Live Updates: Israel Is Examining Whether Hamas Leader Was Killed in Gaza
Here are the latest developments.
The Israeli military said on Thursday that it was assessing whether Yahya Sinwar, the leader of Hamas and an architect of last year’s Oct. 7 terror attack in Israel, had been killed. Eliminating Mr. Sinwar has been a major goal of Israel’s military offensive in Gaza, and his death would be a watershed in almost 13 months of fighting that have reshaped the Middle East.
The military released no further details. But four Israeli officials said the military was taking the body of a slain militant to a laboratory in Israel in order to assess whether its DNA matches that of Mr. Sinwar, who is in his early 60s. Three of the officials said the militant had been killed on Wednesday in a firefight with Israeli soldiers.
Fingerprints and dental records will also be examined by Israeli officials to determine if the militant is Mr. Sinwar, officials told The Times. That determination could come before DNA testing is complete, the officials said. Israel has the Hamas leader’s medical records from his decades in Israeli detention.
For months, Mr. Sinwar has escaped Israeli efforts to find and kill him, even as many of his top allies — including much of the leadership of Hezbollah, the Lebanese militia, and Ismail Haniyeh, Hamas’s former political leader — have been assassinated.
Mr. Sinwar’s death, if confirmed, could raise hopes for an end to the conflict in Gaza, by encouraging Hamas to agree to Israeli demands or by providing Israel with a victory that could push Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to ease its negotiating stance. Hamas and the Israeli government have remained far apart on key issues during months of negotiations over a truce.
U.S. officials said that Israel had told the United States that its soldiers may have killed Mr. Sinwar. All the officials spoke on the condition of anonymity in order to discuss a sensitive matter. Hamas made no immediate comment.
Here’s what else to know:
-
Fighting in Gaza: An Israeli strike on a school building in northern Gaza killed at least 24 people, according to the Palestinian Civil Defense, an emergency service. Israel’s military said that it had attacked the site, in Jabaliya, because dozens of Hamas and Islamic Jihad militants had been meeting there at the time.
-
Extreme hunger: The risk of famine hangs over nearly all 2.2 million people in Gaza amid Israel’s yearlong offensive, but is most severe for people in the north, according to a report released on Thursday by the United Nations-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification global initiative. It said about 133,000 people faced a catastrophic lack of food, and many Gazan children under 5 were acutely malnourished.
-
American warning: The Biden administration warned Israel this week that the United States could cut off military assistance if more humanitarian aid were not allowed to enter northern Gaza, where an estimated 400,000 people are trapped by escalating Israeli military operations. In a rare moment of unity, every member of the United Nations Security Council on Wednesday agreed that Israel must consistently allow aid into the north of the enclave.
-
Targeting Iran’s proxies: American stealth bombers struck weapon facilities overnight in areas of Yemen controlled by the Iran-backed Houthi militia, an attack that could serve as a warning to Tehran. The strikes in Yemen on Wednesday followed the U.S. deployment to Israel this month of an advanced missile defense system — and the 100 troops needed to operate it — after an Iranian missile attack on Oct. 1. On Thursday, the Houthis vowed in a statement: “The American aggression will not pass without a response.”
Ephrat Livni
Israel’s ambassador to the U.N. is also referring to the Hamas leader as “eliminated” in a post on social media, despite the lack of formal confirmation. “Yesterday at the Security Council, many asked why we were still in Gaza” after a year of fighting, he wrote in the post, adding “today they got the answer.”
Raja Abdulrahim
Gazans were reacting to the Sinwar news. Some people hoped that if his death was confirmed, that would mean a quick end to the conflict. Others thought it would do little to change the situation. “Many preceded him,” said Rehab Ibrahim Odeh, 64. “And he is no better than those who have passed away before.”
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Ronen Bergman
Israeli officials will be examining fingerprints and dental records to determine if the militant killed in Gaza is Yahya Sinwar, officials told The New York Times. That determination could come before DNA testing is complete, the officials said. Israel has the Hamas leader’s medical records from his decades in Israeli detention.
