Here are the latest developments.
President Bashar al-Assad has resigned and left Syria, Russia’s Foreign Ministry said on Sunday, a stunning fall for the longtime dictator who had kept rebel forces at bay for years with the help of Moscow and Tehran.
Mr. al-Assad’s departure after rebels opposed to his rule swept through the country in a lightning offensive was an earthshaking moment in the history of Syria, which has been ruled by his family with an iron fist since the early 1970s. It represented a dramatic breakthrough for rebel factions in Syria that have been trying to unseat him for more than a decade, much of which was marked by a devastating civil war.
For many in Syria, Mr. al-Assad’s fall was a moment filled with hope as they no longer feared the regime that had used oppressive tactics to quash their freedoms. But it was also rife with uncertainty over who will rule Syria next and raised fears of a power vacuum in a country that has been rived with competing factions vying for control of different areas of territory.
“Our hearts are dancing with joy,” Walaa Salameh, 35, a resident of the Damascus area, said in a phone interview. “We can’t predict the future and anything is possible, but the most important thing is we got rid of this oppressive regime.”
The Russian Foreign Ministry’s statement did not offer details on Mr. al-Assad’s exact location, saying only that he had held talks with “several parties of the armed conflict.” There was no immediate comment from the Syrian presidency about Mr. al-Assad.
Earlier Sunday, the main rebel coalition, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, had announced on its Telegram channel that it had taken the capital, Damascus, and that Syrian forces were withdrawing.
State television went from trumpeting Mr. al-Assad’s strong defenses to broadcasting an announcement by a group of nine rebels on Sunday: “The city of Damascus has been liberated, the tyrant Bashar al-Assad has been toppled,” one of them read out, adding, “Long live a free and independent Syria for all Syrians of all sects.”
The events capped a startling two weeks in which the coalition of rebel groups that had been pinned down in a small corner of Syria’s northwest swept through the country’s major cities, shattering a stalemate in Syria’s 13-year civil war.
“No one should shed any tears over the end of the Assad regime,” Daniel B. Shapiro, the U.S. deputy assistant secretary of defense for the Middle East, said in Bahrain.
-
Who are the rebels?: After attracting little notice for years, Abu Mohammad al-Jolani spearheaded a stunning lightning offensive that led to the fall of Mr. al-Assad’s regime. First, the rebels seized Syria’s largest city, Aleppo, then days later blazed through Hama and the strategic city of Homs, en route to the capital.
-
Damascus reacts: Three civilians in the capital told The New York Times that they heard gunfire in the city overnight. It was not immediately clear at the time who was firing. One resident said the gunfire appeared to be celebrating the rebels’ advance, and that some people were dancing in the streets. Amid the celebration, Syrians were also mourning all they had lost over 13 years of civil war.
-
Assad’s location: Amid swirling questions over Mr. al-Assad’s whereabouts, Mohammad Ghazi al-Jalali, Syria’s prime minister, said that he had not spoken with him since Saturday. Mr. al-Jalali said that he would stay in the country and was ready to work with whomever Syrians choose as their leader. Hayat Tahrir al-Sham said it would work with Mr. al-Jalali and called on Syrian military forces in Damascus to stay away from public institutions, which it said would remain under the prime minister’s supervision until they are formally handed over.
-
Assad’s allies: Mr. al-Assad had kept rebel forces at bay for more than a decade with Iranian and Russian military support. But in recent days, Iran and Russia appeared to be turning to diplomacy to preserve their interests in the country rather than significant military support. The Foreign Ministry of Iran said decision-making about the future of Syria was “solely the responsibility” of Syrians.
-
Prisoners freed: As the rebels advanced, they took over many of the notorious prisons where the Assad regime has for decades imprisoned, tortured and executed political prisoners. Videos emerging from north of Damascus show groups of men walking through city streets at night, reportedly after being freed from Sednaya Prison, which the rebels have taken, according to war monitors and the fighters.
-
Broader instability: Israel’s military said it had entered a demilitarized buffer zone in territory it controls in the Golan Heights, abutting Syria. The Israeli military, which is concerned about the sudden surge in instability near its borders, said it was acting to protect Israeli civilians. Iraq has secured its border with Syria, according to the official Iraqi News Agency, which said on Sunday that the Al-Qaim border crossing was closed.
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
Syrians walk through ransacked rooms in the Syrian presidential residence on Sunday after rebel forces toppled the government of President Bashar al-Assad. Paintings and other objects are strewn about on the floors.
Peter Baker
The White House said that President Biden would meet with his national security team this morning to receive an update on the situation in Syria.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
A family renews their appeal to find a U.S. journalist missing in Syria.
Family members of Austin Tice, the missing American journalist, said on Sunday that they believe that he is in Syria and alive, and appealed for help locating him now that the regime of President Bashar al-Assad has fallen.
Mr. Tice disappeared in 2012 outside Damascus, the Syrian capital, as the country descended into civil war.
“We are urging everyone on the ground to help us in this unique and singular moment to look for Austin and to help us bring him home,” his younger brother, Jacob Tice, told The New York Times. “What we do know is that he is alive and he is in Syria.”
The United States has said it believed Mr. Tice had been held captive by the government of Mr. al-Assad. The Assad regime had long maintained that it was not holding Mr. Tice and had no information about him.
The Biden administration has “engaged extensively” to try to get Mr. Tice back to the United States, including by directly contacting Syrian officials and working through third parties, according to a senior administration official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the case. However, the official said the Syrian government, which had been under the leadership of Mr. al-Assad until his downfall on Sunday, had not agreed to discuss Mr. Tice’s case.
Mr. Tice, who was freelancing for The Washington Post as well as McClatchy and other outlets when he was abducted, had been in Syria for months, embedding with and writing about opposition rebels.
Assad’s fall deprives Hezbollah of a key ally.
Other than its ideological lodestar, Iran, no other government has been as important to Hezbollah, the Lebanese militant group and political party, than that of Bashar al-Assad, who was, until early Sunday, the president of Syria.
Now, Mr. al-Assad has fled Syria to parts unknown, and rebels have stormed the capital, Damascus, a political earthquake in the Middle East likely to deprive Hezbollah of one of its most important allies.
Hezbollah and Syria under Mr. al-Assad were allies in Iran’s regional network of proxies known as the “axis of resistance,” which sought to confront Israel and push back against American influence.
Syria was key because it gave Iran its only state partner in the Arab world. Syria also has long borders with Iraq, where Iranian-backed militias have significant power, and with Lebanon, where Hezbollah built a major military force on Israel’s northern border.
