Damascus, Syria Dec. 9, 7:10 p.m.
Here are the latest developments.
The rebels who ended the Assad family’s brutal rule in Syria began asserting control over the capital on Monday, announcing that a new government would begin work immediately as its fighters took up positions outside public buildings and directed traffic in a show of their newly claimed authority.
Major questions remained unanswered, including who would lead the new rebel government, as millions of Syrians and the wider world struggled to process the stunning end to the Assad family’s decades-long reign. Euphoria around the ouster of President Bashar al-Assad over the weekend mixed with uncertainty about the future of country and the intentions of the rebels who now hold the capital, Damascus.
The rebels, led by an Islamist leader with the nom de guerre of Abu Mohammed al-Jolani, face the complex task of extending their control over a country with deep ethnic, sectarian and religious divisions. Their military leadership said in a statement on Telegram that rebel forces were “about to finish controlling the capital and preserving public property,” and that a new government would begin work “immediately” after being formed. It did not specify who would lead the new government.
New York Times reporters entering Syria on Monday via Lebanon saw abandoned Syrian military tanks, empty checkpoints and ripped-up posters of Mr. al-Assad littering the main highway to the capital, Damascus.
Syrians who had fled a 13-year civil war clogged the roads from Turkey and Lebanon to return home, as did people who had been displaced within the country.
But some who had supported the Assad government fear they could face retribution. And on Monday, there were early signs of the lawlessness — broken windows of cars and shops — that many fear could spiral and grip the country.
Here’s what to know:
-
Prisons: Hundreds of Syrians were rushing on Monday to try to get to Sednaya Prison, a complex near Damascus that was notorious for torture and executions, in the hopes of finding missing loved ones. Emergency workers are still trying to find prisoners who are thought to be stuck in hidden cells.
-
Israel: Israeli forces entered Syrian territory over the weekend, taking up what officials described as temporary defensive positions. Israel’s foreign minister, Gideon Saar, also said Israel had struck Syrian chemical weapons and missile sites in an effort to keep extremists from seizing them. While many in Israel are concerned about who will succeed Mr. al-Assad, his fall is also seen as the crowning consequence of a yearlong Israeli campaign against Iran and its interests.
-
Al-Assad in Russia: Moscow will not publicize Mr. al-Assad’s location in Russia, the Kremlin spokesman, Dmitri S. Peskov, told Russian news agencies on Monday. He added that President Vladimir V. Putin had made the decision to offer exile to Mr. al-Assad and his family, but there were no immediate plans for the two men to meet.
-
Iran: Iranian officials and commentators are rushing to distance their country from Mr. al-Assad, a tyrant they once considered a close ally. Some officials admitted on state television that Iran had misjudged regional dynamics and overlooked his domestic unpopularity.
-
Turkey: Turkey backed the rebel group that toppled the al-Assad regime. Its military also fired on U.S.-backed Kurdish forces in northern Syria over the weekend. That illustrates how the interests of Ankara and Washington diverge over support for the Kurds, who have been instrumental U.S. partners in fighting Islamic State.
-
The United States: American forces destroyed the so-called caliphate that ISIS carved out of Syria and Iraq for itself. The Biden administration does not want the group to reassert itself, but President Biden has just six weeks left in office. President-elect Donald J. Trump has taken pride in his role in defeating Islamic State in his first term while otherwise agitating to stay uninvolved in Syria.
Germany suspends asylum decisions for Syrians.
Germany has suspended all asylum decisions for people coming from Syria, its office of migration and refugees announced on Monday.
Nancy Faeser, Germany’s interior minister, said that while she was hopeful about recent events in Syria, where rebels ousted the country’s longtime leader President Bashar al-Assad over the weekend, the situation on the ground was complex.
“The further assessment of the protection status of recognized Syrian refugees living in Germany depends on further developments in Syria,” she said in a statement to journalists on Monday. Deportations for Syrians who have been convicted of crimes will also be suspended until the situation becomes clearer, her office said.
Asylum decisions in German are based in part on whether a person would be endangered if they were returned to their home country. It was not immediately clear how many applications would be affected.
The rebels that toppled the repressive Assad government were led by an Islamist group called Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, which was once linked to Al Qaeda but has since tried to gain international legitimacy by eschewing global jihadist ambitions.
More recently, the group’s leader has tried to reassure minority communities from other sects and religions that they would not be treated harshly — but it remains to be seen if they will follow through. And just a day after Bashar al-Assad fled Syria, it is also unclear who will lead a new government.
Nearly a million Syrians currently live in Germany, the vast majority having left during the civil war and Mr. Assad’s brutal crackdown of dissent. Former German chancellor Angela Merkel refused to close the borders during an exodus of Syrians in 2015.
A majority of those who arrived then have learned German and have integrated. Last year alone, 75,000 of them became German citizens. But the issue of migration has become increasingly divisive in Germany, as in several other Western countries, with some local leaders saying the large influx of migrants has strained their resources.
As Germany readies itself for the likelihood of a snap parliamentary election campaign this winter, the question of what to do about Syrian refugees has become a hot topic.
Jürgen Hardt, a foreign affairs specialist with the conservative Christian Democratic Union, which is ahead in the polls, said he believed the end of the Assad government would change things for Syrians living in Germany.
“I think that at the end of the day, a great many Syrians who are here will go back to Syria,” he said.
Jens Spahn, a fellow conservative member of the Christian Democrats who has taken a hard line in the past on migration, suggested providing free flights and 1,000 euros for all Syrians who want to return.
Annalena Baerbock, Germany’s foreign minister and a member of the center-left Green party, warned of trying use the fall of Mr. al-Assad for domestic politics.
“Anyone who is now trying to turn this situation in Syria, where the future is completely unclear, into a political issue has completely lost touch with reality in the Middle East,” she said.
Many Syrians already have asylum protection in Germany, so the decision on Monday would apply to relative newcomers.
.
As rebels rush to establish order, governments weigh recognizing a group they once shunned as extremist.
A day after sweeping into Damascus, the rebel coalition that found itself suddenly in charge of the Syrian capital and its government institutions hurried on Monday to establish order, trying to fill the vacuum left by the crumbling of President Bashar al-Assad’s regime.
The rebels’ military leadership announced in a statement on Telegram that its forces were “about to finish controlling the capital and preserving public property,” and that it was forming a transitional government. The statement did not name the leader of the transitional government, but local news reports said it would be Mohammed al-Bashir, who previously served as the head of a rebel-run administration in northwestern Syria.
The new, de facto leaders of Syria appeared to be striving for security, stability and continuity. Though there were reports over the weekend of looting at the Central Bank and of people ransacking Mr. al-Assad’s personal residence and the embassy of Iran, his main backer, rebel fighters on Monday stood guard outside government institutions throughout the capital. The new authorities also circulated images on social media of security personnel patrolling the streets of Damascus.
Their goal appeared to be to avoid the kind of chaos that has gripped other Arab nations when rebellions overthrew longtime dictators. In Libya during the 2011 Arab Spring revolt and Iraq during the 2003 American invasion, for example, looting was widespread and order broke down, prompting armed groups to jockey for power and leading to years of dysfunction and violence.
Jerome Drevon, an expert at the International Crisis Group who has studied and spoken extensively with Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, the Islamist group that spearheaded the rebel offensive, said the fighters had told him since taking Damascus that they would focus first on establishing security and providing basic services.
