s hospitals, entrances and exits, he said, adding: “People are living in a state of terror and anxiety.”

  • Iranian smuggling: The raid comes as U.S., Israeli and Iranian officials have said that Tehran is trying to flood the West Bank with weapons. The covert operation, employing intelligence operatives, militants and criminal gangs, has heightened concerns that Iran is seeking to turn the territory into another flashpoint in its longstanding conflict with Israel, The New York Times reported in April.

  • Settler violence: While the Israeli military cited rising Palestinian violence, extremist Israelis have also stepped up attacks against Palestinian civilians in the West Bank. Many escape legal accountability for the mob attacks, some of which turn deadly. This month, a 23-year-old Palestinian was killed when dozens of Israeli settlers attacked the town of Jit in the northern West Bank.

  • Jenin a symbol: The city is synonymous with Palestinian rebellion, the source of dozens of suicide bombers who were sent into Israel during the second intifada, or uprising, against the Israeli occupation in the early 2000s. More recently, the impoverished city has been a hotbed for recruiting by Hamas and the militant group Islamic Jihad, as well as newer militias that have emerged among a disaffected younger generation. Israeli officials say that more than 50 shooting attacks on Israelis have emanated from the Jenin area this year.

The Palestinian Health Ministry announced that a Palestinian was killed by Israeli fire in Kufr Dan, a town on the outskirts of Jenin, raising the overall death toll from the Israeli operation to 10.

The Israeli operation follows months of often deadly raids in the West Bank.

Since Hamas’s surprise Oct. 7 attack on Israel, which killed about 1,200 people, more than 580 Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank, according to the United Nations, as Israel has ramped up military raids there and violence by extremist Jewish settlers has increased.

Many Palestinians have died in Jenin or its refugee camp, long strongholds of the armed groups Hamas and Islamic Jihad; in Tulkarm, a West Bank city near the Israeli border; and in the nearby Nur Shams neighborhood. On Wednesday, the Israeli military said it had begun a raid focusing on Jenin and Tulkarm, and that nine people it described as militants had been killed.

Here are some of the notable recent Israeli military operations in the territory:

July 3-5, 2023: Israel launched its largest military operation in years against armed groups in the West Bank, a raid meant to curb attacks by armed Palestinians on Israelis. Israel carried out deadly airstrikes, which had not happened there in about two decades.

Twelve Palestinians were killed during the operation, which involved about 1,000 Israeli soldiers. Militant groups claimed at least nine of them as members. One Israeli soldier was also killed, possibly mistakenly by a fellow soldier. Thousands of people fled their homes and Israel detained and interrogated many others. Here are pictures of the raid.

Oct. 19, 2023: At least 13 Palestinians and one Israeli officer were killed in clashes, less than two weeks after the Hamas-led attacks in southern Israel. At least five of the 13 Palestinians were children.

The worst clashes were in Nur Shams. Israel’s military said that it was “thwarting terrorist infrastructure and confiscating weapons” in the operation — and that Palestinians had fought back, shooting and throwing improvised bombs.

Dec. 12-14, 2023: An Israeli raid killed at least 12 people during a two-and-a-half-day incursion in Jenin. A 13-year-old was pronounced dead at a hospital after his father carried him there, according to the medical charity Doctors Without Borders, which said Israeli armored cars had blocked ambulances.

At least 34 other people were injured. The Palestinian Prisoners Club, a rights group, said that at least 100 Palestinians had been arrested.

Israel disciplined three soldiers for a video showing some of them singing a Jewish prayer in a mosque in Jenin during the raid. The footage had circulated widely online.

Jan. 7, 2024: At least nine Palestinians and an Israeli officer were killed during a day of violence. A drone strike killed seven men in pre-dawn clashes during an incursion into Jenin. Four were brothers, aged 22 to 29, the Palestinian Authority’s official news agency, Wafa, said.

Israeli soldiers killed an eighth man in the central West Bank, Palestinian health officials said. And a 3-year-old girl was killed, apparently by errant fire, when Israeli forces said they shot at a car that rammed a checkpoint near Jerusalem.

The Israeli border police officer was killed when a bomb blew up her military vehicle.

