Here’s the latest on the hostage and prisoner exchange.
Israel on Thursday released more than 100 Palestinian prisoners — including some convicted of deadly attacks against Israelis — in exchange for hostages held in Gaza after a chaotic Hamas-led hostage handover in Gaza cast doubt on whether it would go ahead.
Hamas released a total of eight Israeli and Thai hostages after a year in captivity, including one in a tightly choreographed ceremony in northern Gaza that went relatively smoothly. But in the southern Gaza city of Khan Younis, the handover devolved into tumult, with the hostages surrounded by crowds of people, including some chanting support for Hamas or other armed groups.
The office of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel said after that tumult that he had suspended the prisoners’ release until cease-fire mediators — which included Qatar, Egypt and the United States — secured guarantees from Hamas of “the safe exit of our hostages in the next rounds.”
The government later said that mediators had guaranteed the hostages safe passage in future releases. Not long after, buses carrying 110 Palestinian prisoners were seen leaving the Ofer prison in the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
The Palestinian prisoners were being freed as part of the third hostage-for-prisoner swap in the ongoing cease-fire deal between Israel and Hamas. During the first 42 days of the agreement, Hamas pledged to free at least 33 hostages in exchange for over 1,500 Palestinians jailed by Israel.
On Thursday, large numbers of Palestinians gathered before the hostage release in Khan Younis near the home of Yahya Sinwar, Hamas’s leader in Gaza who was killed by Israel in October. A small white van surrounded by armed gunmen slowly pushed its way through yelling crowds of people seeking any glimpse of the captives.
The militants later carved a path through the surging crowd as many pushed their way to the front with cameras. Photos and video showed hostages walking through the chaotic crowd. In one video, Arbel Yehud, 29, one of the last living female hostages, at times appeared afraid while surrounded by rifle-wielding militants from Hamas and Islamic Jihad as they made their way toward the Red Cross convoy that would take her to Israeli soldiers.
Under the terms of the cease-fire, Israel is to release 110 Palestinian prisoners on Thursday, including 32 serving life sentences for deadly attacks against Israelis. One of them is Zakaria Zubeidi, who was a prominent militant in the north of the Israeli-occupied West Bank during the second intifada. He joined a 2021 prison break before being arrested again.
Here’s what else to know:
-
A closer look: The three released Israeli hostages include a young Israeli army lookout, an 80-year-old farming expert and a woman who worked as a guide at a space and technology center.
-
Thai hostages: The Thai hostages were abducted during the Hamas-led attack in 2023 from four farms close to the Gaza border, where they were agricultural workers. Dozens of Thai farmworkers were kidnapped or killed during the assault, making them the second-largest group of victims in the Oct. 7 attack, after Israelis.
-
Exiled prisoners: About 20 of the Palestinian prisoners are set to be expelled abroad and will not be allowed to return to their homes in the West Bank or Jerusalem, according to the Hamas-linked prisoners’ office. Expelled prisoners can head to the Gaza Strip or leave for Egypt, where discussions over their final destination are ongoing, according to the Palestinian commissioner for prisoners’ affairs.
Palestinians gather in the West Bank to welcome prisoners released by Israel.
Samar Faisal stood among a crowd in the crisp winter air, shivering as much from her excitement as the cold. She was in disbelief, she said, that this day had come. Her brother, after spending more than 20 years in an Israeli prison, was being released.
“I’m anxious and praying for the moment I finally see him,” Ms. Faisal said, as volunteers in fluorescent vests hurried by. Her brother had been jailed for fighting in the armed wing of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which the United States and European Union designate a terrorist group.
Ms. Faisal was among a throng of Palestinian families gathered in the West Bank city of Ramallah on Thursday, eagerly waiting to welcome more than 100 Palestinian prisoners being released from Israel in exchange for hostages held in Gaza. It was the third hostage-for-prisoner swap in an ongoing cease-fire deal between Israel and Hamas. During the first 42 days of the agreement, Hamas has pledged to free at least 33 hostages in exchange for over 1,500 Palestinians jailed by Israel.
Standing outside a government recreation center, people restlessly checked their phones for news or fielded calls from loved ones who were anxious for updates.
Finally, around 7 p.m., a chain of buses arrived carrying dozens of Palestinian prisoners, including some who had been convicted of deadly attacks against Israelis. Sixty-seven prisoners arrived in Ramallah on Thursday, including 27 children, officials said. Another 14 arrived in Jerusalem and nine in Gaza, while 20 were sent to Egypt.
Earlier in the day, Hamas had released eight Israeli and Thai hostages held in Gaza.
For some waiting outside the recreation center, their anticipation was tempered by sorrow.
Alaa Zubeidi waited with her sisters and friends, all dressed in the black clothes of mourning in memory of her eldest son, Mohammad, who was killed by an Israeli drone strike in the West Bank city of Tubas in September.
She was awaiting the release of her husband, Zakariya Zubeidi, a former militant turned theater director whom Israeli forces arrested in 2019. He became well known in both Israel and the Palestinian territories in 2019 for briefly escaping an Israeli prison.
The Zubeidi family was removed from their home in Jenin by Israeli forces after Mohammad’s death, and Ms. Zubeidi and two of her other children, Samira and Ayham, were arrested and detained for several hours. Since then, she said, operations by Palestinian security forces had left them unable to return to their home.
But those concerns were eclipsed by joy after Mr. Zubeidi’s release on Thursday, when people in the crowd hoisted him onto their shoulders and chanted his name.
Beaming, Mr. Zubeidi flashed the victory sign with both hands.
“May God protect Jenin camp at this time,” he told the crowd. “Today is a public referendum in favor of the fighters.”
Muhammad Deif, Hamas Military Commander in Gaza, Is Dead
Muhammad Deif, the shadowy leader of Hamas’s military wing in Gaza and one of the chief architects of the Oct. 7, 2023, attack on Israel that ignited a war, was confirmed by Hamas on Thursday to be dead. He was in his late 50s.
Mr. Deif, whose real name was Muhammad al-Masri, was one of the most senior Hamas leaders inside Gaza, and he was one of Israel’s most-wanted militants for decades. He survived a number of Israeli assassination attempts before the one that killed him and was lionized by some Palestinians as a symbol of Hamas’s resilience — albeit an enigmatic one.
While Israel announced in August that he had been killed, Abu Obeida, the spokesman of Hamas’s military wing, only acknowledged his death on Thursday in a recorded video statement. Both Israel and the United States considered him a terrorist with their citizens’ blood on his hands.
Mr. Deif was killed on July 13, Israel said, when its forces bombed a compound on the outskirts of Khan Younis in southern Gaza, according to the Israeli military — making him one of the most senior Hamas commanders slain inside Gaza in the war.
Mr. Obeida did not say when or where Mr. Deif was killed.
The strike that killed Mr. Deif also killed at least 90 Palestinians on the ground, the Gaza health ministry said, hitting within the Al-Mawasi area of southern Gaza, a part of a humanitarian zone designated by Israel. The health ministry does not distinguish between civilians and combatants in its death tolls.
The zone was a large expanse filled with hundreds of thousands of displaced Palestinians, many living in makeshift shelters, according to the United Nations. Israel said that Hamas was operating from the targeted compound within the zone.
Mr. Deif was “the beating heart” of Hamas’s military wing and one of its most important military strategists, said Michael Milshtein, a former Israeli intelligence officer specializing in Palestinian affairs.
There were few photographs of Mr. Deif in circulation, and he was rarely seen or heard from as he spent decades in hiding. His adopted name, “Deif,” means “guest” in Arabic, widely understood as a nod to the frequency with which he changed locations to avoid death or capture.
