The New York Times 2024-09-04 12:10:54


Middle East Crisis: Polio Vaccinations in Gaza Are Beating Goals, W.H.O. Says

Top News

The vaccine drive has been more successful than expected, a W.H.O. official says.

The World Health Organization said on Tuesday that the campaign to vaccinate 640,000 children in Gaza against polio had so far been more successful than expected as families flocked to receive the treatment.

Teams of health workers delivered the two-drop oral vaccine to 161,030 children in the first two days of the roughly 10-day operation, surpassing the organization’s goal of 150,000 for the first phase of the campaign in central Gaza.

“It’s going well,” Rik Peeperkorn, the organization’s representative for the Palestinian territories, told reporters by video link from Gaza on Tuesday, describing an “almost festive” atmosphere as families went to designated sites to get their children vaccinated.

While Israeli airstrikes continued in other parts of Gaza, Israel agreed to pauses in the fighting in specific areas to allow the vaccination drive to proceed, and “until now they work,” Dr. Peeperkorn said.

Health teams will next take the effort to southern Gaza, where the W.H.O. estimates that it needs to reach 340,000 children before going to the north to inoculate some 150,000 more.

The W.H.O. and its partner agencies in Gaza say they need to reach 90 percent of children under 10 to avert the spread of polio. Gazans are experiencing an explosion of infectious diseases in the overcrowded and unsanitary conditions created by the war and the destruction of Gaza’s health care infrastructure.

Medical Aid for Palestinians, an aid group supporting the effort, said in a statement on Tuesday that the main challenges of the campaign included ensuring safe access for medical workers and keeping the vaccines refrigerated in the face of electricity outages and fuel shortages, as well as the consequences of damage to sanitation and health care infrastructure.

The success of the vaccination campaign relies heavily on the staggered pauses in fighting in different regions of the Gaza Strip, which both Hamas and Israel agreed to and which they appear to be respecting. The pauses are intended to allow families and aid workers to safely reach vaccination sites between the hours of 7:30 a.m. and 2 p.m.

Mohammed Abu Hajar, a 41-year-old driver who has been sheltering in central Gaza, where the campaign kicked off, said he took his two children to get vaccinated because “a child getting sick could lead to death,” given the collapsed health care system and a severe lack of medical supplies. “There is no other option,” he said.

But the vaccination campaign brought with it another blessing for Mr. Abu Hajar: the temporary pause in fighting, during which he said he had been able to “move around comfortably and feel some reassurance” that there would not be strikes.

Mazen Abdulwaha, a displaced father of seven, said he had been worried about his children ever since he first heard that the virus had been detected in Gaza’s wastewater, because they “live in camps where wastewater follows us everywhere.” He took his three youngest children to get vaccinated as soon as the campaign began.

Like others in central Gaza, Mr. Abdulwaha, 36, said his family was “trying to take advantage” of the pauses in fighting during the four days of the campaign in that area, but he remained cautious because he did not trust Israeli forces to adhere to them. “We had to bear this risk to vaccinate our children and protect them from diseases,” he said.

But for some, the humanitarian pauses offered little relief after more than 10 months of a brutal war.

“A calm of five to six hours means nothing,” said Mohammed al-Sapti, a 32-year-old who is sheltering in Nuseirat in central Gaza. “There is no such thing as temporary safety as long as we are living under siege, exhaustion and torture,” he added.

Iyad Abuheweila contributed reporting from Istanbul, and Ameera Harouda from Doha, Qatar.

Israeli forces return to Tulkarm as the West Bank offensive stretches to a 7th day.

Israeli forces were operating again on Tuesday in Tulkarm, a Palestinian city from which they had withdrawn last week, as one of the longest and most destructive recent Israeli raids in the occupied West Bank reached its seventh day.

The Israeli military said the operation in the northern West Bank aimed to crack down on increasingly powerful Palestinian militants in the area. Palestinian militants said they were firing back, and a series of unusual attempted bombings against Israeli targets further highlighted the growing strength and ambition of such groups in the West Bank.

At least 30 Palestinians have been killed, according to Palestinian health officials, since the Israeli raids began on Wednesday last week. Many were publicly mourned as fighters by Palestinian militant groups. Those killed also included two older people, including a man in his 60s who suffered from mental illness, according to his family.

Israeli soldiers withdrew from Tulkarm last week after two days of fighting, even as a raid continued in the city of Jenin to the north. But on Monday evening, Israeli forces began again deploying throughout Tulkarm in large numbers, said Ma’mun Abu al-Heija, a resident of Nur Shams, a neighborhood on the city’s outskirts.

On Tuesday, a 16-year-old Palestinian girl was killed by Israeli gunfire in Kafr Dan, just outside Jenin, the Palestinian Ministry of Health in Ramallah said in a statement. The Israeli military said it was reviewing reports that a 16-year-old girl had been killed, and that it had opened fire on a “suspect who observed the forces” during a gun battle with Palestinian militants who were sheltering in two “civilian structures.”