Gabby Sobelman
While Israeli officials have not confirmed whether Sinwar was killed, some in Israel are already celebrating. A leading organization of hostage families commended Israeli forces for “eliminating Sinwar, who masterminded the worst massacre our country has ever faced” but expressed “grave concern” over what impact that might have on hostages still in the enclave.
An Israeli airstrike on a school used a shelter in Gaza kills at least 24 people.
An Israeli airstrike on a United Nations school being used as a shelter for displaced people killed more than two dozen people in northern Gaza on Thursday, according to rescue workers and the Gaza government media office.
The strike came as Israel faced increasing pressure from the United States and other allies to address an escalating humanitarian crisis in the enclave’s north, where an estimated 400,000 people have remained trapped during an Israeli military offensive.
The Israeli military said the strike on Thursday hit a school complex in Jabaliya that was serving as a command and control center for Hamas and Islamic Jihad. The military said it had killed dozens of fighters in the strike. There were reports that more than 100 people were injured.
Rescue workers, Palestinian media and at least one civilian who had been living there said the site had housed civilians. Juliette Touma, a spokeswoman for UNRWA, the U.N. agency that assists Palestinian refugees, confirmed that one of its schools in Jabaliya was struck on Thursday.
“We received reports that among the scores of people killed are children, which is often the case,” Ms. Touma said, adding that the school was the third UNRWA site to be attacked in the last week. She said the U.N. had not been able to determine the accuracy of Israel’s claims that Hamas and other groups were active in its school compounds.
“We call for an independent investigation and commissions of inquiry to look into these reoccurring claims,” she said. “We call once again on all Palestinian armed groups, including Hamas, to refrain from using UNRWA facilities for military or fighting purposes.”
The Gaza government media office said the strike had killed 28 people and injured 160 more. One man who had been staying in the school compound, Mahmoud Hamdouna, 29, said he left the building just minutes before the strike to search for food. He ran back when he heard the explosion and found a scene that was “horrific, a real massacre,” he said.
“I saw around 25 dead bodies and so many injured,” said Mr. Hamdouna, who had fled to Jabaliya from Beit Hanoun, another town in Gaza’s besieged north. “People lost limbs at the scene and many had serious head injuries. Many others are still under the rubble.”
Satellite imagery captured three days before the strike showed many tents inside the school’s courtyard.
Regular schooling has not happened in the Gaza Strip since the start of the war last October. Instead, displaced people have sought shelter at disused school buildings across the enclave, crowding into classrooms, corridors and playgrounds.
But school buildings have also been a frequent target for airstrikes because Israel argues that many have been used by Hamas to house fighters, store equipment or plan attacks. A vast majority of school buildings, including every university in the Gaza Strip, has been damaged or destroyed during the war.
The Israeli military said in a statement that before the airstrike on Thursday it had taken “numerous steps” to “mitigate the risk of harming civilians, including the use of precise munitions, aerial surveillance and additional intelligence.”
“This is a further example of the Hamas terrorist organization’s systematic abuse of civilian infrastructure in violation of international law,” the military said.
Lauren Leatherby contributed reporting.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
The Israeli authorities just announced that they are examining the possibility that Yahya Sinwar, the leader of Hamas, has been killed. In a joint statement, Israel’s military and domestic intelligence service said they could not yet confirm Sinwar’s death.
Israel is assessing whether a slain militant is the Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar.
The Israeli military said on Thursday that it was assessing whether Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar had been killed in the Gaza Strip.
The military released no further details about the assessment, but four Israeli officials said the military was taking the body of a slain militant to a laboratory in Israel in order to assess whether its DNA matches that of Mr. Sinwar.
The militant was killed on Wednesday during a firefight in southern Gaza with Israeli soldiers, according to three of the officials. The remains of the body will be compared to DNA collected from Mr. Sinwar during his decades-long incarceration inside Israeli jails, two officials said.