He led the Qassam Brigades, the military wing of Hamas, and was credited with transforming what was once a diffuse network of armed cells into a formidable fighting force with tens of thousands in its ranks.
“He’s a legendary figure in Hamas,” Ibrahim Madhoun, a Palestinian analyst close to Hamas, said before Mr. Deif’s death was confirmed by the militant group.
Born in 1965 to a poor Palestinian family, Mr. Deif grew up in the Khan Younis refugee camp in southern Gaza, not far from Yahya Sinwar, the top Hamas leader killed in October. In the 1980s, he studied at Islamic University of Gaza, focusing on the sciences, and joined Hamas around the time it was founded in the late 1980s.
He quickly rose through the ranks, developing a reputation as a master bombmaker and orchestrating a number of attacks on Israel, including a series of deadly bus bombings that killed dozens of people and derailed the peace process in the mid-1990s.
Not long after Hamas was founded, Israel imprisoned Mr. Deif for 16 months, starting in May 1989.
Mr. Deif was also held by the Palestinian Authority for a short time starting in 2000. At that time, the Palestinian Authority was a governing body with limited autonomy over parts of the West Bank and Gaza, and it was dominated by Fatah, a Palestinian faction that rivaled Hamas.
When a founder of the military wing of Hamas, Salah Shehadeh, was killed by an Israeli airstrike in 2002, Mr. Deif took the helm.
He upgraded and expanded the production and importation of rockets and helped develop Hamas’s extensive tunnel network underneath Gaza. He also commanded the so-called Shadow Brigade, which guards Israeli captives held by Hamas, and oversaw investment in new technologies like reconnaissance drones for the Qassam Brigades, according to Mr. Madhoun, the analyst.
Mr. Deif was believed to have lost an eye and suffered other serious wounds in the Israeli attempts to kill him, which often claimed the lives of others, including civilians. His ability to escape death — and oft-stated dedication to the destruction of Israel — enhanced his heroic status among some Palestinians.
Israeli and Palestinian analysts also credited Mr. Deif with transforming the Qassam Brigades into something closer to a traditional army.
Mr. Deif was one of the top names on Israel’s most-wanted list for decades, and survived more than eight attempts on his life, according to Israeli intelligence. In 2015, the U.S. State Department labeled him as a “specially designated global terrorist.”
He was the target of a 2002 missile strike by an Israeli helicopter on a busy street in Gaza City. In 2014, an Israeli airstrike killed one of his wives, an infant son and his 3-year-old daughter. During an earlier war with Hamas in Gaza in 2021, Israel’s military said it had tried to kill him several times.
That war — launched by Hamas after Israeli efforts to evict Palestinians from their homes in East Jerusalem and Israeli police raids of the Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem’s Old City — was a turning point, Osama Hamdan, a Hamas leader based in Beirut, later told The New York Times.
Over the next few years, Hamas enhanced its military abilities.
It stockpiled about 15,000 rockets along with mortars, antitank missiles and portable air-defense systems, according to American and other Western analysts. And its leaders — Mr. Deif and Mr. Sinwar — drew up closely guarded plans for the Oct. 7, 2023, assault on Israel, as Hamas fighters trained on flying paragliders and taking hostages.
Once the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel got underway, Mr. Deif released a rare message. He declared that Hamas had decided to launch an operation so that “the enemy will understand that the time of their rampaging without accountability has ended,” speaking in a recorded address.
“Righteous fighters, this is your day to bury this criminal enemy,” he said. “Its time has finished. Kill them wherever you find them. Remove this filth from your land and your sacred places. Fight and the angels fight with you.”
The Oct. 7, 2023, attack has come to symbolize one of the greatest intelligence failures in Israel’s history and the shattering of its image as an impenetrable military power. It was the deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. Some 1,200 people were killed in the rampage and roughly 250 were taken hostage.
The attack ignited a devastating war that killed tens of thousands of Palestinians, including civilians. The 470-day war displaced most of the people in Gaza, led to a hunger crisis and the spread of dangerous disease, and made many Palestinians wonder if they had a future in the territory. A cease-fire came into effect on Jan. 19, but it remains unclear how long it will hold.
Israel responded by going to war against Hamas in Gaza with Mr. Deif and the other Hamas leaders in its cross hairs. In March, Israel killed his top deputy, Marwan Issa.
In November, the International Criminal Court issued a warrant for Mr. Deif’s arrest, accusing him of war crimes and crimes against humanity in connection with his role before, during and after the October 2023 attack.
The move had been seen as largely symbolic, with a slim likelihood of Mr. Deif’s ending up in custody. He had spent decades underground in Hamas’s tunnels under Gaza, according to Israeli intelligence officials, and had not been seen publicly in years.
The court also issued arrest warrants for Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, and his defense minister, Yoav Gallant.
Recently, senior Israeli defense officials said the military believed that Mr. Deif had developed health problems that forced him to spend more time above ground.
That is apparently where an Israeli airstrike found him on July 13.
An Israeli unit that oversees the identification of high-value targets, staffed by operatives from military intelligence and the Shin Bet, had spent weeks observing a villa inside the southern Gaza humanitarian zone where another top Hamas lieutenant — Rafa Salameh — was believed to be staying with his family, according to the defense officials.
After learning that Mr. Deif appeared to be at the villa, the Israeli government authorized fighter jets to drop at least five precision-guided bombs on it, according to the officials.
That evening, Mr. Netanyahu said that an airstrike had targeted Mr. Deif but that there was not yet “absolute clarity” over his fate.
“His hands are steeped in the blood of many Israelis,” Mr. Netanyahu said. “At the beginning of the campaign, I laid down a rule: The Hamas murderers are dead men, from the first to the last.”
Zakaria Zubeidi, a Palestinian militant who briefly escaped an Israeli prison in 2021, is among those released.
Among the Palestinians released on Thursday in a hostage-for-prisoner swap between Israel and Hamas was Zakaria Zubeidi, who over the past two decades has been a militant, a theater director and an escaped prisoner whose flight stunned Israelis and Palestinians alike.
Mr. Zubeidi, 49, rose to prominence as a militant leader during the Second Intifada, or uprising, in the early 2000s, during which Palestinian militants committed deadly attacks against Israelis, including suicide bombings that targeted civilian thoroughfares.
Israel responded by reoccupying major Palestinian cities amid street battles. Some of the toughest fighting took place in the Palestinian city of Jenin, Mr. Zubeidi’s hometown. His mother and one of his brothers were killed during the clashes.
He later emerged as a top commander in the Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigades, an armed militia loosely linked with the secular Fatah party, the dominant Palestinian political faction in the West Bank. On at least one occasion, Mr. Zubeidi publicly announced that the group had conducted armed attacks against Israelis.
After the Second Intifada, Israel granted sweeping amnesty to militants affiliated with Fatah; the party now controls the Palestinian Authority, with which Israel coordinates closely on security in the West Bank.
Mr. Zubeidi later turned to theater, which he said was a more effective means of resistance than violence. He helped direct the Freedom Theater, a community cultural center in the hardscrabble Jenin refugee camp, which was founded by Palestinians displaced by the 1948 wars surrounding Israel’s establishment.
“I don’t miss weapons,” Mr. Zubeidi said in an interview with Israeli television several years ago. “I miss the intifada, the revolution.”
But in 2019, Israel arrested him again on charges that he had returned to militancy, accusing him of involvement in recent West Bank violence.