Israeli troops typically use less force in operations in the West Bank than they do in Gaza, much of which has been destroyed in Israel’s nearly 11-month-long war against Hamas. But these raids have been unusually destructive, residents and Palestinian officials in the West Bank said.

Israeli bulldozers have torn up main roads — in what military officials say is an effort to unearth improvised explosives planted by militants — along with water pipes and electrical cables. Many Palestinians in Jenin have spent days without electricity or running water, according to the local governor, Kamal Abu al-Rub.

Some residents of Jenin have begun to flee, fearing for their lives. Omar Obeid, 62, said he had left the city over the weekend with his children and many of his neighbors, walking through streets torn up by Israeli forces. They had been trapped at home for days without running water or electricity, he said.

“We tried to take a path that would avoid the army, but we still were risking our lives,” he said in a phone interview.

Eventually, he said, they reached a relative’s home in nearby Yabad and took shelter. Intermittent gunfire and explosions are distant but still audible, he said.

Israeli officials have described the raids as necessary to combat rising Palestinian militancy, particularly a spate of attempted bombings, over the past few weeks. The return of the tactic has revived difficult memories for Israelis, whose national psyche was scarred by dozens of Palestinian suicide attacks in the early 2000s that left hundreds of civilians dead.

Over the weekend, two cars rigged with explosives burst into flames during attacks in the southern West Bank. Israeli forces killed the two assailants, who Hamas said were members of its armed wing. And on Monday, Israel’s police said sappers had disarmed a car bomb near the Israeli settlement of Ateret in the central West Bank.

In mid-August, Hamas and its ally Palestinian Islamic Jihad claimed responsibility for a bombing in Tel Aviv that wounded one person and killed the assailant. The armed groups claimed it was a suicide bombing.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s what we know about those still being held hostage in Gaza.

Protests and labor strikes erupted across Israel after the military said on Sunday that it had recovered the bodies of six hostages from Gaza.

Dozens of other hostages abducted in the Oct. 7 Hamas-led attack on Israel remain in captivity, according to the Israeli authorities.

Here is what we know about them.

How many hostages are still in Gaza?

More than 60 living hostages, and the bodies of about 35 others taken captive on Oct. 7 but believed to be dead, are still in Gaza, according to the Israeli authorities.

In all, about 250 people were abducted on Oct. 7, according to Israeli officials, who include in that number 37 people who were murdered in the initial attack and whose bodies were taken back to Gaza. Those taken were mainly civilians but also included military and security personnel. They were men, women and children, Israeli citizens as well as people who were citizens of the United States, Britain, France, Russia, Germany, Mexico, Thailand and other countries.

How many hostages are Americans?

In all, 12 people with U.S. citizenship were abducted to Gaza on Oct. 7, according to the Israeli government. Two of them, Judith Raanan and her daughter, Natalie Raanan, were freed on Oct. 20 after pressure on Hamas by the United States and Qatar. Two others were released during a cease-fire in November.

One of the hostages, Hersh Goldberg-Polin, 23, a dual Israeli American citizen, was among the six who were found dead in Gaza over the weekend. He had been taken from a music festival in southern Israel on Oct. 7.

The American Jewish Committee, an advocacy organization for Jewish people around the world, on Saturday listed four American citizens who were still being held alive in Gaza. They are Edan Alexander, 20; Sagui Dekel-Chen, 35; Omer Neutra, 22; and Keith Siegel, 64. Three others are presumed dead: Itay Chen, 19; Gadi Haggai, 73; and Judi Weinstein Haggai, 70.

How many hostages have been freed?

Since Oct. 7, 117 people have been released, according to the Israeli authorities. More than 100 were freed during a one-week cease-fire at the end of November in exchange for 240 Palestinians held in Israeli detention.

In addition, eight people have been freed during Israeli military operations. Last week, a Bedouin Arab citizen of Israel was rescued after Israeli commandos found him alone in a tunnel in southern Gaza.

In the most high-profile hostage rescue, in June, soldiers and special operations police rescued four hostages from buildings in the town of Nuseirat, in central Gaza. Scores of Palestinians, including women and children, were killed during that operation, according to the health ministry in Gaza.

In December, Israeli forces mistakenly killed three hostages who had escaped from their captors and were attempting to approach them. The army said the shooting violated its rules of engagement.

What are the conditions like for those still in captivity?

Hostages who have returned from captivity in Gaza have shed some light on where they were held and what the conditions were like. Some were held in hospitals, others in apartments, a mosque and even a destroyed supermarket. Hamas has also been known to hold hostages underground in a network of tunnels. The Israeli military said on Sunday that the bodies of the six slain hostages were found in a tunnel.

Many hostages who have left Gaza have described being moved repeatedly during their captivity, under heavily armed guard. They reported being subjected to physical and psychological abuse.