U.S. officials said that Israel had told the Americans that its soldiers may have killed Mr. Sinwar. All the officials spoke on the condition of anonymity in order to discuss a sensitive matter. Hamas made no immediate comment.
The death of Mr. Sinwar, an architect of the Hamas-led attack last October that set off the war in Gaza, would raise hopes of an end to the conflict. Both Mr. Sinwar and the Israeli government had refused to compromise during the monthslong negotiations for a truce. His death could either prompt Hamas to agree to some of Israel’s demands — or provide Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, with a symbolic victory that would give him the political cover he needs to soften his own negotiating stance.
The military statement on Thursday said that three militants were killed in the exchange and that there were no signs of hostages nearby. It added that soldiers continued to operate in the area.
Israeli officials said they believed the body may be Mr. Sinwar’s because of the physical similarities, and because intelligence had suggested he was hiding in southern Gaza.
But they also urged caution because no DNA test had yet been carried out and because they were surprised that such a senior Hamas leader would have been caught in a gunfight above ground. Mr. Sinwar, who is in his early 60s, was thought to have been killed on previous occasions, only for the initial conjecture to be proven wrong.
Israel and the United States both invested huge resources in the hunt for Mr. Sinwar. American spy agencies formed a targeting cell after last October’s attacks in Israel to study him and try to intercept his communications.
In late January, Israeli and American officials thought they were on the verge of catching him when Israeli commandos raided an elaborate tunnel complex in southern Gaza where they thought he was hiding, according to American and Israeli officials. But Mr. Sinwar had moved from the bunker beneath the city of Khan Younis just days earlier, leaving behind documents and stacks of Israeli shekels totaling about $1 million, the officials said.
In August, Israeli troops who discovered the bodies of six hostages in a warren of tunnels beneath Rafah, in southern Gaza, found signs of Mr. Sinwar’s past presence in the area, according to Yoav Gallant, the Israeli defense minister.
Mr. Sinwar’s decision to attack Israel on Oct. 7 has proved one of the most fateful moves in recent Middle East history. Roughly 1,200 people were killed in Israel some 250 others abducted in the assault, which set off a devastating Israeli counterattack in Gaza in which more than 42,000 Palestinians have been killed and much of the blockaded territory left in ruins.
It also led to a broader war between Israel and Hamas’s regional allies, including Iran, the Houthis in Yemen and Hezbollah in Lebanon, where Israel is currently mounting extensive ground and air attacks.
Mr. Sinwar has been in hiding throughout the war, eschewing electronic devices and relying on a network of couriers to stay in touch with his organization, according to Israeli and U.S. officials. At times, his communications with Hamas have been intermittent, prompting repeated speculation about his fate.
But he remained by far Hamas’s most important figure, with the group’s representatives at cease-fire negotiations in Qatar this year telling diplomats that they needed Mr. Sinwar’s input before taking major decisions. In recent months U.S. officials came to believe Mr. Sinwar did not want to reach a deal and was determined to see Israel enmeshed in a broader regional war.
Mr. Sinwar emerged from two decades of prison in Israel to rise to the helm of Hamas in Gaza in 2017. In August, he was also named political leader of the entire movement, both inside and outside Gaza, after Israel assassinated his predecessor Ismail Haniyeh, consolidating Mr. Sinwar’s influence over the organization.
Julian E. Barnes and David E. Sanger contributed reporting.
Reporting from Haifa, Israel
An Israeli strike on a school building in northern Gaza today killed more than 20 people, according to the Palestinian Civil Defense emergency service. Israel’s military said it had attacked the site, in Jabaliya, because dozens of Hamas and Islamic Jihad militants had been meeting there at the time.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Liam Stack
The World Health Organization said the second phase of its polio vaccination campaign in the Gaza Strip had concluded yesterday, with 181,429 children vaccinated and 148,064 more receiving vitamin A supplements. Eight health facilities in the enclave will continue to provide polio vaccines for families who the campaign had been unable to meet, it said.