Two years later, Mr. Zubeidi and five other Palestinian prisoners conducted a jailbreak by crawling nearly 32 yards through an underground tunnel outside one of Israel’s maximum-security prisons.
Although they were later recaptured, the prison break shook Israelis and thrilled Palestinians. Israelis saw Mr. Zubeidi’s escape as a chilling security breach with the potential to incite further violence. Many Palestinians called it a temporary victory against Israel’s mass incarceration of Palestinians.
An Israeli drone strike killed Mr. Zubeidi’s son, Mohammad, in September. The Israeli military called the son a “significant terrorist” and said he had been involved in shooting at Israeli troops.
Other militants convicted of involvement in deadly attacks against Israelis were also among the Palestinians being released on Thursday.
One was Sami Jaradat, 56, who was serving multiple life sentences for involvement in a deadly 2003 suicide bombing that targeted a restaurant in Haifa, on the Israeli coast. Palestinian Islamic Jihad, a militant group, claimed responsibility for the attack.
At least 21 people were killed in the bombing, according to the Israeli authorities, including women, children and a one-year-old girl.
Mr. Jaradat, like many Palestinian detainees involved in the deadliest attacks against Israelis, will not be allowed to return to his home near Jenin. Under the terms of the deal, he will be expelled to either the Gaza Strip or another country like Egypt.
Unlike Mr. Jaradat, Mr. Zubeidi is expected to remain in the West Bank.
On Thursday, Mr. Zubeidi’s wife, Alaa, 39, stood with her sisters and friends in Ramallah, in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, dressed in black, to wait for him to be released from prison.
She said she had been in mourning since her son Mohammad’s death, visiting his grave daily until mid-December, when Palestinian security forces began operating in the Jenin refugee camp.
Fatima AbdulKarim contributed reporting.
The release in Khan Younis descended into chaos.
The release of hostages in southern Gaza on Thursday descended into chaos and disorder as Palestinian militants struggled to control a large crowd of people trying to catch a glimpse of the handover.
The scene in the southern city of Khan Younis was in stark contrast to the handover of an Israeli soldier in the morning in the north. While both were performative stunts meant to show Hamas maintained popular support and was very much in control in Gaza, the one in the north went relatively smoothly.
Hamas said in a statement that the crowds at the handovers showed how Palestinians were determined to remain on their land. But to Israelis, the chaos in Khan Younis illustrated Hamas’s desire to humiliate and torment the hostages even as they were being freed.
In each of the four handovers since the cease-fire came into effect, militants have driven hostages through crowds before transferring them to the Red Cross.
On Thursday, when a white van, apparently carrying a hostage or hostages, arrived near the home of Hamas’s former top leader, the militants failed to stop people from surrounding the vehicle. Minutes later, Arbel Yehud, 29, one of the last female hostages in Gaza, was marched to a Red Cross vehicle, as people stretched out their arms in an attempt to take images of her.
Ms. Yehud, surrounded by militants from four different groups, was visibly frightened as she walked slowly toward the Red Cross vehicle. At one point, Ms. Yehud seemed to lower her head and close her eyes.
In a separate video, Gadi Moses, an 80-year-old hostage, could be seen escorted by militants through the crowd.
Yves Daccord, a former director general of the Red Cross, said the handover in Khan Younis was “risky,” “unacceptable,” and “absolutely psychological torture.”
“Releasing hostages in this way creates an enormous trauma on top of everything that has already happened,” he said in an interview. Hostages, Mr. Daccord said, should ideally be released away from crowds and cameras.
In total, seven Israeli and Thai hostages were transferred to the Red Cross in Khan Younis on Thursday. All of them were abducted during the Hamas-led October 2023 attack on southern Israel that left roughly 1,200 people dead.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel blasted what he described as “shocking scenes” and called on mediators to ensure they don’t happen again.
“This is additional proof of the inconceivable brutality of the Hamas terrorist organization.” he said.
In a statement, Hamas asserted its military wing was participating in “organized handover operations.”
Hamas has claimed it has treated hostages well. Former hostages, however, have reported being abused, including one who spoke publicly about being sexually assaulted and tortured.
Aaron Boxerman
Hamas just announced that Muhammad Deif, the leader of its military wing, was killed in an Israeli airstrike last year. Abu Obeida, the spokesman for the military wing, confirmed Deif’s death in a video statement after months in which Hamas officials had mostly been silent as to his fate. Israel had announced Deif’s death a couple of weeks after it targeted him in an airstrike that killed and injured dozens of Palestinians.
Aaron Boxerman
Throughout the war, Hamas rarely confirmed the deaths of its senior military commanders or even of rank-and-file fighters. That changed after the cease-fire came into effect. On Thursday night, Obeida formally announced not only the death of Deif, but also those of other senior Hamas military leaders. Last week, Hamas also held a public funeral for Rawhi Mushtaha, a high-ranking Hamas leader in Gaza.
Aaron Boxerman
The Israeli prison authority just said that all 110 Palestinian prisoners slated to be freed in the current hostage-for-prisoner swap had been released. The release had been delayed for a few hours after a chaotic handover of Israeli and Thai hostages in Gaza prompted Israeli ire.
Aaron Boxerman
The release of the Palestinian prisoners concluded the third exchange in the fragile six-week initial cease-fire between Israel and Hamas. On Saturday, Hamas is expected to release three more living male hostages in exchange for Palestinians jailed by Israel as the truce continues.
Aaron Boxerman
Red Cross buses carrying Palestinian prisoners freed in the exchange have arrived in Beitunia in the occupied West Bank, according to footage live-streamed on Arabic television networks. There was no immediate comment by the Israeli authorities.
Aaron Boxerman
Palestinians hurled stones at Israeli forces who fired stun grenades in response, near Beitunia in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. That was around the same time the buses carrying Palestinian prisoners freed in the hostage-for-prisoner swap entered the town. It was unclear whether anyone was hurt.
Isabel Kershner
Agam Berger, the Israeli lookout soldier released from captivity on Thursday morning, arrived in “good” condition, according to Dr. Eytan Wirtheim, the C.E.O. of Beilinson Hospital, where Berger was taken. The four other lookout soldiers who were released on Saturday were “improving from day to day,” Dr. Wirtheim said in a televised statement, adding that they had decided to stay in the hospital to keep Berger company during her first days of freedom.
Israelis gathered outside Sheba Hospital to welcome Arbel Yehud in the city of Ramat Gan, near Tel Aviv, on Thursday.
The family of Arbel Yehud said after her release, “Our life’s mission to bring Arbel back to us has succeeded.” In a statement posted by the Hostage Families Forum, an umbrella organization representing the families of Israeli hostages, the family urged officials to pursue the cease-fire agreement until all hostages, including Ms. Yehud’s partner and his brother, are released.
“Everyone must be brought home immediately so that we can heal as a society,” her family said.
The five released Thai hostages have undergone initial medical examinations and were found to be in “good” condition, a spokesman for Israel’s foreign minister, Gideon Saar, said in a statement. Thailand’s foreign minister, Maris Sangiampongsa, is scheduled to arrive in Israel this weekend, the spokesman said.
Six of the released hostages — Gadi Moses and the five Thais — have left the initial reception point near the Gaza border on helicopters headed toward hospitals in Israel, the Israeli military said. The Thais will be welcomed there by representatives of Thailand’s government, the military said. Another hostage released today, Arbel Yehud, will be flown to a hospital together with her family soon, according to the military.