Jan. 30, 2024: Israeli soldiers raided a hospital and fatally shot a Hamas commander in a patient’s room. During the brief incursion, some of the soldiers were wearing medical garb, surveillance footage showed, as they brandished their guns in the hospital. Two other men were also killed in the shooting.

Experts said the raid raised questions because hospitals have special protection under international laws of war.

April 20, 2024: Israeli soldiers killed at least 10 people at the Nur Shams camp, the military said, in what it described as a “counterterrorism operation.” Palestinian officials said that at least 14 people had died, including a 15-year-old boy.

The next day, Palestinians in the West Bank went on a general strike in protest: Shops, schools, universities, banks and public transit were closed or stopped.

The Israeli military said it would allow residents of Nur Shams, a focal point of its operation in Tulkarm in the West Bank, to “safely leave the area” should they choose to do so. It said it was not ordering them to evacuate.

Palestinians we are speaking to in Jenin and Tulkarm describe hearing intermittent gunfire, which they believe to be clashes between Israeli forces and Palestinian militants. A local Palestinian armed group based in Jenin said on Telegram that it was engaging Israeli forces in two villages on the city’s outskirts. The Israeli operation that began on Wednesday morning included drone strikes, according to Palestinian officials.

Jenin, a focus of the raids, is a symbol of rebellion for Palestinians.

Jenin, a focal point of Israel’s wide-ranging raid into the West Bank on Wednesday, is a potent symbol of rebellion and militancy for Palestinians after decades of fighting against occupying powers.

That history dates back to British rule of Palestine during what was known as the Arab Revolt of the 1930s, and through the 1948 Arab-Israeli war surrounding the creation of the modern Israel and triggered the flight or expulsion of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians.

But Jenin’s resonance today, both for Palestinians and Israelis, largely stems from the second intifada, or uprising, against the Israeli occupation in the early 2000s.

Israelis remember Jenin, which sits in the rolling hillsides of the northern West Bank, as a source of dozens of suicide bombers sent into Israel at that time.

Palestinians remember a 10-day battle, known as the Battle of Jenin, in 2002 between Palestinian militants and Israeli forces. Israel killed 52 people, of which up to half may have been civilians, according to the United Nations in a report on the event. The fighting killed 23 Israeli soldiers.

Yasir Arafat, the late Palestinian leader, dubbed the camp “Jeningrad,” a reference to the Battle of Stalingrad in World War II.

Palestinian officials called the Israeli assault a massacre — a claim that was rejected by the United Nations in its report, though it criticized both sides as putting Palestinian civilians at risk. Nonetheless, the attack is widely remembered as such to Palestinians.

During the period of British administration, Jenin was a stronghold of rebellion against colonial rule and the wave of Jewish immigration to Palestine. British forces blew up a quarter of the town in 1938 after one of their officers there was killed.

In the wake of the 1948 war, Jenin became known as a town that never surrendered, after Palestinian fighters, backed by Iraqi soldiers, repelled an Israeli attempt to take Jenin.

It also was home to one of the original refugee camps set up for Palestinians displaced by that war. Although all of these sites are still called “camps” to recognize the displacement of the residents’ ancestors, the areas are actually ramshackle neighborhoods of apartment blocks and roads, usually of poor quality.

In more recent years, the Jenin refugee camp has frequently been a target for raids by Israeli forces. In addition to widespread violence in Jenin, the camp is considered by the United Nations to have the highest rates of unemployment and poverty in the West Bank.

Both Hamas, which controls Gaza, and the militant group Islamic Jihad have recruited in Jenin. But in recent years, the ranks of the militants have been joined by newer, loosely affiliated militias that emerged among a younger generation that is frustrated with a Palestinian leadership they see as corrupt and enabling of the Israeli occupation.

Israeli officials say that more than 50 shooting attacks on Israelis have emanated from the Jenin area this year. Violence has surged in the West Bank amid Israel’s war in Gaza. Israeli forces say they are fighting off efforts to move arms into the West Bank, but Jewish settlers have also escalated attacks and expanded settlements.