Aurelien Breeden
Reporting from Paris
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel criticized President Emmanuel Macron of France for showing “historical ignorance” and a “lack of respect” after Macron was quoted as saying that Netanyahu should “not forget that his country was created by a U.N. decision.” In an interview with Le Figaro newspaper, Netanyahu said that while the U.N. had “recognized the right of the Jewish people to a state, it certainly didn’t create it.”
Aurelien Breeden
Reporting from Paris
His remarks in the interview, published yesterday, were the latest to reflect tensions between the two leaders. Macron had previously stoked Netanyahu’s ire for saying that countries should stop sending weapons to Israel if they want a cease-fire. “Although we do not receive weapons from France, I find this call shameful,” Netanyahu told Le Figaro.
Liam Stack
The Israeli military’s Arabic-language spokesman, Avichay Adraee, has warned residents of three towns in Lebanon’s central Bekaa Valley — Saraeen, Tamnine and Safri — to evacuate specific buildings. Adraee urged residents to stay at least half a kilometer away from each site.
U.S. stealth bombers target Houthi weapons facilities underground.
The U.S. military struck five underground weapons facilities in areas of Yemen controlled by the Iranian-backed Houthi militia on Wednesday, using warplanes that included B-2 stealth bombers in an attack that could also serve as a warning to Tehran.
Defense Secretary Lloyd J. Austin III said President Biden had ordered the strikes to “further degrade the Houthis’ capability” to attack ships and disrupt the flow of commerce in the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden. Mr. Austin made no mention of Iran, but the rare use of the B-2, the only plane capable of striking Iran’s deeply buried nuclear facilities, against the Houthis was notable at a time of tensions between Israel and Iran that threaten to spill into full-blown war.
“This was a unique demonstration of the United States’ ability to target facilities that our adversaries seek to keep out of reach, no matter how deeply buried underground, hardened or fortified,” Mr. Austin said in a statement late Wednesday night. “The employment of U.S. Air Force B-2 Spirit long-range stealth bombers demonstrate U.S. global strike capabilities to take action against these targets when necessary, anytime, anywhere.”
A statement from U.S. Central Command on Wednesday night said that U.S. Navy “assets” also took part in the attack, which the unit, based in Tampa, Fla., said was launched against “various advanced conventional weapons used to target U.S. and international military and civilian vessels navigating international waters.”
Attacking so-called hardened buried sites generally requires the use of specially built bombs that have much thicker steel cases and contain a smaller amount of explosives than similarly sized general-purpose bombs. The heavy casings of such “bunker buster” bombs allows the munition to stay intact as it punches through soil, rock or concrete before detonating.
The B-2 is the only warplane that can carry the largest of this class of weapon in the Pentagon’s inventory: A 30,000-pound GPS-guided munition called the GBU-57 Massive Ordnance Penetrator, or MOP, that contains the equivalent of about 5,600 pounds of TNT. A Pentagon spokesman declined to say whether that weapon was used in the attack on Wednesday.
The Air Force had only acknowledged building 20 such bombs as of 2015, according to publicly available documents, and five were expended in testing at White Sands Missile Range in New Mexico in 2012. According to an Air Force site, the weapon is capable of reaching targets up to 200 feet underground before exploding.
The U.S. arsenal also includes 5,000-pound and 2,000-pound penetrator bombs that can be dropped by other warplanes.
The Air Force is believed to have just 19 operational B-2 bombers, all of which are permanently based at Whiteman Air Force Base in Missouri, though the Pentagon has occasionally deployed some for exercises in the Pacific and Indian Ocean.
For B-2 bombers to take part in Wednesday’s attack, the aircraft would have either had to fly round-trip from Missouri to Yemen and refuel midair, or take off from a base much closer to their targets.
“Due to operational security, we won’t discuss our operating locations within the region,” Maj. Gen. Patrick S. Ryder, the Pentagon spokesman, said in response to a question about where the B-2s were launched for Wednesday’s attack.