Aaron Boxerman
The Israeli government said that mediators had guaranteed that hostages in the coming exchanges would be given safe passage, averting chaotic scenes like those earlier today in Gaza. Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, had demanded the commitment today in exchange for releasing the 110 Palestinian prisoners as stipulated by the cease-fire agreement with Hamas, according to a statement by Mr. Netanyahu’s office.
A faraway vigil for hostages ends in happy tears in Thailand
Vilas Thanna, the father of Pongsak Thanna, a Thai fruit farmhand who was held hostage in Gaza, could barely get the words out as he digested the news of his son’s release after 15 months of captivity.
“When we are happy, we cry,” he said. “When we are sad, we also cry. But these are happy tears.”
Mr. Pongsak was among five Thai hostages who were released on Thursday. Working on farms in often dangerous parts of Israel, Thai farmhands suffered a heavy toll in the Hamas-led attacks of Oct. 7, 2023. At least 39 were killed, and at least 31 were taken hostage, according to an earlier tally from the Thai foreign ministry.
In November 2023, 23 of those hostages were released. Two more died in captivity, the Thai foreign ministry said last May. (On Thursday evening, a Thai foreign ministry official said that the total fatalities were 46, but it was not clear whether that number referred only to the Oct. 7 attacks.)
The hostages released on Thursday were Mr. Pongsak, Sathian Suwannakham, Watchara Sriaoun, Bannawat Seathao and Surasak Lamnao. The fate of one remaining Thai hostage, Nattapong Pinta, is not clear.
Mr. Vilas, Mr. Pongsak’s father, said he planned to go to Bangkok, the capital of Thailand, to meet the plane carrying his son, although costs can be prohibitive.
Thai hostages in a previous round of releases in November 2023 said they had to initially pay for their flights from Bangkok back to their home provinces. Thai labor officials say they have since disbursed funds to returned workers.
Economic hardship has spurred thousands of Thais, particularly from the Isaan region of northeastern Thailand, to take agricultural jobs in Israel, despite the risks. Besides those who lost their lives in the Oct. 7 killing attack, other Thai farmworkers have been killed over the years in rocket attacks on Israel, including in October.
But the money earned in Israel can be life-changing, and villages in Isaan are dotted with modern houses built from these overseas earnings. Some workers who suffered through the Oct. 7 attacks have since gone back to Israel to finish out their contracts.
Wiwwaeo Sriaoun, the mother of Mr. Watchara, another of the five Thais released on Thursday, was gathered at home with a gaggle of relatives when she heard of his return.
She, too, spoke of tears of joy. As her family cheered around her, Ms. Wiwwaeo’s voice rose to an excited yell.
“I hope he can come home safely,” she said.
But she was not sure whether she could afford to go to Bangkok to meet her son.
For now, she said, she was happy to see her son’s name on the TV screen among those who were finally free.
Aaron Boxerman
Qadura Fares, the Palestinian prisoners’ affairs commissioner, said in a text message the Palestinian prisoners were now slated to be released around 5 p.m. local time (10 a.m. Eastern). There was no immediate comment by the Israeli authorities.
Aaron Boxerman
The office of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel said the release of the Palestinian prisoners was being delayed after the chaotic release of Israeli and Thai hostages in southern Gaza, where they were escorted through a surging crowd by armed Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad militants.
Mr. Netanyahu said Israel would not release the Palestinian prisoners until it had received a commitment for “the safe exit of our hostages in the next rounds.”
Adam Rasgon
The release of over 100 Palestinian prisoners slated for today has been suspended until further notice, according to Zivan Frieden, a spokesman for Israel’s prisons authority. The decision to suspend the release of Palestinian prisoners was made by Israel’s government, he said in a text message.
Israeli officials have expressed outrage at the way that Hamas and Islamic Jihad handed hostages over to the Red Cross in the southern city of Khan Younis, with hundreds of people crowding the area. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu described the scenes as “shocking.”
Adam Rasgon
Nattapong Pinta was not among the five Thai hostages released today. It is unclear whether he is still alive.
Before the release of the five Thai hostages, the Israeli authorities had said that eight Thai hostages were in Gaza, though two were declared dead last May. Mr. Nattapong had not been declared dead.
Here’s a closer look at the 3 Israeli hostages released today.
Hamas released eight hostages, including three Israelis and five Thais, on Thursday as part of a hostage-for-prisoner exchange, more than a year after they were taken captive during the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.
Agam Berger, an Israeli army soldier, was released first in a highly choreographed ceremony in northern Gaza. A second hostage release in southern Gaza descended into chaos as crowds pushed forward to try to get a glimpse of them.
The hostage release is part of a 42-day cease-fire deal that went into effect this month, pausing the fighting between Israel and Hamas. Hamas agreed to incrementally release 33 of the nearly 100 remaining hostages in exchange for more than 1,000 Palestinians jailed by Israel and a partial Israeli withdrawal.
Here’s a closer look at the Israelis released on Thursday.
Agam Berger
Ms. Berger was 19 and recently assigned as a lookout when Hamas-led militants stormed the Nahal Oz army base where she was working, killing more than 50 soldiers and abducting her and six other soldiers. Four of them were earlier released in an exchange on Saturday.
Ms. Berger’s mother, Meirav, said she last saw her daughter when they dropped her off at the base on Oct. 5, 2023, two days before the attack. According to a website created by her family, and her parents’ accounts in Israeli news media, Ms. Berger called her parents in the middle of the attack, using the phone of a friend who was killed next to her. She told them that she could hear shots being fired and that people were crying, but that she was not afraid, according to the website.
In November 2023, Agam Goldstein-Almog, who was taken captive with her daughter and two sons and was released as part of the first cease-fire deal, said that she had been held in a tunnel with Ms. Berger and the other soldiers serving as lookouts who had been captured. She said that Ms. Berger was praying a lot, and seemed to be in good spirits.
In August, Ms. Berger’s family held an event to mark her birthday at Tel Aviv’s Anu Museum of the Jewish People, centered on music because she is passionate about music and plays the violin. She has a twin sister and two other siblings.
Gadi Moses
Gadi Moses, a farming expert, was abducted in Kibbutz Nir Oz after stepping out of a safe room to trying to reason with the militants.
His partner, Efrat Katz, hid inside a safe room in their home with her daughter and two visiting grandchildren, before they were also taken by militants. Their kidnapping was captured on video that showed them squashed in the back of a pickup truck.
Ms. Katz was killed when an Israeli helicopter, responding to the Hamas-led assault, fired on the vehicle in which she was being held. Her daughter and grandchildren were released during the November 2023 cease-fire.
Mr. Moses, then 79, was seen in December of 2023 in a video released by Palestinian Islamic Jihad, calling on Israel to work for his release. The family said in September that they had had no word of his fate since.
Arbel Yehud
Arbel Yehud was 28 when she was taken hostage along with her boyfriend, Ariel Cunio, from their home on Kibbutz Nir Oz in southern Israel. Mr. Cunio is believed to still be held captive. Her brother, Dolev Yehud, a medic, was thought to be a hostage as well but was identified last year as having been killed during the Oct. 7 attack.
Ms. Yehud’s family has described her as passionate about space and astronomy and said she had worked as a guide at a space and technology center.
In February, her father, Yechi Yehud, told The Daily Mail that he had been avoiding watching or reading any news so as not to raise his hopes for a deal. Her mother, Yael Yehud, described herself as “broken” and said she often imagined her children walking through the door again.
On Ms. Yehud’s 29th birthday in June, her close friend, Shani Goren, who had been a hostage and was released in the first cease-fire deal, spoke at a rally in Tel Aviv and described the difficulty of recovering.