Andrey Kozlov, 27, a Russian Israeli, provided a detailed account of his time in captivity after he was rescued by the Israeli military in June. He described being held in six locations in the first two months and being moved to an apartment in mid-December. In some places, he and the hostages he was held with had only a pail for a toilet, and food was scarce.

After the rescue of Mr. Kozlov and three other captives, Dr. Itai Pessach, the head of a medical team for returning hostages, said they were malnourished. “They were all abused, punished and tortured physically and psychologically in many ways,” he said.

Gabby Sobelman contributed reporting.

No Time to Run: Russian Missiles Hit Ukraine City Just After Sirens Sound

Want to stay updated on what’s happening in Ukraine? , and we’ll send our latest coverage to your inbox.

Russian missiles struck a military academy in eastern Ukraine on Tuesday only minutes after air-raid alarms blared, killing more than 50 people, wounding many others and underscoring Moscow’s superior firepower in one of the war’s deadliest attacks. Ukraine’s president said a hospital also was hit.

Rescue workers in the eastern city of Poltava described scenes of dismembered bodies pulled from the rubble of the school, which Ukrainian news outlets identified as the Poltava Institute of Military Communications.

The entire area was littered with shattered glass, with nearby high-rises missing windows and doors. By some accounts more than 200 people suffered injuries, overwhelming hospitals.

Denys Kliap, the 26-year-old director of Free and Unbreakable, a volunteer emergency response team, was asleep when the first blast rocked him out of bed. “As soon as it happened, we went straight to the site,” Mr. Kliap said. “When we arrived, the only thing I remember was the pile of bodies scattered all over the territory of the institute.”

While he has seen many horrific scenes, the devastation after Tuesday’s strikes was shocking, he said. He recalled bodies being pulled from the rubble “without legs, others without arms, some even without heads.”

The strike was a demoralizing blow to Ukraine, coming as its troops have been retreating from relentless Russian advances along the war’s main front in the Donbas region.

“Russia is taking away our most valuable asset, our lives,” Ukraine’s first lady, Olena Zelenska, said of the missile strike.

The attack on Tuesday extended a wave of Russian assaults on cities across Ukraine that began a week ago and that have been among the largest since Russia’s invasion in February 2022.

President Volodymyr Zelensky said the strike had been carried out with ballistic missiles, which can travel at supersonic speed and reach a target anywhere in Ukraine in a matter of minutes.

Vladimir Rogov, a Kremlin-appointed occupation official in southern Ukraine, claimed in a post on the Telegram messaging app that the military school hit in the missile strike offers training in radar and electronic warfare.

Witnesses said the strikes, one after the other, had come shortly after the air raid sirens sounded. The Ukrainian Air Force said that the short time between the warning siren and the strikes demonstrated the speed of the missiles, which arrived “literally a matter of minutes” after launch.

Poltava is a little more than 100 miles from the Russian border.

Ukraine has pleaded since the outset of Russia’s full-scale invasion in February 2022 for more tools to defend its skies from Russian missiles, and on Tuesday Mr. Zelensky took to social media to issue a fresh request for more aid. “Ukraine needs air defense systems and missiles now, not sitting in storage,” he wrote.

The only proven defense against ballistic missiles, Patriot missile systems, were sent from the United States and Germany but did not arrive until the spring of 2023 and Ukraine says it needs more.

Mr. Zelensky has said he desperately needs at least seven Patriot batteries to fend off attacks across the country. Germany has sent three and, in July, President Biden announced the deployment of a second Patriot missile system from the United States. Other American allies also have Patriots: Romania has pledged one, and the Netherlands has given parts of the complex system. U.S. officials have said they hope European powers will send more.

It was unclear if Ukraine used any of those Patriot batteries to try to fend off Tuesday’s attack in Poltava.

A number of questions about the strikes, and the high death toll, remained unanswered on Tuesday.

Just after the missiles struck, there were reports in the Ukrainian media that cadets had been lined up outside the military school. Mr. Rogov also claimed the missiles had hit cadets gathered for an event.

But Dmytro Lazutkin, the spokesman for Ukraine’s defense ministry, denied on national television that the victims had been participating in a parade or ceremony, saying that classes were underway when the air raid sirens sounded.

Since the start of the war, Ukraine has banned large gatherings, including at sports stadiums and large concert venues. But large numbers of people still congregate in malls, schools and markets.

In recent weeks the pace of the war has accelerated in Ukraine, both in the air and on the ground.

Russian advances in the direction of the eastern city of Pokrovsk, a vital logistics hub, have prompted local authorities to urge civilians to evacuate and the Ukrainian military to send reinforcements.

The capture of Pokrovsk by Russian forces would be their biggest gain in the region since they seized Avdiivka in January and February after intense ground fighting and bombardment. It also would bring Russian forces one step closer to achieving a key goal for President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia: full control of the Donbas.

Mr. Putin was in Mongolia on Tuesday, some 3,000 miles from the front lines of the Ukraine war. He said nothing in public about Ukraine, according to Kremlin transcripts of his remarks.

