A French Fair as Workers’ Paradise, Feting Cuisine, Music and Communism
Christine Marlier was angry when President Emmanuel Macron called a snap election this summer. She’s even angrier now that he appointed a right-wing prime minister, despite the fact that a leftist bloc won the most seats in Parliament.
But Ms. Marlier left that anger behind at home in the far northeast of France when she boarded a bus for a four-hour ride to a nearly 100-year-old festival on the outskirts of Paris that celebrates left-wing politics in general, and French Communism in particular.
The Fête de l’Humanité — festival of humanity — is an unlikely mixture of Burning Man, Woodstock and a political convention.
“We are never angry here,” said Ms. Marlier, 51, in between doing 1 euro shots of alcohol with her husband, both their faces decorated by sparkles.
They were standing in the middle of a dirt lane, between large white booths set up by Communist Party associations from around the country, offering the food specialties of their regions — including raw oysters and steamed lobsters, giant pans of tartiflette, and axoa, a minced veal dish from the Basque region.
A loudspeaker advertised the coming debate between the head of the French Communist Party, Fabien Roussel, and one of the country’s top union leaders, but Ms. Marlier and her husband were already tipsy. They were planning on seeing some bands play instead.
“Here, we’re in a suspended dream, outside our daily problems and worries,” said Ms. Marlier, who works with handicapped children in elementary schools in the département of Moselle, bordering Germany and Luxembourg.
Every year, usually during the second weekend of September as the country is shaking off its vacation slumber, the festival’s organizers build a huge village out of the mud and grass of an abandoned military airport, in the distant nether regions of Paris where suburban homes give way to corn fields. Up go the stages, and up go some 350 large booths in long lines to make streets, which are often named after dead French Communist heroes.
Every year, dozens of musicians come to perform. In the past, they’ve included acts like Manu Chao, Pink Floyd, Ray Charles and Youssou N’Dour, and French stars like Aya Nakamura and Zaho de Sagazan.
And in all those booths, hundreds of political debates, lectures, and question and answer sessions are held throughout the festival’s three days. This year there were 360, running morning to evening.
That meant on Saturday afternoon, you could see a union leader square off against the head of an employers’ association; or settle into the large film tent to watch Judith Godrèche’s latest short film, “Moi Aussi,” on the prevalence of rape; or see a children’s play; or dash over to the Angela Davis stage to listen to the French musician Santa belt out lyrical songs — all more or less at the same time.
Or you could try to squeeze into the crowd pouring into the “agora” — the central red booth where the big ticket speeches happen — to see Ms. Davis herself. The retired California philosophy professor, activist and Communist presidential candidate was back at the festival for the third time since 1973.
“Hope is a discipline which you have to cultivate,” she said, her voice reverberating over loud speakers. “Because without it there is no possibility of moving forward.”
The Fête de l’Huma, as the faithful call it, began in 1930 to raise money for the official Communist Party newspaper, L’Humanité. Today, the left-wing daily is no longer the party’s official organ, but it continues to run the annual festival.
The budget has climbed to about €8 million, but the festival barely breaks even most years, said L’Humanité’s publisher, Fabien Gay, who also is an elected Communist senator.
That’s because the newspaper refuses to raise ticket prices, in keeping with the founding idea that the festival should offer culture to workers. The top price for three days of 60 music concerts is just €60 — the typical cost of a single concert in Paris, Mr. Gay pointed out.
“This is for us Communists, this is what we fight for — everything that is exceptional and grandiose must remain accessible to everyone,” said Mr. Roussel, the French Communist Party leader, who spent some of the fête in full-on campaign mode, shaking hands, slapping backs and visiting party booths from across the country, even though no election is near.
During an interview, he remembered fondly the year 1988, when the French designer Yves Saint Laurent put on a fashion show — which he called a “work of art,” comparable to the “Mona Lisa” or “Guernica” by Picasso, who also, incidentally, had exhibitions of his work here.
“Bodies must be always nourished, but so must minds,” Mr. Roussel said.
When you arrive at the fête, 22 miles south of central Paris, it feels as if you’ve entered an alternative universe, where the Communist Party is joyfully running France and not continually losing seats in the National Assembly, including Mr. Roussel’s last summer. The party currently has just nine seats in the 577-seat legislature.
Here, it’s not K.F.C. but C.F.K.: Communist Fried Kitchen, with Colonel Sanders transformed into Marx. Red flags with the hammer and sickle flap from the awnings of booths, and people wear Communist Party shirts and hats.
In 1945, with the memory of the prominent role played by French Communists in the Resistance still fresh, some one million people crammed into the festival. This year, the attendance was 450,000, according to Mr. Gay. While many come just for the music, organizers hope some will drift into a lecture or debate — particularly those camping in the 8,000 or so tents set up along the fête’s flank.
“Millions of French people were Communists at one moment of their life, and they come back each year, because they feel part of the family,” explained Frédérick Genevée, a high school history teacher who has written four books on French Communist history, the most recent of which he was signing at the festival’s book fair. “It’s confirmation in what we believe in.”
Most of the labor at the festival is done by 10,000 volunteers who arrive in convoys, towing stoves, refrigerators, mattresses and kegs of beer from as far as Biarritz, 475 miles away.
Over two weeks, they work to build their regional booths, set up kitchens and sleeping quarters, and stay up late to talk. In many families, it’s a tradition going back generations.
“It gives us a taste of what the world could be,” said Catherine Lavauzelle, 64, a retired teacher who started coming with her father to volunteer at age 7. “If we all gave the best of ourselves, and weren’t always in competition with one another.”
The cheap wine and beer helps with the bonding. Add music, and you have a surefire recipe for love, which Mr. Genevée said was another festival theme. He met two of his ex-wives here.
Gregory Moser not only met his wife, Noémie, here; he married her on-site 11 years ago.
“We were married in the Cuba booth, had our wine reception in the People’s Republic of China booth,” Mr. Moser said with a laugh outside the regional booth from Charente, where the couple continue to volunteer. After the wedding ceremony, friends drove the newlyweds around the festival in a golf cart trailing cooking pans.
People often predict the festival’s demise. They are always proved wrong.
Similarly, every year, once the revelers have cleared out, and Ms. Lavauzelle is bleary eyed and packing up the sinks and stoves, peeling the tents up off the muddy ground, and beginning the long drive back home, she swears it will be her last. But it never is.
“It’s the feeling that draws us back,” she said. “It helps me feel better for the rest of the year, when I return to real life.”
Ségolène Le Stradic contributed reporting.
Live Updates: Netanyahu and Hezbollah Trade Fresh Threats
Here are the latest developments.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Sunday that Israel would take “whatever action is necessary” to diminish the threat posed by Hezbollah, as the deputy leader of the Iranian-backed Lebanese militia warned the conflict was entering “a new stage.”
The threats added to mounting fears that intensifying tit-for-tat violence between Israel and Hezbollah in Lebanon has put the region on the brink of a wider catastrophe.
Hezbollah launched more than 100 rockets, missiles and drones at Israeli territory overnight in a large-scale response to a wave of deadly attacks against the group in Lebanon that included exploding pagers and walkie-talkies, along with airstrikes against senior commanders.
Mr. Netanyahu seemed to refer to those attacks against Hezbollah opaquely in saying on Sunday that Israel had dealt the group “a series of blows” that it hadn’t anticipated.