“Every day I wake up, I’m still held hostage,” she said. “Because until Arbel and everyone else return home, we can’t even begin to discuss rehabilitation and moving forward. I know. I was there.”
Ms. Yehud had been expected to be released on Saturday, prompting one of the most significant disputes between Israel and Hamas since the start of the cease-fire.
Israeli officials had said they believed she was not being held by Hamas, and had suggested that another militant group was responsible for the holdup in her release. The Palestinian Islamic Jihad on Monday released a video, which an analysis by The New York Times dates to Jan. 25, in which she says, “My family, I’m OK. I miss you endlessly and I hope to return to you soon, like the girls who had been released.”
Rights groups and international law experts have noted that, by definition, such hostage videos are made under duress, and that the statements in them are usually coerced.
Hannah Beech
Wiwwaeo Sriaoun, the mother of Watchara Sriaoun, a Thai hostage who was just released, said: “I’m so, so happy. I was tearing up earlier.” As she said this, there were cheers in the home, and her voice rose to an excited yell. “I hope he will come home safely,” she said.
She said she hadn’t heard from any Thai or Israeli officials, but saw her son’s name on the TV screen.
Aaron Boxerman
The Israeli government confirmed that Arbel Yahud and Gadi Moses were back in Israeli custody after over a year in Hamas captivity in Gaza.
The Israeli prime minister’s office also identified the five Thai hostages released today: Pongsak Thanna, Sathian Suwannakham, Watchara Sriaoun, Bannawat Seathao and Surasak Lamnao.
Aaron Boxerman
All seven have crossed into Israeli territory, according to the Israeli military. Ms. Yehud and Mr. Moses will soon be reunited with their families, while the five Thai hostages will be met by Thai government officials, the military said.
Adam Rasgon
The seven Israeli and foreign hostages are now in the custody of Israeli security forces in the Gaza Strip, the Israeli military and the Shin Bet security service said. They will undergo an initial medical assessment after arriving in Israeli territory.
An eighth hostage, released earlier today, has already arrived in Israel.
Isabel Kershner
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel said he viewed the chaotic scenes surrounding today’s release of hostages in southern Gaza “with utmost severity.” In a statement, he described the unruly crowd around them as shocking, and demanded that the mediators ensure that such scenes do not recur.
Adam Rasgon
The Red Cross says that seven Israeli and foreign hostages were handed over to its representatives in Gaza, the Israeli military and Shin Bet security service said in a joint statement. Two Israeli hostages and five Thai captives were expected to be released from southern Gaza today.
This is in addition to the Israeli hostage released in northern Gaza today, a total of eight.
Isabel Kershner
Steve Witkoff, the U.S.’s new Middle East envoy, has joined Israelis in Tel Aviv who have gathered to watch the hostage releases in what has become known as “Hostage Square,” according to images broadcast on Israeli television.
Isabel Kershner
The crowd in Tel Aviv had been watching in trepidation as the chaotic scenes of the latest handover in Gaza were projected on screens in the square.
Adam Rasgon
Al Jazeera, a Qatari-funded TV channel, broadcast a video of Arbel Yehud, one of the last living female hostages, walking through a chaotic crowd of people. Ms. Yehud was surrounded by militants from Hamas and Islamic Jihad as people nearby stretched out their arms attempting to take footage of her. At one point, Ms. Yehud appeared to be afraid of the people pressing toward her as she slowly walked toward a Red Cross vehicle.
Aaron Boxerman
In increasingly chaotic scenes, a small white van surrounded by armed gunmen, apparently carrying the hostages, slowly pushed its way through a large, seething crowd in Khan Younis. The van then went inside a partly ruined structure.
A short while later, a small group of Palestinian gunmen marched through the crowd — apparently escorting the hostages — as large numbers of Gazans mobbed them, seeking any glimpse of the soon-to-be-freed captives.
Adam Rasgon
This handover is in stark contrast to the one that took place in northern Gaza this morning, which was highly choreographed and controlled.
In Thailand, an anxious vigil continues for hostages half a world away.
In the impoverished villages of Isaan, as Thailand’s northeast is known, families have become used to a vigil from half a world away.
On Thursday, five families hoped that their loved ones were finally being released from Gaza, after 15 months as hostages in a conflict whose contours they do not fully understand. The Thai foreign ministry has said that five Thai nationals will be among those released on Thursday.
“Is there any news yet?” asked Wiwwaeo Sriaoun, the mother of Watchara Sriaoun, one of the remaining Thai hostages. “We are happy but also anxious waiting for the names to come out.”
Neither Israel nor Hamas have named the Thai hostages due to be released on Thursday.
Like the other 30,000 Thai farmworkers laboring in Israel before the Hamas-led attacks on Oct. 7, 2023, Mr. Watchara had grown accustomed to nurturing produce in what sometimes turned into a battle zone, his mother said.
At least 39 Thai agricultural workers were killed in the Oct. 7 attacks, and at least 31 were taken hostage, according to the Thai foreign ministry. Of the 31 hostages, at least two died in captivity, Thai officials said. During a cease-fire in November 2023, 23 Thai hostages were released.
Vilas Thanna, the father of Pongsak Thanna, another Thai hostage, said he hoped that his son, a fruit tender, might be one of the five to be released on Thursday. The family, including Mr. Pongsak’s 14-year-old daughter and many other relatives, had gathered in an excited throng at his home in Buriram, in Isaan.
“I am very super duper happy, so excited,” Mr. Vilas said. “I couldn’t sleep since last night.”
The fate of the sixth Thai hostage believed to be in Gaza is unclear. While Thai government officials have said he is alive, Thai and Israeli workers charged with taking care of the released hostages say they have been told he has died.
Despite the dangers, Thai farmhands have continued to tend fields in Israel. Among them are some who suffered through the Hamas-led killing spree 15 months ago.
In October, four Thais were killed by Hezbollah rockets in northern Israel. The same month, another Thai was killed near the Israel-Lebanon border when unexploded ordnance detonated in an orchard.
In India, Concerns of Cover-Up After Stampede at Massive Hindu Festival
- Dozens Dead
- Photos of Aftermath
- Video
- Concerns of Cover-Up
- What Is Maha Kumbh Mela?
The pre-dawn stampede at the massive Hindu festival in northern India created havoc. But order was restored swiftly in the next few hours.
On Wednesday morning, ambulances cut through a swarm of millions of people who had gathered in the city of Prayagraj. They ferried dozens of people to hospitals, some who had been trampled to death.
Local officials moved to resume the rites at the Maha Kumbh Mela, relying on thousands of “A.I.-powered” video cameras. Soon, the faithful were doing what they came for: bathing at the confluence of three rivers considered sacred, one of them mythical. A helicopter showered rose petals on seers leading the holy dip.
Officials had studied stampedes at earlier iterations of the festival. But as prepared and equipped as they seemed to be, they did not release even an initial death toll for nearly 15 hours after the tragedy.
What they kept releasing was good news: regular updates on how many people had completed the bathing ritual.
The dearth of information on the victims of the stampede, analysts said, appeared to be an official effort to cover up damage at an event that holds significance to the fortunes of political leaders. It left families of those searching for loved ones in the dark, running from hospital to morgue.
And it left a cloud over the official tally that was finally released on Wednesday evening — 30 dead and 90 injured.
Among those searching for their loved ones in the vacuum of information was Shiv Shankar Singh, 55, a retired army officer He and his wife had bathed at the confluence of the Ganges and Yamuna Rivers, and the mythical Sarasvati, soon after midnight, and then got caught in the stampede.
