Israel Strikes Near Beirut for First Time in Days
Here are the latest developments.
Israel’s military carried out airstrikes early Wednesday in Hezbollah-dominated areas in southern Lebanon and outside Beirut. They were Israel’s first attacks in days near the Lebanese capital and came a day after the United States said that it had expressed concerns about the scale of Israel’s weekslong bombardment there.
The strikes in southern Lebanon hit municipal buildings in Nabatieh and killed at least 16 people, including the city’s mayor, and injured more than 50, Lebanese officials said. The attacks targeted a meeting of the municipal council, according to Lebanon’s caretaker prime minister, Najib Mikati. The Israeli military said that it had struck Hezbollah targets in and around Nabatieh, one of the largest cities in southern Lebanon, many of whose residents have fled after recent Israeli evacuation warnings.
At least three others were killed and 50 others wounded in an overnight strike on Qana, also in southern Lebanon, the Lebanese health ministry said on Wednesday. The Israeli military said it had targeted a local Hezbollah commander there, along with several other militants.
Two strikes in Beirut’s southern outskirts, in the neighborhood of Haret Hreik, were aimed at underground weapon storage facilities used by Hezbollah, Israel’s military said in a statement. They came about an hour after a spokesman for the Israeli military had issued a warning in Arabic to residents to move at least 500 meters away from a building in the area.
Haret Hreik, which was heavily damaged by Israeli airstrikes in the 2006 war between Israel and Hezbollah, is part of a collection of neighborhoods south of Beirut known as the Dahiya, where the armed group holds sway. Since last month, Israel has repeatedly struck in and around the area as part of an offensive to kill leaders of Hezbollah and to take out its arsenal.
On Tuesday, a State Department spokesman, Matthew Miller, told reporters that the United States had conveyed to Israel concerns about the civilian toll of its weekslong bombing campaign in Beirut, during which many of the strikes have been in the Dahiya. “When it comes to the scope and nature of the bombing campaign that we saw in Beirut over the past few weeks, it’s something that we made clear to the government of Israel we had concerns with and we are opposed to,” Mr. Miller said.
Here’s what else to know:
-
Gaza aid: A day after the United States publicly warned Israel of consequences within 30 days if it does not allow more humanitarian aid into Gaza, there was no official response from the Israeli government. Israel said it had let 50 aid trucks into northern Gaza on Wednesday “in accordance with international law.” That is a small fraction of what aid agencies say is needed in northern Gaza, where Israel “has tightened a siege,” the United Nations has said, as it steps up military operations against Hamas.
-
Conditions deteriorate: Lebanon’s health ministry on Wednesday said that it had detected a case of cholera in the country’s northeast, the first known occurrence of the waterborne disease this year. The World Health Organization has warned of the likelihood of disease outbreaks in Lebanon because of crowding in displacement shelters and shuttered hospitals. Health authorities fear that the war in Lebanon could lead to outbreaks similar to those in Gaza, where disease has surged because of mass displacement and worsening conditions.
-
Northern Lebanon: The U.N. human rights office called on Tuesday for an investigation into an Israeli airstrike a day earlier that killed at least 21 people in the Christian village of Aitou in northern Lebanon, citing potential violations of international laws.
-
Medical evacuations: The Israeli Supreme Court on Tuesday ordered the Israeli government to explain why there appeared to be no comprehensive system to facilitate evacuations of sick Gazans who are not involved in the Hamas-Israel war to other countries for treatment.
-
Peacekeepers in peril: The U.N. peacekeeping force in Lebanon, known as UNIFIL, said that Israeli troops in southern Lebanon had fired at a UNIFIL watchtower early Wednesday, damaging the tower and destroying two cameras. The Israeli military has fired several times over the past week at UNIFIL, operating along Lebanon’s border, injuring peacekeepers and drawing widespread international condemnation. The Israeli military said in a statement that “UNIFIL infrastructure sites and forces are not a target and every irregular incident will be thoroughly examined.”
U.N. Security Council calls on Israel to increase flow of aid into Gaza.
Members of the United Nations Security Council met Wednesday to discuss the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, and every member called on Israel in speeches to consistently allow aid into northern Gaza and drastically scale up assistance to the rest of the enclave.
The Security Council has rarely spoken in unity when it comes to the war in Gaza, and differences remain on how to reach and impose a cease-fire between Hamas and Israel. But at an emergency meeting on Wednesday, diplomats agreed that the lack of sufficient aid into Gaza needed to be addressed urgently.
Many also denounced Israel’s strike of a hospital complex on Monday that ignited fires that spread to a tent shelter for displaced people next to a hospital, leading to accounts that people were burned alive.
Some of the sharpest criticism came from Israel’s allies, including the United States, which vetoed three resolutions blocking efforts for a cease-fire in the first eight months of the war and abstained from one that eventually passed in June.