Hezbollah could not have done that without Syria, since most of Hezbollah’s weapons reached Lebanon through the border, with Mr. al-Assad’s approval.
Hezbollah threw a lifeline to Mr. al-Assad earlier in the Syrian civil war, which began with an anti-Assad uprising in 2011, by sending thousands of fighters to prop up his exhausted military. Hezbollah’s commandos not only fought but trained and oversaw other militia fighters sent by Iran from Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere.
In 2014, Hassan Nasrallah, the Hezbollah leader whom Israel assassinated in September, declared in a speech that the insurrection against Mr. al-Assad had failed. He called for peace talks but said they must “start and end with President Bashar al-Assad.”
Mr. al-Assad did not return the favor. As Israel escalated its war against Hezbollah in September, Mr. al-Assad said little, even waiting two days to release a statement mourning Mr. Nasrallah’s death.
Now Hezbollah, which was deeply battered by Israel before the two reached a tentative cease-fire last month, appears to be keeping its options open for whoever leads Syria next.
After years of dismissing any armed opposition to Mr. al-Assad as “terrorism,” Al-Manar, Hezbollah’s television station, reported on its website on Sunday that “Syrian opposition factions” had entered Damascus and that Russia had announced that Mr. al-Assad had fled.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Mazlum Kobani, the Kurdish leader of the U.S.-backed Syrian Democratic Forces, who is known by a nom de guerre, called the success of the rebel offensive “historic” and an “opportunity to build a new Syria.” The S.D.F. controls much of Syria’s northeast and established a semi-autonomous civil administration.
As Assad loses control, the skies above Syria go quiet.
For more than a decade of civil war, Syrians in rebel-held areas craned their necks to look at the sky — listening and fearing the sounds of an airplane engine or the whirring blades of a helicopter.
Those sounds meant imminent danger.
People scrambled in every direction. Mothers futilely tried to shield their children. After the strikes, rescue workers and ordinary Syrians rushed to tend to the wounded and bury the dead.
The planes and helicopters — which dropped terrifyingly destructive barrel bombs filled with TNT and shrapnel — instilled terror. Only when the government captured an area did the airstrikes stop. But in the northwest, which remained a rebel stronghold, they continued until days ago.
On Sunday morning, for the first time in years, people who lived in fear of those bombs woke to silence in the skies.
“Always, that was our life during all those years,” said Hamid Qutaneh, a member of the White Helmets rescue group. He and the other members of the rescue team spent more than a decade responding to the aftermath of airstrikes by Syrian and Russian warplanes that were key to keeping President Bashar al-Assad in power.
Mr. Qutaneh, 30, a father of two, grew up in the northwest city of Khan Sheikhoun, which was hit by chemical weapons in 2017.
Warnings of airstrikes came in brief phrases or in one word: “The warplane has taken off.” “The warplane is flying overhead.” “Airstrike.”
Mr. Qutaneh’s own home in Khan Sheikhoun was destroyed in one of those strikes.
“You can’t imagine the joy today,” he said, adding that people for the first time were gathered in the streets in large crowds, no longer fearful that they could be targeted from the skies. “What happened is the beginning of the road to justice.”
More than 100,000 Syrians have been killed from airstrikes alone, according to the Syrian Network for Human Rights, a watchdog group.
“We are living a happiness that can’t be described,” Ramez Abu Farhan, 41, from the central city of Homs said after he returned home from celebrating in the city’s main square. “There is safety, there isn’t shelling; there aren’t airstrikes; there are no planes, and we are hopeful for the future.”
The city had not been hit with airstrikes for years after the Assad regime regained control of it. But for years, he said, “we saw the shelling and the destruction.”
Even when planes weren’t carrying out airstrikes on his neighborhood, he said, he could hear them flying overhead, headed to drop their bombs in the countryside.
Adam Rasgon
Reporting from Jerusalem
Iran’s foreign ministry said in a statement that decision-making about the future of Syria was “solely the responsibility” of Syrians and called for a national dialogue that includes all parts of Syrian society in order to form a new government. Iran was one of the primary backers of the Assad regime.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Christina Goldbaum
Reporting from Masnaa, Lebanon
A few miles from Lebanon’s main border crossing with Syria, the road is packed with traffic as Syrians who fled during the country’s civil war make their way home. People are cheering, honking their car horns and blasting songs written during the Syrian uprising to celebrate the fall of Bashar al-Assad — their lyrics no longer a fantasy but a reality. Others are hanging out of car windows, waving the flag of the Syrian opposition and holding their fingers up in a “V” shape for victory.
Adam Rasgon
Reporting from Jerusalem
King Abdullah II of Jordan appeared to offer support to the rebels who ousted Mr. al-Assad from power, saying he respects the “will and choices” of the Syrian people. The monarch also emphasized the need for stability in Syria. Jordan, which shares a border with Syria, is host to hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees.
Who is Abu Mohammad al-Jolani, the Islamist leader of the Syrian rebel offensive?
After attracting little notice for years, Abu Mohammad al-Jolani spearheaded a stunning lightning offensive that led to the fall of the regime of President Bashar al-Assad of Syria after over 13 years of brutal civil war.
Mr. al-Jolani, 42, is the leader of Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, an Islamist group once linked to Al Qaeda that has controlled most of Idlib Province, in northwestern Syria, for years during a long stalemate in the conflict.
“By far, he’s the most important player on the ground in Syria,” said Jerome Drevon, a senior analyst of jihad and modern conflict at the International Crisis Group, who has met Mr. al-Jolani several times in the past five years.
In late November, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham launched the most significant challenge to Mr. al-Assad’s rule in a decade, sweeping through Aleppo, Syria’s largest city, before charging south, capturing territory across several provinces without facing much resistance.
By Sunday, rebels were celebrating in Syria’s capital, Damascus, and declared it free of Mr. al-Assad. Syria’s longtime leader had left the country after holding talks with “several parties of the armed conflict,” according to Russia’s Foreign Ministry. It did not say where Mr. al-Assad might be.
Born Ahmed Hussein al-Shara in Saudi Arabia, Mr. al-Jolani is the child of Syrian exiles, according to Arab media reports. In the late 1980s, his family moved back to Syria, and in 2003, he went to neighboring Iraq to join Al Qaeda and fight the U.S. occupation.
He spent several years in a U.S. prison in Iraq, according to the Arab media reports and U.S. officials.
He later emerged in Syria around the start of the civil war and formed the Nusra Front, an Al Qaeda affiliate, which eventually evolved into Hayat Tahrir al-Sham. At some point, he took on the nom de guerre Abu Mohammad al-Jolani.