He searched for her all day, making his way on foot from hospital to hospital in an area where vehicular movement had been restricted for miles.
“Everybody was pushing everybody else. My wife fell down,” Mr. Singh said. “I grabbed a pole and stood on the ground. I saved myself, but I don’t know what happened to her.”
The Kumbh Mela, which happens every 12 years, is a massive undertaking by any standard. This year, because of a rare celestial alignment, it was deemed a once-in-a-century occurrence. The government in Uttar Pradesh, India’s most populous state, said it expected more than 400 million pilgrims and visitors to arrive in Prayagraj for the 45-day festival.
Yogi Adityanath, the state’s chief minister, is considered among the contenders to succeed Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Analysts said he put himself front and center as the organizer of the world’s largest gathering in an attempt to build his national profile as an administrator who could mix two things dear to India: faith and technology.
While assessing the preparations for the festival early in January, Mr. Adityanath, 52, had pointed fingers at his predecessors over the operation of past festivals, which had led to deadly stampedes. He said that he wanted arrangements that could be “a lesson to those who had made the organization of the Maha Kumbh synonymous with filth and stampede.”
“Yogi has been touted as larger-than-life, larger-than-Uttar Pradesh,” said Rasheed Kidwai, an author and political analyst. “The success of the event would have meant to announce to the world, ‘Here is a man who micromanaged a gathering of 400 million people effortlessly.’ This posturing would become important for the post-Modi era.”
The Uttar Pradesh government has a public relations budget of over $100 million for the year, and some of that goes to media outlets that provide friendly coverage.
It has also introduced a new social media policy that gives financial incentives to influencers who promote the state’s success, while promising action against the reporting of “government schemes in a wrong manner or with wrong intention,” according to news reports.
The hold of that influence was clear in the aftermath of the tragedy. Television channels headlined Mr. Adityanath’s regular phone conversations with Mr. Modi, 74, and that everything was under control. They repeated throughout the day a video statement by Mr. Adityanath, in which he made no mention of deaths but asked people to not fall for rumors.
But some saw through the public relations campaign.
“It is reminiscent of the opacity of Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath and his government after the widespread deaths during the second Covid-19 wave in March 2021, the scale of which was evident later when horrific images of bodies floating in the Ganga emerged,” The Hindu, a national newspaper, wrote in an editorial Thursday.
Mr. Adityanath has ordered a probe into the lapse. His officials have not explained what caused the delay in providing a casualty toll. His office did not respond to requests for comment.
Vikram Singh, a former police chief of Uttar Pradesh who has overseen arrangements in past Kumbhs, said a part of the delay could be attributed to the massive logistical demand of such a huge event. Officials would have been focused on evacuating the injured and getting them proper treatment, he said.
But he, too, struggled to understand the extent of the delay, which he said only fueled a rumor mill that “was working overtime” to put the death toll anywhere from 50 to 200 in the vacuum of official information.
The other Mr. Singh, who had been separated from his wife, went to the festival’s lost and found stands to look for her. He registered a complaint with her details. He went back to the confluence of the rivers. He walked from hospital to hospital and back to the festival site.
There, in the evening, Mr. Singh finally had good news at one of the lost and found centers. His wife had fallen down in the stampede but, luckily, wasn’t hurt and had been waiting for him for hours.
“If they had communicated, then I would have found her much earlier,” he said, referring to the lost and found booths. “But I am happy now that I found my wife.”
Pragati K.B. and Suhasini Raj contributed reporting from New Delhi.
What We Know About Ahmed al-Shara, Syria’s Interim President
- The Latest
- Interim President Declared
- Who Is Ahmed al-Shara?
- Photos
- Alliances and Rivalries
- Syrians Reclaim Freedoms
Ahmed al-Shara, the leader of the rebel coalition that swept to power in Syria last month, has been declared the country’s interim president, a role that will see him navigate a time of untold change for a fractured nation.
Under Mr. al-Shara’s stewardship, Syria’s interim government will now face a delicate political transition after the overthrow of the dictatorship led by President Bashar al-Assad.
Among the many challenges he faces are uniting a complex patchwork of rebel groups, gaining control over multiple regions under the sway of powerful factions and rebuilding relations with the international community to undo crippling sanctions.
Here’s what you need to know:
- How did Mr. al-Shara rise to power?
- What is the new leader’s background?
- What challenges does Syria face?
How did Mr. al-Shara rise to power?
Formerly known by his nom de guerre, Abu Mohammad al-Jolani, Mr. al-Shara spearheaded an offensive last month that ousted Mr. al-Assad and ended the Assad family’s iron grip on the country, which had lasted more than five decades.
Mr. al-Shara was the leader of Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, an Islamist rebel group once linked to Al Qaeda. His faction controlled most of Idlib Province, in northwestern Syria, during a long stalemate in the country’s civil war, which dragged on for nearly 14 years.
In late November, Mr. al-Shara launched the most significant challenge to Mr. al-Assad’s rule in a decade, capturing territory across several provinces without facing much resistance from the government’s military forces or from their powerful international allies Russia and Iran.
Hayat Tahrir al-Sham and other armed factions in the rebel coalition would be disbanded and integrated into the fledgling government’s armed forces, a spokesman for the coalition, Col. Hassan Abdel Ghani, announced on Wednesday. He also declared that the Constitution had been nullified and that the legislature and army formed under the Assad regime had been dissolved, according to the Syrian state news agency, SANA.
It was not immediately clear whether there was a broad consensus among armed groups across Syria about Mr. al-Shara’s appointment as interim president. It was also unclear how long the transitional period would last.
What is the new leader’s background?
Born in Saudi Arabia, Mr. al-Shara is the child of Syrian exiles, according to Arab media reports. In the late 1980s, his family moved back to Syria, and in 2003, he went to neighboring Iraq to join Al Qaeda and fight the American occupation. There, he spent several years in a U.S. prison, according to American officials.
Mr. al-Shara later emerged in Syria around the start of the civil war and formed the Nusra Front, an affiliate of Al Qaeda. He eventually broke ties with Al Qaeda, and the Nusra Front evolved into Hayat Tahrir al-Sham.
After sweeping to power in Syria last month, Mr. al-Shara has seemed to be trying to distance himself from his militant past, ditching his combat fatigues and donning a suit and tie as he welcomed a roster of foreign diplomats to Damascus, the Syrian capital. By eschewing global jihadist ambitions, Mr. al-Shara apparently hopes to gain international legitimacy, which would help to attract much-needed sanctions relief and funds for rebuilding.
There are signs that the strategy may be working.
Last month, the U.S. government — which has designated Hayat Tahrir al-Sham a terrorist organization — dropped a $10 million bounty on Mr. al-Shara’s head.
Washington has also eased some restrictions on humanitarian aid to Syria, and the European Union announced this week that it would lift some sanctions. Those moves should give Mr. al-Shara’s transitional government some breathing room as it attempts to build a more stable future.
What challenges does Syria face?
Mr. al-Shara has laid out lofty goals, including rebuilding state institutions, ridding the government of corruption and cronyism, and freeing the country from the torture and repression that came to define the Assad regime.
“What Syria needs today is greater than ever before,” he said in remarks published by SANA on Wednesday. “Just as we were determined to liberate it in the past, our duty now is to commit to rebuilding and advancing it.”
But many Syrians have questioned whether Mr. al-Shara can deliver on the ambitious promises and also reconcile his former rebel group’s militant Islamist roots with a largely secular state. Under the watchful eye of the international community, Mr. al-Shara has sought repeatedly to reassure minority communities, and he has pledged to build a country that is tolerant of other beliefs.