“If Hezbollah didn’t understand the message, I promise you it will understand the message,” he said in a recorded statement, adding that Israel was determined to return Israelis displaced by the cross-border violence to their homes in the north.
His statement did not address Hezbollah’s overnight attack, which set off air-raid sirens in scores of towns in northern Israel. Hezbollah said it had targeted Israeli military bases, including one near Haifa, on the coast. The Israeli military said most of the missiles were intercepted by air defenses. But a town north of Haifa suffered a direct hit and officials tightened restrictions on public gatherings in areas including the Golan Heights and Galilee.
The barrages were seemingly the most distant rocket strikes into Israeli territory since Hezbollah started firing at Israel a little over a year ago in solidarity with Hamas. They also seemed to be carefully calibrated — a show of force near one of Israel’s biggest cities, but one that avoided the center of the country, which could draw a harsher response from Israel.
Still, hours later, Hezbollah’s deputy leader, Naim Qassem, addressed the funeral for one of the group’s commanders who was killed on Friday in an Israeli strike. “What happened last night is just the beginning,” he warned.
Here’s what else to know:
-
Shifting focus: The wave of attacks against Hezbollah in Lebanon last week has fueled fears that Israel’s military was shifting its focus away from Hamas in Gaza toward Hezbollah. And on Sunday, the Israeli military said it had intercepted fire that came from the direction of Iraq, where another Iran-backed group claimed to have fired drones at Israel.
-
Friday attack: On Sunday, Lebanese authorities said the death toll had risen to at least 45, including women and children, from an Israeli airstrike on Friday in Beirut. Hezbollah confirmed the death of a top commander, Ibrahim Aqeel, who was wanted by the United States for his role in two 1983 bombing attacks in Beirut that killed more than 350 people at the U.S. Embassy and the U.S. Marine Corps barracks, many of them American citizens.
-
Gaza war: The Palestinian Civil Defense said on Sunday that seven people were killed and several others were wounded in an Israeli strike on a school building that was housing displaced people in Gaza City. Israel’s military said in a statement that it carried out “a precise strike” on Hamas militants who were operating from the school-turned-shelter, and had taken “numerous steps” to mitigate civilian harm.
-
West Bank: The Israeli military raided the office of Al Jazeera in the Israeli-occupied West Bank on Sunday and ordered its closure for 45 days, the latest move in Israel’s effort to clamp down on the channel.
Gabby Sobelman, Hwaida Saad, Christina Goldbaum and Hiba Yazbek contributed reporting.
Hezbollah’s latest barrages went deeper into Israel.
Hezbollah fired barrages of rockets deep into Israeli territory on Sunday morning, targeting a town just north of Haifa, one of the largest cities in Israel, the Israeli military and Hezbollah said.
The barrages appeared to be the furthest strikes by rockets into Israeli territory since Hezbollah started firing at Israel a little over a year ago in solidarity with Hamas, an ally that spearheaded the Oct. 7 attacks on southern Israel.
But the rocket attacks by the Lebanese militia group also seemed to be carefully calibrated — a show of force near one of Israel’s biggest cities, but one that avoided the more populated center of the country, which could draw a harsher response from Israel.
A security expert said that Hassan Nasrallah, the leader of Hezbollah, was keen to escalate its attacks on Israel, while not pulling the Israeli military into a full-scale war.
“He’s trying to maneuver between two conflicting needs: staying out of a total war and responding to the very successful attacks in Lebanon,” said Giora Eiland, a retired major general and the former head of Israel’s National Security Council.
Last week, Hezbollah suffered a major setback when pagers and walkie-talkies used by its members exploded, killing dozens and injuring thousands, including militants and civilians. While Israel is widely believed to be behind the pager and walkie-talkie explosions, it has not explicitly taken responsibility for them.
On Friday, Israel delivered yet another blow to Hezbollah, killing senior commanders in the group in airstrikes on Beirut.
It was unclear when the current escalation would conclude, but following the fusillade of rockets early Sunday, Israel’s military said it carried out strikes against the group in Lebanon. For the past year, both sides have engaged in tit-for-tat attacks across the border.
Mr. Nasrallah’s resistance to an all-out conflict was because he didn’t want to start a conflict that would end with Beirut looking like the Gaza Strip, which has been devastated by the war, General Eiland said.
“He understands very well that full destruction of the Lebanese capital isn’t something he’ll be able to explain to the Lebanese people,” he said.
Israel’s military said that most of the missiles fired overnight were intercepted by air defenses. Still, the rocket salvos on Sunday caused some damage. One hit a residential neighborhood in the town of Kiryat Bialik, a short drive from the Haifa Port. Three people were wounded by shrapnel, emergency services said, and homes and cars sustained damage. Another landed in a dairy farm, killing several cows, according to local officials.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
Rescuers were still searching for victims and survivors of Friday’s airstrike in Beirut. Lebanon’s health minister, Firass Abiad, said that between 10 and 15 people were still believed to be trapped under the rubble.
Hwaida Saad
Reporting from Beirut
Hezbollah’s deputy leader, Naim Qassem, said that “what happened last night is just the beginning,” referring to the barrage of rockets, missiles and drones that Hezbollah launched. He warned that the conflict with Israel had entered “a new stage.” Hezbollah will fight Israel “from where they expect and from where they do not expect,” he told thousands of people gathered in southern Beirut for the funeral of Ibrahim Aqeel, a Hezbollah commander killed on Friday in an Israeli strike.
Reporting from Washington
The White House is watching the deadly missile strikes across the Israel-Lebanon border with “great concern” and has told Israeli officials that “escalating this military conflict” is not “in their best interest,” John Kirby, President Biden’s national security spokesman, said on ABC’s “This Week.”
Reporting from Washington
Kirby insisted that Biden is still committed to a diplomatic solution in the region — even as he conceded the situation is worsening. “We all, of course, recognize that the tensions are much higher now than they were even just a few days ago,” he said, adding, “We want to make sure that we can continue to do everything we can to try to prevent this from becoming an all-out war there with Hezbollah across that Lebanese border.”
Videos show the moment a Hezbollah missile hit a residential area in northern Israel.
A missile fired by Hezbollah slammed into a residential neighborhood in the Israeli town of Kiryat Bialik on Sunday morning, setting cars and a building ablaze and blowing out the windows of nearby apartments, numerous videos verified by The New York Times show.
The missile was part of a large overnight barrage that Israel’s military said included around 150 rockets, cruise missiles and drones. Air defenses intercepted most, according to the military, but Kiryat Bialik, near the city of Haifa, suffered a direct hit.
A dashcam video recorded inside a parked car in a densely populated neighborhood of the town captured the sound of loud booms before a missile was seen exploding with a flash and smoke around 30 yards away.
A second video showed at least two vehicles engulfed in flames and a building next to them on fire, as people ran toward the vehicles and sprayed extinguishers. “Firefighters are on the other side,” one person says. “Get closer, get closer.”
Across the street from the strike, a resident filmed inside an upper-floor apartment. The force of the blast shattered the apartment’s windows, scattered glass across the floor and kitchen countertops and knocked photographs off a wall, the video shows.