Attempts by Ukraine to divert the focus of war have so far not borne fruit. The incursion into the Kursk region of Russia in early August by Ukrainian forces drew Russian reinforcements but not from the front lines in eastern Ukraine.

Mr. Zelensky on Tuesday said the Ukrainian offensive in Kursk was going “according to plan.” He told NBC News in an interview Tuesday that Ukraine would hold onto Russian territory for an unspecified amount of time. “For now, we need it,” he said, adding that it was part of a “victory plan.”

The Ukrainian military has also for months been targeting Russian oil and gas facilities with drone attacks. But the campaign has not yet had a demonstrable effect on the fighting in the Donbas.

Ukraine had hoped that the long-awaited arrival of Western-supplied F-16 fighter jets would assist in repelling Russian attacks. That effort suffered a blow last week when one of the warplanes crashed while defending against an intense Russian aerial attack, in what may have been a friendly-fire incident.

Reporting was contributed by Cassandra Vinograd, Matthew Mpoke Bigg, Liubov Sholudko, Anton Troianovski, Andrew E. Kramer and Thomas Fuller.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

Christmas Starts in October, Venezuela’s Autocrat Declares

A nationwide blackout. A broken economy. A widely contested presidential election. A populace terrified of its autocratic leader and his increasingly violent security forces.

What’s a president to do?

Declare the early arrival of Christmas, of course.

Facing widespread domestic and international criticism over his claim that he won a July presidential vote, President Nicolás Maduro of Venezuela is trying to turn the nation’s attention toward the one thing almost every Venezuelan loves: Christmas.

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.

Dozens Die in Congo Jailbreak Attempt After Stampede and Gunfire

At least 129 people died during an attempted jailbreak at the largest prison in the Democratic Republic of Congo, the country’s authorities said on Tuesday. It was the latest upheaval to hit an overcrowded detention facility notorious for conditions that human rights groups have long decried as inhumane.

Inmates said they had been held in stifling cells without water and electricity, and some had initially broken out to escape the heat.

A stampede was to blame for most of the deaths, but at least 24 inmates were killed by gunfire as they tried to escape from the Makala Central Prison early on Monday, according to Congo’s interior minister, Jacquemain Shabani.

He said on the platform X that 59 people had been injured and that there had been “some cases of women raped,” without providing further details. As of late Tuesday, it was unclear if any inmates had escaped.

Makala is the only prison in Kinshasa, Congo’s capital and one of Africa’s most populous cities. Its intended capacity is 1,500 people but it holds at least 15,000, Congo’s deputy minister for justice, Samuel Mbemba, said in an interview.

The violence occurred as President Felix Tshisekedi of Congo was in Beijing for a forum on China-Africa cooperation, and adds to the challenges facing the Central African country. Home to more than 100 million people, Congo is battling multiple crises, including a deadly mpox outbreak and a conflict in its eastern region that has killed more than six million people and displaced millions of others over the past three decades.

With outdoor temperatures near 90 degrees, the inmates had been without running water or electricity to power fans for more than a day and a half, according to four inmates who spoke on condition of anonymity to protect their safety inside the prison.

Many felt that they were suffocating, one said, and on Sunday evening some broke the doors of their cells to get out.

A Congolese intelligence official, speaking on condition of anonymity because he wasn’t authorized to discuss the events publicly, said guards opened fire in the early hours of Monday morning when inmates tried to escape from the precinct of the prison.

Stanis Bujakera Tshiamala, a well-known Congolese journalist who served time at Makala last year but has since been released, shared a video showing a chaotic scene, with inmates running outside as shots rang out around them. In another video he shared that was filmed at night, several inmates are standing around what appears to be a corpse within the prison grounds.

Several videos verified by The New York Times as being filmed inside the prison complex showed the aftermath of the attempted jailbreak.

In one very graphic video, a large crowd stands around at least 25 lifeless bodies lined up in a central alleyway between prison blocks. Bodies were loaded onto a truck and driven from the grounds in another video filmed by the eastern perimeter of the prison complex, while a third video showed thick black smoke billowing from a building near the prison’s entrance.


Mr. Shabani, the interior minister, said that the inmates who died from bullet wounds had been shot “after warning.” The spokesman for Congo’s government, Patrick Muyaya, was traveling with Mr. Tshisekedi in Beijing and did not immediately reply to a request for comment on Tuesday. It was unclear what had happened to the prison’s water and power.

Human rights groups have long denounced horrifying detention conditions at the Makala prison, a facility built in 1957, before Congo became independent from Belgium, and which has had few renovations since. Its population ranges from those convicted of petty crimes to high-profile and political prisoners.

Last year, more than 500 inmates died from suffocation and various diseases, according to Emmanuel Adu Cole, a human rights advocate based in Kinshasa. He and one inmate said that as of Tuesday, there was still no running water and nothing to eat, as a food depot had burned.

