INDEPENDENT 2026-01-07 00:02:15


Trump says ‘nobody can take us’ after US military’s stealth capture of Maduro

The Trump administration is weighing options to acquire Greenland, including the use of the military, days after completing a covert operation to capture Venezuela’s now-deposed President Nicolás Maduro.

“The president and his team are discussing a range of options to pursue this important foreign policy goal, and of course, utilizing the U.S. military is always an option at the Commander-in-Chief’s disposal,” the White House said Tuesday.

On Monday, White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller said on CNN, “The president has made clear for months now that the United States should be the nation that has Greenland as part of our overall security apparatus.”

Greenland, a mineral-rich Arctic island, is a self-governing territory of the Kingdom of Denmark.

Trump told reporters last Sunday Greenland is “so strategic right now,” adding the territory “is covered with Russian and Chinese ships all over the place.”

Also over the weekend, the U.S. captured Maduro and his wife, Cilia Flores, in Caracas. They both subsequently pleaded not guilty to drug and weapons charges in New York.

On Tuesday, six major European nations said in a joint statement: “Only Denmark and Greenland can decide on matters concerning their relations.”

21 minutes ago

Seven U.S. service members injured in Venezuela raid: report

Seven U.S. service members were injured in the operation that led to the capture of Venezuela’s now-deposed President Nicolás Maduro, the Associated Press reported, citing the Pentagon.

Out of those seven service members, two are still recovering from their injuries that occurred during Saturday’s raid.

A U.S. official told the AP the service members suffered from gunshot wounds and shrapnel injuries.

Rachel Dobkin6 January 2026 23:40
41 minutes ago

Democrat senator gladly backs Ruben Gallego’s war powers resolution to prevent Greenland invasion

Senator Tim Kaine, a Virginia Democrat, told The Independent Tuesday that he has gladly co-sponsored Senator Ruben Gallego’s war powers resolution to prevent President Donald Trump from invading Greenland.

The Arizona Democrat wrote on X on Monday, “Trump is on a high from his illegal operation in Venezuela and is bragging about potentially sending our young men and women into more stupid wars of conquest. Greenland could be next.”

Rachel Dobkin and Eric Garcia6 January 2026 23:20
1 hour ago

Watch: Chuck Schumer says he was ‘very disappointed’ by Trump administration’s answer when asked about targeting more countries

Rachel Dobkin6 January 2026 23:00
1 hour ago

Europe’s showdown with Trump over threat to Greenland

Europe set up a showdown with Donald Trump after its leaders joined Canada and Denmark to rally behind Greenland, insisting it “belongs to its people” as the US president doubled down on threats to imminently annex the strategic, mineral-rich island.

Despite backlash from Europe the White House insisted on Tuesday it is “discussing options for acquiring Greenland.”

“President Trump has made it well known that acquiring Greenland is a national security priority of the United States, and it’s vital to deter our adversaries in the Arctic region,” the Trump administration said in a statement.

“The president and his team are discussing a range of options to pursue this important foreign policy goal, and of course, utilising the U.S. military is always an option at the commander-in-chief’s disposal,” the statement added.

Earlier in the day, leaders of the UK, France, Germany, Italy, Poland and Spain had joined Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen in defending Greenland’s sovereignty.

“Greenland belongs to its people,” the statement said. “It is for Denmark and Greenland, and them only, to decide on matters concerning Denmark and Greenland.”

Read on…

Europe’s showdown with Trump over threat to Greenland

Nato unity put to the test as Keir Starmer and European allies warn US president he can’t decide future of Danish territory
Bel Trew6 January 2026 22:40
1 hour ago

Watch: Pam Bondi calls Nicolás Maduro a ‘monster’

Rachel Dobkin6 January 2026 22:25
1 hour ago

INSIDE STORY: What the Greenland locals really think of Trump – and why he could be in for a shock

When President Trump first said he wanted to buy Greenland, I asked many local people what they thought. I didn’t hear a single person say it would be a good idea then, and I am still waiting. As for the most recent soundbite from the president about looking down the coast and seeing “Russian and Chinese ships all over the place”, the typical response here is: “Trump is talking nonsense again.”

But then Katie Miller, the wife of Stephen Miller, a former senior adviser to Trump, posted a picture of Greenland draped in the American flag, accompanied by the ominous single word “SOON”, and suddenly everything feels a bit more serious. Not for nothing are Greenlandic people now flooding social media with pictures of Greenland in the colours of their flag.