The new government has also vowed to hunt down and prosecute senior figures from the Assad years.
But accountability will be a daunting challenge, and there is mounting concern about revenge attacks on members of the old regime.
Adam Rasgon, Raja Abdulrahim, and Christina Goldbaum contributed reporting.
Man Who Burned Quran in Stockholm Is Killed
Salwan Momika, an Iraqi immigrant who set off protests in Sweden and several Muslim countries when he burned a Quran in Stockholm in 2023, has been killed, the Swedish Prosecution Authority said Thursday morning.
The police said that they had arrested five people and that a murder investigation had been launched.
Mr. Momika had been set to appear in Stockholm District Court on Thursday morning. He was scheduled to receive a verdict on charges related to the Quran burning that prompted international outrage in 2023, and to other demonstrations later that year at which he repeated the act.
The shooting took place late on Wednesday in Sodertalje, a city near Stockholm.
The authorities did not say if they believed the killing was connected to Mr. Momika’s burning of the Quran, but Ulf Kristersson, Sweden’s prime minister, said that the country’s security service was looking into the killing.
“There is obviously a risk that there is also a connection with a foreign power,” Mr. Kristersson told reporters. Mr. Momika’s defense attorney, Anna Roth, said he had received death threats.
“He was quite convinced that he would sooner or later be killed,” Ms. Roth said in a phone interview on Thursday.
Mr. Momika had set the Quran ablaze during Eid al-Adha, a major Islamic holiday, outside a mosque in Stockholm. He was born and raised a Christian, but later said he was an atheist, Ms. Roth said. By burning the Quran, he said that he was trying to raise awareness about the mistreatment and killing of Christian minorities by Islamists in some parts of the Muslim world.
“I am warning the Swedish people about the dangers of this book,” Mr. Momika had said through a megaphone outside the mosque.
The response from the Muslim world was swift and furious, with much of the criticism aimed at the Swedish authorities for not stopping the burning.
In Iraq, several hundred people stormed the Swedish Embassy in Baghdad and set parts of it ablaze. Iraq expelled Sweden’s ambassador and directed its ambassador to Sweden to withdraw from its embassy in Stockholm.
Egypt called the Quran burning “a disgraceful act.” And Morocco recalled its ambassador in Sweden, its state news agency reported.
The Swedish authorities had condemned Mr. Momika’s actions at the time, but the police granted a permit for his planned demonstration after a Swedish court ruled that banning it would impinge on the right to freedom of speech.
The permit, however, did not allow him to burn objects, and Mr. Momika was subsequently charged with agitation against an ethnic or national group in four incidents of kicking, stamping on and burning a Quran. He also made speeches with derogatory statements directed against Muslims and Islam, according to the indictment.
“The fact that statements are made in a large square and disseminated is a prerequisite for incitement to racial hatred,” said Anna Hankkio, a Swedish prosecutor who initially brought the charges against Mr. Momika. “It is up to the district court to assess whether the burning of the Quran can also be considered incitement against a group of people.”
Later that summer, Mr. Momika again burned Qurans, according to the indictment.
The Quran burnings — and the resulting horror and outrage from the Muslim world — sparked debates in Sweden, which has struggled with whether to allow such protests.
Before Mr. Momika burned the holy book, Swedish authorities had denied other anti-Quran protests, citing concerns about disruption to public order. After the burning, Sweden’s foreign ministry called Mr. Momika’s action Islamophobic, and officials warned that such protests could affect the country’s national security policy. The domestic security agency briefly raised its terrorism threat to its most severe designation.
Salwan Najem, who joined Mr. Momika in some protests and was also accused of burning a Quran, was a co-defendant in the case that was to be decided on Thursday. He is now set to receive his verdict on Feb. 3.
On Thursday, Mr. Najem expressed fear, posting a link on X to a story about Mr. Momika’s killing.
“I am next,” he wrote.
- Confirmations Tracker
- Change at Lighting Speed
- Funding Freeze’s Chaotic Rollout
- Plan to Slash Federal Work Force
As he does every three months, Sibusiso traveled on Wednesday morning to a clinic in the capital of Eswatini, a tiny southern African nation, to get a refill of the H.I.V. medication he needs to save his life. When he arrived, the door was locked and about 20 other patients stood outside, baffled that the clinic was closed.
Sibusiso, 39 and unemployed, had heard rumors that President Trump was pulling funding for the program that supported his treatment. Now, though, he learned the reality: The Trump administration had ordered a halt to the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, or PEPFAR, one of America’s most consequential aid programs in Africa.
The abrupt pause of a $6.5 billion program established by former President George W. Bush and credited with saving the lives of tens of millions of people sent patients, clinicians and public health advocates across Africa into a panic. Many feared a return to some of the darkest days on the continent, when H.I.V. spread rapidly and a diagnosis was akin to a death sentence.
As Sibusiso stood outside the clinic, he feared he could be next. He had taken the last of his antiretroviral medication that morning. And even though the Trump administration had backtracked, suddenly announcing on Tuesday that lifesaving medications and treatments could continue to be distributed, the clinic remained shuttered in the confusion.
Sibusiso, standing outside, had no idea where or when he could get more medicine.
“I’m now thinking of dying,” said Sibusiso, who requested that only his first name be used to protect his privacy. “What am I going to do without this treatment?”
The Trump administration has said that foreign assistance programs will be paused for three months as it reviews how money is being spent. If the administration decides to end PEPFAR, it could lead to 600,000 deaths over the next decade in South Africa alone, where the program has its largest number of beneficiaries, according to a study.
“The next 90 days are looking so dystopian,” said Nozizwe Ntsesang, the chief executive of a leading gay rights advocacy group in Botswana.
Across South Africa and other countries in the region, fear and uncertainty are palpable. Some African leaders had shared optimism and excitement about a second Trump term. But now, one of his first moves appeared to put lives at risk.
“I’m scared,” said a 19-year-old South African college student who was born with H.I.V. “People will die. It’s going back to the ’90s where people did not have enough medication to treat the disease.”
The student, who also requested anonymity to protect her privacy, said the clinic that she goes to in Johannesburg gave her a three-month supply of her antiretroviral medication on Wednesday instead of the usual six months. Officials explained that they wanted to reserve some stock in case other clinics ran short, she said.
PEPFAR does not provide medication for the South African health system, but it does employ around 13,000 medical professionals, from doctors to community health workers, who are responsible for ensuring that people are tested and seek proper treatment. Virtually all of those employees were ordered to stop working after the Trump administration froze foreign aid programs, according to health care advocates.
The staff shortages, health workers and rights groups said, led to much larger crowds at public clinics in South Africa, where roughly eight million people are living with H.I.V. and 5.7 million receive treatment.
Amid the chaos of the freeze and the Trump administration’s backpedaling, many clinics remained shuttered on Wednesday, with medical workers unsure about the new rules and patients frantic to secure their medication.
Some patients have been forced to wait 10 hours for treatment, advocates said. There were also fears that, without counselors to talk to, some patients, especially those newly diagnosed with H.I.V., would not administer their treatments properly or seek help in the future.
“The abrupt stop is not responsible,” said Solange Baptiste, the executive director of the International Treatment Preparedness Coalition, an organization that works to improve access to treatment for people with H.I.V. “Lives are at risk when you do that.”
South Africa is in a better position than many other African countries. The government procures most of its H.I.V. drugs directly and relies on PEPFAR for only about 17 percent of its overall H.I.V. treatment budget.