The Houthis started targeting civilian tankers and cargo ships at sea in solidarity with Hamas last year. U.S. forces have shot down dozens of Houthi attack drones and anti-ship missiles launched at commercial merchant vessels since mid-November and have also frequently launched airstrikes against Houthi missile and radar sites.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
U.N. Security Council calls on Israel to increase flow of aid into Gaza.
Members of the United Nations Security Council met Wednesday to discuss the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, and every member called on Israel in speeches to consistently allow aid into northern Gaza and drastically scale up assistance to the rest of the enclave.
The Security Council has rarely spoken in unity when it comes to the war in Gaza, and differences remain on how to reach and impose a cease-fire between Hamas and Israel. But at an emergency meeting on Wednesday, diplomats agreed that the lack of sufficient aid into Gaza needed to be addressed urgently.
Many also denounced Israel’s strike of a hospital complex on Monday that ignited fires that spread to a tent shelter for displaced people next to a hospital, leading to accounts that people were burned alive.
Some of the sharpest criticism came from Israel’s allies, including the United States, which vetoed three resolutions blocking efforts for a cease-fire in the first eight months of the war and abstained from one that eventually passed in June.
“There are no words, simply no words, to describe what we saw,” said Linda Thomas-Greenfield, the United States ambassador to the United Nations. “Israel has a responsibility to do everything possible to avoid civilian casualties, even if Hamas was operating near the hospital in an attempt to use civilians as human shields. We have made this clear to Israel.”
Ms. Thomas-Greenfield also said that a “policy of starvation” in northern Gaza would be “horrific and unacceptable and would have implications under international law and U.S. law.”
The rebuke came as the United States warned Israel on Sunday in a letter that if it did not provide scaled-up humanitarian aid to Gaza in the next 30 days, it would face repercussions that could include a halt to American military aid to Israel.
Riyad Mansour, the Palestinian envoy to the United Nations, accused Israel of trying to force Palestinians out of Gaza by withholding food aid, saying, “This is not war; these are crimes.” Mr. Mansour added: “This is genocide. They must be stopped, and they must be stopped now.”
Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations, Danny Danon, defended Israel’s actions and blamed Hamas for using Palestinian civilians as human shields and for robbing aid trucks.
“The only way to improve the humanitarian situation in Gaza is to defeat Hamas and completely disarm it,” Mr. Danon said. He claimed Hamas “steals, stores and sells the aid that enters the Gaza Strip and uses it to feed its terrorist machine and not to feed the Gazans.”
Scott Peterson, the Gaza director of UNRWA, the main U.N. aid agency for Palestinians, said on Wednesday that Israel had allowed 12 aid trucks into northern Gaza on Sept. 30, but no other trucks were allowed into that region of the enclave after that.
COGAT, the Israeli government agency that oversees policy in Gaza and the West Bank, insisted that it was not limiting aid to Gaza and has accused humanitarian agencies of failing to distribute the supplies it has admitted into the enclave after screening. On Wednesday, it said that it had inspected and permitted 50 aid trucks to enter northern Gaza from Jordan — carrying food, water, medical and other supplies — “in accordance with international law.”
To service civilians adequately, the United Nations said it needed about 40 to 50 trucks per day in northern Gaza and about 250 to 300 aid trucks per day in the south.
“The level of suffering in Gaza defies our ability to capture it in words, or even to comprehend its scale,” said Joyce Msuya, the U.N.’s acting humanitarian chief to the Council. “Reality is brutal in Gaza, and it gets worse every day, as the bombs continue to fall, as fierce fighting continues unabated and as supplies essential for people’s survival and humanitarian assistance are blocked at every turn.”
Ms. Msuya told the Council that Israel’s military on Monday had detained U.N. aid workers who were evacuating severely burned patients to other hospitals in Gaza, holding them up at checkpoints for hours and threatening the lives of the injured.
“Medical staff kept one child alive by hand-pumping oxygen for over seven hours until they made it through the checkpoint,” she said.