Since breaking ties with Al Qaeda, Mr. al-Jolani and his group have tried to gain international legitimacy by eschewing global jihadist ambitions and focusing on organized governance in Syria.
In recent years, Mr. al-Jolani and his group have built an administration in the territory they govern, collecting taxes, providing limited public services, and even issuing identity cards to residents, according to a U.N. report. They have also come under criticism from inside and outside the country for using authoritarian tactics and cracking down on dissent.
Questions have emerged about what kind of government Mr. al-Jolani would support and whether Syrians would accept it. In Idlib, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham has espoused a government guided by a conservative and at times hard-line Sunni Islamist ideology.
Since the rebel offensive began, Mr. al-Jolani has sought to reassure minority communities from other sects and religions. Some analysts said he now faces the test of his life: whether he can unite Syrians.
Mr. Drevon likened the situation facing Mr. al-Jolani to those of other leaders who have taken on greater prominence during war, like President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine.
“In a way, this is his Zelensky moment,” Mr. Drevon said. “Zelensky was criticized before the war in Ukraine and then he became a statesman. The question is can Jolani make the same transformation.”
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Vivian Yee
In a statement, Egypt’s foreign ministry called on the parties in Syria’s conflict to start a “comprehensive political process” to establish peace. It emphasized its support for Syria’s “sovereignty, unity and territorial integrity,” underscoring Egyptian concerns that the country could fragment in the chaos surrounding the fall of the government.
Vivian Yee
The statement said Egypt would work with regional and international partners to “end the prolonged suffering of the Syrian people,” stabilize and rebuild the country and help Syrian refugees return home.
The location of Bashar al-Assad remains unclear.
President Bashar al-Assad of Syria was nowhere to be found as armed rebels stormed Damascus, the Syrian capital, and entered the presidential palace, declaring his decades-long rule at an end.
The Russian Foreign Ministry announced on Sunday that Mr. al-Assad had resigned and left Syria, without saying where he might have gone. His departure followed negotiations with his other “participants in the armed conflict” in Syria, according to the Russian authorities. Russia has been a key ally of Mr. al-Assad throughout the country’s long civil war.
It was unclear when Mr. al-Assad might have made his exit.
On Saturday afternoon, as opposition forces closed in around Damascus, the Syrian presidency said Mr. al-Assad remained in the capital. But he did not address the nation or provide any televised statements, prompting widespread speculation over his whereabouts.
Syria’s prime minister, Mohammad Ghazi al-Jalali, told Al Arabiya, the Saudi-owned news channel, that he had last spoken with Mr. al-Assad on Saturday. He said that he had not been able to reach him since.
Iran, Mr. al-Assad’s longtime patron and ally, has also not immediately stated where Mr. al-Assad might be.
Hakan Fidan, Turkey’s foreign minister, said on Sunday that he could not specifically address Mr. al-Assad’s location. But Mr. al-Assad was “probably outside of Syria,” Mr. Fidan told reporters at a conference in Doha, Qatar.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
News of Mr. al-Assad’s departure ended a bitter chapter in the lives of many Syrians who fled the country. “I feel for once that I have a country, that I have a place I can return to. For the first time ever, I feel I have a home,” said Talal Alasaad, 31, who fled Aleppo’s countryside for Lebanon as a young man and now lives in Switzerland.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
Alasaad said he had not seen his elderly parents in over ten years, fearing that he would be conscripted into the army if he returned to Syria. “Now and god willing forever, he’s gone and all this fear inside me is gone,” he said of al-Assad. “We don’t have to fear him anymore, and we can scream it so loudly.”
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Al-Assad has resigned and left Syria after holding talks with “several parties of the armed conflict,” according to Russia’s foreign ministry. It did not say where Mr. al-Assad might be.
There was no immediate comment from the Syrian presidency.
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
Syria’s foreign ministry has issued a statement that appears to hail the unfolding events in Damascus, without mentioning al-Assad. “A new page in Syrian history is being written, consecrating a national oath and covenant that will bring all Syrians together,” the statement said. Syrian embassies abroad will continue to provide services to the country’s citizens, it added.
Nader Ibrahim
Footage distributed by The Associated Press news agency showed the Iranian embassy in Damascus damaged and ransacked on Sunday morning. Iran has been a key backer of Mr. al-Assad’s government.
Nader Ibrahim
The rebels appear to have taken over Syrian state television in Damascus. A message broadcast on Syrian television shows a banner that reads: “Victory of the great Syrian revolution and the fall of the criminal Assad regime.” Mr. al-Assad’s whereabouts remained unclear, hours after rebels entered the capital.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Amelia Nierenberg
The United Nations special envoy for Syria, Geir Pedersen, said in a statement on Sunday that he was looking forward with “cautious hope” to the opening of a new chapter for Syria. He urged “all Syrians to prioritize dialogue, unity, and respect for international humanitarian law and human rights as they seek to rebuild their society.”
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
Celebrations have erupted across parts of Lebanon, which is home to more Syrian refugees per capita than any other country in the world. Local news stations broadcast footage showing crowds chanting at the country’s border crossings with Syria, along with jubilant processions in the capital, Beirut, and the northern city of Tripoli.
Euan Ward
Reporting from Beirut
The Syrian civil war stoked sectarian violence in Lebanon during the early years of the conflict, with many of Lebanon’s Sunni Muslims supporting the rebels, and many of Lebanon’s Shiite Muslims – who make up the bulk of Hezbollah’s constituents – supporting the Assad regime.
Hiba Yazbek
Iraq has secured its border with Syria, according to the official Iraqi News Agency, which said on Sunday that the Al-Qaim border crossing was closed.
Raja Abdulrahim
Reporting from Istanbul
Footage from Damascus that was livestreamed on social media by a resident of the city showed few people out on the streets on Sunday morning, but the sound of celebratory gunfire could still be heard. Rebel leaders had told fighters not to fire their weapons into the air to avoid scaring residents.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Israel says it has entered the demilitarized buffer zone in the Golan Heights.
Israel said Sunday that it had entered a demilitarized buffer zone in the Golan Heights, abutting Syrian-held territory, amid a lightning fast rebel offensive that swept across Syria and drove President Bashar al-Assad from power.
Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, announced that he had ordered troops to “take over the buffer zone” between the countries. He also said Israeli forces had taken up military posts abandoned by Syrian troops, without specifying whether they had entered Syrian territory.
“We gave the Israeli army the order to take over these positions to ensure that no hostile force embeds itself right next to the border of Israel. This is a temporary defensive position until a suitable arrangement is found,” said Mr. Netanyahu.