That will be easier said than done, especially because the rebels across Syria do not all belong to the same group. Hayat Tahrir al-Sham leads the group in Damascus, which now controls most of the country. Another group dominates in the south. Kurdish-led, U.S.-backed forces hold sway in the northeast.
So far, however, other rebels appear to be heeding the main coalition’s directives to preserve state institutions and avoid looting and acts of revenge.
“You need to present as much continuity as possible to avoid what happened elsewhere,” Mr. Drevon said. “Security is a major, major issue, because as people start fighting, weapons start spreading, everything goes down from there.”
There were signs that Mr. al-Assad’s bureaucrats were accepting their new leaders. A day after Syria’s foreign ministry said in a statement that embassies overseas would continue providing services to Syrian citizens, the Syrian Embassy in Russia raised the rebels’ green, white and black flag over its mansion in central Moscow on Monday morning, according to news footage.
It was not immediately clear whether many foreign governments would soon recognize the transitional government, a step that would add to the rebels’ legitimacy and one that would help unlock more international humanitarian aid. Many countries, including the United States, designate Hayat Tahrir al-Sham as a terrorist organization and have not had formal contacts with the group.
A British minister told the BBC that Britain was considering striking the group from its list of banned terrorist groups, the first step toward a direct relationship. Mr. Drevon said France had also made overtures toward the rebels. The New York Times reported on Sunday that the Biden administration is also weighing how much to engage with Damascus.
Those moves were likely to expand the influence of Turkey, which has long maintained ties with Hayat Tahrir al-Sham and openly backs other Syrian rebel factions. It is now emerging as a crucial go-between for the rebels and outside powers.
Turkey’s foreign minister, Hakan Fidan, said in a televised address to diplomats in Ankara on Monday that Turkey was in touch with all parties.
“The new administration must be established in an orderly manner,” he said in remarks on Sunday, outlining principles he said Turkey wanted respected in Syria. “The principle of inclusiveness must never be compromised. There must never be a desire for revenge. It is time to unite and reconstruct the country.”
Mr. Fidan also called on Syria’s new leaders to secure any chemical weapons stores left over from the Assad regime, preserve state institutions and ensure equal treatment for Syrian minorities, including Christians, non-Arabs and Kurds.
Western countries are likely to demand similar conditions in exchange for dropping Hayat Tahrir al-Sham’s terror designation and granting the group the international legitimacy it has long craved, Mr. Drevon said.
Among Arab governments, most of whom regard Islamist groups with extreme wariness and had long ago resigned themselves to working with Mr. al-Assad, the mood appeared even more cautious.
“We’ve seen countries in the region fall in a deep abyss after temporary moments of jubilation,” Tamim Khallaf, a spokesman for Egypt’s foreign ministry, said on Monday. “Egypt will continue to work with regional and international partners to assist Syria during this delicate stage in its history.”
Safak Timur contributed reporting from Istanbul, and Rania Khaled from Cairo.
Fighting still rages in northern Syria as rebel groups vie for territory.
Fighting raged in parts of Syria on Monday, a day after rebels overthrew the Assad regime, as armed groups with competing interests continued to vie for territory and power.
Many of the clashes were centered around Kurdish-controlled areas in northern Syria, where Turkish-backed rebel groups have intensified a military offensive against forces backed by the United States.
As the rebel alliance that toppled President Bashar al-Assad held meetings in the Syrian capital, Damascus, and announced on Monday that it intended to form a transition government, the violence elsewhere highlighted Syria’s complex web of opposition groups, many of them holding different objectives and visions for a post-Assad future.
There were fierce battles in the northern city of Manbij, near Syria’s border with Turkey, which has for years been under the control of the Syrian Democratic Forces, a Kurdish-led coalition of rebel groups supported by the United States. According to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, a war monitoring group based in Britain, the city was captured on Monday by the Syrian National Army, a ragtag coalition of armed opposition groups backed by Turkey. A spokesperson for the Syrian Democratic Forces said fighters with the Syrian National Army had taken only 60 percent of the city. The claims could not be independently verified.
The offensive has been supported by Turkish airstrikes, leaving dozens of combatants dead and forcing many of the city’s hundreds of thousands of residents to flee, according to Kurdish-led forces and the Observatory.
Since the separate rebel assault against the Assad regime gathered pace last month, the Turkish military appears to have ramped up its attacks on areas controlled by the U.S.-backed Kurdish-led forces. Among them, a Turkish drone strike on a house killed 11 civilians, six of them children, the Observatory said on Monday.
Turkey and the United States are allies, sworn to protect each other as members of the NATO alliance. Though both countries celebrated the ouster on Sunday of Mr. al-Assad, their interests diverge over support for the Kurds in northern Syria, and the conflict in Syria has long strained the alliance between Ankara and Washington.
Turkey views the presence of armed Kurds so close to its border as a threat. For years, the Kurdish-led forces in Syria have been important partners for the U.S. in fighting Islamic State, the Islamist terrorist group that swept through the country and neighboring Iraq more than a decade ago amid the chaos of Syria’s civil war.
Although the Islamic State’s so-called caliphate has since been destroyed, the group has reconstituted in recent years in the Syrian desert and has launched sporadic attacks against Syrian regime troops.
The head of the Syrian Democratic Forces, Mazloum Abdi, warned last week of the Islamic State’s resurgence, stating at a news conference that there had been “increased movement” by the group in the desert region.
The warning added to growing fears that the Islamic State could exploit the power vacuum left by the Assad regime’s downfall — a key concern for U.S. leaders.
“We’re cleareyed about the fact that ISIS will try to take advantage of any vacuum to reestablish its capability, to create a safe haven,” President Biden said on Sunday, using an acronym for the terror group.
“We will not let that happen,” he added.
Hours later, Mr. Biden authorized U.S. airstrikes against Islamic State camps and operatives inside Syria. A swarm of B-52, F-15 and A-10 warplanes hit more than 75 targets in central Syria with about 140 munitions, according to U.S. officials.
Eve Sampson contributed reporting.
Crowds throng to a prison outside Damascus, desperate for news of detainees.
Crowds descended on a prison on the outskirts of Damascus, the Syrian capital, on Monday, desperate to learn the fate of friends and relatives detained at a place that symbolized terror and death under the regime of President Bashar al-Assad.
Some hailed taxis or waited for buses from the city to the prison, Sednaya, which opened over the weekend as Mr. al-Assad fell. Others packed into cars, inching through traffic. Many appeared conflicted by hope and dread amid the euphoria that has gripped Damascus since Mr. al-Assad fled to Russia.
“Seizing the city is a joy — we are joyous,” said one rebel fighter, Mohammad Bakir, who sat in the back of a mud-caked car en route to the prison, his rifle tucked between his knees. He said he had not heard from his mother, brother and cousin since they disappeared in 2012 after they protested against the government and were presumably detained.
“But the real victory will be when I find my family,” Mr. Bakir, 42, said above the din of car horns.
Prisons were central to Mr. al-Assad’s ability to crush the civilian uprising that began in 2011 and the rebellion that followed. He set up an industrial-scale system of arbitrary arrests and torture prisons, according to reports by human rights groups.