Mr. Danon did not respond to her comments when addressing the Council.
Egypt Replaces Its Powerful Spy Chief, a Key Gaza Mediator
President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi of Egypt replaced the powerful head of the country’s intelligence services on Wednesday, according to state media, switching out the Egyptian official who plays a leading role in cease-fire negotiations between Israel and Hamas.
The official, Gen. Abbas Kamel, had overseen many of Egypt’s most important domestic and foreign policy matters, becoming the face of its extensive security apparatus, which has overseen crackdowns on political opponents and kept Mr. el-Sisi firmly in control. The spy chief’s power often appeared to be second only to the president’s.
The reasons for the move were unclear, and the longstanding secrecy surrounding the highest levels of Egypt’s government means that Mr. el-Sisi’s decision is likely to go unexplained. But it came as Egypt is rocked by the regional instability set off by the nearby war in Gaza, which is damaging Egypt’s already struggling economy and putting intense pressure on its peace treaty with Israel as well as on its relationships with Hamas and the United States.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Gazans Are So Malnourished That They Could Face Famine, Report Warns
People in Gaza are so malnourished that they could face famine, and life in overcrowded makeshift camps because of a prolonged Israeli military offensive has made them even more vulnerable, according to a report by experts released on Thursday.
The hunger emergency affects nearly all of Gaza’s population of around 2.2 million, but it is worst for people in the north of the enclave, where Israeli forces have intensified operations this month, according to the report, by the United Nations-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification global initiative. It added that many Gazan children under 5 were acutely malnourished.
Since the conflict began more than a year ago, reports by the panel — which is made up of U.N. agencies and international relief groups — have measured the scope of the hunger crisis in Gaza.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Zelensky Tries to Sell His ‘Victory Plan’ to European Leaders
President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine told leaders of the European Union’s 27 member states in Brussels on Thursday that his country desperately needed their support for his plan to end the war, which he maintains could happen no later than next year, but which it is unclear how much Ukraine’s allies will embrace.
Mr. Zelensky made the impassioned plea on his latest trip abroad as he tries to attract sustained international support for Ukraine, two and a half years into the war, and as Ukrainian forces steadily lose ground to Russian troops. He had hoped to present the plan to European leaders in Germany earlier in the month, but that gathering was postponed when President Biden canceled his participation to deal with the effects of Hurricane Milton.
“You all know Russia’s psychology,” Mr. Zelensky told E.U. leaders on Thursday. “Russia will resort to diplomacy only when it sees that it cannot achieve anything by force.”
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
In India, Some Doctors Go on Hunger Strike to Protest Killing of Colleague
More than two dozen doctors in India have been on an indefinite hunger strike for nearly two weeks, one of many nationwide protests demanding a safer work environment set off by the rape and killing of a medical resident in August.
Six of those doctors have been subsisting only on water and been taken to the hospital for care, a doctors’ group formed after the episode said on Thursday. At least two of them were in critical condition.
The brutalized body of the female doctor was found on Aug. 9 in a seminar room at R.G. Kar Medical College and Hospital, a state-run institution in Kolkata, where she was completing a residency. She had many injuries, including a broken neck, according to local news media reports. The name of the 31-year-old victim may not be published under Indian law because of privacy laws relating to sexual assaults.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Moscow Roils a Country on the Edge of Europe and Russia
Moldova’s police chief, appointed by a government committed to joining the European Union and leaving Russia’s orbit, was alarmed to find his country’s capital suddenly plastered with posters bearing a blunt message: “No EU.”
The posters — written in Russian and Romanian, Moldova’s main language — appeared overnight on bus stops across Chisinau last month, ostensibly part of an advertising campaign for a concert by a popular Russian-speaking singer from Ukraine.
The timing, however, set off alarm bells: The anti-E.U. message came just as Moldova, a former Soviet republic, was gearing up for a contentious referendum on whether to amend its Constitution to enshrine the “irreversibility” of its “European course.”
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.