A later video showed the scene after the blaze was extinguished. A large hose lay on the ground, the cars were smoldering and smoke was rising from a window of the building that had been alight but was now blackened. Debris had pockmarked the walls of other buildings in the area.
Adam Rasgon
Magen David Adom, an Israeli emergency response service, said four people were wounded by shrapnel in Hezbollah’s rocket attacks on northern Israel early Sunday. It said a man in his 70s was in moderate condition after a shrapnel injury to his eye. The injuries of the three others were categorized as mild, the service added.
Adam Rasgon
In a recorded statement, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Israel has dealt Hezbollah “a series of blows” that the group hadn’t anticipated. “If Hezbollah didn’t understand the message, I promise you it will understand the message,” he said, adding that Israel was determined to return displaced people to their homes in northern Israel.
Adam Rasgon
Netanyahu appeared to be referring to the pager and walkie talkie attacks last week and the strikes that killed senior Hezbollah commanders in Beirut. While Israel is widely believed to be behind the exploding pagers and walkie-talkies, it hasn’t explicitly taken responsibility for them.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
As the clashes between Israel and Hezbollah intensified, the U.N. warned that the region was “on the brink of an imminent catastrophe.” The U.N’s special coordinator for Lebanon, Jeanine Hennis-Plasschaert, said in a statement that military action would not make “either side safer.”
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
Lebanon’s health ministry said that at least three people had been killed and four others wounded in Israeli strikes in southern Lebanon today.
Hiba Yazbek
In the Gaza Strip, the Palestinian Civil Defense said that seven people were killed and several others were wounded in an Israeli strike on a school building that was housing displaced people in Gaza City. Israel’s military said in a statement that it carried out “a precise strike” on Hamas militants who were operating from the school-turned-shelter, and had taken “numerous steps” to mitigate civilian harm.
Cassandra Vinograd
Israel’s military has just issued an update saying that the overnight barrage launched by Hezbollah included around 150 rockets, cruise missiles and drones. Most were intercepted by air defenses, it said, adding that there were a “small number” of hits, and also cases where debris from interceptions fell on Israeli territory.
Israel’s military closes Al Jazeera’s office in the West Bank.
Israel’s military raided the office of the influential Arab broadcaster Al Jazeera in the Israeli-occupied West Bank on Sunday and ordered its closure for 45 days, the latest move in Israel’s effort to clamp down on the channel.
The raid illustrated that Israeli authorities were prepared to take far-reaching action to undermine the channel, which is based in Qatar and has provided extensive coverage of Israel’s military operations in Gaza and the West Bank.
In the early hours of Sunday, a group of Israeli soldiers forcibly entered Al Jazeera’s office in Ramallah and told Walid al-Omari, the local bureau chief, that he and his staff should leave immediately.
When Mr. al-Omari asked why the Israeli forces were closing the office, one of the soldiers told him to contact the commander of the Israeli military in the West Bank for more details. Al Jazeera broadcast the initial minutes of the raid live.
Military documents shared with reporters by Mr. al-Omari and reviewed by The New York Times showed that the soldiers had seized dozens of items from the office, including computers and cameras.
The Israeli military said in a statement that it had closed the offices following a “directive of the political echelon,” without stating who within the government ordered the office’s closure.
The military also cited a legal opinion and “an up-to-date intelligence assessment” that it said had determined that “the offices were being used to incite terror” and “to support terrorist activities.” It did not provide further details on that assessment.
Al Jazeera called Israel’s allegations “unfounded” and condemned the raid on its office, saying it was “an affront to press freedom and the very principles of journalism.”
“These oppressive measures are clearly intended to prevent the world from witnessing the reality of the situation in the occupied territories and the ongoing war on Gaza,” it said in a statement.
In May, Israeli security forces raided Al Jazeera’s office in Nazareth and a hotel room used by the network in East Jerusalem after the government voted to shut down the Qatari-funded channel’s operations in Israel, under a new law that provides the authorities with tools to crack down on foreign news organizations. At the time, it was unclear if the decision would extend into the West Bank.
Earlier this month, Israel’s government press office said it was revoking official credentials from Al Jazeera reporters working in Israel.
Under the new law, if the prime minister deems that a foreign news outlet is “concretely” undermining Israel’s national security, the government can temporarily close its offices and confiscate its equipment. It can also remove an outlet from Israeli cable and satellite television providers and block access to its online content that is hosted on servers in Israel or owned by Israeli entities.
Press freedom advocates have decried Israel’s actions against Al Jazeera, saying they have set a worrying precedent for international news outlets working in Israel. They have demanded that Israel permit Al Jazeera and other media organizations to carry out their work freely. Since the start of the war in Gaza, Israel has not permitted foreign reporters to enter Gaza with the exception of trips it organizes for journalists to specific locations.
In late July, Israel killed Ismail al-Ghoul, an Al Jazeera reporter in Gaza, in an airstrike, claiming he was a member of Hamas’s military wing. Al Jazeera rejected the allegation as “baseless.”
In 2022, an Israeli soldier fatally shot Shireen Abu Akleh, an Al Jazeera reporter in the West Bank, who had been in the area of a military convoy that was engaged in a firefight with a group of Palestinians. She was wearing a protective vest marked “PRESS” and was hundreds of feet away from the shooter. The military later apologized for her death.
In Israel, Al Jazeera’s Arabic-language coverage has frequently come under criticism for amplifying the perspective of Hamas during the war.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other Israeli officials have called the network a “mouthpiece” for Hamas, which led the Oct. 7 attacks on Israel that set off the war. That day, Al Jazeera repeatedly reported on statements from Hamas officials calling for a violent uprising in the occupied West Bank.
Amelia Nierenberg contributed reporting.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
Lebanon’s health ministry raised the death toll from Israel’s airstrike on Friday in Beirut. It said that at least 45 people — including women and children — were killed. Rescuers continue to search through the rubble of the two high-rise apartment buildings. Many people are still missing.
Vivek Shankar
The Israeli military said that it had intercepted dozens of “projectiles” fired by Hezbollah earlier in the day. But some fell in and around the Haifa district and caused fires, which were being put out by fire crews.
Vivek Shankar
Hezbollah in the past few hours has fired more than a hundred “aerial threats” at civilian areas in Israel, the Israeli military said, adding it has resumed striking Hezbollah targets.
Vivek Shankar
Israeli troops on Sunday raided Al Jazeera’s office in Ramallah in the West Bank, the network said. The news outlet’s journalists were ordered to leave the premises and told that their office would be shut. In May, Israeli officials ordered Al Jazeera to shut down operations in Israel.
Patrick Kingsley
Magen David Adom, Israel’s main emergency medical organization, said its medics had treated a man, around age 60, who had been “lightly scratched” by a small piece of shrapnel. The group said in a statement that it had also treated several people who had been injured while running to air raid shelters or who suffered anxiety during the recent barrage.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
Hezbollah said in a statement that it had targeted the Ramat David air base, southeast of the northern Israeli city of Haifa, with dozens of missiles. The barrage was a response to Israeli strikes in Lebanon which had caused civilian deaths, the group said.
Patrick Kingsley
The skies above northern Israel have now been calm for more than 45 minutes, following the barrage of rockets fired unusually deep into Israel at around 1:10 a.m. local time. The Israeli military has announced that one rocket evaded Israel’s air defense missiles. Kan, the Israeli national broadcaster, said that one person was lightly injured.