More than 130,000 people were subjected to arbitrary arrest and detention by the government, according to a report in August by the Syrian Network for Human Rights, a nonprofit, which began its count when the conflict started in 2011. The network said that more than 15,000 people had died “due to torture” by government forces from 2011 to July this year.
The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, a separate organization that is based in Britain and that documents abuses in Syria, has estimated that more than 30,000 detainees were killed in Sednaya alone.
A crucial element of the pall that the prisons cast over the country was secrecy. People were swallowed up by the system, and families often struggled to discover whether their relatives had even been detained, much less to determine their fate. As a result, the opening of the prisons became an imperative for the rebels.
Videos sent to The New York Times by a group of doctors visiting Sednaya appeared to show the dire conditions inside. The footage was shared by the Independent Doctors Association, a group providing humanitarian and medical assistance in Syria.
Numbered cells, each of which appear to have held a dozen or more people, are seen littered with debris, clothing and personal belongings. Journalists, armed fighters and civilians, including children, roam the prison. Several men scrape at the concrete and grates along a wall in an apparent attempt to reach hidden cells.
In the northwestern city of Aleppo, dozens of families gathered at a traffic circle, hoping for the arrival of loved ones who had been detained. The spot was known during the war as the Death Roundabout because it was a regular target of government airstrikes.
Some were certain that their family members were alive and would arrive soon. Others had no information, only hope.
A vehicle dropped off one former prisoner from Sednaya, his face gaunt and his legs and body weakened by years of detention. Two relatives helped him stand. A small band of musicians beat drums to celebrate his survival.
The man was soon thronged by people holding their cellphones up to his face. They were showing him photographs of detainees, hoping he might have news.
Oil markets shrug off the overthrow of Bashar al-Assad’s regime.
Oil markets have shown little reaction to the collapse of the Syrian regime of Bashar al-Assad, as traders most likely calculated that Syria was only a modest producer and that events there did not immediately threaten exports from the wider region.
In trading on Monday, Brent crude oil, the international benchmark, rose about 1 percent, to $71.80 a barrel.
Syria has modest oil reserves, and President-elect Donald J. Trump said during his first presidency that they should be secured, but markets were largely shrugging off the risk that conflict in the Middle East could lead to disruption of supplies. There are about 900 U.S. troops in Syria.
In more than a year since Hamas-led militants stormed into Israel from Gaza, there has been little interruption to flows of oil and natural gas, beyond rerouting tanker traffic to avoid attacks by Houthi fighters in Yemen.
The markets have instead focused on the tepid growth of global demand that can probably be met by new supplies from the United States, Brazil, Canada and other producers not bound by the agreements of the OPEC Plus cartel.
On Thursday, OPEC Plus pushed back plans to increase output to at least the second quarter of next year, the third delay in recent months.
Richard Bronze, head of geopolitics at Energy Aspects, a research firm, said, “There’s still a residual view that the oil market will be oversupplied next year.” He added that traders were worried that Mr. Trump’s policies would push oil prices lower “whether due to higher U.S. production or tariffs disrupting economic activity.”
Mr. Bronze said he thought that those theories would prove incorrect, but “the market will have to see it to believe it.”
Syria is in the neighborhood of large oil producers such as Iraq and Saudi Arabia, but its own production has been sharply curtailed by a decade of civil war.
In 2023, Syria produced 40,000 barrels of oil a day — a trickle relative to major oil producers, according to the Statistical Review of World Energy, published by the Energy Institute, a London-based nonprofit.
In the early 2000s, Syria pumped more than 600,000 barrels a day, comparable to midsize producers like Azerbaijan or Egypt. That performance gives hope that with a stable political environment and improved management, oil sales could be an important source of revenue for a future Syrian government.
Vivian Yee
The military leadership of the rebels who took control of Damascus said in a statement on its Telegram channel that its forces were “about to finish controlling the capital and preserving public property,” and that a new government would begin work “immediately” after being formed. It did not specify who would lead the new government.
‘The Daily’ podcast covers al-Assad’s fall.
The Assad family ruled Syria for more than half a century with repression and violence. But about two weeks ago, the regime began to falter. Then, over the course of one night, it collapsed.
On “The Daily” podcast, Carlotta Gall, a senior correspondent for The New York Times, discusses the fall of President Bashar al-Assad and what comes next.
Syrians displaced by the civil war are rushing to return home.
As rebels swept through towns and cities across Syria on their push to the capital, Damascus, displaced people followed close behind.
Roads and highways where tanks and armored vehicles had driven just a day earlier were packed with bumper-to-bumper traffic on Monday as thousands of Syrians who had been displaced inside their country for years tried to get back home. They drove in cars and trucks piled high with the belongings they had accumulated — mattresses, and bags of clothes and blankets.
“We were like fish out of water when we left,” said Yasmeen Ali Armoosh, 30, speaking this past week from the dilapidated home they have rented for years in the town of Binnish, in northwestern Syria. “We felt suffocated.”
She and her family had withstood years of airstrikes from Syrian and Russian warplanes, she said, and had refused to leave their home in Saraqib, a town in northwestern Syria that became an opposition stronghold soon after the civil war began. But once government forces captured Saraqib in 2020, Ms. Armoosh’s family fled — fearful, she noted, of what living under a brutal dictatorship again could mean.
The 13-year civil war in Syria caused one of the “largest displacement crises in the world,” according to the United Nations. Some 7.2 million Syrians were displaced from their homes inside the country, mostly to rebel-held areas, while more than six million fled and became refugees.
The rebel offensive that ultimately drove President Bashar al-Assad from power on Sunday has prompted an untold number to start making their way back, crowding some border crossings with neighboring countries.
In Binnish, Ms. Armoosh, a teacher, was only around 10 miles from her hometown for around four years, but she said that it felt like living in another country.
On Nov. 29, she was feverishly messaging with dozens of friends about the rebel advance. One friend wrote, “Yasmeen, they liberated Saraqib, you’re finally returning home.”
The day after, as rebels pushed on from Saraqib toward the city of Aleppo, Ms. Armoosh went with her brother and two friends to see what had become of their hometown.
Driving on the road leading to Saraqib was a familiar comfort, she said.
Ms. Armoosh was relieved to find her house is still standing — many homes have been destroyed during the war — but government soldiers had used it as some kind of outpost, she said.
Pro-Assad graffiti was written on the wall, and the floors were littered with bullet casings, she added.
Ms. Armoosh and her family will need to work to make it habitable again, but it is still home.
“A person’s homeland is where their home is, where their friends are,” she said.
Israel claims credit for al-Assad’s ouster, but sees risk in his absence.
For the past year, Israel’s allies and enemies pressed Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to limit his attacks on Iran and its partners in Lebanon and Syria, hoping to avoid a regional escalation.
Mr. Netanyahu forged ahead regardless, intent on weakening the Iran-led axis. Israel’s military bombarded Hezbollah, the Iran-backed Lebanese militia; launched its first open assaults on Iran; and regularly struck Syria, seeking to block the routes by which Iran sent arms to Hezbollah.
Despite the Biden administration’s fears that such attacks might spiral beyond control, those operations strengthened Israel without drawing a sustained response from Iran, leaving many Israelis feeling vindicated.
Hezbollah was left weakened before a cease-fire last month, its leaders mostly assassinated. Iran’s air defenses and missile factories were damaged, limiting its ability to harm Israel. And diplomats believe that Hamas, Iran’s beleaguered ally in Gaza, may soon compromise in cease-fire talks with Israel.