“There are no words, simply no words, to describe what we saw,” said Linda Thomas-Greenfield, the United States ambassador to the United Nations. “Israel has a responsibility to do everything possible to avoid civilian casualties, even if Hamas was operating near the hospital in an attempt to use civilians as human shields. We have made this clear to Israel.”
Ms. Thomas-Greenfield also said that a “policy of starvation” in northern Gaza would be “horrific and unacceptable and would have implications under international law and U.S. law.”
The rebuke came as the United States warned Israel on Sunday in a letter that if it did not provide scaled-up humanitarian aid to Gaza in the next 30 days, it would face repercussions that could include a halt to American military aid to Israel.
Riyad Mansour, the Palestinian envoy to the United Nations, accused Israel of trying to force Palestinians out of Gaza by withholding food aid, saying, “This is not war; these are crimes.” Mr. Mansour added: “This is genocide. They must be stopped, and they must be stopped now.”
Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations, Danny Danon, defended Israel’s actions and blamed Hamas for using Palestinian civilians as human shields and for robbing aid trucks.
“The only way to improve the humanitarian situation in Gaza is to defeat Hamas and completely disarm it,” Mr. Danon said. He claimed Hamas “steals, stores and sells the aid that enters the Gaza Strip and uses it to feed its terrorist machine and not to feed the Gazans.”
Scott Peterson, the Gaza director of UNRWA, the main U.N. aid agency for Palestinians, said on Wednesday that Israel had allowed 12 aid trucks into northern Gaza on Sept. 30, but no other trucks were allowed into that region of the enclave after that.
COGAT, the Israeli government agency that oversees policy in Gaza and the West Bank, insisted that it was not limiting aid to Gaza and has accused humanitarian agencies of failing to distribute the supplies it has admitted into the enclave after screening. On Wednesday, it said that it had inspected and permitted 50 aid trucks to enter northern Gaza from Jordan — carrying food, water, medical and other supplies — “in accordance with international law.”
To service civilians adequately, the United Nations said it needed about 40 to 50 trucks per day in northern Gaza and about 250 to 300 aid trucks per day in the south.
“The level of suffering in Gaza defies our ability to capture it in words, or even to comprehend its scale,” said Joyce Msuya, the U.N.’s acting humanitarian chief to the Council. “Reality is brutal in Gaza, and it gets worse every day, as the bombs continue to fall, as fierce fighting continues unabated and as supplies essential for people’s survival and humanitarian assistance are blocked at every turn.”
Ms. Msuya told the Council that Israel’s military on Monday had detained U.N. aid workers who were evacuating severely burned patients to other hospitals in Gaza, holding them up at checkpoints for hours and threatening the lives of the injured.
“Medical staff kept one child alive by hand-pumping oxygen for over seven hours until they made it through the checkpoint,” she said.
Mr. Danon did not respond to her comments when addressing the Council.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Ephrat Livni
Reporting from Washington
Matthew Miller, a State Department spokesman, told reporters on Wednesday that he found the actions described in The New York Times article on Israeli soldiers using Palestinian detainees to check buildings and carry out life-threatening tasks “incredibly disturbing.”
Ephrat Livni
Reporting from Washington
Miller called for the resulting investigation by the Israeli military, also known as the I.D.F., to hold accountable anyone found to have taken part. “There can be no justification ever for the use of civilians as human shields,” he said. “It would be a violation not just of international humanitarian law but of the I.D.F.’s own code of conduct.”
Ephrat Livni
Reporting from Washington
After the U.N. peacekeeping force in Lebanon, known as UNIFIL, said that Israeli troops had on Wednesday morning targeted a UNIFIL watchtower in southern Lebanon, the Israeli military responded in a statement that “UNIFIL infrastructure sites and forces are not a target and every irregular incident will be thoroughly examined.” The military added that Hezbollah has been planning and launching attacks against Israel from “sites that have been built within and adjacent to UNIFIL posts for many years.”
Farnaz Fassihi
Reporting on the United Nations
UNICEF’s deputy executive director, Ted Chaiban, told reporters after visiting Lebanon that nearly all public schools were either being used as shelters or had been destroyed and that only 16 percent were actually serving students, leaving the majority of children at risk of missing out on an education this year.
Farnaz Fassihi
Reporting on the United Nations
He added that children were often getting separated from their families in the upheaval, especially when crossing the border into Syria, so UNICEF was putting identifying wrist bands on children, with the names of their parents.
Ephrat Livni
Reporting from Washington
The U.N. international peacekeeping force in Lebanon, known as UNIFIL, said that Israeli troops in southern Lebanon had fired at a UNIFIL watchtower early Wednesday near Kfar Kela, causing damage to the tower and destroying two cameras. “Yet again, we see direct and apparently deliberate fire on a UNIFIL position,” UNIFIL said in a statement.