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
The Israeli military said roughly 10 rockets crossed into Israel from Lebanon as part of the volley toward communities in northern Israel. Most were intercepted by Israel’s aerial defense, the military said.
Patrick Kingsley
The recent rockets from Lebanon were fired deep into Israel, but they may have avoided three of the most populated cities in northern Israel, Haifa, Nahariya and Tiberias. The military’s alert system has not reported rocket fire over those three cities.
For Americans haunted by the 1983 Beirut bombings, the killing of a Hezbollah leader resurfaces decades of pain.
Two deadly bombings in Beirut, Lebanon, that killed scores of U.S. military personnel more than 40 years ago have cast a long shadow over survivors and victims’ families.
A day after the killing of a senior Hezbollah member seen as a key figure in those attacks, many of those Americans welcomed the news but said it stirred painful memories without resolving the past.
“It doesn’t bring closure,” said Michael Harris, 59, a Marine veteran who was “blown out” of his barracks in one of the attacks and lives today in Rhode Island. “It wasn’t just one person responsible.”
The senior Hezbollah commander Ibrahim Aqeel was killed on Friday after Israeli fighter jets bombed a heavily residential area of Beirut’s southern suburbs. Mr. Aqeel has been long been wanted by the United States for his role in two 1983 bombings in Beirut that killed over 350 people, most of them U.S. service members. The United States had placed a multimillion-dollar bounty on his head, but he had survived multiple assassination attempts.
The first attack, a bombing of the U.S. Embassy in Beirut in April 1983, killed 63 people, including 17 Americans. Six months later, a suicide bomber drove a truck packed with explosives into the U.S. Marine Corps barracks in Beirut, killing more than 300 people, including 241 American service members.
For many survivors and victims’ loved ones, those bombings never go away.
Every time Mr. Harris picks up the paper or watches the news about another bombing, he said, “it opens up wounds.”
Elisa Camara, 58, of Daytona Beach Shores, Fla., said Mr. Aqeel’s death brought back hard memories of her brother, Mecot Camara, who was one of the Marines killed in the October bombing. Her voice broke as she described him as a kindhearted man who “never had an enemy” and cherished hunting, fishing and spending time with his family.
Like many families, she said, she never experienced the sense of resolution of the killings through the legal system, so Mr. Aqeel’s death offered a measure of finality — at least regarding one of those involved.
“Justice is served,” she said. “That’s one less evil person in the world.”
Still, she added, more must be done to combat terrorism so that more people do not lose their loved ones.
Valerie Giblin, 61, of Smithfield, R.I., shared a similar sense of unresolved grief. Her husband, Timothy Giblin, died in the barracks attack when their daughter was 2 years old.
“I was 20 years old,” she said. “I never remarried. I’ll be his wife until the day I die.”
When Mrs. Giblin heard the news from friends and family, she said her reaction was, “It’s about time.” After all these years, she added, little has been done to hold those responsible accountable.
Lisa Weide, 62, of Daytona Beach, Fla., who lost her brother, Brett Croft, in the barracks attack just three days before his 21st birthday, shared a similar sentiment about Mr. Aqeel.
“As cruel as it may sound, I’m glad he’s dead,” she said.
However, Mrs. Weide said, she found her own closure years ago. A few months after Mr. Croft’s death, she said she had a dream so vivid that she was convinced it was him.
In the dream, Mr. Croft appeared in his favorite shirt — the black button-down he always had her iron for him before going out — and invited her on a walk. They eventually stopped, and he told her, “I have to go now.”
Before he left, she asked, “Did you suffer?”
“We locked eyes,” she recounted, choking up. “And he said, ‘No.’”
“That really helped me,” she said. “I don’t walk around dwelling on it. I felt at peace.”
Sheelagh McNeill and Jack Begg contributed research.
Patrick Kingsley
Israel’s military alert system has just warned of rockets in the skies above roughly 70 towns in northern Israel. Some of the towns are more than 30 miles south of the Israel-Lebanon border, which would make this the farthest militants in Lebanon have fired into Israel since the start of the conflict in October.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
The Israeli military said that it had struck around 400 targets across southern Lebanon since Saturday afternoon, following an additional wave of attacks. The bombardment represented a significant uptick.
A week of chaos pushes Lebanon’s doctors to the limit.
Dr. Dania El-Hallak was already exhausted. After wireless devices exploded across Lebanon, there had been little time to process what she had seen — the hundreds of wounded, many of their faces disfigured beyond recognition.
“I am hoping that it was all just a bad dream,” Dr. El-Hallak said, still struggling to take stock of the carnage on Friday.
Then, without warning, Israeli fighter jets ripped through the skies above Lebanon’s capital.
“There are strikes in Dahiya?” she said in disbelief, using the Arabic name for Beirut’s southern suburbs.
Her nightmare had only just begun.
The attacks on Hezbollah’s communication devices this week — widely attributed to Israel — wounded thousands of people, leaving many of them permanently disabled and in need of long-term rehabilitative care. The Israeli airstrike just miles from downtown Beirut on Friday, which killed at least 37 people and injured dozens more, has only added to the toll. Others are still presumed trapped in the debris.
Lebanon’s ailing health system — already embattled by a crippling economic collapse — has been sent into overdrive.
“The sense is that war is inevitable, especially after yesterday’s air raid,” said Dr. Ghassan Abu Sitta, the chief reconstructive surgeon at the American University of Beirut Medical Center.
Last year, Dr. Abu Sitta spent 43 days volunteering in Gaza at Shifa hospital’s burn treatment unit. When the Israeli airstrike hit on Friday as he was still operating on those wounded in the wireless device attacks, he said it felt like he was suddenly back in the besieged Palestinian enclave.
“We are stuck in this loop,” Dr. Abu Sitta said. “You just operate and operate. You feel like you are playing catch up all the time.”
For 11 months, Hezbollah has been firing into northern Israel in support of Hamas in Gaza. Israel has responded by bombarding Lebanon and assassinating the Hezbollah’s leaders. More than 160,000 civilians have fled areas on both sides of the border. The violence seen in recent days, however, has represented a significant escalation in the conflict, fueling fears that Israel is beckoning all-out war.
The sudden brutality of the wireless device attacks this week, which saw pagers and hand-held radios detonate without warning, have shocked even the most hardened of Lebanese doctors. Eyes blown out of their sockets. Faces torn to pieces by burning shards of plastic. Hands and fingers so mangled that doctors had no choice but to amputate them.
Many of the victims — among them women and children — would never see again, doctors said.
“This attack was literally directed at the eyes,” said Dr. Pierre Mardelli, a veteran eye doctor who answered the call for volunteers this week when news broke of the first wave of explosions on Tuesday.
His patients said they had received an error message on their pagers, prompting them to try to fix the problem. Then the devices exploded in their hands. It appeared to be one of the key factors that accounted for so many people being blinded.
“People did not even have time to blink,” he said.
With hospitals swamped by the influx of patients, Dr. Mardelli said he was forced for the first time in his 27-year career to suture eye wounds without anesthesia.
“It was an indiscriminate attack,” Firass Abiad, Lebanon’s health minister, told reporters on Thursday, describing the burden the attacks had put on Lebanon’s health system. “It was a war crime.”