Palestinian officials have denounced the Israeli operation. Hamas accused Israel of expanding its war in Gaza to the occupied West Bank and said the international community was letting it happen. The Palestinian Authority, which administers parts of the West Bank in coordination with Israel, also condemned it. Israel’s actions were leading to “disastrous consequences for which everyone will pay the price,” said Nabil Abu Rudeineh, a spokesman for the Palestinian Authority president, Mahmoud Abbas.

Kamal Abu al-Rub, the Palestinian governor of Jenin, said Israeli officials had informed their Palestinian counterparts that they were imposing a formal curfew on parts of the city. Israeli forces were surrounding the city’s hospitals, entrances, and exits, he said. “People are living in a state of terror and anxiety,” Abu al-Rub said.

‘We are in the first stages of this operation,’ an Israeli military spokesman says.

The Israeli military said on Wednesday that an unusually wide-scale operation in the northern part of the occupied West Bank had only just begun as Israeli troops raided two major Palestinian cities there in an effort to crush militant groups.

“We are in the first stages of this operation,” Lt. Col. Nadav Shoshani, an Israeli military spokesman, told a news briefing.

Israeli forces launched the unusually large military raids, focusing on the cities, Jenin and Tulkarm, after months during which Palestinian militants resisted Israeli efforts to subdue them in the territory.

Both cities have seen deadly battles between Israeli troops and Palestinian militants. Colonel Shoshani said that more than 150 “shooting and explosive attacks” against Israelis had originated in the two cities over the past year, including an attempted bombing in mid-August in the coastal metropolis of Tel Aviv.

Since the Hamas-led Oct. 7 attacks prompted full-blown war in Gaza, Israeli forces have stepped up raids in the West Bank, targeting what it says are Hamas and allied groups. More than 500 Palestinians have been killed, including both militants and civilians; at least 4,500 have been arrested, according to the Israeli military.

In the operation announced on Wednesday, nine militants were killed, the Israeli military said; Colonel Shoshani said that at least seven had been killed in aerial attacks. The West Bank once rarely saw bombardments by Israeli drones, but they, too, have become commonplace since Oct. 7.

Another Israeli security official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the matter, said that roughly hundreds of soldiers were participating in the operation. In Jenin, Israeli forces deployed near a major hospital, stoking fears that they might raid it. Colonel Shoshani argued that the military was trying to prevent the hospital from becoming a haven for militants.

Israeli officials have long said that militants have planted improvised explosive devices in an attempt to blow up Israeli soldiers as they drive along roads in Palestinian towns. Colonel Shoshani said that Israeli troops had worked overnight to disarm the explosives, deploying combat engineers specialized in dismantling them.

During another major raid in Jenin last year, scores of Palestinians fled their homes temporarily as Israeli troops pursued people suspected of being militants. Colonel Shoshani said there were currently no plans to order the evacuation of residents. Earlier, Israel’s foreign minister had raised the prospect of temporarily ordering residents to evacuate as the military operation goes on.

“If people wish to leave, they can leave,” Colonel Shoshani told reporters. “But I am not aware of a plan of evacuation or something like that.”

Patrick Kingsley contributed reporting.

Surveillance video posted on social media and shared by the Reuters news agency shows military vehicles driving down a street in Jenin, in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, just before 1 a.m. local time on Wednesday.

Iran has smuggled arms to the West Bank to foment unrest, officials say.

The Israeli military’s West Bank raid comes as U.S., Israeli and Iranian officials have said that Tehran is operating a clandestine smuggling route across the Middle East to deliver weapons to Palestinians in the Israeli-occupied territory.

The goal, as described by three Iranian officials, has been to foment unrest against Israel by flooding the enclave with as many weapons as it can, The New York Times reported in April.

The covert operation, employing intelligence operatives, militants and criminal gangs, has heightened concerns that Iran is seeking to turn the West Bank into another flashpoint in its longstanding conflict with Israel.

Israel’s foreign minister, Israel Katz, said on Wednesday that its military was operating in the West Bank “to thwart Islamic-Iranian terrorist infrastructures,” adding: “Iran is working to establish an eastern terrorist front against Israel in the West Bank, according to the Gaza and Lebanon model.”