Now, the fall of President Bashar al-Assad of Syria, a longtime ally of Iran, is seen in Israel as the crowning consequence of its yearlong campaign against Iran and its interests, even if it is also tinged with uncertainty about what comes next.
Without Israel’s blows against Hezbollah and Iran, Israeli analysts and leaders say, Syria’s rebels might not have dared revive their rebellion against Mr. al-Assad. And Iran and Hezbollah, which had propped up his regime for a decade, might have been better placed to save him.
Mr. al-Assad’s collapse “is the direct result of our forceful action against Hezbollah and Iran, Assad’s main supporters,” Mr. Netanyahu said as he toured the Golan Heights on Sunday, a territory that Israel captured from Syria in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.
“It set off a chain reaction of all those who want to free themselves from this tyranny and its oppression,” Mr. Netanyahu said.
Still, Israelis are concerned about who will succeed Mr. al-Assad in Syria.
Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, the main opposition alliance, has been fighting Hezbollah and its Iranian allies in Syria for years and is unlikely to allow Iran to continue to use Syria as a thoroughfare for arms deliveries to Lebanon. Abu Mohammed al-Jolani, the leader of Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, said in an address in Damascus on Sunday that the Assad regime had brought many ills upon Syria and had allowed the country to become “a farm for Iranian greed.”
But Hayat Tahrir al-Sham is also a hard-line Islamist group with no love for the Jewish state. Abu Mohammad al-Jolani is a nom de guerre derived from the Arabic word for the Golan Heights.
And the rebels’ main foreign backer, Turkey, has been strongly critical of Israel’s actions in Gaza — leading to unease in Israel about the prospect of a Turkey-backed government controlling one of Israel’s northern borders.
“The collapse of the Assad regime, the tyranny in Damascus, offers great opportunity but also is fraught with significant dangers,” Mr. Netanyahu said on Sunday.
Pre-empting any fallout from Mr. al-Assad’s departure, the Israeli military openly crossed into sovereign Syrian territory over the weekend for the first time since the 1970s, seizing strategic positions close to the border.
Less openly, Israeli fighter jets also struck military infrastructure in Syria that Israel feared might otherwise have fallen into the hands of the rebel forces, according to Israeli officials.
Israel has also been talking with Kurdish rebels that control northeast Syria, Gideon Saar, the Israeli foreign minister, said at a press briefing on Monday.
Mr. Saar declined to give more details, but analysts have said that it was most likely an effort to increase Israel’s influence in postwar Syria. The Kurdish-led forces form a secular alliance, backed by the United States, that played a leading role in the defeat of jihadist groups in Syria over the past decade.
The Kurdish factions also have a fraught relationship with the Islamist factions that led the charge on Damascus last week, and analysts say Israel may see them as a good counterweight to Turkish influence as well as a jihadi resurgence.
But an Israeli alliance with the Kurds is a risky move because it could bring about a clash with Turkey, said Itamar Rabinovich, an Israeli expert on Syria.
For now, Turkey has other matters to deal with “before they mess with us,” said Mr. Rabinovich, a former ambassador who led back-channel talks with Syria in the 1990s.
But if Israel forms a partnership with the Syrian Kurds, whom Turkey sees as a threat, “This would be a way of turning Turkey into a real enemy,” Mr. Rabinovich said. “The profit does not justify the risk.”
More generally, some Israeli analysts see Mr. al-Assad’s downfall as another sign of the failure of Hamas’s effort to undermine Israel over the past year.
Hamas’s attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, was partly intended to upend the status quo in the Middle East in favor of Hamas and its Iran-led alliance.
Instead, Hamas has been hugely damaged by a year of Israeli bombardment and ground operations in Gaza. Its leader Yahya Sinwar is dead, and so is his predecessor Ismail Haniyeh. Hezbollah, which began clashing with Israel in solidarity with Hamas, is now severely weakened. Iran’s regional influence is diminished. And now Mr. al-Assad is gone.
“The mad megalomaniac, Yahya Sinwar, dreamed of changing the map of the Middle East,” Ehud Yaari, an Israeli commentator on Arab affairs, said in a television interview. “He succeeded, but the map of the region is now changing before our very eyes in the very opposite way that he had hoped for.”
Still, other Israeli analysts say that so long as Hamas still survives in Gaza, holding roughly 100 hostages, it is premature to celebrate.
“Hamas still controls Gaza, it still has cells in the West Bank, it holds 100 hostages,” Seth Frantzman, an Israeli security analyst, wrote in a social media post. “While Iran’s axis may be weaker, the larger threat to Israel still comes from Hamas in many ways in the long term.”
And it is unclear how Iran will respond to its loss of influence, with some in Israel warning that it may now rush to build a nuclear weapon in order to project strength.
“Iran is more dangerous now,” said Benny Gantz, Israel’s former defense minister, in comments distributed by his spokesman. “A nuclear breakout in response to these developments is a realistic option.”
Aaron Boxerman contributed reporting.
In the Golan Heights, events in Syria bring relief and uncertainty.
As rebels were claiming power in Syria on Sunday evening, long convoys of Israeli military trucks traveled slowly along the roads of the Israeli-controlled Golan Heights, followed by military and civilian ambulances making their way north. The Israeli military was openly crossing into Syrian-held territory for the first time in half a century, seeking to contain any threats to Israel that the collapse of the Syrian regime might bring.
Once held by Syria, the Golan Heights, a fertile plateau of less than 500 square miles, was seized by Israel during the Six-Day War of 1967 and annexed in 1981, a move that remains unrecognized by most countries and by the United Nations. Thousands of Syrians fled north; Israel offered citizenship to the primarily Druse residents who remained, but most refused it.
This past summer, the Golan Heights was in the spotlight when a rocket launched from Lebanon struck a soccer field in Majdal Shams, a picturesque Druse Arab village, killing 12 children and injuring dozens more. The following day, the entire town, where it seems everybody knows everybody, wore black.
On Sunday, at a military outpost near Mount Hermon — which straddles the borders of Israel, Syria and Lebanon and was the scene of fierce fighting between Israel and Syria in 1974 — old tanks, now used for practice, were parked on muddy roads with their barrels pointed east toward Syria.
Tucked away behind the dirt roads stood an old pyramid-like structure made of volcanic rocks, now held together with metal wires. Israeli soldiers were patrolling the area, carrying out some general monitoring tasks and trying to keep warm.
Mahmoud Abu-Shaheen, 39, a grocery store owner from the Druse village of Buka’ata, in the north of the Golan Heights, stopped his car along a road outside the old structure, which overlooks the buffer zone between Israel and Syria. He said he was “curious and hopeful” about the current situation, which, he added, was “not surprising to me.”
“I drove out here to get a close sense of the fighting,” he said, as powerful explosions were heard in the distance and the sound of jet engines pierced a foggy sky.
“I have relatives in Suwayda, in Syria,” Mr. Abu-Shaheen continued. “We have been in touch all of these years and they told us that over this past year the situation became very difficult for them. They have no work and no regular income. They have been telling us how only the people who are close to Assad’s regime were able to make money, but this is not clean money.”