Read on…

What the Greenland locals really think of Trump – and why he’s in for a shock

When Dennis Lehtonen, 30, left city life behind for one of the remotest places on Earth, he could not have imagined the extremes that awaited him. Three years later, after enduring –37C temperatures, using bags as toilets and sledding 20km to the nearest local shop, he explains why he has stayed – and what Greenland’s response to the US president really looks like
Dennis Lehtonen6 January 2026 22:19
1 hour ago

ANALYSIS: The White House wants to ‘own’ the Western hemisphere. Voters aren’t really buying it

Like a novice gambler whose response to a big win is to start betting bigger, the Trump White House is doubling down on their aggressive approach to the Americas in the wake of the U.S. military raid to capture Venezuelan dictator Nicolas Maduro over the weekend.

Over the four days that have elapsed since the daring, unprecedented — and according to critics, illegal — special forces action that brought Maduro from a Caracas safe house to a New York courtroom on drug and weapons charges, the president and his allies in the White House have proceeded to threaten or warn of military action against multiple American allies and neighbors, including Colombia, Cuba, Mexico, and Denmark, the NATO member kingdom which has controlled Greenland in whole or in part since the 16th century.

Trump himself told reporters on Sunday that the result of his decision to have U.S. forces seize Maduro was to show that “American dominance in the Western Hemisphere will never be questioned again,” while claiming that his administration’s aim was to make sure the hemisphere was filled with “countries around us that are viable and successful and where the oil is allowed to freely come out.”

For Trump, it was a return to the bellicose rhetoric he’d spouted since the days immediately following his 2024 election victory, when he began claiming the U.S. needs to annex Greenland for “national security” reasons despite the existence of a decades-old treaty that essentially gives America carte blanche to base troops there as part of the country’s commitment to NATO.

Read on…

The White House wants to ‘own’ the Western hemisphere. Voters aren’t really buying it

ANALYSIS: Trump still wants Greenland but Americans are overwhelmingly opposed to his expansionist dreams, writes Andrew Feinberg
Andrew Feinberg6 January 2026 22:16
1 hour ago

Trump is considering using military to acquire Greenland

The Trump administration is weighing options to acquire Greenland, including the use of the military.

“The president and his team are discussing a range of options to pursue this important foreign policy goal, and of course, utilizing the US military is always an option at the Commander-in-Chief’s disposal,” the White House said Tuesday.

Rachel Dobkin6 January 2026 22:04

Starmer prepares Brexit ‘reset’ bill to align UK with EU law

Sir Keir Starmer is preparing a bill which would hand ministers powers to bring the UK into alignment with EU law, as part of an attempt to reduce paperwork and boost growth in Britain.

The bill, which will be brought forward this year as part of the government’s Brexit reset, would give ministers overarching powers to bring the UK in line with EU law in certain areas, such as food standards, animal welfare and pesticide use – a process known as dynamic alignment.

It is understood that the new powers could be used to implement deals struck with the EU, such as agreements to align electricity and carbon markets, or plant and animal standards.

Ministers argue that dynamic alignment would have little material impact as UK food manufacturers have already largely followed EU rules since Brexit, but it is hoped that it would reduce expensive and time-consuming paperwork for suppliers who want to export to the single market.

But there are concerns that it would see the UK surrender control over its own laws.

When the UK was a member of the EU, the government previously had a vote on new laws being passed by Brussels. But now, the UK would need to accept the laws without a vote if it wants to remain in dynamic alignment with the trade bloc.

Both Conservative and Reform UK MPs are expected to oppose the plans, with the Tories accusing the prime minister of “surrendering our freedom” to appease his Labour backbenchers, and trying to “undo” Brexit.

But a Labour source argued that “all international agreements involve shared rules”.

Meanwhile, the Liberal Democrats are calling for the government to go even further and negotiate a customs union with the EU, accusing the government of having been “too timid” in its ambitions for closer ties with Brussels.

While the government has ruled out such a plan, sympathetic Labour MPs could rebel and vote with the Lib Dems.

Sir Keir has recently faced pressure from his own backbenchers to change course on a customs union, with some 13 Labour MPs backing proposals that would pave the way for such an arrangement in a Commons vote last month.

When he became prime minister, Sir Keir promised to reset Britain’s relationship with Brussels and rebuild ties with the bloc after years of tension and mistrust under the Conservatives.

And over the weekend, the prime minister signalled that the government would be prepared to align even more closely with the EU single market if the move is in the national interest.

Sir Keir insisted Britain should “go further” in strengthening post-Brexit ties with Brussels following a trade deal agreed earlier this year.

But he appeared to pour cold water on suggestions that the UK should rejoin a customs union with the bloc after his health secretary Wes Streeting said the arrangement had “enormous economic benefits”.