The Israeli military said it was “not interfering with the internal events in Syria.” But it added that its forces would “continue to operate as long as necessary in order to preserve the buffer zone and defend Israel and its civilians.”
The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, an independent monitor, said Israeli tanks and armored vehicles had been deployed in Quneitra, a border region. But it remained unclear whether they had actually entered Syrian-controlled territory or remained in the zone between the two sides.
Israeli officials and analysts have voiced concern that the fall of Mr. Assad’s government could empower militant groups who seek to carry out attacks against Israel. But while Mr. Netanyahu insisted that the deployment was temporary, it could also raise concerns that Israel might be trying to capitalize on the instability in Syria.
Israel captured the Golan Heights during the Middle East war of 1967. Israel annexed much of the territory in 1981 and the rest is controlled by Syria. Most of the world views this area as Israeli-occupied Syrian territory, though former President Donald J. Trump recognized Israeli sovereignty there in 2019.
The Israeli operation announced on Sunday aimed to position its forces between Syrian rebel groups that have taken control of parts of the Golan Heights controlled by Syria and Israeli communities on the border of the Israeli-controlled part of the territory.
The Golan Regional Council, a local government entity which supervises Israeli settlements in the Golan Heights, said that a wide-scale military operation had started early in the morning and told residents that it would affect some roads and agricultural areas.
The Israeli military announced that two agricultural areas would become closed military zones and that schools in four communities would do distance learning for the time being.
Constant Méheut
Reporting from Kyiv, Ukraine
Russia’s recent failure to prop up the Assad regime in Syria, a close ally it has backed with military support for years, is evidence of the strain the war in Ukraine has put on Moscow’s capabilities, Ukrainian officials have said. Heorhii Tykhyi said at a news conference last week that Russia was unable to sustain combat operations on two fronts. “Why? Because Russia’s significant losses in Ukraine have forced Moscow to withdraw much of its well-trained personnel and equipment from Syria,” he added.
Ismaeel Naar
Reporting from Manama, Bahrain
If al-Assad’s fall is confirmed “no one should shed any tears over the end of the Assad regime,” Daniel Shapiro, the U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for the Middle East, told an audience in Bahrain. He added that the United States will maintain a presence in eastern Syria “to ensure the enduring defeat of ISIS” and will take all necessary measures to defend its forces in the area.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
The fall of the Assad regime would raise questions about what the future holds for the millions of Syrian refugees around the world. Muhammad al-Shammary, who fled the Damascus suburbs for Turkey in 2013, said he hoped to return to Syria as soon as it was safe and feasible to do so. He hasn’t seen most of his family members — including his siblings and in-laws — for over a decade. Many Syrian refugees had resigned themselves to a life in exile, said Mr. al-Shammary, 44. “They engraved this inside our minds: that they would rule forever,” he said.
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
Footage broadcast by the Al Arabiya television channel appears to show armed men in civilian clothes escorting Mohammad Ghazi Al-Jalali, the prime minister of Syria, into a car.
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
Syria’s prime minister, Mohammad Ghazi al-Jalali, told a Saudi-owned news channel in a phone interview that he last spoke with President Bashar al-Assad on Saturday. He has not been able to reach him since. The rebel forces that entered Damascus have said they will work with al-Jalali.
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
News media across the Arab world is airing video of a group of men said to be broadcasting from the studio of Syrian state television. In it, the men, who say they represent rebel forces, announce “the liberation of the city of Damascus, the toppling of the dictator Bashar al-Assad, and the liberation of all oppressed prisoners from the regime’s jails.”
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Syrians mourn all they have lost, even as they celebrate.
For nearly all the years that the al-Assad family ruled Syria, silence reigned. No one spoke freely, fearful of who might hear. Everyone knew the consequences of dissent: disappearance into government prisons, from which few ever returned.
But as Saturday turned to Sunday — the first day in more than five decades that dawn broke without an al-Assad in the presidential palace — the streets were loud with joy.
Nonstop celebratory gunfire crackled around Damascus, the capital, like so many fireworks displays. Crowds shouted in the squares. Rebel fighters celebrated from atop their trucks.
“Our hearts are dancing with joy,” Walaa Salameh, 35, a resident of the Damascus area, said in a phone interview. “We can’t predict the future, and anything is possible, but the most important thing is we got rid of this oppressive regime.”
It had been 13 years since those opposed to President Bashar al-Assad first hoped to follow revolutions in Tunisia, Egypt and Libya by overthrowing their own autocratic leader: 13 years of bloodshed and death, of homes and loved ones lost, of lives abandoned and ruptured.
Mr. al-Assad’s opponents had to wait until Sunday. Years after most Syrians had given up on ever witnessing such moments at home, scenes familiar from past Arab Spring revolts were playing out, with unthinkable suddenness, in Damascus.
State television went from trumpeting Mr. al-Assad’s strong defenses on Saturday to broadcasting an announcement by a group of nine rebels on Sunday: “By the grace of God Almighty, the city of Damascus has been liberated, the tyrant Bashar al-Assad has been toppled, and all the unjustly detained people from the regime’s prisons have been released,” one of them read out. “Long live a free and independent Syria for all Syrians of all sects.”
News photographs showed a rebel sitting behind what appeared to be a vast, gleaming desk in an office in the presidential palace, all intricate inlaid wood and fine carpets. Others showed people wandering through Mr. al-Assad’s residence, pulling down a chandelier, picking through rooms they were never meant to see.
The embassy of Iran, one of Mr. al-Assad’s fiercest allies, was also ransacked, news photographs showed. Syrians tore down a poster that had hung there of Qassem Soleimani, a key Iranian commander who helped Mr. al-Assad push back the rebels earlier in the war.
A video from Damascus showed one of the military checkpoints that had proclaimed Mr. al-Assad’s power dark and empty, its soldiers’ uniforms in a heap on the ground.
“Thank God, thank God,” said Eman Ouad, whose husband was killed in the civil war. Her voice was close to breaking.
“Our freedom has returned,” said Ms. Ouad, 44, who was forced to leave her home in Damascus and now lives in Syria’s northwest. “Thirteen years of subjugation. Thirteen years of displacement.”
When he heard Mr. al-Assad was gone, Ahmed al-Misilmani, a journalist in northwest Syria, ran onto his balcony in sheer elation, yelling so loudly that his wife and children woke up.
“God is great, Assad the dog has fallen,” he shouted.
Yet no amount of euphoria, no wellspring of hope, could make Syrians forget all they had lost.