Many weapons smuggled to the West Bank largely travel along two paths from Iran through Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Israel, the officials said. As the arms cross borders, the officials added, they change hands among a multinational cast that can include members of organized criminal gangs, extremist militants, soldiers and intelligence operatives. A key group in the operation, the Iranian officials and analysts said, are Bedouin smugglers who carry the weapons across the border from Jordan into Israel.

“The Iranians wanted to flood the West Bank with weapons, and they were using criminal networks in Jordan, in the West Bank and in Israel, primarily Bedouin, to move and sell the products,” said Matthew Levitt, director of the counterterrorism program at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, a research organization, and the author of a study on the smuggling route.

Lt. Col. Nadav Shoshani, an Israeli military spokesman, said at a news briefing that there were currently no plans to order the evacuation of residents from Jenin or Tulkarm in the West Bank. “If people wish to leave, they can leave,” he said. “But I am not aware of a plan of evacuation or something like that.” Earlier, Israel’s foreign minister had raised the prospect of temporarily relocating residents as the military operation goes on.

Israeli forces have begun an unusually broad operation in the West Bank, focusing on Jenin and Tulkarm, the military announced. The Israeli military said in a statement that its troops had killed nine Palestinian militants in clashes across the West Bank. Israeli troops have escalated their raids of Palestinian cities and towns across the occupied territory since Oct. 7, arresting thousands.

Israeli forces carry out raids in the West Bank.

Israel’s military carried out raids and aerial strikes in the occupied West Bank on Wednesday in a wide-scale operation that appeared to cover a large part of the territory. The Palestinian Health Ministry said at least nine people had been killed in the attacks, and Israel’s foreign minister suggested that some residents of the West Bank would need to evacuate their homes.

The foreign minister, Israel Katz, said Israel’s military had started an operation in Jenin and Tulkarm to thwart terrorist groups. “We must deal with the threat just as we deal with the terrorist infrastructure in Gaza, including the temporary evacuation of Palestinian residents and whatever steps are required,” he posted on social media.

The comments suggested the start of a significant escalation in Israel’s military campaign in the West Bank, which has ramped up since the war in Gaza began. While 90 percent of Gaza’s population of more than two million people have been forced to leave their homes, residents of the West Bank have not endured the scale of bombardments, raids and evacuation orders that Gazans have in the past 10 months of war.

The Israeli military said it was carrying out counterterrorism operations in Tulkarm and in Jenin, without providing details. The operations appeared to be occurring elsewhere in the West Bank as well. The Palestinian Health Ministry said that seven of the people had been killed in Tubas, in addition to two in Jenin, and that 11 others had been injured.

Wafa, the Palestinian Authority’s official news agency, said that Israeli troops had moved in on hospitals, hindering ambulances at one medical facility, and were bulldozing infrastructure in Jenin and Tulkarm.

Israeli forces blocked access in and out of Jenin and Tulkarm early Wednesday, and large numbers of military vehicles entered Jenin, Wafa reported.

On Monday, the Israeli military carried out an airstrike on the densely populated Nur Shams area in the West Bank, killing at least five people whom it described in a statement on Wednesday as terrorists. The military said that one of those killed in that strike was a man who had been released in November in the prisoner exchange that was part of the weeklong cease-fire with Hamas in Gaza.

Since the war in Gaza began last Oct. 7, more than 600 Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank, according to the United Nations. The U.N. humanitarian coordinator also said Israeli forces had demolished, confiscated or forced the demolition of more than 1,400 structures across the West Bank since then.

With Hezbollah-Israel Conflict Contained, Iran’s Next Move May Be Modest

New

Listen to this article · 8:38 min Learn more

Erika Solomon

As rockets and missiles streaked across Lebanese and Israeli skies on Sunday, the moment people across the region lived in fear of seemed as if it might have arrived: all-out war.

But very quickly, Israel and the Lebanese militia Hezbollah wrapped up their exchange, with both claiming victory and signaling that the fighting — for now, at least — was done.

That ambiguous result, however, revealed something: Neither Hezbollah nor its regional patron, Iran, has found a better way to respond to embarrassing Israeli strikes in a way that could both warn Israel off another attack, yet not provoke an even bigger war that could be devastating for them.