Ephrat Livni
Reporting from Washington
The peacekeeping mission operating along Lebanon’s border has come under Israeli fire several times over the past week, injuring peacekeepers and drawing widespread international condemnation. The Israeli military said it was looking into the latest reports.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut, Lebanon
Lebanon’s health ministry said that it had detected a case of cholera in northeastern Lebanon, the first known occurrence of the water-borne disease this year. The World Health Organization warned last week of disease outbreaks because of crowded conditions in displacement shelters and because hospitals had been forced to shutter amid Israel’s offensive.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut, Lebanon
Israel’s military said on Wednesday that the country’s navy was operating off the coast of southern Lebanon and had attacked “dozens of Hezbollah targets” in coordination with Israeli ground troops. The military previously warned civilians not to enter the sea or approach the country’s southern coastline.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut, Lebanon
At least three people were killed and 50 others injured in an overnight strike on the town of Qana in southern Lebanon, according to the Lebanese health ministry. Lebanon’s civil defense agency said rubble removal work continued. Israel’s military has not commented.
Israel permits a small amount of aid into northern Gaza after the U.S. issues a warning.
A day after the United States said it had told Israel that a failure to allow more humanitarian aid into Gaza could prompt a cutoff of military supplies, one of the starkest U.S. warnings since the war began, there was no official response from the Israeli government.
COGAT, the Israeli government agency that oversees policy in Gaza and the West Bank, insists that it is not limiting aid to Gaza and has blamed humanitarian agencies for failing to distribute the supplies it admits into the enclave after screening. On Wednesday, it said that it had inspected and permitted 50 aid trucks to enter northern Gaza from Jordan — carrying food, water, medical and other supplies — “in accordance with international law.”
That is a small fraction of what aid agencies say is needed to offset a severe hunger crisis in Gaza, especially in the north, where Israel “has tightened a siege” this month, the United Nations has said, as it steps up military operations against Hamas.
“People have run out of ways to cope, food systems have collapsed and the risk of famine is real,” the U.N. World Food Program said this week, referring to northern Gaza.
On Sunday, Defense Secretary Lloyd J. Austin III and Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken sent a letter addressed to Israel’s minister of defense, Yoav Gallant, and its minister of strategic affairs, Ron Dermer, saying that Israel had 30 days to allow more aid into Gaza or the United States, Israel’s main military supplier, would consider cutting off military aid.
The letter, a copy of which was obtained by The New York Times, describes the humanitarian situation as “increasingly dire.” It also criticizes Israel’s government for halting commercial imports, preventing aid workers from moving from south to north Gaza, confining the population into a narrow coastal strip and for enabling a burdensome process of vetting what aid can enter the enclave.
Israel should enable a minimum of 350 aid trucks per day to enter, to allow people confined into a so-called humanitarian zone on the coast to move inland before winter and also take other measures, the letter said.
The letter appeared to depart from the United States approach of “hectoring” Israel’s government to allow more aid, according to Michael Hanna, U.S. program director for the International Crisis Group think tank.
As a result, it gives the administration “the possibility of having a really serious conversation” with Israel about aid. But, Mr. Hanna said, some policymakers in Israel would likely view its eventual outcome as an affirmation of the status quo.
Ivo Daalder, a former American ambassador to NATO, said that one striking element of the letter was its warning that the U.S. Foreign Assistance Act bars military support from going to any nation that restricts the delivery of humanitarian aid. He said that this reference to U.S. legal obligations would increase its “political impact” in Israel.
The British government added to the pressure, urging Israel to ensure civilians are protected and aid routes remain open. It called an urgent meeting of the U.N. Security Council on Wednesday to discuss the issue.
At the meeting, the U.N.’s acting humanitarian chief, Joyce Msuya, told the Council that it needed to act to address the humanitarian situation in Gaza.
“The level of suffering in Gaza defies our ability to capture it in words, or even to comprehend its scale,” she said. “Reality is brutal in Gaza, and it gets worse every day, as the bombs continue to fall, as fierce fighting continues unabated and as supplies essential for people’s survival and humanitarian assistance are blocked at every turn.”
Aid workers say that extreme hunger in Gaza has been growing for months. The 30-day deadline falls after the U.S. presidential election, potentially making it politically easier for President Biden to take tougher action against Israel than he has so far been willing to.
Matthew Miller, a State Department spokesman, told reporters on Tuesday that aid into Gaza “has fallen by over 50 percent from where it was at its peak” during the war. According to COGAT figures, at least 465 relief trucks entered Gaza over the first half of October, compared to roughly 2,500 over a similar period last month.
On Tuesday, a total of 145 aid trucks entered Gaza through border crossings in the north and south, COGAT said. It added that 610 trucks of aid permitted into Gaza were “waiting for collection” inside the enclave.
Aid groups, for their part, argue that the Israeli military has made it difficult to distribute what little aid is getting into Gaza, often refusing permission for convoys to pass Israeli checkpoints and sometimes firing on them. In addition, Israel’s invasion of the city of Rafah in southern Gaza in May led to the closure of the border crossing there, one of the main conduits for aid.