Undated videos shared earlier this summer by Mr. Bujakera, the Congolese journalist, show haggard inmates crammed in detention rooms and restrooms, unable to sit or properly lie down.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

At Least 12 Die Trying to Cross English Channel, French Officials Say

At least 12 people, including what appeared to be six minors, died after a flimsy, overcrowded boat suddenly capsized off the coast of northern France on Tuesday during an attempt to cross the English Channel, the French authorities said.

It was the deadliest episode in the waterway this year as the French and British governments struggle to prevent migrants from attempting the perilous crossing.

Crammed by smugglers onto a boat that was less than 25 feet long, more than 60 people fell into the water after their “extremely fragile” vessel started sinking, according to Gérald Darmanin, France’s interior minister. Almost none of them had life vests, he said.

“This is a tragedy that affects us all,” Mr. Darmanin told reporters at a news conference in Boulogne-sur-Mer, a city in the coastal Pas-de-Calais area, which is where the sinking occurred and which at some points is less than 30 miles from the British coastline.

The vessel sank about three miles off the coast, French authorities said. Twelve people were hospitalized, two of them in critical condition, they added.

Jacques Billant, the Pas-de-Calais prefect, told reporters that the boat “rapidly and brutally” broke apart shortly after 11 a.m. as it headed toward Britain.

Guirec Le Bras, the prosecutor in Boulogne-sur-Mer, told reporters it was not immediately clear what had caused the boat to sink or how the victims had died. But he said his office had opened an investigation into a range of potential criminal charges, including involuntary manslaughter. Investigators had not yet determined the exact nationalities and ages of the people on board, he said, but most of them appeared to be from Eritrea and it seemed that most of the victims were women or children.

The French maritime authorities said in a statement that rescue operations involving helicopters, fishing boats and French Navy ships were quickly set in motion and that rescue workers picked up 65 people out of the water.

One of the worst migrant-related accidents in the Channel happened in 2021, when 27 people died after their boat capsized, but deadly tragedies have repeatedly occurred on a smaller scale.

Many of the most recent incidents have unfolded near Boulogne-sur-Mer, an area that has become more attractive for smuggling networks after French authorities tightened patrols and security farther north on the coastline, Mr. Darmanin said.

Nearly 36,000 people trying to reach Britain were the subject of search-and-rescue operations in the English Channel in 2023, according to a report by the French maritime authorities, down from over 51,000 in 2022.

But the average number of people per boat grew to 50 from 30 — making a perilous crossing even more so, according to the report. Last year, 12 people attempting the crossing died in France’s search-and-rescue zone, the report said.

The Channel is one of the busiest shipping routes in the world. Its waters are especially icy in the winter, winds can be treacherous, and migrants trying to cross often crowd onto flimsy inflatable boats.

Both France and Britain blame human smuggling networks for putting the lives of migrants at risk.

“The gangs behind this appalling and callous trade in human lives have been cramming more and more people onto increasingly unseaworthy dinghies, and sending them out into the Channel even in very poor weather,” Yvette Cooper, Britain’s home secretary, whose office oversees immigration into the country, said on Tuesday. “They do not care about anything but the profits they make.”

The British and French authorities agreed last year that Britain would pay France 541 million pounds, currently more than $700 million, over three years to help pay for drones, a new detention center and hundreds of additional police officers to patrol beaches in northern France — one of several deals that the two countries have struck over the past few years to try to reduce the number of crossings.

But the Channel crossings have become a recurring sticking point in relations between the two countries, and on Tuesday, Mr. Darmanin said that only a new “migration treaty” to harmonize asylum and deportation rules between Britain and the European Union would provide a lasting solution.

Less than 5 percent of migrants from Africa or the Middle East who cluster in makeshift camps on the coast end up requesting asylum in France, he said.

Many prefer risking the trip across the Channel over staying in France because they see Britain as an attractive destination with a strong job market where English is spoken, or because they already have family there or people they know from their home country.

“Nothing can resist that desire to continue to live with your family, to find a job, and live correctly,” Mr. Darmanin said.

At least 19,294 people have arrived in England across the Channel on small boats since the start of 2024, according to British government data, comparable to the number of arrivals in the first eight months of the previous year.

The arrival of the small boats across the Channel has become a major point of political tension in Britain after the former Conservative government vowed to “stop the boats” and introduced a contentious plan to send asylum seekers to Rwanda in an attempt to dissuade migrants from attempting the crossing.

The Labour government of Prime Minister Keir Starmer of Britain announced after a landslide victory in July that it would scrap those plans. Since then, though, the issue of immigration has taken center stage, with far-right riots rattling cities across Britain this summer.

Though the number of boat arrivals has risen significantly since 2018, they make up just a fraction of immigration into Britain overall, and the majority of people making this crossing are asylum seekers fleeing war and persecution.

Some 93 percent of the people who arrived in small boats between 2018 and March 2024 claimed asylum, and of those who had received a decision by March 31, around three-quarters were successful, according to the Migration Observatory at Oxford University.