Iran’s response — if it comes — remains an unknown, and Tehran could still choose a course of action that regional observers have not predicted. But Hezbollah’s choice to stick to a limited attack is an option some regional experts now think may reflect plans from Iran, as it considers how to settle its own score with Israel.

“The Iranians keep dropping hints about striking a target with precision,” said Mohammed Ali Shabani, an Iran analyst and editor of an independent regional website, Amwaj.media. “Precision and proportion is now key to how we look at this.”

Just a few weeks ago, the region was — once again — in an extraordinarily precarious position, months after Israel launched its deadly Gaza war in response to the Hamas-led Oct. 7 attacks.

The latest round of Middle East brinkmanship began last month, when Israel blamed Hezbollah for a rocket that struck a soccer field and killed children in the Israeli-controlled Golan Heights. Hezbollah denied responsibility.

Then Israel launched a retributive escalation that quickly set the entire region on edge.

On July 30, Israel struck Lebanon’s capital, Beirut, to kill one of Hezbollah’s top commanders, Fuad Shukr. Hours later, an explosion killed Hamas’s top political leader, Ismail Haniyeh, in Tehran, where he was attending the inauguration of Iran’s new president.

The Haniyeh assassination, which both Hamas and Iran blame on Israel, was an extreme provocation for Iran’s leaders.

“If Israel can get away with killing Iranian allies in the middle of Tehran, there is no safe haven for Iranian leadership anywhere. That signal of weakness to opponents, at home and abroad, is intolerable for Iranian leaders,” said Ali Vaez, the Iran project director at the International Crisis Group. “Their dilemma was that there is no way that objective can be achieved at a low cost, and many ways in which it can backfire.”

Yet not responding, he said, is as much an existential threat as the risks of retaliation.

Part of what complicated any response for Iran was that it had already flexed its military muscle in response to an apparent Israeli strike in April that successfully targeted its embassy compound in Damascus, Syria. Back then, Tehran responded by firing a barrage of over 300 missiles and armed drones at Israel — but appeared to telegraph that attack well in advance, offering Israel and the United States an opportunity to prepare air defenses and down nearly everything that was fired.

For weeks, the concern among regional leaders and experts was less that Iran and Hezbollah wanted war, and more that their best option for a dramatic retaliation was deploying a coordinated regional show of force with other Iran-backed militant groups in Yemen and Iraq. Such a move could have resulted in a far less predictable outcome than intended by those who would have carried it out — such as hitting a site with a large number of civilians, which would have spurred Israel to jump further up the escalation ladder.

Hezbollah, which has been branded a terrorist group by Washington and is the most powerful militia supported by Iran, would have been critical to any such coordinated response.

Hezbollah’s move to act first and alone signals that option was likely ruled out, regional experts said. Hassan Nasrallah, the leader of Hezbollah, said in a speech after Sunday’s attack that “people can take a breath and relax.”

For Hezbollah, risking all-out war had a high political cost: With Lebanon still reeling from a devastating economic crisis and a yearslong political vacuum, it faces intense pressure from other segments of society not to drag the country deeper into crisis. And tens of thousands of Hezbollah’s own supporters in southern Lebanon have been driven from their homes by near-daily Israeli strikes.

Hezbollah’s critics mocked the response, sharing photos of Israeli firefighters extinguishing a fire at a chicken farm that was struck. “Sayyed Hassan has set a new equation for the Zionist enemy: We will respond to the killing of every Hezbollah fighter with the killing of a chicken,” one Twitter account posted, referring to Mr. Nasrallah.

Regardless of how Hezbollah’s response is assessed in Tehran, regional diplomats pointed to several recent comments by Iranian leaders, released shortly before and after Hezbollah’s strikes, that hint at an impending, but probably targeted and limited, retaliation.

Last week, when Hossein Salami, the commander in chief of the Revolutionary Guards Corps, visited pilgrims who were chanting slogans to avenge Mr. Haniyeh’s death, he replied, “You will hear good news about revenge, God willing.”

Shortly after Hezbollah’s strikes, Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, told students at a gathering that a response “does not always mean taking up arms; rather, it means thinking correctly, speaking properly, understanding things accurately and striking the target with precision.”