“The last couple of months, they have not been good at all,” Juliette Touma, a spokeswoman for the main U.N. agency that aids Palestinians, UNRWA, said in an interview on Tuesday.
The letter from the United States also provides a significant show of diplomatic backing for UNRWA at a time when Israel’s Knesset is considering bills that would declare it a terrorist organization. The United States is deeply concerned about the bill and restrictions on UNRWA that would devastate the humanitarian response at a critical moment, the letter said.
A panel of global experts said in June that almost half a million Gazans faced starvation because of a catastrophic lack of food. This has also made it harder for people to recover from illnesses and war-related injuries amid a health care system that has been devastated by the conflict.
“Medical needs are overwhelming,” the medical charity Doctors Without Borders said on Tuesday.
Aaron Boxerman and Farnaz Fassihi contributed reporting.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Reporting from Haifa, Israel
The main U.N. agency aiding Palestinians in Gaza said that more than 64,000 children received the polio vaccine on Tuesday, the second day of a resumed vaccination campaign in the enclave. A total of 157,000 children have been vaccinated over the first two days of a multiphase campaign that aims to reach 590,000 children under 10, the agency said.
Israel strikes dozens of targets in Lebanon, killing the mayor of a southern city.
Israel continued its bombing campaign in Lebanon on Wednesday, carrying out airstrikes on the southern outskirts of the capital, Beirut, for the first time in days and bombarding the southern city of Nabatieh, killing several people, including Nabatieh’s mayor, according to Lebanese officials.
Israel’s military said that two strikes had hit the Dahiya, a densely packed civilian area near Beirut where Hezbollah holds sway. The blasts rattled residents after nearly a week without any such attacks in or around the Lebanese capital. Hours later on Wednesday, Israeli fighter jets flew overhead, causing sonic booms that sent screaming schoolchildren running for cover.
Israel’s military said that it had been targeting “Hezbollah facilities” in the Dahiya strikes, which took place just after 7 a.m. local time on Wednesday. The attack came about an hour after the Israeli forces had issued an evacuation warning for a building in the area. The human rights group Amnesty International said this week that such warnings were inadequate because they were frequently issued when many people were still asleep and gave little time for residents to take action.
In southern Lebanon, where Israel is engaged in a ground offensive, heavy bombardment in Nabatieh killed at least 16 people and injured more than 50 on Wednesday, according to the Lebanese Health Ministry. The city’s mayor, Dr. Ahmad Kahil, was among the dead, according to Hwaida Turk, the regional governor.
The U.N.’s humanitarian coordinator for Lebanon, Imran Riza, said that the mayor had been part of a relief team that the U.N. had partnered with for more than a year. Four of the team members were killed in the strikes, which occurred just as a crisis meeting was convening in the city’s municipality building, Mr. Riza said.
“Health care facilities, mosques, historical markets, residential complexes and now government buildings are being reduced to rubble,” he said in a statement.
When asked on Wednesday about the strike that killed Dr. Kahil, Matthew Miller, a State Department spokesman, said that if Israel had been “targeting civilians, obviously that would not be acceptable.”
The strikes came a day after Lebanon’s caretaker prime minister, Najib Mikati, said that his government had received “a sort of guarantee” from the Biden administration that Israel would scale back its attacks on Beirut. The White House press secretary, Karine Jean-Pierre, affirmed on Wednesday that the Biden administration had told Israel that it opposed “near-daily strikes” in “densely populated areas of Beirut.”
“We also understand that what they’re conducting — the operations that they’re conducting to destroy Hezbollah infrastructure — is targeted,” Ms. Jean-Pierre said. She added that it was “critical that these operations be conducted in a way” that would not threaten the lives of civilians.
Though Hezbollah exercises de facto control over much of southern Lebanon, including Nabatieh, the group does not enjoy unanimous public support. Dr. Kahil was an elected local government official.
The Israeli military said it had struck “dozens of Hezbollah terrorist targets” in the area, which, it said, included command centers and weapon storage facilities “embedded by Hezbollah adjacent to civilian infrastructure.” The military provided no evidence to support those claims, but Israel has frequently accused Hezbollah of hiding among civilian populations.
At least three more people were killed and 50 others wounded in an overnight strike on Qana, also in southern Lebanon, according to the health ministry. The Israeli military said it had targeted a local Hezbollah commander, along with several other militants. The town was the site of an Israeli strike on a U.N. compound in 1996 that killed at least 100 civilians sheltering there.
Many residents of Nabatieh — once home to tens of thousands — and other cities in southern Lebanon have fled in recent weeks after evacuation orders by the Israeli military. Rema Jamous Imseis, Middle East director for the U.N. refugee agency, said on Tuesday that more than a quarter of Lebanese territory was now under Israeli evacuation orders.
“People are heeding these calls to evacuate,” Ms. Jamous said, “and they’re fleeing with almost nothing.”