Enver Solomon, the chief executive of the Refugee Council, a British charity that supports asylum seekers and refugees, said in a statement on Tuesday that “the number of deaths in the Channel this year has been shockingly high.”

But “enforcement alone is not the solution,” Mr. Solomon said. “Heightened security and policing measures on the French coast have led to increasingly perilous crossings, launching from more dangerous locations and in flimsy, overcrowded vessels.”

He added that the British government needed to take action against the criminal gangs that are often responsible for smuggling people across the Channel, but that it also “must develop a plan to improve and expand safe routes for those seeking safety.”

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

South Korean Teenagers Detained Over Deepfake Sexual Images

The authorities in South Korea are investigating a surge of sexually explicit images and video clips that have spread online and shocked the nation, leading the police to detain seven male suspects — six of them teenagers — the police said on Tuesday.

The South Korean authorities began investigating the images and videos late last month after local media reported the spread of the content, which was created using deepfake apps. Young men were said to be stealing social media images from female classmates, teachers and neighbors, and then using them to create the sexually explicit material before circulating them in chat rooms on the messaging app Telegram.

The crimes triggered a panic among many women in South Korea, and President Yoon Suk Yeol last week called on his government to root out digital sex abuse.

“Many of the victims are minors and most of the perpetrators are teenagers,” Mr. Yoon said last Tuesday during a cabinet meeting. “They may say that they created this as a ‘mere prank,’ but this is a clear criminal act that exploited technology behind the wall of anonymity.”

The investigation in South Korea followed the arrest of Pavel Durov, Telegram’s Russian-born founder, by the French authorities last month. The authorities in France were investigating child sexual abuse material, drug trafficking and fraud on the encrypted messaging app. Mr. Durov was later charged with a range of crimes, including complicity in crimes such as enabling the distribution of child sexual abuse material.

The steep rise in deepfakes in South Korea made headlines in the country after reporters found Telegram channels on which female university, high and middle school students were among the victims.

“Telegram has been actively removing content reported from Korea that breached its terms of service and will continue to do so,” the company said in a statement.

Last week, 118 cases of suspected deepfake sexual crimes were reported, resulting in the detention of the seven male suspects, the police said Tuesday. The police have not yet charged any of those who have been detained.

Under South Korean law, people convicted of making sexually explicit deepfakes with the intention to distribute them face punishments of ​up to five years in prison or a fine of up to 50 million won, or $37,000. Women’s rights groups have called for new legislation ​to punish those who possess and watch such materials.

Most of the people involved in the production and spread of the imagery — as well as many of the victims — are in their teens, according to data compiled by the Korean National Police Agency. Of the 178 people identified by the agency as criminal suspects in the first seven months of the year, 131 were teenagers, the police said.

The number of suspects was expected to increase as more people reported cases of deepfake sexual violence.

South Korea has struggled with digital sex crimes in recent years. In 2020, Cho Joo-bin, the mastermind of a digital sex crime ring, was sentenced to 40 years in prison on charges of luring young women, including teenagers, into making videos that he sold online through encrypted chat rooms on Telegram.

This year, South Korea has reported a surge in online deepfake sex crimes. Between January and July, 297 cases were reported, almost three times the number reported in the same period last year, according to the police.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

Ugandan Opposition Leader Bobi Wine Shot in Leg in Clash With Police

Uganda’s top opposition figure, Bobi Wine, was shot in the leg by the police on Tuesday, his political party said, calling it an escalation of a government campaign of intimidation against a prominent critic who challenged the country’s autocratic leader in a run for the presidency in 2021.

It was not immediately clear whether a bullet or a tear-gas canister was the projectile that had hit Mr. Wine’s leg, Mr. Wine’s international lawyer, Bruce Afran, said in a phone interview. Mr. Afran said that Mr. Wine’s wound does not appear to be life-threatening and that he was receiving treatment at a hospital in the capital, Kampala.

Mr. Wine, whose real name is Robert Kyagulanyi, rose to prominence in recent years to become the leading challenger to the government of President Yoweri Museveni, a key Western ally who has won six terms in office in elections often marred by allegations of fraud and rigging.

Mr. Wine, 42, a musician-turned-lawmaker and the subject of an Oscar-nominated documentary, “The People’s President,” challenged Mr. Museveni, 79, for the presidency in the most recent national elections, three years ago. During the campaign, Mr. Wine was repeatedly beaten and detained, and security forces surrounded his house as the results trickled in.

His party, the National Unity Platform, which holds more seats than any other opposition party in the National Assembly, said in a post on X that Mr. Wine had been shot in the leg on Tuesday as he returned from visiting one of his party’s lawyers in the town of Bulindo, northeast of the capital. Mr. Wine and his entourage were surrounded by military and police officers who began firing live bullets and tear-gas canisters, the party said.

Videos and photos shared on social media show Mr. Wine writhing in pain and bleeding from a wound just below the left knee.

Uganda’s police force said in a statement that the police had warned Mr. Wine against starting a street procession as he left Bulindo. But he and his team, the police said, “insisted on proceeding and closing the road, leading to police intervention to prevent the procession.”