Mr. Abiad has pledged to pay for the long-term care of those injured, but Lebanese remain skeptical of any promises by the country’s ailing government. Despite assurances, the health system itself would most likely be unable to cope in the event of an all-out conflict, doctors said.
“The Lebanese health system is in no way able to treat war wounded if it were to escalate into a full-blown war,” Dr. Abu Sitta said.
The rehabilitation process, doctors said, would be a long and difficult road for hundreds if not thousands of people.
Dr. Antoine Abi Abboud, who leads the plastic and reconstructive surgery unit at Beirut’s Mount Lebanon hospital, estimated that at least 40 percent of those wounded in the wave of wireless device attacks had been left permanently disabled.
The hospital had received some of the most severe cases on Tuesday because of its proximity to Beirut’s southern suburbs, where the bulk of the pager detonations took place. Dr. Abi Abboud said most of the people he treated had lost one or both of their eyes.
“It was savage,” he said.
At a Hezbollah funeral, a chaotic week brings a mix of sorrow and defiance.
I attended a funeral for three Hezbollah members in southern Beirut on Saturday, where you could feel a mix of sorrow and defiance among the mourners after a deadly and chaotic week for the militant group.
The coffins, draped in Hezbollah’s yellow and green flag, were carried by a procession of men chanting Shiite religious and pro-Hezbollah slogans, while the audio of a speech by Hezbollah’s leader, Hassan Nasrallah, played in the background. Mr. Nasrallah has vowed retribution against Israel for a week of attacks that included exploding wireless devices, which killed dozens and maimed thousands, and an airstrike that targeted a meeting of Hezbollah commanders.
Hezbollah members I spoke to said they are eagerly awaiting orders from Mr. Nasrallah, and the group’s regional patron, Iran, as to how — or whether — to respond to Israel’s latest attacks. Everyone I spoke to refused to give me their full names for fear of reprisals.
But some reflected an ambivalence over what that response should be: One told me he hoped Mr. Nasrallah would order a fierce retaliation. Others said that idea gave them pause. After being dealt heavy blows, they said the group needed time to recover and prepare a response that was substantive and not merely symbolic.
Ahmad, who gave me his first name, was holding Hezbollah’s flag and said he was ready to fight, but also that he would wait to receive orders.
No matter their positions, everyone at the funeral expressed continued loyalty to Mr. Nasrallah and faith in his decisions at a time when many other Lebanese have expressed shock at how deeply Israeli intelligence appeared to had penetrated Hezbollah.
Even after Israel’s string of attacks this week, Hezbollah has continued its daily bombardment of northern Israel, which it has vowed to continue until Israel reaches a cease-fire with Hamas to end the war in the Gaza Strip.
In a symbolic gesture of their continued support of the Palestinian cause, some mourners at the funeral draped the black-and-white checkered Palestinian scarf, known as the kaffiyeh, over their shoulders.
U.N. Meets Amid a Backdrop of Growing Chaos and Violence
When the United Nations General Assembly convenes on Tuesday, attention will focus on the major wars raging in Ukraine, Gaza and Sudan, amid a reckoning that neither the global body nor world powers have been able to end the violence.
By all accounts, the world has descended deeper into chaos and turmoil since last year’s annual gathering, when Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and Sudan’s civil war cast shadows. Now, those have been eclipsed by the Hamas-led Oct. 7 attack on Israel, and the war that followed in Gaza, with its catastrophic humanitarian toll on Palestinians.
The United Nations itself has had a turbulent year. A record number of its staff, 220 in total, have been killed in the war in Gaza. Its humanitarian resources, a crucial backbone of the global relief effort, are overstretched and underfunded as needs multiply rapidly because of wars, climate change and natural disasters. At the same time, its leadership struggles to play a meaningful role in conflict mediation.
“International challenges are moving faster than our ability to solve them,” said Secretary General António Guterres in a news conference this past week. “We see out-of-control geopolitical divisions and runaway conflicts — not least in Ukraine, Gaza, Sudan and beyond.”
The Security Council, which typically holds one session on the sidelines of the General Assembly, is scheduled to meet three times this year, on Ukraine, Gaza and the broader question of leadership challenges in resolving conflicts.
President Biden will address the General Assembly for the last time as his presidency draws to a close. With the exception of the European allies, the majority of U.N. member states have been highly critical of Mr. Biden’s staunch support of Israel and the United States’ blocking multiple calls for a cease-fire during the first eight months of the war.
Mr. Biden has in recent months led an effort, with Egypt and Qatar, to broker a cease-fire between Israel and Hamas and secure the release of all the hostages held by Hamas. But the talks have stalled, and the electronic devices attack in Lebanon this past week and an Israeli airstrike in Beirut on Friday that killed at least nine people, seem to be dimming prospects of any breakthrough.
France’s president, Emmanuel Macron, and Prime Minister Keir Starmer of Britain will attend this year after both France and Britain sat out last year’s gathering. Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelensky, will deliver three speeches in person, including at the Security Council meeting on Ukraine, where he is expected to present a new peace plan and renew his pleas to authorize Ukraine’s use of Western missiles to strike military targets deep inside Russia, diplomats said.
“It feels like we say this every year, but this year’s meeting could not come at a more critical and more challenging moment,” said Linda Thomas-Greenfield, the United States ambassador to the United Nations, at a briefing with reporters. “The list of crises and conflicts that demand attention and action only seems to grow and grow.”
Middle East Crisis: Live Updates
- Israel’s military closes Al Jazeera’s office in the West Bank.
- Here are the latest developments.
- For Americans haunted by the 1983 Beirut bombings, the killing of a Hezbollah leader resurfaces decades of pain.
Ms. Thomas-Greenfield said the United States would pursue three policy priorities during the General Assembly: international cooperation on peace and stability, improving global humanitarian aid responses, and revamping the Security Council.
Iran’s new reformist president, Masoud Pezeshkian, making his debut on the international stage, will be trying to present his government as moderate, pragmatic and open to diplomacy with the West, in contrast with his hard-line conservative predecessor, Ebrahim Raisi, who died in a helicopter crash in May.
That might not be an easy sell. Iran’s support of a network of militias in Lebanon, in Yemen and in Gaza and the West Bank, and recent reports that it is supplying Russia with ballistic missiles for its war against Ukraine, pose obstacles to defusing tensions with the West that Mr. Pezeshkian will struggle to overcome.
Richard Gowan, an expert on the United Nations with the International Crisis Group, said that the prospects for breakthroughs on Gaza or Ukraine at the assembly were bleak. But Sudan, Mr. Gowan said, could be an exception.
“I actually think the General Assembly could do some good on Sudan, probably in a way that it cannot on Gaza and Ukraine,” he said. “There is an emerging feeling among a lot of the U.N. membership that the U.N. failed unnecessarily on Sudan and that it’s time to push for more diplomacy.”
Climate change and rising sea levels will join with restructuring of the Security Council and the World Bank as major topics for discussion. For years, countries in Africa, Asia and South America have complained that the Security Council’s core group of five permanent, veto-wielding members — the United States, Britain, France Russia and China — is outdated, overlooking economic powers like India, Brazil and Japan, as well as the entire continent of Africa.