Like others in the Golan Heights and elsewhere, Mr. Abu-Shaheen is uncertain of how the near future will play out. He said he doesn’t know what role Israel might play, given its “active front in Gaza. At least Hezbollah is now weak.”
But, he said, “I hope Israel can make peace with Syria, and solve the status of the Golan Heights. But we can at least return to the days when Israel used to sell our apples to our Syrian neighbors.”
Dafna Meir, 47, a tour guide from Moshav Alonei Habashan, an Israeli settlement in the eastern Golan Heights, echoed Mr. Abu-Shaheen’s expressions of hope mixed with uncertainty and trepidation.
“This has been a difficult year, with endless explosions, fires, sirens and tension in the air,” she said, speaking by phone. “And when the cease-fire was announced we were so relieved, thinking to ourselves that this terrible year was finally over and that life here could finally return to normal,” she said, referring to the cease-fire that took effect between Israel and Hezbollah in Lebanon late last month.
“We are now again in a state of uncertainty, unsure where this is all going,” Ms. Meir added, citing the proximity to the Syrian border and “the danger of a security escalation, with errant fire crossing over the border.”
“This is such a beautiful area, all I want is for the nature to recover and for the beauty to return,” she said.
Hours later, Israeli forces took control of the mountain summit of Mount Hermon on the Syrian side of the border.
Safak Timur
Reporting from Istanbul
Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan of Turkey said in a televised address to Turkish diplomats that “a new period” had started in Syria. “Turkey, which extended a hand to its Syrian brothers in their tough days, will continue to be with them in this new stage in Damascus,” he said. “We desire a Syria where different ethnic and religious groups live in peace, under an inclusive understanding of governance.”
Dmitri S. Peskov, a Kremlin spokesman, said Moscow was not going to disclose the location of Bashar al-Assad, who was flown to Russia over the weekend. Peskov told Russian news agencies that it was President Vladimir Putin’s personal decision to offer shelter to al-Assad and his family, but that there were no immediate plans for the two to meet.
Christina Goldbaum
Reporting from Damascus, Syria
Hundreds of people in Damascus whose friends and relatives had disappeared into al-Assad’s torture prisons are rushing to get to the notorious Sednaya prison on the city’s outskirts, hoping to find missing relatives. One rebel, Mohammad Bakir, 41, sat in the back of a mud-caked car, his rifle tucked between his knees. His mother, brother and cousin all disappeared in 2012 after protesting against the regime, he said, and he had not heard from them since.
“We are joyous,” Bakir said, shouting over car horns. “But the real victory will be when I find my family.”
Christina Goldbaum
Reporting from Damascus, Syria
A day after seizing Damascus, the rebels appear to be trying to restore a sense of order to the city. Groups dressed in mismatched camouflage and with rifles slung over their shoulders are stationed outside government buildings and banks, a day after throngs set fire to some government offices and looted al-Assad’s former residence. Plainclothes fighters carrying rifles were directing traffic at major intersections.
The Syrian Embassy in Russia has raised the rebels’ flag — green, white and black — over its mansion in central Moscow. The Russian news agency Tass published footage of men hoisting the flag on Monday morning.
Aaron Boxerman
Reporting from Jerusalem
In recent days, Israel has conducted strikes against Syrian chemical weapons sites, as well as caches of long-range missiles and rockets, Foreign Minister Gideon Saar told reporters in Jerusalem. The Israeli government had feared that some of the Syrian government’s weapons would fall “into the hands of extremists” after the fall of al-Assad, Saar said.
Journalists from the Times enter Damascus a day after the collapse of the government.
We arrived in Damascus early Monday, after passing surreal scenes on the highway leading into the city from Lebanon. Scattered across the main highway to the Syrian capital are newfound relics of the government of Bashar al-Assad whose oppressive rule has defined the country for decades.
Less than a day after rebels took Damascus in a lightning fast offensive, abandoned Syrian military tanks littered the road. A handful of posters of Mr. al-Assad remained intact on billboards over the highway, but most had been torn down and ripped to shreds.
Checkpoints typically manned by Syrian intelligence and security forces, who would question drivers and passengers for hours on end, were empty. A few miles from the border, a body of a man in military uniform lay sprawled on the ground next to an abandoned pickup truck.
Down the road from one Syrian military base, a convoy of 10 rebel vehicles sped down the highway. They drove four-wheel drive vehicles — their doors and windows caked in mud as makeshift camouflage — and Syrian military vehicles armed with rockets that once belonged to the al-Assad government.
There were also signs of the lawlessness that many fear could seize the country, the celebration over the fall of Mr. al-Assad mixed with the uncertainty of what comes next.
A duty free shop just across the border from Lebanon appeared to have been broken into — its storefront windows smashed while bottles, chocolates and bags of snacks were strewn across its floor. Windshields and windows of dozens of abandoned cars along the roads were broken and their doors flung open.
Two young men fiddled with the wires beneath one abandoned truck, in apparent attempt to jump start the vehicle.
Nearby, one young man stood in front of an abandoned tank taking a selfie. He then picked up his toddler, placed him on top of the tank and told him to hold his fingers up in a V for victory before taking a photo.
In Old Damascus, the centuries-old city center of winding, narrow alleys, Victor Dawli, 59, stood in his apartment’s entryway, a cigarette in hand. As a truck carrying Syrian rebels passed, Mr. Dawli waved. One fighter, clutching his rifle and hunched over in the bed of the truck, nodded in response.
Mr. Dawli’s neighborhood, Babsharqi, is home to mostly Christians, many of who supported the Assad government and now fear they could face retribution from rebels and others who were part of the uprising.
As dawn broke on the second day of life in Syria without Mr. Assad, there was a sense of unease in the neighborhood, as people here walked a tightrope. Some have kept their heads down and stayed inside their homes. Others like Mr. Dawli say they have secretly supported the rebels from the start of their offensive.
When one neighbor passed by, Mr. Dawli shouted to him: “Good morning, congratulations!” The man gave him a blank stare, then hurried down a nearby alleyway.
“There are people who are scared, you tell them congratulations and they feel uneasy,” he said.
Revolutions Swept the Middle East in 2011. Will Syria’s End Differently?
When protesters started trying in 2011 to overthrow President Bashar al-Assad of Syria, they were part of a cascade of revolutions, known as the Arab Spring, that aimed to oust authoritarian leaders across the Middle East.
While opposition groups elsewhere experienced swift success, the Syrian revolution devolved into a 13-year civil war that has killed hundreds of thousands, displaced millions and carved the country into competing fiefs.
Mr. al-Assad’s stunning fall finally allows Syrians to feel the joy that their counterparts experienced more than a decade ago in Egypt, Libya, Tunisia and Yemen — the four Arab countries where dictators were toppled far more quickly.
Yet while those four states provided a template for revolutionary success, their trajectories since the Arab Spring also constitute a warning.
In Egypt and Tunisia, new strongmen eventually rose to power, crushing efforts to build pluralist democracies. In Libya and Yemen, rival militias jockeyed for control, leading to civil war and the partition of both countries.
“The people who have survived the last 13 years deserve to enjoy the moment before they worry about the future,” said Alistair Burt, a former minister in the British government who helped spearhead its Mideast policy during the Arab Spring.
“At the same time, we all know the experience of the region since 2011,” Mr. Burt said. “We want to hope for the best but we prepare for something worse.”