Mr. al-Misilmani’s mind went immediately to friends who had been imprisoned at Sednaya, a government prison infamous for torture and mass executions — just one part of a labyrinthine detention system where so many Syrians disappeared, most without a trace.
“We hope to God they are still alive,” said Mr. al-Misilmani, who was displaced six years ago from his home near the city of Homs.
Anas Khoury, 24, an opposition activist who fled his Damascus suburb with his wife after a 2013 chemical attack there, spent the first hours of his post-Assad life scanning lists of prisoners freed from Sednaya, he said. His brother was detained there in 2011. The family does not know if he is still alive.
Mr. Khoury was struggling to process it all. His children were born in Idlib Province, where the family fled, and had never met their grandparents. Until a few days ago, it would have been reasonable to predict that they never would.
“They were born in displacement,” he said. “They were born among the tents.”
In the hours after Mr. al-Assad disappeared from Syria, his image was disappearing, too.
Like his secret police, the president’s face was once impossible to escape. Along Syrian roads and at the entrances to cities, banners featuring the president’s photo read, “Assad Forever.” His image watched from cigarette lighters hawked at Damascus souvenir stands, shoulder-to-shoulder with two of his most important backers, President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia and the Hezbollah leader at the time, Hassan Nasrallah. Street corners and army checkpoints were festooned with Assads, as if his face were the national flag.
On Sunday, photos and videos circulating on social media showed people tearing his pictures down , setting them on fire and stomping on them, a small form of personal revenge.
Statues of the president’s father and elder brother fell with a crash in several cities, according to photos and videos: in Damascus; Latakia, the al-Assad stronghold on the Mediterranean coast; and Qamishli, in northeastern Syria.
One statue people had not succeeded in toppling was one of Mr. al-Assad’s father and predecessor, Hafez al-Assad, outside the Dar al-Assad Center for Culture and Arts in Damascus, a video live-streamed on Instagram showed.
Instead, they left it with a trash can upturned over its head.
“Now and God willing forever, he’s gone and all this fear inside me is gone,” said Talal Alasaad, 31, who fled the countryside near Aleppo for Lebanon as a young man and now lives in Switzerland. “We don’t have to fear him anymore, and we can scream it so loudly.”
He had not seen his elderly parents in more than 10 years, afraid he would be forced into military service if he returned. Now his mother was sending him videos she had taken of his childhood home, which had been commandeered early in the war by forces loyal to Mr. al-Assad. His parents had returned to see it after rebels retook Aleppo in a shock offensive on Nov. 30.
“It’s insane what is happening,” Mr. Alasaad said. “I’m full of emotion. I feel for once that I have a country, that I have a place I can return to. For the first time ever, I feel I have a home.”
The Syrian government’s fall could allow Mr. Alasaad and millions of other Syrian refugees around the world to return. Already on Sunday, people were lining up to enter Syria at a border crossing in Lebanon. Others were celebrating in Beirut, the Lebanese capital, where hundreds of thousands of Syrians fled over the course of the war.
In Turkey, which hosts more than three million Syrian refugees, photos showed crowds of revelers outside the Fatih Mosque in Istanbul waving the opposition’s three-starred flag.
Mr. al-Assad’s downfall was “a miracle,” said Muhammad al-Shammary, who fled the Damascus suburbs for Turkey in 2013. It had been more than a decade since he had seen most of his family members, including his siblings and in-laws. He hoped to return to Syria as soon as it was safe and feasible, he said.
Many Syrians had resigned themselves to lives in exile, said Mr. al-Shammary, 44.
“They engraved this inside our minds: that they would rule forever,” he said.
Now it was the al-Assads who were in exile, and Mr. al-Shammary could think of going home.
Aaron Boxerman, Adam Rasgon and Euan Ward contributed reporting.
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
They Love France. So When Notre-Dame Burned, They Wanted to Help.
Like many of the millions of tourists who visit Paris, Nick and Suzie Trivisonno, of Charlotte, N.C., would usually catch at least a glimpse of Notre-Dame on their frequent visits to town. Often, the Trivisonnos, who are Catholics, would go to the cathedral and pray — for family, friends and peace.
On Saturday, they were back in Paris to offer a prayer for Notre-Dame itself.
The centuries-old cathedral, badly damaged by fire in April 2019, reopened on Saturday with an official ceremony, after a restoration carried out by roughly 2,000 workers. They labored on what President Emmanuel Macron of France has called “the most beautiful construction site of the century,” in an effort funded with about $900 million in donations from around the world. The Trivisonnos were among those who donated.
They were moved to contribute after watching, horrified, as a live video feed showed the mainstay of European history, culture and faith engulfed in flames and teetering on the brink of oblivion.
On Saturday morning, Mr. Trivisonno, 77, and Mrs. Trivisonno, 72, were taking coffee and croissants on the ground floor of the Hotel Regina Louvre on the right bank of the Seine. They were still buzzing from the night before, when they had attended a special meal for donors at the Tour d’Argent, the fine-dining establishment in the Fifth Arrondissement that dates to the 16th century. They were served plates of poached lobster and duck. But the main course was the view of Notre-Dame through the big windows.
The cathedral is still partly clad in spindly scaffolding; the restoration job will not be fully done for years. But there, dramatically lit against the night sky, the cathedral seemed to announce to the donors, and the world, that it had recovered.
“I don’t think there was a closed mouth,” Mrs. Trivisonno said. “The jaws were dropping.”
After the French, Americans were the second-largest donors to the Notre-Dame project, offering an estimated $62 million to the cause, said Michel Picaud, president of Friends of Notre-Dame de Paris, a nonprofit group that helped lead the international fund-raising push. Mr. Picaud said some 45,000 American donors gave to the charity alone, with many other Americans donating to similar groups.
That generosity was a testament to the enduring hold that France has on American hearts. Some people chipped in a few dollars. Others gave millions, including the Starr Foundation, of New York, and the Marie-Josée and Henry R. Kravis Foundation, of West Palm Beach, Fla.
In an interview, the Trivisonnos declined to disclose exactly how much they contributed. But on the website of the Friends of Notre-Dame de Paris, Mr. Trivisonno noted that they gave enough to be recognized at the “Quasimodo’s Circle” level, which means a gift of at least $10,000.
“It’s always held a very special place in our hearts,” Mrs. Trivisonno said. “It’s been kind of like a cornerstone for everything that’s important to us.”
The outpouring of American largess for Notre-Dame is part of a centuries-old tradition of mutual aid between the two countries that has survived many famous quarrels. It began with Louis XVI’s contributions to the American Revolution. In the 20th century, the United States pumped billions into France to help rebuild the country after World War II.