This month Ms. Thomas-Greenfield said that the United States supported adding two permanent African members to the Security Council and proposed starting preliminary negotiations on the matter. Washington also supports adding seats for Germany, India and Japan, but none of the new permanent members would have veto power.
Any changes to the Security Council require altering the U.N. charter and the approval of all current five members, a tall task given the divisions among Russia, China and the United States.
In an effort to spearhead the changes, Mr. Guterres will host a conference on Sunday and Monday, ahead of the General Assembly. The goal is for countries to approve three negotiated documents that are meant to serve as blueprints for addressing current and future challenges on climate, artificial intelligence, conflict and restructuring U.N. institutions.
“So many of the challenges that we face today were not on the radar 80 years ago when our multilateral institutions were born,” Mr. Guterres said. “Our founders understood that times would change.”
At a Remote Scottish Pub, a Pint Worth Hiking 20 Miles
The simple pleasure of a hot pub meal and a cold pint can be found just down the street for most people in Britain. Then, there is The Old Forge: perhaps the most remote pub on the mainland, lying at the end of a multiday wilderness hike through craggy mountains and glistening lochs.
Isolation is part of the charm that draws adventurers to the untamed landscapes and quieter lifestyle of Knoydart, a rugged peninsula on the west coast of Scotland. To get to its main settlement, Inverie — home to half of the peninsula’s 120 or so residents — travelers must churn over the waters of Loch Nevis from Mallaig or walk some 20 miles from the nearest road.
In Knoydart, there are no roads connected to other towns, no major supermarket, and in some places, even no cellphone signal. But there is, of course, a pub.
“You definitely need a pub at the end of that big trip,” said Stephanie Harris, business development manager at The Old Forge. “We try our best to make sure that folks have a good welcome when they get here.”
-
NHS Is in Deep Trouble: The National Health Service is in “critical” condition, according to a report that cited long waits for treatment, crumbling hospitals, mental health patients in “vermin-infested cells” and far fewer M.R.I. scanners than in comparable countries.
-
Greener Steel Comes WIth Job Losses: The British government and the Indian company Tata said they would invest 1.25 billion pounds in a plan to convert the steel mill at Port Talbot in Wales to an electric furnace. As part of the overhaul, about 2,800 of the company’s 8,000 jobs will be lost.
-
Revolt Over Winter Fuel Aid: Prime Minister Keir Starmer survived a test of his authority, but more than 50 Labour lawmakers did not back his plan to reduce fuel aid.
-
Princess of Wales Completes Chemotherapy: In a video message, Catherine said she would return to more of her duties, but many questions remain about her condition and treatment.
The trek is rewarding, but not without danger. One hiker, Paul Conway, spent nearly a week outdoors this month, according to Police Scotland, after he got lost and went missing on the 24-mile walk from Glenfinnan to Inverie, one of two main hikes into the village. Mr. Conway, 67, was eventually found in “good health and good spirits” after a challenging search that pulled in mountain rescuers, the police said.
In a Facebook post, the pub said it was relieved to hear Mr. Conway had been reunited with his family. “We hope to see you in the Forge afore long,” it said.
The Old Forge, once an 18th-century cottage on the peninsula, has long served as a meeting place for Knoydart’s residents and thirsty hikers. In 2022, a group of residents raised more than one million British pounds (about $1.3 million in 2022) to buy the pub and refurbish it.
“Being the only pub in the area, it’s a real focal point,” Ms. Harris said of The Old Forge, describing it as an economic and social center for Knoydart. The previous owner had closed the pub during winters, and that had dampened morale in the village, she said.
These days, the pub is open year round, and most days a crew of hikers stop by for food or a pint of locally brewed beer.
“So far, it is looking like a really successful year,” Ms. Harris said. (For a time, they offered beer for free to hikers as part of a collaboration with an online sports retailer. That offer is no longer valid, she clarified.)
To reach The Old Forge, hikers trek between two deep-sea lochs, Loch Nevis and Loch Hourn — popularly translated from Gaelic as “Heaven” and “Hell” — into a lush limbo of steep hills, mountain passes, woodland and valleys. Ravens and eagles circle above, while deer and highland cows roam through the grassland.
“It is the mystery of what is on the other side,” said Ben Thorburn, a spokesman for Wilderness Scotland, which leads guided hikes through Knoydart, of the walk’s appeal. “It’s almost like you’re entering a wonderland.”
But there is very little cellphone signal along the route, which includes some challenging sections, said Finlay Greig, a ranger in Knoydart.
“People have it in their heads that it is a pleasant stroll to the pub, but seriously, it is rough country,” he said, adding that hikers should carry a personal locator device on the journey. Those not up for the long route to the pub can visit via ferries and boats, which also bring supplies from the mainland, he said.
Mr. Greig, 31, moved to the peninsula after a hiking trip three years ago turned into a longer stay, and eventually a permanent relocation from Glasgow. “It was the landscape that attracted me, but it was the people and the hardworking community that made me stay,” he said.
He sometimes misses the conveniences of city life, he said, like easily getting a haircut. “You need to be more practical and a little more organized — a little more self-sufficient,” he said.
“You definitely have to have a certain hardiness to live here,” Ms. Harris said. But those who choose to make Knoydart their home share a desire to be close to the land, she said. There is a common saying on the peninsula, she said, “If you make it through two winters, you probably will never leave.”
In April, Ruth Aisling, who makes travel videos, made the trek to Inverie. She left her vehicle in Kinloch Hourn, a settlement from which the hike to Inverie takes two days, and stayed overnight at a bothy, or a shelter for hikers maintained by a national charity.
“It really does feel like a wilderness because there are no roads,” she said. “You can go long stretches without meeting anyone.”
She, like many others before her, was excited when the village, and then The Old Forge, came into view at the end of the long walk. She went in and ordered a drink.
“It was the best beer I’ve ever had,” she said.
What to Watch For in a Key German State Election
Voters are going to the polls on Sunday for state elections in Brandenburg, the eastern German state that surrounds Berlin like a doughnut, in a regional contest that could affect the stability of Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s government.
Mr. Scholz’s government has been struggling in recent months as Germans worry about the poor economy and uncontrolled migration and blame his coalition for not solving these problems.
Both the far right and the far left are expected to make significant gains on Sunday, as was the case with elections in two other eastern German states this month, further weakening the grip of the country’s center-left and center-right parties.
Here is what to know about the vote and its possible ramifications.
Why is this election important?
The election in this relatively small state — involving only about 3 percent of Germany’s voters — is being widely watched, even though it does not directly affect Mr. Scholz’s government.
Brandenburg is one of the last two eastern bastions for the chancellor’s center-left Social Democratic Party. And the state’s incumbent governor, Dietmar Woidke, is one of the most popular Social Democrats in the country.
But the far right Alternative for Germany party (widely known as AfD, its initials in German) and the far-left Alliance Sahra Wagenknecht, or B.S.W., are both poised to make significant gains. Polls suggest that the AfD is set to win a plurality of the seats in the statehouse.
If voters oust Mr. Woidke in favor of the AfD, it would be a symbolic and a practical loss for Mr. Scholz, his party and the government he leads.
Germany’s state leaders meet regularly in Berlin at the Federal Council of the States, where they approve — or block — laws passed by Parliament. If Mr. Woidke were ousted, the Council of the States could become less willing to rubber-stamp laws drafted by the government that includes his party.