The police statement said that officers on the scene said that Mr. Wine was injured when he “stumbled while getting into his vehicle” during the confrontation. The police said that they will investigate the incident.

The shooting of Mr. Wine caps a long campaign of government harassment and intimidation of both Mr. Wine and other political opposition and civil society groups in Uganda.

Protesters have marched in the streets against corruption in recent months and have demanded the resignation of the speaker of the Parliament, who has been accused of graft and been sanctioned by both Britain and the United States.

Even after Mr. Museveni won the last election, the Ugandan authorities continued to pursue Mr. Wine’s supporters, abducting them in unmarked white minivans, and torturing them, according to activists and opposition party members.

Mr. Wine and others have accused Mr. Museveni, his son and other top government officials of committing crimes against humanity and have filed a case against them in the International Criminal Court.

Last year, Mr. Wine was seized at the Entebbe International Airport, Uganda’s main airport, and put under house arrest after he returned home from holding political rallies abroad and attending screenings of the documentary focusing on his life.

On Tuesday, Mr. Afran said that in light of Tuesday’s shooting, the United States should review its financial and military support of the government of Mr. Museveni.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

Elon Musk’s Starlink Agrees to Block the X Social Network in Brazil

Starlink, the satellite-internet service controlled by Elon Musk, reversed course on Tuesday and said it would comply with Brazilian government orders to block Mr. Musk’s social network X in the country.

The move was the first sign of any backing down by Mr. Musk in Brazil since he began battling with the authorities there last month. X has been blacked out across the nation of 200 million since Saturday because of a dispute between Mr. Musk and Brazil’s Supreme Court over what can be said online.

Starlink escalated the fight on Sunday when, according to Brazilian regulators, the company declared it would continue allowing its 250,000 customers in Brazil to log on to X, defying the government.

Carlos Baigorri, president of Brazil’s telecommunication agency, said on Sunday that if Starlink refused to comply, his agency could revoke its license to operate in the country and could seize 23 ground stations it uses to improve the quality of its connections.

Mr. Baigorri said that Starlink had told him earlier that it would not comply until Brazil’s Supreme Court lifted financial sanctions against it in the country.

Alexandre de Moraes, the Brazilian Supreme Court justice who has led the action against X, froze Starlink’s assets and blocked it from completing financial transactions in Brazil in a bid to collect more than $3 million in fines he has imposed against X.

In a post on X on Tuesday afternoon, Starlink said that “regardless of the illegal treatment of Starlink in freezing of our assets, we are complying with the order to block access to X in Brazil.” The company added that it would “continue to pursue all legal avenues.”

Brazil’s Supreme Court has already dismissed a request from Starlink to lift the sanctions. Unable to make financial transactions in Brazil, Starlink said it would offer free internet service to Brazilian customers for now.

Justice Moraes blocked X in Brazil because Mr. Musk has refused to comply with court orders to remove certain accounts on the social network, and then closed X’s office in the country. Mr. Musk has criticized Justice Moraes for months, accusing him of illegally censoring free speech. The justice has said Mr. Musk is obstructing his work of removing hate speech and attacks on democracy from the Brazilian internet.

X has begun publishing some of the sealed orders that Justice Moraes has issued to the company to suspend accounts. Those orders do not explain why a given account should be suspended.

On Monday, a panel of Brazilian Supreme Court justices upheld the order to block X in the country.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more

Pope Visits Indonesia, Where Muslim-Christian Harmony Is Under Strain

The hallelujahs rang out on Sunday from a small hall on the outskirts of Jakarta, the capital of Indonesia. The sounds from the Christian service could be heard within the green and orange mosque across the way, as a group of young girls in hijabs walked by.

On the surface, the scene was a reflection of the interfaith harmony that Indonesia, the world’s largest Muslim-majority country, is proud of. But the Christians were not in their own church. Earlier this year, their congregation’s building was stormed by dozens of angry Muslims, and now they were temporarily gathering in a government-owned building in a different area.

This is the complex reality awaiting Pope Francis as he begins a four-day trip to Indonesia on Tuesday, which will include an interfaith dialogue at the national mosque. There are many vibrant examples of how Christianity and Islam coexist in Indonesia — a dynamic that Francis wants to encourage — but at the same time, religious minorities face discrimination.

By and large, Indonesian Muslims practice a moderate brand of Sunni Islam that is tolerant of other faiths. But other branches of Islam, notably the Shias and Ahmadiyyas, have long felt marginalized. And conservative strains of Islam have spread here in recent years, with one province, Aceh, having enforced Shariah law for nearly a decade.

In dozens of cities, young girls are pressured, bullied, and harassed to wear hijabs at schools and public spaces, Human Rights Watch has documented.

With the rise of conservative Islam, some believers in minority faiths say, the space for religious freedom in Indonesia has shrunk.