Neither gift was purely altruistic. Louis XVI opened his purse to the American rebels to weaken the British, France’s great 18th-century rival, while the Americans, according to a Central Intelligence Agency memo made public in 2004, hoped that huge cash injections into France in the latter half of the 1940s would help quell intense postwar labor unrest fueled by French communists, and encourage the idea of “salvation beyond revolution.”
The Trivisonnos’ altruism was far less complicated. Neither has blood ties to France. They simply fell in love with the place.
He grew up lower-middle class in Brooklyn. She grew up on a farm in New Mexico. He first saw Notre-Dame in 1964, after talking his parents into letting him come on a trip to celebrate their 25th wedding anniversary. She first saw Notre-Dame a few years later, when her parents, who had been working for the U.S. Foreign Service in Uttar Pradesh, India, stopped in the French capital on their way home.
They were married in 2000, and over the years, France continued to beckon. They are not alone. With 100 million international tourist arrivals last year alone, France, according to United Nations figures, is the most visited country in the world. The United States sends its backpackers, gourmands, art lovers, “Emily in Paris” fans and a group that travel planners often refer to as HNWIs, or high-net-worth individuals.
The Trivisonnos, who are retired, fall into the latter group. Mr. Trivisonno made his living in finance, and as a chairman and chief executive of a provider of marketing information for consumer packaged goods companies. She was a classical clarinetist by training, but also had a long career in the business world.
Both of them, in recent years, have fallen hard for the pleasures of Burgundy, both the region and the prized (and often expensive) wine. Both are members of the Confrerie des Chevaliers du Tastevin, the worldwide organization of devoted Burgundy fans, and many of their recent trips to France have been to the storied region. There, on the small farms and in the homes of winemakers, Mrs. Trivisonno said, their conversations often run on gestures and bonhomie when their limited French runs out.
“We’ve become fluent in French,” Mrs. Trivisonno said, with a chuckle. “We just can’t understand a word they’re saying.”
Mr. Trivisonno, who formerly served in the U.S. Army Reserve, noted that the bodies of thousands of U.S. soldiers are buried in French soil. Such, he said, are the strong and tangible roots of the friendship.
On April 15, 2019, the Trivisonnos were on a plane watching the Masters golf tournament on their cellphones when the coverage was interrupted by the footage of Notre-Dame on fire. It gutted them. Later, Mr. Trivisonno said, they received a solicitation in the mail that asked them to donate to the rebuilding effort.
After their contribution, they were invited, with other U.S. donors, to dine at the French ambassador’s residence in Washington. Mr. Trivisonno eventually became a board member of the Friends of Notre-Dame de Paris group.
At breakfast on Saturday, they said they were waiting for further instructions for attending the evening’s reopening ceremony, to which they had also been invited. The French organizers seemed to be doing some last-minute improvising around matters of protocol and timing, due to President-elect Donald J. Trump’s late announcement that he planned to attend, and a weather forecast that was calling for rain.
As a young man, Mr. Trivisonno had studied for a career in the priesthood before moving into the secular world of business. He said that with Mr. Trump’s planned attendance, the event on Saturday seemed to have taken on more of a political than a spiritual tone.
He said he was more excited about the inaugural Mass on Sunday morning. “The dignitaries are going to be gone,” he said. “Trump is going to be gone. We’re going to get to be parishioners.”
He Was Shot in the Face. Now Ukraine Wants to Draft Him.
Early in Russia’s war against Ukraine, Mykola Kulichenko endured an ordeal. He was abducted as a civilian, survived a Russian execution attempt by a stroke of luck and then climbed out of his own grave by pushing through the dirt heaped above him.
His brothers died beside him, but Mr. Kulichenko had turned his head at the last moment and a bullet passed through his cheek, leaving a hole but not causing life-threatening wounds.
His case elicited widespread shock and sympathy in Ukraine — but it did not shield him from Ukraine’s mobilization system. He received a draft summons in October.
Mr. Kulichenko has used his second lease on life to care for his elderly father and return to raising ducks and chickens on a farm in northern Ukraine. But he said he still has trouble sleeping, as he flashes back to being shot and buried alive then finding his way home with his body covered in bruises and his cheek bleeding and tremendously swollen.
Given the trauma of his ordeal, he doesn’t think he should be drafted into the army. “It was very hard to climb out of my grave,” he said.
“What would it change if I go” to the trenches now, he said, claiming that his presence would have no impact on the fighting. “I would take my life to the front and leave it there, for nothing.”
The summons of Mr. Kulichenko, who is 35, underscores the unpredictable and lopsided mobilization system in Ukraine that leans heavily on recruiting older men.
The policies have drawn criticism from the Biden administration, which has said Ukraine should expand its draft to younger men aged 18 to 25, who are now exempt, to defend hundreds of miles of front line. The need for soldiers is now more acute than the need for weapons, American officials have said.
Ukrainian officials say they cannot draft men in their late teens and early 20s without risking demographic shortfalls in the future, and they have pushed back against the American criticism.
-
Sign up to receive an email from The New York Times as soon as important news breaks around the world.
-
On weekdays and Sundays, we recommend one piece of exceptional writing from The Times — a narrative or essay that takes you someplace you might not expect to go.
-
Stories handpicked by our editors, just for you.
“Ukraine cannot be expected to compensate for delays in logistics or hesitation in support with the youth of our men,” Dmytro Lytvyn, a communications adviser to the president, wrote recently in a post on X. It was another swipe at the pace of Western weapons support, which Ukraine views as tepid and overly cautious.
Mr. Kulichenko’s experience also points to the difficulty Ukraine has had in calibrating the rules governing draft exemptions. He became eligible for recruitment after rule changes last spring eliminated some exemptions for hardship, including for those caring for ailing relatives.
Like a game of Whac-a-Mole, each change knocks out some who enjoyed exemptions while adding others who had not — with civilians left to argue over which hardship was more deserving.
The changes to the law were intended to crack down on draft dodgers who abused the mobilization system by claiming hardship when little actually existed, a practice abetted by corruption in the draft operation.
With the loopholes supposedly plugged, recruitment officials stepped up the draft through the summer. Ukraine does not disclose figures, but military analysts have said an initially promising flow of recruits for the army has since tapered off. Fewer men are entering basic training, and many of them are old or in poor health, military commanders say.
Ukraine plans to draft an additional 160,000 men in the “near future,” the secretary of the National Security and Defense Council, Oleksandr Lytvynenko told Parliament late last month. This number would restore units to 85 percent of their full strength, he said.