Such a loss would sting on a personal level for Mr. Scholz, given that he lives in Brandenburg and maintains his election district there.
It would also not bode well for the national coalition government parties — the Social Democrats, the climate-conscious Greens and the pro-business Free Democrats — with a general election looming.
In a recent poll of German voters, more than half of respondents said they wanted the general election scheduled for September of next year to be held earlier. That sort of angst prompted the Christian Democrats, the mainstream opposition to Mr. Scholz’s party, to meet this past week to agree on their candidate for chancellor — meaning that they will be ready if the government falls and an early election is called.
Why are people moving away from the center?
The AfD in particular has been gaining support for its positions on curbing migration and ending German military support for Ukraine, a cause that is unpopular in eastern Germany.
And because the party has held seats in the state legislature for a decade but has never had a chance to govern, that has given its politicians a wide berth to claim that they could help solve the state’s many problems if only they were let into government.
The B.S.W., led by Sahra Wagenknecht, a former communist, has also been outspoken on the issues of immigration and support for and an end to military support for Ukraine. Although neither of those planks is directly related to state politics, recent polls suggest that the party is to likely garner significantly more than a tenth of the votes.
Yet even if the AfD meets the expectations of the highest projections, it will receive less than a third of the vote, which is not enough to run the government on its own. And every other major party on the ballot has vowed not to work with them.
Why is Brandenburg a special case?
Because it surrounds Berlin, the country’s capital, parts of the state tend to be wealthier and younger than other regions of eastern Germany. By attracting Tesla to build its only European car factory there, Brandenburg has created thousands of well-paying jobs.
But other parts of the state are still reeling from a decline in coal mining, which was a major economic driver in the days before the reunification of East and West Germany in the early 1990s.
Politically, Brandenburg differs from Thuringia and Saxony, the two other eastern states that just voted. Although the far right also does well in Brandenburg, the country’s two largest mainstream parties still command significant support there. Combined, those parties — the Social Democrats and the Christian Conservatives — are posed to get more than 40 percent of the vote.
If they do, and if the Greens eke out the 5 percent needed to return to the legislature as polls suggest they will, the state’s current governing coalition of those three parties could continue.
How close is the race?
Mr. Woidke, the popular incumbent governor, recently announced that he would retire if the AfD received the most votes, even if his party can still lead a government coalition. And Mr. Scholz, fully aware that he and the Berlin government are unpopular, has refrained from campaigning for Mr. Woidke in the state.
The party’s tactics appear to have had some effect. Recent polling shows that although the Social Democrats are still trailing the AfD, the gap has been slowly closing.
Congo Releases More Than 700 Inmates After a Deadly Stampede
More than 700 inmates were released from the largest prison in the Democratic Republic of Congo, the country’s authorities said on Saturday, as officials sought to ease overcrowding in a facility where at least 129 people died in an attempted jailbreak this month.
Congo’s justice minister, Constant Mutamba, announced their release during a visit to the Makala Central Prison, where the deadly episode highlighted the alarming conditions faced by inmates in the only prison in Kinshasa, Congo’s capital and one of Africa’s most populous cities.
Mr. Mutamba promised that Kinshasa would get a new prison, though he did not give details.
Of the 729 inmates released, most — 648 — were released on bail.
On the evening of Sept. 2, inmates, whose cells had been without water and electricity for more than a day and a half, tried to break out to escape the stifling heat, several inmates told The New York Times.
The details remain unclear, but most of the deaths occurred in a stampede that followed, while at least 24 people were fatally shot while trying to escape, the country’s authorities have said. Several female prisoners were raped, according to Human Rights Watch and Congo’s interior minister.
The Makala Prison, which was built in 1957 during the era of Belgian colonial rule and little renovated since, has a capacity of 1,500, but has at times held 10 times more than that.
The prison’s director, Joseph Yusufu Maliki, has been suspended, and dozens of inmates accused of raping female inmates during the jailbreak soon faced trial.
Some of the women told the television channel TV5 Monde that 10 men, some of whom were armed with scissors and knives, had raped them and threatened to kill or mutilate them if they resisted.
Human rights organizations and journalists have long described conditions in Makala and other prisons in the Central African country as inhumane: overcrowded, violent and filthy.
Last year, more than 500 inmates died from suffocation and various diseases at the prison, according to Emmanuel Adu Cole, a human-rights activist based in Kinshasa. Mr. Cole said that out of about 15,000 inmates, only 2,500 had been convicted; the rest were awaiting trial.
“Most of the inmates have no reason to be held in such inhumane conditions,” Mr. Cole said in a telephone interview. “This cannot continue.”
More than 500 inmates had been released from the Makala Prison in August, before the attempted jailbreak shed a new light on the conditions there.
“There is a program, across the country, that aims at building new prisons,” Patrick Muyaya, a government spokesman, said this month on the television channel France 24. “The incident that happened is going to accelerate the process that had already started.”
Mr. Muyaya did not provide details on how many facilities would be built, nor when they would be operational.
Explosion at an Iranian Mine Kills Dozens, State Media Says
A methane explosion at a coal mine in eastern Iran killed at least 51 miners, and the death toll was expected to rise, Iranian state media said on Sunday.
The miners died of suffocation from the rapid release of methane and carbon monoxide, according to a report by Iran’s state news agency, IRNA. At the time of the explosion on Saturday, in the eastern Iranian city of Tabas, there were 69 workers in the mine, the news agency said.
Many may still be trapped, according to Tasnim news agency, which is affiliated with the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps.
It was not possible to independently verify details of the incident.
Officials say they are trying to work quickly to rescue the workers trapped in the mine, which is operated by the Madanjo Company, according to the Fars news agency, affiliated with the Revolutionary Guards.
President Masoud Pezeshkian of Iran ordered an investigation into the explosion, IRNA reported. Mohammad-Ali Akhondi, a crisis management official, urged caution about the rescue efforts, IRNA reported.
“The reality is that it is a difficult task to rescue the injured,” he said, according to IRNA. The report said rescuers would need to go about 2,300 feet diagonally and 820 feet vertically underground to reach the trapped workers.
Industrial accidents are common in Iran, and many construction and mining sites operate with outdated and inadequate materials.
In 2017, dozens of miners were killed and many were hurt after an explosion at a coal mine near the northern Iranian town of Azadshahr, in the Golestan Province.
For Mideast Foes, Diplomacy Takes a Back Seat to Military Force
The last, best chance for a peace plan between Israel and the Palestinian authorities came in 2008, when then-Prime Minister Ehud Olmert was prepared to give up territory in the West Bank, allow some refugees to reclaim land and even relinquish control of Jerusalem’s Old City to an international committee as part of recognizing Palestine as a sovereign state.
And then the potential deal fell apart, for reasons that Mr. Olmert still finds difficult to explain. “This was something that would have changed the Middle East,” he said in an interview about his failed talks with the Palestinian Authority’s president, Mahmoud Abbas. “He was not ready to take any risk.”
Mr. Abbas has said he was not given a proper opportunity to examine the proposed map of the West Bank and asked for more time. Days later, Mr. Olmert resigned under a cloud of corruption accusations, and the deal died.
No one in Israel today is thinking about such peace talks, amid fears that a sovereign Palestinian state would find it easier to mount another attack like the one Hamas undertook last Oct. 7, killing 1,200 people and setting off the war in Gaza.