Neighboring Botswana, which has received nearly $72 million in aid from PEPFAR since 2003, also buys its own treatment medication, but the work and funding stoppage has weighed heavily on local organizations.
Stanley Monageng said he cried when he learned about the Trump administration’s order. Mr. Monageng, 78, has been running an organization in Molepolole, in southern Botswana, since 2005. It provides support for children with H.I.V. and relies mostly on PEPFAR funding, he said.
Mr. Monageng said he was worried all week that he would not be allowed to provide antiretroviral medication to the dozens of children, many of them orphaned, who rely on his organization for help. Mr. Monageng himself has been living with H.I.V. for 25 years and says he has personally benefited from the PEPFAR program.
“I asked myself, ‘How are these orphans going to survive? How am I going to help them?’” he said on Wednesday from the three-bedroom house that he uses for the center. “I’ve been surviving all these years because of America.”
At HealthPlus 4 Men, the clinic that was closed in Eswatini on Wednesday, officials encouraged anxious patients to go to a public hospital to seek medication. But most patients were uncomfortable with that option.
HealthPlus primarily treats gay men, a population that has been historically stigmatized in Eswatini. Many of its patients fear going to government-run facilities, where they worry they will face discrimination. Public hospitals also often provide prescriptions that many patients can’t afford to fill, said Sibusiso Maziya, the executive director of HealthPlus.
“It’s a sad moment for us,” Mr. Maziya said. “They want to know when this situation will change, when are we opening.”
Despite the waiver issued by the U.S. government on Tuesday, Mr. Maziya said his organization was continuing to withhold antiretroviral medication supplied with PEPFAR funds as it awaits clarity from its funders on what it is allowed to do.
Msizi Mkhabela, the operations manager for HealthPlus, added that the organization promotes diversity, equity and inclusion by supporting equal treatment for gay men. That mission could run afoul of the Trump administration’s freeze on such programs and may put the clinic at a higher risk of being permanently defunded.
In addition to medication, HealthPlus also has a mobile clinic and outreach programs to make sure that people living in rural areas are being tested and receive treatment for H.I.V. The organization considers those programs an essential part of its efforts to prevent the spread of the disease. But all of that was put on hold because the funding came from PEPFAR and HealthPlus is unsure what activities are allowed to continue.
“We are literally shaking and worried,” Mr. Mkhabela said. “Very much frustrated.”
Reporting was contributed by Yvonne Mooka from Molepolole, Botswana, Lynsey Chutel from London and Golden Matonga from Blantyre, Malawi.
- The Latest
- Photos
- U.S. Aid Freeze
- Trump-Putin Relationship
- Ukrainian Casualties
- North Koreans Go It Alone
Internal political tensions in Ukraine have been rising in anticipation of a cease-fire that might lead to elections. This week, they burst into the open with a striking public rebuke of President Volodymyr Zelensky by the mayor of Kyiv.
In a video address issued on Wednesday, the mayor of the country’s capital, Vitali Klitschko, accused the president’s office of abusing the powers of martial law, the latest salvo in a continuing dispute over the use of military rule during the nearly three-year war against Russia.
Mr. Klitschko, a former heavyweight boxing champion who has built a political base in the capital, has engaged in a low-boil feud with Mr. Zelensky for several years, chafing at what he views as the president’s attempt to usurp the authority of the city.
In his statement, Mr. Klitschko accused Mr. Zelensky of appointing a military administrator for the city who he said had tried to assume the powers of the elected City Council.
The administrator, Tymur Tkachenko, was appointed as the martial law chief of Kyiv on Dec. 31. He was part of a round of appointments in regions and cities across Ukraine that began in 2022 and were intended to bolster defenses by giving authority to officers in the military chain of command over local governments.
Mr. Klitschko said Mr. Tkachenko had no military background, which he said “indicates political motives for this appointment.” He accused Mr. Tkachenko of “interference in and blocking of economic activity” in the capital by delaying decisions on infrastructure and construction unrelated to the war.
“While you, as the supreme commander in chief, are focused on the war and the defense of Ukraine, people around you are tirelessly engaged in political intrigue,” Mr. Klitschko said in a video addressed to Mr. Zelensky.
The presidential office did not immediately respond on Thursday to a request for comment about Mr. Klitschko’s accusation.
Mr. Tkachenko issued a combative response to the accusations, saying that he did not see any scope for constructive dialogue with Mr. Klitschko and that the military administration would therefore “solve the city’s problems and help Kyiv residents.”
The feud has escalated at an awkward time for Ukraine, as it waits to see whether President Trump continues American support to Kyiv or tries to forge cease-fire terms with President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia that could be favorable to the Kremlin.
Under martial law introduced when Russian forces invaded in February 2022, frontline towns and cities in Ukraine are governed solely by military administrations. Many of those farther from the front line have both civilian and military authorities.
Civil society groups in Ukraine have long been raising concerns that the central government uses military administrators to secure a stronger grip on authority, even on issues not directly related to defense. The move comes against a backdrop of a preinvasion setback for Mr. Zelensky’s political party in local elections that left opposition politicians in control of most cities and regional governments, including in Kyiv.
In the last local elections before the invasion, the president’s party, Servant of the People, did not win a single mayoral position in Ukraine. Yet today under martial law, one-third of the heads of local and regional military administrations appointed under martial law in Ukraine have ties to Servant of the People.
The expectation is that if a cease-fire is achieved, Ukraine would lift martial law and hold elections; the last presidential election occurred in 2019, when Mr. Zelensky took office. Mr. Klitschko is considered a potential competitor to Mr. Zelensky in a presidential election, though he has not declared an intention to run.
Mr. Klitschko has been mayor of Kyiv since 2014. In his video criticizing Mr. Tkachenko, the appointed military administrator, he accused him of failing to review documents on “orders to restore buildings, compensate owners for damaged facilities, restore infrastructure and many other things.”
He added that the main tasks of the military administration should concern drafting men to serve in the army, civil defense, public safety and the protection of critical infrastructure.
The conflict in Kyiv comes amid criticism from opposition lawmakers that Mr. Zelensky has used martial law powers to enhance the authority of a close circle of advisers, as well as to clear out political opponents in local government.
In 2022 after the full-scale invasion, for example, the elected mayor of the city of Chernihiv, north of the capital, said the presidential office was trying to remove him and appointing a military administrator in his place.
The tension between that mayor, Vladyslav Atroshenko, and the Zelensky administration predates the war, political analysts say, when the mayor decided to collaborate with Mr. Klitschko’s opposition political party, UDAR, which means “Punch.” Mr. Atroshenko was later stripped of his powers as mayor in a court decision in a case accusing him of conflicts of interest.
In December last year, the acting mayor of Chernihiv, Oleksandr Lomako, resigned and also posted a video address to Mr. Zelensky accusing the military appointee of abusing powers. He said the military administrator had taken the city hostage.
Elections can only be held after martial law is lifted.
Analysts say that the largest problem in the relationships between military and civil administrations is the duplication of powers. It was not always the case.
Initially, when Mr. Zelensky created the Kyiv City Military Administration in February 2022, Mr. Klitschko as mayor automatically became its head. But later, to “improve the capital’s defense,” Mr. Zelensky said, he split the two roles, with Mr. Klitschko staying on as mayor, and a general, Mykola Zhernov, taking charge of the parallel military administration office for the city.
Members of Mr. Klitschko’s political party serving on the City Council regularly raise questions about the appropriateness of operating a separate military administration in the city after the Russians were pushed back from the capital nearly three years ago and the city became relatively well protected from missile strikes with air defenses.