But reaching deeper into the pool of older men risks filling the ranks with less motivated and healthy soldiers. Even now, none of the brigades in combat are fully staffed, said Maj. Maksym Zhorin, a commander in the 3rd Assault Brigade. Of the new soldiers turning up, he said, “the quality of personnel has significantly deteriorated recently.”
Ukraine, meanwhile, is falling back at two locations on the front inside the country, in the eastern Donbas region and near the town of Kupiansk in northeastern Ukraine, and it has lost about half of the territory captured in an incursion into the Kursk region of Russia in August.
“We are truly on the verge of a military catastrophe,” Yevhen Dykyi, a military veteran and commentator on the war for Ukrainian media, told radio NV. It is not because of mistakes by the army, he said, but because of the failure to draft enough soldiers.
But aggressive mobilization efforts, mostly aimed at older men in rural areas, have led to a backlash in society. Women have blocked roads to prevent recruitment officials from searching for draft dodgers in some western Ukrainian villages.
Men have slipped across the borders to Europe to avoid the draft, sometimes swimming across rivers. Others simply remain at home, lest they get picked up at a checkpoint or other location.
Parliament has been considering a partial swing of the pendulum back — introducing several overhauls to reduce draft evasion and desertion by restoring exemptions and granting draftees more choice in how they serve. Men are now sometimes allowed to choose or change the units in which they serve, for example.
An amendment passed in Parliament in a first reading on Nov. 20 would grant deferments to civilians whom the Russians had arrested earlier in the war and to those who lost close relatives in the fighting.
If signed into law, Mr. Kulichenko could qualify on both points, though under current rules he is still eligible for the draft.
The issue of whether war injuries should merit an exemption from future service has been a divisive one in Ukraine. Men have returned to serve after suffering more grievous injuries than Mr. Kulichenko. Some have voluntarily returned to service even after their legs or arms were amputated. Such dedication is praised by Ukrainians who view their lives and homes depending on holding back Russian soldiers.
Russians arrested Mr. Kulichenko and his two brothers in March 2022 in their hometown, Dovzhyk, north of Kyiv. The dynamic in the war was the opposite of today — the Russians were retreating from northern Ukraine. The brothers were suspected of planting or helping to plant a roadside bomb that killed several Russian officers, Mr. Kulichenko said. He denied any role in the incident.
The brothers were held for three days in an abandoned sawmill where they were interrogated and severely beaten. With the Ukrainian Army approaching, Mr. Kulichenko said, the Russians decided to shoot the brothers to eliminate evidence of the torture. His ordeal was reported at the time by The Wall Street Journal and later taken up in a war crimes prosecution in Ukraine, in which Russian soldiers were tried in absentia.
Russians loaded the brothers in a truck, drove them into the forest, lined them up beside the grave and opened fire. A bullet passed through Mr. Kulichenko’s cheek and he fell to the ground. He lay still as the soldiers piled on dirt, then clambered out after they left.
The draft summons arrived in October. He said he understands the army “lacks people and that is why they take everyone.”
He has not responded to the letter by appearing at a draft board, and said he does not intend to. He does not want to fight in the war, given what happened to him, he said.
“I didn’t get over it,” he said.
Oleksandra Mykolyshyn contributed reporting.
South Korea’s government was paralyzed Sunday, mired in a new constitutional crisis after President Yoon Suk Yeol of South Korea clung to his office, but his own party’s leader suggested that he had already been ousted from power.
Mr. Yoon has barely been seen in public since his ill-fated decision last week to declare martial law. Meanwhile, Han Dong-hoon, the chairman of Mr. Yoon’s People Power Party, or P.P.P., has presented himself as the government’s decision maker and said the president is no longer running the country.
The trouble is that South Korea’s Constitution doesn’t allow for anyone to replace the president unless he resigns or is impeached.
Mr. Yoon’s office did not comment on Mr. Han’s statement. But Mr. Yoon “has not and by law, cannot, cede power to anyone” except through resignation, impeachment or election, said a senior government source familiar with the discussions inside Mr. Yoon’s office. Mr. Yoon exercised his role as president on Sunday by accepting the resignation of his home minister, Lee Sang-min.
Opposition groups immediately complained that Mr. Han was overreaching: trying to use the power vacuum created by Mr. Yoon’s ill-fated imposition of martial law and the ensuing turmoil to establish himself as the top leader in the governing camp.
“We have a situation where the president cannot make decisions, he cannot give guidelines, he cannot give orders,” said Kang Won-taek, a professor of political science at Seoul National University. “Although we have a president, we are in a state of anarchy.”
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Tens of thousands of South Koreans from across the country gathered in the streets outside the National Assembly in Seoul on Saturday, demanding President Yoon Suk Yeol’s ouster. Mr. Yoon briefly imposed martial law on Tuesday, reopening old wounds and plunging the country into political chaos. An attempt to impeach Mr. Yoon failed to garner the required number of votes, prolonging the political upheaval and uncertainty that has roiled the country this week.
Protests in the city and around the country have intensified since Mr. Yoon’s audacious move on Tuesday. The rally at the National Assembly ahead of the impeachment vote on Saturday was the largest one yet, despite freezing temperatures. By 3 p.m. the areas in front of the National Assembly were filled.
People waved flags representing labor unions, human rights groups and smaller political parties. The police, wearing neon jackets, were lined up along the crowds to keep order.
As the grand boulevard facing the National Assembly filled up with protestors, people moved to the street that runs across the front of the complex.
Meanwhile, in another part of Seoul, supporters of Mr. Yoon gathered near Gwanghwamun Square. There were chairs set up for the supporters, unlike the crowds sitting on the ground outside of the National Assembly. Soon after the impeachment vote began, speakers were quick to announce that impeachment looked unlikely, and the crowd turned jubilant.
Protesters in front of the National Assembly stayed well into the night, as the voting session dragged on. People held candles and colorful light sticks. South Korea has a tradition of holding candlelight rallies to express political dissent.
As 9 p.m. approached, it became clear there were not enough votes to impeach Mr. Yoon and the crowd began to thin out.
However, many protesters said they would not give up. “I plan to come every weekend,” said Subin Park, 29, who had traveled from Bucheon, west of Seoul. “I hope a lot of people will show up from Monday.”
For years after coming out as transgender, Ling’er, an aspiring influencer in eastern China, struggled from heartbreak to heartbreak. Her family refused to accept her. When she tried to find an interim job to support herself, employers would not hire her.
And when her parents sent her to a hospital to try to change her gender identity, she was held there for three months, despite her repeated protests. She was forced to undergo treatment that included multiple rounds of electroshock therapy.