Many have taken shelter in school buildings across the country, forcing the facilities to suspend classes, Ted Chaiban, UNICEF’s deputy executive director, told reporters on Wednesday. He said that nearly all public schools were being used as shelters or had been destroyed, and that only 16 percent of the schools were serving students.
Victoria Kim, and Farnaz Fassihi contributed reporting.
Aaron Boxerman
Abbas Araghchi, Iran’s foreign minister, continued a dayslong tour of Arab states on Wednesday, meeting with Jordan’s King Abdullah II, the Jordanian royal court said in a statement. His trip comes with the region on edge over Israel’s anticipated response to the Iranian ballistic missile barrage last week. Araghchi recently visited Oman, Qatar and Saudi Arabia.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Britain imposes sanctions on West Bank settlers and organizations amid rising violence.
Britain has imposed financial sanctions on three Israeli settler outposts and four organizations in the occupied West Bank that it said had supported and sponsored violence against Palestinians in the area, amid a sharp spike in such incidents in the last year.
“The inaction of the Israeli government has allowed an environment of impunity to flourish where settler violence has been allowed to increase unchecked,” David Lammy, the British foreign secretary, said Tuesday in a statement. He added, “As long as violent extremists remain unaccountable, the U.K. and the international community will continue to act.”
The British action follows similar moves taken by its government, the United States and others to address rising Israeli settler violence in the West Bank since the Hamas-led attack in Israel set off a war in Gaza a little over a year ago.
Earlier this month, the U.S. similarly sanctioned individuals and organizations that State Department spokesman Matthew Miller said were “creating an environment where violence and instability thrive.” The U.S. government has taken at least a half dozen similar actions against Israeli settlers and groups supporting or inciting settler violence in the West Bank this year.
Britain in its statement said the measures “follow an unprecedented rise in settler violence in the West Bank over the last year,” noting that the United Nations has recorded more than 1,400 attacks by Israeli settlers against Palestinian communities since last October. The violent encounters often drive Palestinians off their land, the British statement said, allowing Israeli settlers to seize the territory.
The international community largely considers Israeli settlements in the West Bank illegal, and many of the outposts are illegal under Israeli law, too. But they are often tolerated by the Israeli government and sometimes subsequently legalized, granting them formal access to services like running water, electricity, building permits and funding. The far-right government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been expanding settlements.
Palestinians have long argued that the settlements are a creeping annexation enforced by armed settlers and the Israeli military, carving territory that should become a Palestinian state into an unworkable patchwork and steadily pushing Arabs out of their homes and farms.
The recent increase in settler violence has also drawn condemnation from the Israeli authorities. In August, after a riot by Israeli settlers on the Palestinian town of Jit, Mr. Netanyahu’s office issued a statement decrying the attack and pledging to prosecute settlers who acted criminally.
But Mr. Netanyahu’s governing coalition has outspoken supporters of settlements in the West Bank, most notably Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir. Both vocally oppose the establishment of a Palestinian state, and their proclamations and policies have emboldened some settlers.
This year, Britain, France, Canada, and the U.S. have all imposed sanctions on settlers and organizations that they have said were violating the human rights of Palestinians, destabilizing the West Bank and threatening security for everyone in the area. “The measures taken today are part of wider U.K. efforts to support a more stable West Bank, which is vital for the peace and security of both Palestinians and Israelis,” Britain’s statement said on Tuesday.
Canada and the United States on Tuesday also took action against a group and individual they said were tied to a Palestinian terrorist organization operating in the West Bank and Gaza. In a statement, the Treasury Department said it had designated Samidoun Palestinian Prisoner Solidarity Network, commonly known as Samidoun, as a “sham charity” that raises funds internationally for humanitarian support while actually funding the terrorist organization Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which the U.S. designated as a terrorist organization in 1997.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut, Lebanon
Heavy bombardment in the southern Lebanese city of Nabatieh killed at least five people on Wednesday, the Lebanese health ministry said, adding that local municipality buildings had been targeted. Israel’s military said it had struck “dozens of Hezbollah terrorist targets” in the area. The city — once home to tens of thousands — has seen many of its residents flee in recent weeks after the Israeli military issued evacuation warnings.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut, Lebanon
The mayor of Nabatieh, Ahmad Kahil, was among those killed in the strikes, said Hwaida Turk, the regional governor.
Victoria Kim
Israel’s military said it had carried out two early-morning strikes in the southern outskirts of Beirut where Hezbollah holds sway, the first attacks near the city in several days. The strikes in the Haret Hreik neighborhood were aimed at underground weapons storage facilities used by Hezbollah, Israel’s military said in a statement. They came an hour after an Israeli military spokesman warned residents to move away from a building in the area.
Victoria Kim
There were no immediate reports of fatalities in the strikes. On Tuesday, a State Department spokesman, Matthew Miller, said that the United States had conveyed to Israel concerns about “the scope and nature” of its weekslong bombing campaign in the Beirut area.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Israel’s high court orders the state to explain its system for medical evacuations from Gaza.