The dynamics in Syria make for a particularly fraught transition of power. The Islamist rebel alliance that led the rapid advance on Damascus, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, is one of several rival opposition groups that must now agree on how to run Syria in the post-Assad era.
While Hayat Tahrir al-Sham is now the most influential group in Syria, it is competing for influence with another Turkey-backed group based in northern Syria, as well as a secular Kurdish-led alliance in eastern Syria that is supported by the United States. And southern Syria is dominated by local rebel groups, including militias led by the Druse minority, an offshoot of Islam.
-
Map: Where Rebels Have Advanced in Syria
-
Israel’s Military Says Hostages Were Likely Killed by Hamas as Airstrike Hit
-
Shalom Nagar Dies; Reluctant Executioner of Adolf Eichmann
Once affiliated with Al Qaeda, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham has tried to present itself as a moderate movement that seeks to preserve the rights of Syria’s many minorities, including its Christians, Druse and Alawites, the Shiite sect that formed Mr. al-Assad’s base.
Unless the group, which the United States has designated as a terrorist organization, makes good on that promise, analysts say, it could end up prolonging the civil war: Militias from different minorities may feel obliged to defend their areas from the new central government.
“You can’t tell people that they’re safe: They have to believe it,” said Mr. Burt. “That’s why the conduct of H.T.S. — and all those with guns at the moment in the liberated cities — is so important.”
Foreign powers like Iran, Turkey, Russia and the United States, which support different sides in the conflict, are expected to push to retain influence in the new era, potentially prolonging Syria’s internal disputes.
The role and intentions of Mr. al-Assad’s former generals and security chiefs also remain unclear. They could yet prove decisive in any new power play, as their counterparts did in the countries where leaders were toppled in 2011-12.
After the fall of Hosni Mubarak in Egypt in 2011, the military leadership still controlled the pace of the political transition. After allowing elections, the military later took back power in a popular coup in 2013, ousting Mohamed Morsi, Egypt’s first freely elected president. Mr. Morsi, an Islamist, had himself angered many Egyptians through heavy-handed governance, leading some to lose faith in the democratic process.
Elections were also held in Libya after the ouster of Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi in 2011, but the country has been partitioned since civil war broke out three years later.
In Yemen, the departure of Ali Abdullah Saleh in 2012 was also followed by a civil war, which allowed the Houthis, an Iran-backed movement, to seize the capital.
For years, Tunisia was the most successful of the Arab Spring countries, holding several elections after the downfall of Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali. But Tunisia returned to a form of one-man rule in 2021, when President Kais Saied removed checks on his power and began to restrict the media, weaken the judiciary and exert greater control over the electoral authorities.
Given the complexity of Syria’s internal dynamics, some think that Mr. al-Assad’s departure is more likely to widen the rifts left by the country’s 13-year war, rather than heal them.
But other analysts say that it is precisely because of their wartime experience that Syrians may be able to achieve what their counterparts in Egypt and elsewhere could not.
A side effect of suffering for so many years is that Syrians have had far longer to prepare for this moment and consider how to navigate a post-Assad transition, according to Sanam Vakil, head of the Middle East and North Africa program at Chatham House, a London-based research institute.
That is “what distinguishes this moment for Syria,” she said. “There’s also been a lot of learning, there’s been mobilizing, there’s been activism.”
For now, though, many Syrians say they want to enjoy the euphoria of Mr. al-Assad’s departure.
Mr. al-Assad oversaw a cruel government that threw hundreds of thousands of opponents into dirty, overcrowded prisons, where thousands were tortured and killed. Mr. al-Assad’s forces dropped thousands of barrel bombs on his own citizens and gassed some of them with chemical weapons.
His refusal to relinquish power in 2011 led to a bloody civil war that displaced millions of people, destroyed much of the country and led to the rise of terrorist groups like ISIS.
“No matter what comes next, it won’t be worse than Bashar al-Assad’s regime,” said Hashem Alsouki, a Syrian former civil servant detained and tortured early in the war who later sought safety with his family in Europe.
“Yes, there is concern for the future,” Mr. Alsouki added in a telephone interview. “At the same time, I have faith that we will overcome this stage. Because the Syrian people have learned a lot in these 13 years.”
Massacre in Haiti’s Capital Leaves Nearly 200 Dead, U.N. Says
More than 180 people were killed in a massacre over the weekend in one of the poorest neighborhood’s of Haiti’s capital, the United Nation’s human rights chief said on Monday.
A leading Haitian human rights group described the killings as the personal vendetta of a gang boss who had been told that witchcraft caused his son’s fatal illness.
The slaughter began on Friday in the Wharf Jeremie section of Cité Soleil, a sprawling slum in Port-au-Prince, according to the National Human Rights Defense Network, a civil rights group based in the capital.
Older people who practiced voodoo appeared to have been targeted, according to the group. That assessment was backed by another rights organization and a Cité Soleil resident.
The U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights, Volker Turk, told reporters in Geneva that at least 184 people had been killed.
Nearly 130 of those who were killed were over 60 years old, according to the U.N., adding that gang members burned bodies and flung them into the sea.
The brutality of the killings reflect a country enduring an “accelerating spiral into the abyss,” said William O’Neill, the U.N.’s human rights expert for Haiti.
-
Catch up on the biggest news, and wind down to end your day.
-
Stories handpicked by our editors, just for you.
-
Make sense of the news, every day, with David Leonhardt.
Haiti has been convulsed by violence since early this year, when rival gangs banded together in an attack on government institutions, including police stations, prisons and hospitals.
The National Human Rights Defense Network said that one of the gang leaders, Monel Felix, ordered the killings in Wharf Jeremie after being told by a priest that voodoo was responsible for his son’s illness. The child died on Saturday afternoon, according to the widely respected rights group.
The group said that Mr. Felix, who is also known as Micanor Altes and by the nickname King Micanor, and his gang affiliates used machetes and knives to commit the massacre, according to the rights organization. The group did not say how it had obtained its information.
A resident of Cité Soleil, who asked to remain anonymous for fear of retribution, said the killings began on Friday night and targeted people who practice voodoo. In some homes, five or six people were killed, the resident said.
The Committee for Peace and Development, another Haitian civil organization, said the dead included some younger people, including several motorcycle-taxi drivers who were gunned down while trying to save others.
“Mutilated bodies were burned in the streets,’’ according to a statement by the National Human Rights Defense Network.
Mr. Felix could not be reached for comment, and there was no evidence that he had made any kind of public statement about the killings.
Wharf Jeremie is one of the most impenetrable gang strongholds in the capital, and the police generally do not go there. The lack of a law enforcement presence delayed the reporting of the massacre, experts who were following the developments said.
Voodoo, which originated in West Africa, is one of Haiti’s official religions. Its practitioners believe that all living things have spirits, including animals and plants. Brought to Haiti by slaves, voodoo, which is largely misunderstood in Western popular culture, coexists with Christianity as one of several recognized faiths.
The National Human Rights Defense Network said it was not the first time that Mr. Felix had been accused of killing older people who practice voodoo. He is believed to have been responsible for the killings in 2021 of 12 elderly female practitioners, the rights group said.
About 5,000 people in Haiti have been killed this year and more than 700,000 displaced as a result of gang-related violence, according to the United Nations. In the spring, the gangs succeeded in forcing out a prime minister.