So when she later sued the hospital for subjecting her to unnecessary and unwanted treatment, she was not optimistic. Then the seemingly unthinkable happened: A court accepted her complaint, in China’s first known lawsuit over so-called conversion therapy involving a transgender person. And the hospital agreed in October to pay her a sizable settlement.
“To me, this is a win. With this money, I can start my new life, and start my own business,” said Ling’er, 28. “I can live my own life.”
The case is a rare bright spot in the fight for L.G.B.T.Q. rights in China. Ling’er’s lawsuit was covered sympathetically by some mainstream Chinese news outlets, even as overall coverage of L.G.B.T.Q. issues has diminished. That her lawsuit was accepted at all was a hard-won victory, her supporters said, in a country with no laws protecting L.G.B.T.Q. people.
As China’s leader, Xi Jinping, has overseen a crackdown on civil society, many L.G.B.T.Q. advocacy groups have been forced to shut down, and Pride celebrations have been canceled. Nationalist influencers have attacked L.G.B.T.Q. activism as a hostile foreign force. People have been punished for displaying rainbow flags.
It is unclear whether the payout to Ling’er will have any effect on preventing future cases of conversion therapy, a practice that has been widely discredited by medical experts. The hospital pressed for the exact terms of the settlement to be confidential, and it has not acknowledged wrongdoing.
Ling’er was initially reluctant even to file the lawsuit. “Sexual minorities in China have no guarantees,” she said. “How could you possibly protect your rights?”
She was ultimately convinced by a group of L.G.B.T.Q. advocates, in China and overseas, with whom she had connected online and who helped her find lawyers. It was a support network that she could not have imagined finding in her rural, mountainous hometown in China’s Hebei Province.
Ling’er, who is using a chosen name, had known since childhood that she preferred spending time with girls, and she realized while studying at a vocational school that she was transgender. She eventually began taking estrogen and dressing in women’s clothing. But when she came out to her parents in 2021, during a visit home, they said she was disgracing their family.
-
Top Commander Suspended: The case of Adm. Miao Hua suggests the persistence of graft at high levels of the military, despite the efforts by Xi Jinping, China’s top leader, to stamp out corruption.
-
Women Mobilize Against Subpar Sanitary Pads: An online campaign has prompted major pad manufacturers to apologize. Regulators said they would consider women’s criticisms when writing new standards.
-
Court Sentences Journalist: A court sentenced a journalist to seven years in prison on espionage charges. His family said it was punishment for past writings that were critical of the government, as well as a warning to Chinese citizens against engaging with foreigners.
-
The World’s Largest Car Exporter: Tariffs from the United States and other countries are unlikely to stop China’s auto export dominance.
In 2022, Ling’er agreed to her parents’ requests to see a psychiatrist at a hospital in the nearby city of Qinhuangdao, hoping it would appease them.
She explained to doctors at Qinhuangdao Jiulongshan Hospital that she did not think there was anything wrong with her gender identity, and that it was her parents who could not accept her. She acknowledged feeling anxious and depressed, but not to a serious extent. Hospital staff noted that she seemed clearheaded and spoke at a normal pace, medical and legal records show.
Even so, she was diagnosed with anxiety and “ego-dystonic sexual orientation.” The term, which has generally referred to people who are unhappy with their sexual orientation, was dropped from the World Health Organization’s official list of medical conditions in 2019, due to concerns that it contributed to discrimination against L.G.B.T.Q. people and had been used as justification for conversion therapy.
Over Ling’er’s protests, her mother had her involuntarily hospitalized.
She remained in hospital for 97 days, despite repeatedly pleading to leave. She was given psychiatric medication and subjected to seven rounds of modified electroconvulsive therapy.
The doctors did not explicitly say that the electric shocks were intended to change her gender identity, Ling’er said, but they urged her to cut her hair short and wear men’s clothing, and they made clear that they believed her transgender identity was wrong.
“The doctors didn’t listen to anything I said,” she said. “They thought I was sick, so I was sick.”
Medical and private institutions offering “conversion therapy” are common in China, according to activists, because the stigma against transgender people is widespread.
The Chinese Society of Psychiatry removed homosexuality from its list of mental disorders in 2001, but it retained the ego-dystonic diagnosis, and it also continues to classify transgender individuals as having a mental illness. People are allowed to change their legal genders, but only if they undergo gender-affirming surgery and notify their families.
In two landmark lawsuits — one concluded in 2014 and another in 2017 — judges ordered clinics to compensate the plaintiffs, gay men who had been subjected to conversion therapy, noting that their rights had been violated. But previous court rulings are not binding precedents in Chinese law.
The authorities’ continued classification of transgender people as mentally ill also makes it harder to build a legal case, said Chen Junmi, an L.G.B.T.Q. rights activist in the United States who helped Ling’er bring her lawsuit.
When Ling’er was finally released from the hospital, she returned home to find that her parents had thrown away her clothes and makeup. At first, she tried to live as a man. But in September last year, she decided to cut off her family and leave home.
For months, she drifted from city to city. She was turned away when she tried to find work as a waitress or caterer and at times slept on the street. Seeking solace, she connected with L.G.B.T.Q. communities online, including Mx. Chen. In July, she sued the hospital. (Her lawyers also suggested suing her parents, but Ling’er said she could not bring herself to do that.)
The hospital denied any wrongdoing, arguing that Chinese law allows people with mental disorders to be hospitalized against their will with their families’ consent, if they cannot consent on their own. The hospital could not be reached for comment.
The hospital initially offered only one-quarter of the 80,000 yuan, or $11,000, that Ling’er had sought. But after months of negotiations, they reached a settlement that Ling’er said would allow her to start her own shop or street food stall, and to begin saving for gender-affirming surgery. She is now renting an apartment in the city of Tianjin, and she dreams of becoming an entertainer, playing instruments or chatting with viewers on livestream apps.
Ling’er said she thought she had won a favorable outcome in part because the judge overseeing the negotiations had been sympathetic to her.
“Her attitude toward me was, ‘You are you, no one can change you,’” Ling’er said. “If all Chinese parents could be like that, our community’s problems could be resolved very easily.”
Mx. Chen, the activist, said that Chinese society has become more accepting of L.G.B.T.Q. people. That has created room to keep pushing for change, even if explicit activism has largely been shut down.
“I think the government is learning too,” Mx. Chen said.
Ling’er said she hoped to see legal protections for, and education about, diverse gender identities.
“My own strength is far from enough,” she said. “We need all sisters to stand up and work together to improve the situation of transgender people in China.”
Siyi Zhao contributed research.