Israel’s Supreme Court on Tuesday ordered the Israeli government to explain why there appears to be no comprehensive system in place to facilitate evacuations of sick Gazans who are not involved in the Hamas-Israel war to other countries for needed treatment.
The order stems from a petition filed by three Israeli human rights groups in early June, following the closure of the Rafah border crossing between Gaza and Egypt after the Israeli military began assaulting the area in May.
About 50 patients were able to evacuate daily before the closure, said Adi Lustigman, a lawyer for Physicians for Human Rights Israel, one of the groups that filed the petition. Even that level was just a drop in the bucket, she said, but the medical evacuations trickled to a halt after Israel closed the border crossing. The petition demands that Israel create a transparent process for applications for medical evacuations.
“People don’t know where to turn,” Ms. Lustigman said. Even when people apply for evacuations, there does not appear to be a reasoned approach to when permission is granted, with some critically ill patients still waiting while less sick individuals who applied later are allowed out, she said.
“We didn’t ask Israel to treat people, just to move them in a humane tempo,” Ms. Lustigman said. The petition did not specifically seek that patients be transferred abroad, only that they not be blocked from access to medical care, but Israel prefers for “security reasons” that they travel to a third country, she said.
An unstated reason might be Israeli public opinion, she added. “There is a very strong public objection to the petition as it is,” she said.
Nonetheless, Ms. Lustigman argued, Israel has a responsibility for civilians because it controls Gaza and its borders. “The state is subject to fundamental principles of Israeli law, the principles of administrative law, the Basic Laws, and the rules of natural justice,” Ms. Lustigman noted, and it has obligations under international treaties.
The Supreme Court set urgent hearings about the matter over the summer. Lawyers for Israel expressed agreement on the need for medical evacuations but sought more time in court to show the state was complying. And some permits were granted in the interim. At least 19 sick children, most of them cancer patients, were permitted to leave Gaza for treatment in late June.
But the court’s order on Tuesday puts the focus on the state, the defense minister and the authority responsible for humanitarian coordination in Gaza, known as COGAT, to clarify how the process works. The state has argued at hearings that there is a system, Ms. Lustigman said, but it has yet to convincingly show it.
Israel has until Nov. 11 to provide a response, based on the court’s order. The justice ministry declined to comment on the order. The defense ministry did not respond to a query.
COGAT on Wednesday said in a statement responding to a query about the order that the Israeli military “remains committed to continuing its efforts, in coordination with the international community, to facilitate further exits of patients for continued treatment outside the Gaza Strip, subject to their acceptance by those countries and security screenings.”
The agency noted that the Supreme Court had recognized “that the state is indeed taking actions to allow the exit of patients” but at the same time it “requested the state to explain why it has not published a written procedure on the matter.” COGAT said it was still reviewing the decision.
“Every day that passes with sick and injured individuals in Gaza left without medical treatment means human lives, children and infants are in jeopardy,” Ms. Lustigman and her colleague, Tamir Blank, a lawyer for Physicians for Human Rights Israel who worked on the petition, said in a statement on Tuesday. “The state is obligated to allow access to medical treatment so that those who can still be saved may be saved.”
For many patients, it is already too late. After months of waiting, Fida Ghanem, 42, was granted a permit by Israel and Egypt to leave Gaza for urgent lymphoma treatment in the spring, just before Israeli forces seized the Rafah crossing. With the crossing closed, she died in Gaza in June. The border crossing is still shut.
Aaron Boxerman contributed reporting.
The U.N. calls for an investigation into a deadly Israeli airstrike in northern Lebanon.
The United Nations’ human rights office called on Tuesday for an investigation into an Israeli airstrike a day earlier that killed at least 21 people in northern Lebanon, saying it posed “real concerns” because it may have violated international laws governing war.
“We understand it was a four-story residential building that was struck,” Jeremy Laurence, a spokesman for the U.N.’s human rights office, said at a news briefing in Geneva. The U.N. had received reports that most of the deaths were of women and children, he said, and added that the strike might have breached laws designed to minimize civilian harm in conflicts.
The Israeli military said without elaborating that it had struck a Hezbollah target and that it was examining reports that Lebanese civilians had been killed. “The incident is being examined,” it said in a statement.
The Israeli strike on Monday in the normally sleepy hill village of Aitou, more than 70 miles from the Israeli border, was the first known time since the war began a year ago that the largely Christian region had been hit. The region lies far from Hezbollah’s traditional power bases in southern and eastern Lebanon, and the strike has heightened growing fears that no area in the country is safe.
Rema Jamous Imseis, the U.N. refugee agency’s Middle East director, said on Tuesday that more than a quarter of Lebanese territory had come under Israeli evacuation orders. Nearly a million people in Lebanon have already been displaced, according to the United Nations.
“People are heeding these calls to evacuate,” Ms. Jamous said, “and they’re fleeing with almost nothing.”
Johnatan Reiss contributed reporting.