A separate gang massacre two months ago in a farming town about 60 miles north of Port-au-Prince left roughly 80 civilians dead.
The bloodshed has continued despite the presence of a U.N.-backed police force, known as the Multinational Security Support Mission, which is composed largely of officers from Kenya.
Last month was a particularly deadly one in Haiti. Three U.S. airliners were struck by gunfire while taking off or landing from Haiti’s main airport in Port-au-Prince. The airport is still closed, and American Airlines decided it would not return to the country at least through next year, The Miami Herald reported.
With violence in Haiti surging, the United States has asked the United Nations to take over the security mission and turn it into an official peacekeeping operation. The change would allow for a steady supply of funding, personnel and equipment. Russia and China, which have veto power at the U.N. Security Council, have objected to the proposal.
The security mission recently announced that it had expanded its operations, opening a new base that will enable international police officers to work in more locations. The mission said it was committed to safeguarding critical infrastructure, reopening key national roads and creating a secure environment for national elections.
“We wish to call on gang leaders to surrender their weapons and turn themselves in, as their time is running out,” the mission said in a statement last week.
A spokesman for the mission said he was not aware of the killings in Wharf Jeremie. A spokesman for the Haitian National Police did not respond to requests for comment.
David C. Adams and André Paultre contributed reporting.
He Was Shot in the Face. Now Ukraine Wants to Draft Him.
Early in Russia’s war against Ukraine, Mykola Kulichenko endured an ordeal. He was abducted as a civilian, survived a Russian execution attempt by a stroke of luck and then climbed out of his own grave by pushing through the dirt heaped above him.
His brothers died beside him, but Mr. Kulichenko had turned his head at the last moment and a bullet passed through his cheek, leaving a hole but not causing life-threatening wounds.
His case elicited widespread shock and sympathy in Ukraine — but it did not shield him from Ukraine’s mobilization system. He received a draft summons in October.
Mr. Kulichenko has used his second lease on life to care for his elderly father and return to raising ducks and chickens on a farm in northern Ukraine. But he said he still has trouble sleeping, as he flashes back to being shot and buried alive then finding his way home with his body covered in bruises and his cheek bleeding and tremendously swollen.
Given the trauma of his ordeal, he doesn’t think he should be drafted into the army. “It was very hard to climb out of my grave,” he said.
“What would it change if I go” to the trenches now, he said, claiming that his presence would have no impact on the fighting. “I would take my life to the front and leave it there, for nothing.”
The summons of Mr. Kulichenko, who is 35, underscores the unpredictable and lopsided mobilization system in Ukraine that leans heavily on recruiting older men.
The policies have drawn criticism from the Biden administration, which has said Ukraine should expand its draft to younger men aged 18 to 25, who are now exempt, to defend hundreds of miles of front line. The need for soldiers is now more acute than the need for weapons, American officials have said.
Ukrainian officials say they cannot draft men in their late teens and early 20s without risking demographic shortfalls in the future, and they have pushed back against the American criticism.
-
Get expert analysis of the news and a guide to the big ideas shaping the world every weekday morning.
-
A round-up of the best stories personalized to you.
-
Make sense of the news, every day, with David Leonhardt.
“Ukraine cannot be expected to compensate for delays in logistics or hesitation in support with the youth of our men,” Dmytro Lytvyn, a communications adviser to the president, wrote recently in a post on X. It was another swipe at the pace of Western weapons support, which Ukraine views as tepid and overly cautious.
Mr. Kulichenko’s experience also points to the difficulty Ukraine has had in calibrating the rules governing draft exemptions. He became eligible for recruitment after rule changes last spring eliminated some exemptions for hardship, including for those caring for ailing relatives.
Like a game of Whac-a-Mole, each change knocks out some who enjoyed exemptions while adding others who had not — with civilians left to argue over which hardship was more deserving.
The changes to the law were intended to crack down on draft dodgers who abused the mobilization system by claiming hardship when little actually existed, a practice abetted by corruption in the draft operation.
With the loopholes supposedly plugged, recruitment officials stepped up the draft through the summer. Ukraine does not disclose figures, but military analysts have said an initially promising flow of recruits for the army has since tapered off. Fewer men are entering basic training, and many of them are old or in poor health, military commanders say.
Ukraine plans to draft an additional 160,000 men in the “near future,” the secretary of the National Security and Defense Council, Oleksandr Lytvynenko told Parliament late last month. This number would restore units to 85 percent of their full strength, he said.
But reaching deeper into the pool of older men risks filling the ranks with less motivated and healthy soldiers. Even now, none of the brigades in combat are fully staffed, said Maj. Maksym Zhorin, a commander in the 3rd Assault Brigade. Of the new soldiers turning up, he said, “the quality of personnel has significantly deteriorated recently.”
Ukraine, meanwhile, is falling back at two locations on the front inside the country, in the eastern Donbas region and near the town of Kupiansk in northeastern Ukraine, and it has lost about half of the territory captured in an incursion into the Kursk region of Russia in August.
“We are truly on the verge of a military catastrophe,” Yevhen Dykyi, a military veteran and commentator on the war for Ukrainian media, told radio NV. It is not because of mistakes by the army, he said, but because of the failure to draft enough soldiers.
But aggressive mobilization efforts, mostly aimed at older men in rural areas, have led to a backlash in society. Women have blocked roads to prevent recruitment officials from searching for draft dodgers in some western Ukrainian villages.
Men have slipped across the borders to Europe to avoid the draft, sometimes swimming across rivers. Others simply remain at home, lest they get picked up at a checkpoint or other location.
Parliament has been considering a partial swing of the pendulum back — introducing several overhauls to reduce draft evasion and desertion by restoring exemptions and granting draftees more choice in how they serve. Men are now sometimes allowed to choose or change the units in which they serve, for example.
An amendment passed in Parliament in a first reading on Nov. 20 would grant deferments to civilians whom the Russians had arrested earlier in the war and to those who lost close relatives in the fighting.
If signed into law, Mr. Kulichenko could qualify on both points, though under current rules he is still eligible for the draft.
The issue of whether war injuries should merit an exemption from future service has been a divisive one in Ukraine. Men have returned to serve after suffering more grievous injuries than Mr. Kulichenko. Some have voluntarily returned to service even after their legs or arms were amputated. Such dedication is praised by Ukrainians who view their lives and homes depending on holding back Russian soldiers.
Russians arrested Mr. Kulichenko and his two brothers in March 2022 in their hometown, Dovzhyk, north of Kyiv. The dynamic in the war was the opposite of today — the Russians were retreating from northern Ukraine. The brothers were suspected of planting or helping to plant a roadside bomb that killed several Russian officers, Mr. Kulichenko said. He denied any role in the incident.
The brothers were held for three days in an abandoned sawmill where they were interrogated and severely beaten. With the Ukrainian Army approaching, Mr. Kulichenko said, the Russians decided to shoot the brothers to eliminate evidence of the torture. His ordeal was reported at the time by The Wall Street Journal and later taken up in a war crimes prosecution in Ukraine, in which Russian soldiers were tried in absentia.
Russians loaded the brothers in a truck, drove them into the forest, lined them up beside the grave and opened fire. A bullet passed through Mr. Kulichenko’s cheek and he fell to the ground. He lay still as the soldiers piled on dirt, then clambered out after they left.