Experts say, however, that these recent comments hint that Iran’s response will look less like what it did in April — though that cannot be ruled out — and more like a targeted attack.

Tehran’s main calculation is finding a response that does not risk pulling in the United States, whose warships have deployed around the region.

“The Iranians got cold feet,” said Gen. Kenneth F. McKenzie Jr., the former head of the Pentagon’s Central Command, which oversees Middle East operations. General McKenzie said that Iran would possibly retaliate by striking “a soft target” — one not heavily protected — such as an embassy or other facility in Europe, Africa or South America.

And Iranian leaders are also likely to delay any response as long as talks are ongoing to broker a cease-fire in the Gaza Strip, some U.S. officials said.

Some regional experts also pointed to intense diplomatic efforts over the prospect of negotiations on lifting sanctions.

“Iran is very pragmatic and of course has been wondering how to capitalize on this” effort by Western diplomats, Maha Yahya, director of the Carnegie Middle East Center in Beirut, said in an interview.

Mr. Khamenei, in comments viewed as underscoring a desire to renew talks with the West, said on Tuesday that there was “no barrier” to renewing negotiations over Iran’s nuclear program.

Mr. Shabani, the Iran analyst, said that by showing pragmatism and regularly projecting their thinking in advance, both Mr. Nasrallah and Mr. Khamenei may ironically have dulled their main edge against a nation far superior in intelligence prowess and military might.

“The problem for both Khamenei and Nasrallah is that the Israelis know they are logical now,” he said. “When you give away that you are not so unpredictable, it contributes to Israel’s escalation dominance.”

Some regional diplomats, however, acknowledge that even as Hezbollah and Iran look weaker today, there are ways in which Iran and its allies have already imposed a heavier toll on Israel.

By appearing to signal they have let the Gaza cease-fire negotiations take precedence — talks widely seen as being stymied by Mr. Netanyahu — they could find an opportunity to erode relations between Israel and its Western allies, diplomats warned. Like the Lebanese in the south, Israel’s own citizens, too, are unable to return home — and are growing increasingly frustrated with their government.

“For 75 years, we were the ones being displaced and the Israelis remained in their colonies,” Mr. Nasrallah told his followers last month. “Our homes were demolished, their colonies remained; our factories were burned, and their factories remained. Now, that has all changed.”

Hwaida Saad contributed reporting from Beirut and Eric Schmitt from Washington.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

U.S., Chinese Officials Discuss Future Talks Between Biden and Xi

Want to stay updated on what’s happening in China? , and we’ll send our latest coverage to your inbox.

Senior American and Chinese officials meeting in Beijing discussed plans for a call between President Biden and China’s top leader, Xi Jinping, as well as talks between their military commanders in the region, as the two countries work to stabilize relations.

The White House said in a statement after the talks on Wednesday that the countries were “planning for a leader-level call in the coming weeks.”

Jake Sullivan, President Biden’s national security adviser, and Wang Yi, China’s top foreign policy official, met for nearly 11 hours on Tuesday and Wednesday along with their aides, the fifth round of negotiations in less than 18 months between the two top officials.

The Biden administration has sought to smooth over tensions with China while continuing to turn up the pressure on China by curbing its access to the U.S. economy and technology. The meetings between Mr. Sullivan and Mr. Wang, following talks between Mr. Biden and Mr. Xi last November in California, are also aimed at showing that the rival powers can manage their differences.

Mr. Sullivan and Mr. Wang met at a lakefront resort in the mountains on the northern outskirts of Beijing, near the Great Wall.

One big question in the discussions is whether or when the two leaders might talk in the coming months. They are running out of time to schedule the next meeting as Mr. Biden is preparing to leave office in January.

The Chinese statement was less specific about further contacts. It said that the two countries would, “maintain high-level exchanges and communication at all levels.”

Both sides said they had agreed to a video call between their top military commanders in the region. The United States said that such a call would be held in the “near future,” but China was more noncommittal, saying that it would take place “at an appropriate time.” Admiral Dong Jun, China’s defense minister, met Secretary of Defense Lloyd J. Austin III in May in Singapore.