Italy Criminalizes Surrogacy From Abroad, a Blow to Gay and Infertile Couples
Italy passed a law on Wednesday that criminalizes seeking surrogacy abroad, a move the country’s conservative government said would protect women’s dignity, while critics see it as yet another crackdown by the government on L.G.B.T. families, as the law will make it virtually impossible for gay fathers to have children.
Surrogacy is already illegal in Italy. But the government of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has vowed to broaden the ban to punish Italians who seek it in countries where it is legal, like in parts of the United States.
Analysts saw the legislation as a way for Ms. Meloni to assert her conservative credentials and appeal to her political base, which disproportionately opposes surrogacy and adoption by gay couples. Italy, home to the Vatican, already ranks low in Europe when it comes to civil liberties, and Italian critics say that by imposing further restrictions on gay families, Ms. Meloni has taken a particularly hard line.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Fuel Tanker Explosion Leaves at Least 150 Dead in Nigeria
More than 150 people were killed in northern Nigeria on Tuesday after an overturned fuel tanker exploded, according to a police spokesman, in one of the deadliest road disasters ever recorded in Africa’s most populous country.
While the death toll was exceptionally high, the incident followed an all too common pattern on Nigeria’s roads: a truck driver lost control of a fuel tanker, and people rushed in to collect the spilled gasoline from the overturned vehicle. Shortly after, an explosion turned into a deadly inferno.
As residents in the town of Majia, where the explosion occurred, mourned their dead on Wednesday during a day of mass burials, more than 100 injured people remained hospitalized, according the police spokesman, Lawan Shiisu.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Zelensky Pitches His ‘Victory Plan’ to Ukrainian Lawmakers
President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine made a rare appearance in Parliament on Wednesday, pitching a plan to lawmakers that he said could end the war by next year but which has drawn a lukewarm response from allies.
Some broad outlines for the plan — which Mr. Zelensky referred to as a “peace through strength” strategy — had been shared in recent weeks. The president’s address to Parliament, his first so far this year, was seen by many Ukrainians as an attempt to sell his message at home and reassure a nation where war fatigue is on the rise amid steady Russian advances.
The proposal, which Mr. Zelensky has called a “victory plan,” aims to strengthen Ukraine’s position enough on the battlefield to force Russia to negotiate an end to the war. Much of that would hinge on increased Western support.
“If we start moving forward with this victory plan now, we may be able to end the war no later than next year,” Mr. Zelensky said in his speech on Wednesday, which was also broadcast on television.
“This plan can be implemented,” he added. “It depends on our partners. I emphasize: on partners.”
But whether Kyiv’s allies will endorse the plan remains to be seen. Mr. Zelensky recently visited Washington and European capitals to brief Ukraine’s allies on the strategy, and the responses have been limited. Gen. Charles Q. Brown Jr., the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, raised questions about the plan, noting that it repeats some of Ukraine’s earlier calls for increased military aid.
NATO defense ministers will discuss Mr. Zelensky’s plan during two days of talks that begin on Thursday, the military alliance’s new secretary general, Mark Rutte, said at a news conference on Wednesday. “It will no doubt be on the table,” he said.
Mr. Rutte would not comment on the specifics of the proposal, or on Mr. Zelensky’s desire to be offered a formal invitation to join NATO, even if the conflict with Russia makes that currently impractical. He said that Ukraine would one day join the alliance, but that the defense ministers would concentrate on providing up to 40 billion euros in military support for Ukraine as promised at their last summit meeting.
Given the context, experts said, Mr. Zelensky’s speech seemed primarily aimed at reassuring and rallying support from the Ukrainian public around the idea that Kyiv can turn the tide on the battlefield after steadily losing ground to Russian troops this year. In recent weeks, Russian forces have been closing in on the northeastern city of Kupiansk, prompting the Ukrainian authorities there to order a mandatory evacuation on Tuesday.
“It’s necessary to boost the Ukrainian morale today,” Olexiy Haran, a professor of comparative politics at the National University of Kyiv — Mohyla Academy, said in an interview. “This speech is meant to send a political and psychological message to the Ukrainians.”
More than two years into the fighting and faced with steady Russian advances, war fatigue in Ukraine has risen. And sentiment in some cases has shifted from an unwavering resolve for total and outright victory to a more conciliatory stance.
A study released in August by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology found that 57 percent of Ukrainians believe that Kyiv should engage in peace negotiations with Moscow.
Mr. Zelensky cast his plan as a “bridge” to a future peace settlement, saying on Wednesday that the goal was to make it impossible for Russia “to continue the war,” so that Moscow felt pressured to come to the negotiating table.
The plan would require allies to extend an invitation to join NATO, lift the restrictions that bar Kyiv from using Western-provided weapons to strike inside Russia, and establish joint weapons production with Ukraine — all asks previously made by Mr. Zelensky’s government.
On Wednesday, the Ukrainian leader also said he wanted Ukraine’s neighbors to help shoot down Russian missiles and drones from their own territory, an idea that some allies have rejected in the past.