The draft summons arrived in October. He said he understands the army “lacks people and that is why they take everyone.”
He has not responded to the letter by appearing at a draft board, and said he does not intend to. He does not want to fight in the war, given what happened to him, he said.
“I didn’t get over it,” he said.
Oleksandra Mykolyshyn contributed reporting.
Road to Damascus Littered With Relics of Fallen Assad Government
Reporters for The New York Times entered Syria on Monday, finding remnants of former President Bashar al-Assad’s oppressive rule.
Christina Goldbaum and Hwaida Saad
Daniel Berehulak
The journalists traveled to Damascus, Syria from Lebanon.
We arrived in Damascus early Monday, after passing surreal scenes on the highway leading into the city from Lebanon. Scattered across the main highway to the Syrian capital are newfound relics of the government of Bashar al-Assad whose oppressive rule has defined the country for decades.
Less than a day after rebels took Damascus in a lightning fast offensive, abandoned Syrian military tanks littered the road. A handful of posters of Mr. al-Assad remained intact on billboards over the highway, but most had been torn down and ripped to shreds.
Checkpoints typically manned by Syrian intelligence and security forces, who would question drivers and passengers for hours on end, were empty. A few miles from the border, a body of a man in military uniform lay sprawled on the ground next to an abandoned pickup truck.
Down the road from one Syrian military base, a convoy of 10 rebel vehicles sped down the highway. They drove four-wheel drive vehicles — their doors and windows caked in mud as makeshift camouflage — and Syrian military vehicles armed with rockets that once belonged to the al-Assad government.
There were also signs of the lawlessness that many fear could seize the country, the celebration over the fall of Mr. al-Assad mixed with the uncertainty of what comes next.
A duty free shop just across the border from Lebanon appeared to have been broken into — its storefront windows smashed while bottles, chocolates and bags of snacks were strewn across its floor. Windshields and windows of dozens of abandoned cars along the roads were broken and their doors flung open.
Two young men fiddled with the wires beneath one abandoned truck, in apparent attempt to jump start the vehicle.
Nearby, one young man stood in front of an abandoned tank taking a selfie. He then picked up his toddler, placed him on top of the tank and told him to hold his fingers up in a V for victory before taking a photo.
In Old Damascus, the centuries-old city center of winding, narrow alleys, Victor Dawli, 59, stood in his apartment’s entryway, a cigarette in hand. As a truck carrying Syrian rebels passed, Mr. Dawli waved. One fighter, clutching his rifle and hunched over in the bed of the truck, nodded in response.
Mr. Dawli’s neighborhood, Babsharqi, is home to mostly Christians, many of who supported the Assad government and now fear they could face retribution from rebels and others who were part of the uprising.
As dawn broke on the second day of life in Syria without Mr. Assad, there was a sense of unease in the neighborhood, as people here walked a tightrope. Some have kept their heads down and stayed inside their homes. Others like Mr. Dawli say they have secretly supported the rebels from the start of their offensive.
When one neighbor passed by, Mr. Dawli shouted to him: “Good morning, congratulations!” The man gave him a blank stare, then hurried down a nearby alleyway.
“There are people who are scared, you tell them congratulations and they feel uneasy,” he said.
South Korea’s political dysfunction deepened Monday as its Ministry of Justice barred President Yoon Suk Yeol from leaving the country while officials investigate whether his brief declaration of martial law last week amounted to leading an insurrection.
Oh Dong-woon, the chief prosecutor who heads the office for investigating high-ranking officials, told lawmakers that he had sought the travel ban as the office carries out search-and-seizure operations targeting officials who were involved in the martial law order.
No sitting president has ever been arrested in South Korea, and the order adds to the spiraling fallout of Mr. Yoon’s extraordinary move last Tuesday. Since his short-lived martial law declaration, the country has been thrust into a leadership vacuum, and widespread protests have called for his removal.
The justice ministry’s quick acceptance of Mr. Oh’s request shows how Mr. Yoon’s grip on his own government is coming unglued. Mr. Yoon, a former prosecutor, has gone to extraordinary lengths to keep the prosecutors and the justice ministry on his side as a key governing tool, appointing loyalists to key posts there. Home Minister Lee Sang-min, another staunch Yoon ally who controlled the police, stepped down on Sunday.
But the ban also suggested that the investigators considered the allegations of insurrection against Mr. Yoon serious enough to bar the head of state from leaving the country. Mr. Yoon did not immediately notify the National Assembly of his declaration of martial law, as required by law. Even during martial law, the president has no right to detain lawmakers unless they are caught in the act of a crime — a legal provision law scholars say Mr. Yoon violated when he sent troops into the Assembly to physically remove legislators.
The president can be arrested or indicted while in office if he commits insurrection or treason. Legal scholars were divided over whether Mr. Yoon could continue to run the government as president if he were arrested. Some say that his arrest would mean that he was unable to perform his duties and that the prime minister would step in as an interim president until Mr. Yoon’s fate is decided through trial or impeachment. But others say that unless he was convicted and removed from office through impeachment or resignation, he is still the president and could try to act as one, even from prison.
Opposition lawmakers have accused Mr. Yoon and officials including his former defense minister, Kim Yong-hyun, of staging an insurrection when they sent armed soldiers into the National Assembly in an effort to seize the legislative body after the declaration of martial law. If convicted, the leader of an insurrection would face the death penalty or life imprisonment.
An attempt on Saturday by opposition lawmakers to impeach Mr. Yoon failed after the president’s party boycotted the vote, prolonging the uncertainty over who was at the nation’s helm. South Korea’s defense ministry said Monday in a regularly scheduled briefing that command over the country’s military remained with the president.
South Koreans are unsure who is governing the country with Mr. Yoon largely absent from view. Han Dong-hoon, the chairman of Mr. Yoon’s governing People Power Party, said over the weekend that the president had been excluded from performing his duties. Han Duck-soo, the prime minister, said the cabinet, in consultation with the ruling party, would keep the country running.
Opposition groups have said that the party chairman had no legal basis to exclude Mr. Yoon and accused him of making his own grab for power.
The constitutional crisis is unfolding as South Korea faces a raft of policy challenges abroad and at home, and has raised questions over the health of the country’s democracy. The repercussions spread to financial markets on Monday. South Korea’s currency lost value, and the country’s benchmark stock index tumbled 2.8 percent, a steep drop that added to deeper concerns about the country’s economy.
The justice ministry’s travel ban order came as dissension has emerged in the ranks of the military that stormed the legislature during the few hours of martial law command.
Col. Kim Hyun-tae, who led a special forces unit that was sent into the National Assembly, held a news conference on Monday and told reporters that his troops were victims exploited by the defense minister.
Colonel Kim said he received orders to forcibly remove lawmakers from the Assembly chamber. His commanders appeared to be relaying orders from the defense minister, who said the troops needed to prevent 150 lawmakers — the threshold required to repeal martial law — from gathering in the Assembly, he said.
Mr. Kim, the former defense minister, was taken into custody on Sunday for questioning by prosecutors. He is also barred from leaving the country.
After the martial law declaration, Mr. Yoon’s approval rating dropped by nearly eight points to 17 percent, its lowest level during his term, according a survey released on Monday by Realmeter, a South Korean polling company. His party, which boycotted the impeachment vote, also took a hit, its approval rating dropping by six points to 26.2 percent.