The United States has long sought more contact between the two countries’ militaries, in the hope that improved links might reduce the risk of miscommunication in case of a future crisis. Worries about possible miscommunication or escalation during a conflict have increased as China has deployed military forces ever closer to longtime American partners in the region like Taiwan, Japan and the Philippines.

But while the two sides did agree on an initial call, they did not establish the ongoing line of high-level communication between the two countries’ militaries that the Biden administration has sought. And the statements issued by both sides underlined that many other differences remain.

Each side used identical language describing the discussions as “candid, substantive, and constructive.” But the Chinese statement emphasized Beijing’s unhappiness with American export controls and its stance on Taiwan, an island democracy that China claims as its territory.

The White House statement said American officials urged China to work together to fight narcotics that end up on the streets in the United States, and raised concerns over the detention of American citizens in the country.

American officials are scheduled to hold further talks with other top officials in downtown Beijing on Thursday.

Brad Setser, a former Biden administration and Obama administration economic policy maker, said that the two countries appeared to have made more progress on security issues than on the many economic disputes that divide them. The United States has been pressing China to slow its very heavy investments lately in new factories, contending that this will cause overcapacity. China has denied that overcapacity is a problem.

“The U.S. focus has been on confidence-building measures that limit the risk of a future misunderstanding, and the U.S. certainly welcomes the coming call between ‘theater’ commanders,” Mr. Setser wrote in an email.

In Quebec’s Casse-Croûtes, Fast Food for a Short but Sweet Summer

New

Listen to this article · 7:10 min Learn more

Norimitsu Onishi

Reporting from Gaspé, Quebec

When newcomers to Canada, the Italian couple had discovered along Quebec’s country roads the joys of the casse-croûtes, the food shacks that lie dormant in the frozen landscape during winter and then burst to life during the all-too-short warm months.

And so on a recent afternoon, the couple, Marta Grasso and Andrea La Monaca, sat side by side at a picnic table at one of these shacks, La Mollière, a lobster roll before him and a shrimp roll for her. A large blue sky spread out behind the casse-croûte, built on a promontory over the Gulf of St. Lawrence.

“You can taste the sea,” Ms. Grasso said. “We are from Sicily, so we are used to good, fresh seafood.”

The most famous menu item of Quebec’s casse-croûtes — the dish of French fries layered with cheese curds and gravy known as poutine — has become known far beyond this French-speaking province’s borders, with restaurants as far afield as Seoul specializing in the dish.

But what about the funny-sounding pogo? Or a pinceau, sometimes spelled pinso? And the guédille, whose etymology remains obscure, even though it’s a staple of casse-croûtes?

Clockwise, from top left; chicken poutine from Chez Cathy; a “guédille,” or lobster roll, from La Mollière; a shrimp “guédille,” or shrimp roll, from Chez Cathy, and a club sandwich with fries, a typical menu item from La Mollière.

Ms. Grasso, who now calls Montreal home, was mystified when she first encountered a guédille — a sandwich consisting of a split-top hot-dog bun stuffed with seafood salad, meat or whatever is handy — on a trip three years ago. She was immediately hooked.

Her mother also became a fan during a visit from Italy last year. “She wanted to go eat a guédille every day,” Ms. Grasso said.

Casse-croûtes can be found everywhere across Quebec, many open year round.

But in far-flung areas of the vast province — as in the small towns along the St. Lawrence River or on the Gaspé Peninsula some 600 miles northeast of Montreal — they are typically mom-and-pop operations that open and close with the seasons. The menus, displayed on the exterior walls, offer American-style fast food but with a French Canadian reinterpretation.

“Casse-croûtes are summer,” said Nicole Boulay, a local resident who was eating poutine at La Mollière, in Cap-des-Rosiers, a village that is part of the city of Gaspé. “Winters here are really long.”

Mélanie Grandmont and Pascal Noël bought La Mollière shortly after getting married in 2011, turning what had been an ice cream shop into a full-fledge casse-croûte. They kept the establishment’s name, which referred to its old-fashioned ice cream.

“It’s not written the same way, but it’s also a reference to Molière,” Mr. Noël said of the 17th-century French playwright, adding, perhaps with an overabundance of caution of what customers can expect: “We have nothing to do with Molière.”