He framed the plan as mutually beneficial for Ukraine and the allies upon whose backing it would require. He noted that Ukraine had rich metal resources that its partners could use and suggested that Kyiv’s military could play a crucial role in protecting the West from further Russian aggression.
The lawmakers, government ministers and military leaders in attendance gave Mr. Zelensky a standing ovation when he emphasized that “trading Ukraine’s territory or sovereignty” was not part of the plan.
But opposition lawmakers were quick to express skepticism after the address. Oleksiy Honcharenko, a member of European Solidarity, the party of Mr. Zelensky’s chief rival, called the plan “very unrealistic.” He noted that it depended heavily on Western assistance yet did not outline what Ukraine could do on its own to improve the situation.
“According to the plan, it seems that someone has to do everything for us,” Mr. Honcharenko wrote on social media.
Some Kyiv residents were similarly unconvinced.
“The victory plan sounds great. Very glossy. But whether anyone will actually do something and how Russia will react — it’s unclear,” said Anton Sokol, 25, who was reading about the speech on his phone.
“It sounds great, but also unrealistic,” Mr. Sokol added.
Yehor Kuryschenko, 28, said the plan sounded more like a collated list of demands for Ukraine’s partners than a strategy to win the war.
“There’s nothing fundamentally new,” he said. “It’s just putting everything into one request with an emphasis on swift and decisive action.”
Daria Mitiuk contributed reporting from Kyiv, Ukraine, and Steven Erlanger from Berlin.
Where a Million Desperate People Are Finding Shelter in Lebanon
Alissa J. Rubin
David Guttenfelder
Alissa J. Rubin and David Guttenfelder reported from Tripoli, Beirut and Mina, Lebanon, over several days and interviewed and photographed dozens of people for this article.
At dusk, the parking lot of Tripoli’s Quality Inn is packed with cars and families milling about. Children’s shouts fill the air, reminding some of better times, when the hotel hosted weddings and birthdays parties.
Now, though, the cars in the lot are dusty and battered, the families sit on patches of grass, their faces worn with worry, and the children play in a drained swimming pool. That is because the Quality Inn has been transformed into one of the biggest shelters in Tripoli for displaced Lebanese fleeing Israeli bombing in the country’s south.
“I am lucky. I am with my whole family, and we just want this war to end so we can go home,” said Hassan al-Aaker, 54, voicing a rare note of optimism even though he has no idea whether his house near the southern coastal city of Tyre will still be standing when he finally does go home.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
England Entrusts a National Treasure to (Gasp!) a German
The post of coach of the England men’s national soccer team has long been described — with only a hint of exaggeration — as the second-most important job in the country. In terms of prestige, significance and pressure, the theory goes, it is outstripped only by the even more thankless task of being prime minister.
As of Jan. 1, the position that occupies such an outsize role in the national psyche will be filled by a German. The Football Association, the body that oversees England’s national sport, confirmed on Wednesday that it had agreed to a deal with Thomas Tuchel to take charge of the country’s team until the end of the 2026 World Cup.
The sporting logic behind the appointment of the 51-year-old Tuchel is impeccable. He has coached several of the world’s most prominent clubs, including Borussia Dortmund, Paris St.-Germain, Bayern Munich and Chelsea. He has won domestic honors in both France and Germany, and lifted the Champions League trophy with Chelsea in 2021.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
With Jets and Ships, China Is Honing Its Ability to Choke Taiwan
The Chinese warplanes, deployed in record numbers, crossed an informal boundary between China and Taiwan. Chinese Coast Guard boats joined naval ships in encircling Taiwan. Fighter jets took off from an aircraft carrier parked off the island’s east coast.
The large-scale military drills China held this week were aimed at demonstrating its potential to choke Taiwan’s access to food and fuel and block the skies and waters from which the United States and its allies would presumably approach in coming to the island’s defense.
The exercises showed how China was improving its coordination of complex operations involving a range of military, coast guard and rocket forces. They also raise the risk of a confrontation or accident that could draw in the United States and its Asian allies.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Is Elon Musk’s Brazilian Nemesis Saving Democracy or Hurting It?
Jack Nicas
Jack Nicas spoke with Brazilian Supreme Court justices, federal prosecutors, federal judges and legal scholars to report this article. He reported from Brasília, the nation’s capital.
Daniel Silveira, a policeman turned far-right Brazilian congressman, was furious. He believed Brazil’s Supreme Court was persecuting conservatives and silencing them on social media, and he wanted to do something about it.
So he sat on his couch and began recording. “How many times have I imagined you getting beat up on the street,” he said in a 19-minute diatribe against the court’s justices, muscles bulging through his tight T-shirt. He posted the video on YouTube in February 2021, adding, “I’ll say what I want on here.”
A Brazilian Supreme Court justice immediately ordered his arrest. A year later, 10 of the court’s 11 justices convicted and sentenced him to nearly nine years in prison for threatening them.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.