Diplomacy has taken a back seat to military force, reflecting years of distrust and failed deals that have all but cemented the belief among the adversaries that neither side will negotiate in good faith. Officials and experts doubt those attitudes will be reversed any time soon.
Among the democratic nations it is widely agreed that Israel has a right to defend itself from the so-called ring of fire it faces from Iran and its proxy fighters in Lebanon, Iraq, Syria and Yemen that want to destroy Israel.
But last week’s deadly pager and walkie-talkie explosions against Hezbollah operatives in Lebanon — followed by the strike on Friday in Beirut targeting a senior Hezbollah commander that killed at least 45 people — have fueled concerns that Israel is pivoting from cease-fire negotiations to free hostages in favor of military action that could escalate the regional conflict.
“The right path, the right steps, is certainly doing the hostage deal, first and foremost, and nothing else,” Efrat Rayten Marom, a left-leaning member of the Israeli Parliament, said in an interview on Wednesday. “We have to do everything in our power to bring them home now.”
Her son, a soldier, is deployed to Israel’s northern border with Lebanon, where more than 60,000 Israeli residents are waiting to return home after leaving last year when Hezbollah began shelling the area to protest the war in Gaza.
“We have to deal with the north because Hezbollah is there,” Ms. Rayten Marom said. But “there was a plan, a strategy, to finish the war in the Gaza Strip, first and foremost, and then to deal with the north.”
Diplomacy no longer seems to be a priority, she said, under the increasingly combative policies of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel. “I think it reflects this government’s opinion and policy, generally,” Ms. Rayten Marom said. “Netanyahu, with his extremist coalition partners, chose and still are choosing this path.”
Mr. Netanyahu’s office did not respond to a request for comment this past week. On Wednesday, responding to reports in the Israeli news media, his office said it strongly denied “the claim that he has torpedoed any deal whatsoever due to political considerations.”
Nevertheless, a few hours earlier, Israel’s defense minister, Yoav Gallant, confirmed that “the center of gravity is moving north,” referring to the new focus on Hezbollah.
But, he added, “We have not forgotten the hostages and we have not forgotten our missions in the south — we are committed to our duties and we are carrying them out simultaneously.”
The sophisticated attacks in Lebanon on Tuesday and Wednesday killed Hezbollah operatives, but also several civilians, including children. The blasts wounded thousands, spreading panic across Lebanon, and prompted international concerns that Israel had risked further escalating tensions in the region. Reeling from those attacks and the strike on Friday, Hezbollah responded on Sunday with a missile barrage that went deeper into Israeli territory than most of its previous salvos.
“I consider this situation extremely worrying,” Josep Borrell Fontelles, the European Union’s top diplomat, said in a statement on Wednesday. He called on “all stakeholders to avert an all-out war, which would have heavy consequences for the entire region and beyond.”
Middle East Crisis: Live Updates
- Videos show the moment a Hezbollah missile hit a residential area in northern Israel.
- Israel’s military closes Al Jazeera’s office in the West Bank.
- Here are the latest developments.
Even Israel’s most reliable ally, the United States, sounded alarmed that negotiations for a cease-fire and hostage release in Gaza — efforts it is leading, with Egypt and Qatar — would now be sidelined by the pager attacks. Negotiations were already complicated by Israel’s targeted assassinations of the top leaders of Hamas, Hezbollah and other Palestinian groups like Islamic Jihad.
“Anything of that nature, by definition, is probably not good in terms of achieving the result that we want, which is the cease-fire,” Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken said in Egypt on Wednesday, when asked if the attack in Lebanon would make the Gaza talks more difficult.
He left the region shortly afterward without stopping in Israel. Another American envoy, Amos Hochstein, was in Israel on Monday to urge the government against escalating tensions with Hezbollah.
The pagers in Lebanon began exploding the next day.
Brett McGurk, a White House adviser on Middle East policy, said on Friday that while the United States agreed Israel should defend itself from Hezbollah, “we have disagreements with the Israelis about tactics and how you measure escalation risk.”
“We want a diplomatic settlement in the north,” Mr. McGurk told the Israeli-American Council in Washington, in remarks reported by The Jerusalem Post. “That is the objective, and that’s what we’re working towards.”
The United States has worked with Israel for years to help warm relations with skeptical or hostile neighborhood states. In 2022, for example, the United States backed an agreement to allow Western companies to explore for natural gas in disputed territory between Israel and Lebanon, where Hezbollah is part of the government. And the Trump administration was instrumental in brokering the historic Abraham Accords in 2020 that normalized diplomatic relations between Israel and Bahrain, Morocco, Sudan and the United Arab Emirates.
But recent hopes that Saudi Arabia would finally agree to join the accords were dashed this past week when Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, in a speech on behalf of King Salman, said anew that there would be no normal diplomatic relations with Israel until Palestine is recognized as a sovereign state.
Israel’s diplomatic contacts with adversaries are generally delivered through intermediaries, mostly Arab states in the Mideast, but also the United States and countries in Europe.
It does not negotiate directly with Hamas or Hezbollah, both of which want to eradicate Israel, and both of which Israel considers terrorist organizations, as does the United States. It also does not negotiate with Iran, which supports both groups as well as the Houthis in Yemen.
Israel and its allies say it is unrealistic and naïve to expect diplomatic efforts with groups that are trying to end its existence. “This is a different ballgame when you’re handling this situation, when you have a ring of fire — when you have Hezbollah and Houthis and Iran and Hamas, all these threats all around you,” Ms. Rayten Marom said.
Elliott Abrams, an Israel expert who was deputy national security adviser to President George W. Bush and is now a senior Middle East fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, said in an interview that attempts at diplomacy with Iran would never amount to “more than a cease-fire, as long as Iran’s ambitions don’t change — and that ambition is to destroy Israel.”
But Walid Kazziha, a retired professor of Middle East policy at the American University in Cairo, said Israel’s hallmark since its creation in 1948 has been to use military or economic means to coerce its neighbors.
“If you live by hard power alone, you die by hard power,” Mr. Kazziha said in an interview on Wednesday. “To be able to survive in this world, you’ve got to have soft power,” he said, referring to diplomacy, “so that people feel you’re useful.”
Either way, a number of officials and experts in Israel believe Hezbollah will continue its frequent strikes until the fighting ends in Gaza and Israeli hostages are freed in exchange for the release of Palestinian prisoners.
Even if Israel were serious about negotiations, a peace deal appears out of reach in no small part because of the, at best, rocky relationship between Hamas in Gaza and the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank that is led by Mr. Abbas. (A later effort during the Obama administration also fell through, in 2014, as did a proposal from the Trump administration, which was roundly rejected by Palestinian officials.)
But Mr. Olmert, the former Israeli prime minister, said it was at least time to focus on negotiating an end to the war in Gaza and finding a compromise with Hezbollah that allows citizens to move back to their homes in northern Israel.
“We have exhausted all the benefits that we can get from a military operation, so we have to stop now and get back all the hostages” in Gaza, Mr. Olmert said. “It think it’s in the interest of Israel. We have to do it.”
“Look: I prefer negotiations every time, all the time, than fighting,” he said. “Fighting is inevitable and unavoidable. But it has to be the last resort.”