The couple are hardly miserly in their use of local products. The strawberries and raspberries on their sundaes came from their gardens. Mr. Noël made sure to secure a steady supply of local shrimp, the small but tasty Nordic kind, whose population has dwindled with the St. Lawrence’s warming waters.

One winter, the couple came to install a new dishwasher in the shack. But a wall of snow in front blocked the entrance.

“We came back in the spring,” Ms. Grandmont said.

La Mollière stirs back to life in May. The owners spend the next five months in a trailer behind the casse-croûte, no days off.

Each casse-croûte boasts of, it seems, its own secret sauce, and the trailer is also where they safeguard the ingredients of their highly classified poutine sauce — a mix of barbecue sauce with ketchup, the recipe for which was handed down by his octogenarian grandfather.

“I prepare it in secret every morning,” Ms. Grandmont said. “I bring over the ingredients to the restaurant and then hide them back in the trailer. The recipe’s in my head.”

Every casse-croûte purports to offer something unique, which is part of the restaurants’ charm, Mr. Noël said.

Casse-croûtes are “time travel machines” in the history of Quebec and the lives of its people, according to “Moutarde Chou,” a book on the establishments.

Quebec’s casse-croûtes first flourished amid the growing prosperity after World War II, said Gwenaëlle Reyt, an expert on the history of food in Quebec at the Université du Québec à Montréal.

“Casse-croûtes emerged with the boom in cars and tourism in Quebec,” Ms. Reyt said.

Although casse-croûtes became a Quebec institution, the influence on them of American fast food and car culture was strong. Burgers and hot dogs became indispensable items.

“The casse-croûtes offered dishes that we never made at home,” said Michel Lambert, an author of several books on the history of family cooking in Quebec who worked at a casse-croûte as a teenager in the 1950s. “That’s why they were considered exotic.”

Over the decades, dishes were reinvented and reimagined inside the modest shacks. Sometimes the transformations seemed more linguistic than culinary. Isn’t a pogo really a corn dog after all? And a guédille au homard is pretty similar to a Maine lobster roll, though it could be argued that the various mutations of the guédille have made it as Québécois as poutine.

At one point, Mr. Lambert researched the sandwich’s etymology.

“I never found the origins of the word guédille,” he said. “I don’t know whether it’s French or Indigenous. Maybe one day we’ll find a historical link to one man.”

At Chez Cathy, a casse-croûte in Rivière-au-Renard, another village in Gaspé city, you can get a pinso, a reinterpretation of the club sandwich. Instead of chicken, it contains ground beef patties.

“It’s one of our popular items,” said Mario Noël, who along with his two sons owns Chez Cathy.

The casse-croûte began offering the sandwich under its longtime previous owner, whose daughter was named Cathy.

“Now many other places offer it,” though elsewhere it was usually spelled “pinceau,” said Mr. Noël, who is not related to his namesake at La Mollière.

When Mr. Noël bought Chez Cathy in 2019, the deal included a secret sauce dating back to the 1960s, as well as the restaurant’s pinso and its top-selling guédilles.

Chez Cathy’s poutine had a rocky start a couple of decades ago.

“In the beginning, they used Kraft cheese instead of cheese curds,” said Danielle Samuel, who has worked at Chez Cathy for 41 years. She shook her head.

By noon on most days, the parking lot at Chez Cathy is filled, but not all the customers were exiting their vehicles; it’s one of the few places that still serve customers by the side of their cars.

For the past nine seasons, Nathalie Dufresne has flitted from car to car, taking orders and returning with food on trays that are hung on the windows.

“The locals stay in their cars, but the tourists get out and come order at the window,” Ms. Dufresne said.

“A car!” Ms. Samuel alerted Ms. Dufresne, spotting the day’s first customer, though it was still morning, as the waitress sprinted outside.

It was Dave Mainville’s day off from his job as an electromechanical technician, and he wanted to spoil himself by starting the day with his favorite, a poutine from Chez Cathy. He had been coming for years and so had his mother, with whom he was planning to share the dish.

“Casse-croûtes are open only a short season, so you want to come as often as you can,” Mr. Mainville said. “You know you won’t be able to get a poutine at Cathy’s in the month of December.”