The Christians who met on Sunday in Tangerang, the city on the outskirts of Jakarta, had been attacked in their building in March as children prepared costumes for an Easter show. They were told that they could not have a church in a Muslim area, members of the community said.

Last year, there were 329 acts of violence against religious minorities, nearly one per day, according to the Setara Institute for Democracy and Peace, a human rights watchdog. There has been deadly violence in the past, including bombings at churches.

The Indonesian government officially recognizes six faiths: Islam, Catholicism, Protestantism, Buddhism, Hinduism and Confucianism. It has adopted some measures to protect religious freedom, like forbidding schools to make hijabs compulsory. But some minorities say those protections aren’t honored in practice and that parts of Indonesian law effectively discriminate against them.

The biggest issue has been the building of houses of worship. To do so, religious groups have to get the signatures of 60 people from other faiths in the community, as well as approval from the local interfaith council, which is made up of religious leaders but almost always dominated by Muslims. This, critics say, effectively gives Muslims veto power.

Cardinal Ignatius Suharyo Hardjoatmodjo, the archbishop of Jakarta, downplayed the issue of church construction being blocked, saying that such incidents largely came down to vote baiting by Muslim politicians. The bigger challenges facing the Catholic Church in Indonesia, he said, are ones that face the nation as a whole: corruption, threats to democracy and income inequality.

Still, the Christian community in Tangerang has not been able to get even half of the 60 signatures for their church, members said.

“We have been independent for 79 years, but for me it is a half-independence,” said Oktaviyanto M.I. Pardede, 59, a leader of the congregation. “Why am I still being colonized by my own people, why can’t I practice my religion freely?”

The Vatican was one of the first states to recognize Indonesia’s independence after it became free of Dutch rule in 1947, and the two have maintained close ties ever since.

Yet when Pope John Paul II visited in 1989, he was met with protests because of his faith. Two decades later, when President Barack Obama visited the Istiqlal Mosque in Jakarta, the national mosque, many Muslims asked why a practicing Christian was being allowed into their house of worship.

But the reaction to Francis’s trip — part of his outreach to what he calls “the peripheries” of Catholicism — has been different.

“I think it’s a very important visit,” said Nurlaila, a Muslim woman who, like many Indonesians, goes by one name, and who had just finished praying at the Istiqlal Mosque.

Much of the credit for changing attitudes has gone to the Nahdlatul Ulama, the largest Muslim social organization in the world, with some 150 million members. Its leader, Yahya Cholil Staquf, said the group had protected churches from extremist groups and lobbied local officials to let them be built.

Three percent of Indonesia’s 280 million people are Catholics, but they have a substantial presence in some parts of the country, like the eastern island of Flores, where theirs is the dominant faith. Nationwide, Protestants account for 10 percent of the population.

Nasaruddin Umar, the grand imam of the Istiqlal Mosque, said Catholics had offered to donate animals to the mosque to be sacrificed during the Muslim festival of Eid al-Adha.

The grand imam pushed for the construction of a “tunnel of friendship” to connect the Istiqlal Mosque and the nearby Jakarta Cathedral. On Thursday, Francis will visit the Istiqlal for an interfaith dialogue, and mosque officials hope he will see the tunnel.

Such blending of religions is not unusual in Indonesia.

On a recent Friday night, Diah Purwanti, 47, laid out her prayer mat in the presence of a picture of Jesus. Raised a Catholic, she had converted to Islam after marrying a Muslim man. Her parents were Muslims who had converted to Catholicism, and one of her brothers is studying to be a Jesuit priest. As children, they celebrated both Eid and Christmas.

But some worshipers see a contradiction between their own experience and Indonesia’s image as a multicultural, tolerant place.

“Unity is the foundation of the country,” said Manav Hardinata, 23, whose Lutheran community has not been allowed to build a house of worship. “But here it is a competition, they treat us as if we want to take their people.”

Though they were Lutherans, not Catholics, many of the worshipers in Tangerang were hopeful and excited about the pope’s visit.

“We are hoping that it will bring changes to this issue,” said Robert Sinaga, 62. “His message is a message of community.”

On Sunday evening in Bekasi, another suburb of Jakarta, the Muslim call to prayer could be heard from the Catholic church Santa Clara, as a priest prepared for communion.

After a 17-year wait, Santa Clara received a permit to begin building in 2015, said Rasnius Pasaribu, the coordinator of the church’s construction committee. But thousands of Muslims protested the project at the local city hall. So Mr. Pasaribu’s committee agreed to make changes to the church’s design.

From the highway, Santa Clara, a sprawling white complex with a congregation of 10,000, does not look like a church. It cannot display a cross or a bell there. Instead, its facade, and its statue of the Madonna, enclosed in a cave of rose petals, lie toward the back of the compound.

Still, Mr. Pasaribu said: “We are happy. It’s amazing that we can pray in a church.”

Muktita Suhartono, Rin Hindryati and Hasya Nindita contributed reporting.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Times.

6-month Welcome Offer
original price:   $3sale price:   $0.50/week

Learn more