Speaking to the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg over the weekend, Sir Keir pointed to steps already taken to align with the EU more closely on agriculture and food, adding: “That’s the sovereign decision that we have taken.

“I think we should get closer, and if it’s in our national interest to have even closer alignment with the single market, then we should consider that, we should go that far.”

He added: “I think it’s in our national interest to go further.

“What I would say about the customs union is that I argued for a customs union for many years with the EU, but a lot of water has now gone under the bridge.

“I do understand why people are saying, ‘Wouldn’t it be better to go to the customs union?’ I actually think that now we’ve done deals with the US which are in our national interest, now we’ve done deals with India which are in our national interest, we are better looking to the single market rather than the customs union for our further alignment.”

The prime minister insisted freedom of movement – a core principle of the EU single market – was off the table as he faced questions about what concessions he was willing to offer in return.

A Labour source told The Independent: “The bill will give us the powers to share rules with the EU. All international agreements involve shared rules. That’s their very nature.

“We’re confident in making the case for specific trade-offs, where it has clear benefits for businesses and consumers.

“Kemi has a short memory – it wasn’t long ago she was making similar arguments, when she U-turned on the Brexit bonfire of EU regulation in the name of pragmatism and what works in the real world.

“Yet, the Tories and Reform are keen to protect a broken status quo and want to rip up our deal, all in the name of petty ideology.”

Police wrongly told parents their teenage son died in car crash

The family of a teenager badly injured in a car crash were wrongly told that he had died after police mixed him up with the actual victim.

South Yorkshire Police have referred themselves to the police watchdog over their identification process following their handling of the collision in Rotherham.

A 17-year-old girl was killed in the crash on Todwick Road on 13 December.

But officers also told the relatives of Trevor Wynn, 17, that he had died.

A young man who officers believed was Joshua Johnson, 18, was sedated in hospital after being injured.

But the force says that on Sunday, “information came to light” that led to further formal identification processes, including forensics, to be carried out.

Those tests showed that Trevor Wynn was the teenager in hospital and Joshua Johnson was killed.

“The families and surviving victim, Trevor, will be offered support from specialist officers and additional specialist services,” police said.

An 18-year-old was arrested on suspicion of causing death by dangerous driving, and a 19-year-old was arrested on suspicion of perverting the course of justice. Both are on bail pending further enquiries.

Assistant Chief Constable Colin McFarlane said: “This has obviously come as a huge shock to everyone and we recognise the additional trauma this may cause.

“We are supporting Trevor and all the families through this and have engaged specialist agencies to help provide that support.”

Mr McFarlane said he had offered to meet both sets of parents.

“I am sure they will have many questions, most of which we are not able to answer yet, but we are absolutely committed to understanding how this happened so it cannot happen again,” he said.

“We have taken the decision to refer ourselves to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) to consider our role in the identification processes which were followed following the road traffic collision.”

He said the force would co-operate fully with any investigation and would be led by the IOPC on finding out how it happened, and how to ensure it never happened again.

The police force said the families had asked that them to thank the public for their support but that they be left in peace “to process the future they now face”.

Unexploded bomb causes severe delays at major train station

An unexploded wartime bomb has been found near a major transport hub, causing an evacuation of passengers and severe delays.

Train services across Birmingham were disrupted on Tuesday morning after the device – believed to be an old mortar – was discovered near a railway line.

It was found at Duddeston Mill Trading Estate, on Duddeston Mill Road, Washwood Heath, at around 9.45am, triggering an immediate emergency response.

Lines between Birmingham New Street and Duddeston were closed as bomb disposal teams moved in, forcing major delays and cancellations on routes to Tamworth, Derby and Sheffield.

National Rail warned disruption could continue into the afternoon.

A 100‑metre exclusion zone was set up around the site while specialists assessed the device.

Network Rail said it was working with the police, adding that services would remain disrupted while the incident is made safe.

A spokesperson said: “We are currently supporting West Midlands Police as they deal with an incident in Duddeston.

“As a result, some train services are currently disrupted. We will keep you updated with information as we receive it.”

Later on Tuesday, West Midlands Police told The Independent that the device had been removed and services would reopen.

A spokesperson for West Midlands Police said: “The EOD bomb disposal team attended and made the mortar safe. The exclusion zone has been lifted and nearby railway line reopened.”

In an update, National Rail said: “All lines have now reopened following an earlier wartime bomb near the railway at Birmingham New Street.”

“Trains running to/from and through this station may continue to be cancelled, delayed by up to 50 minutes, revised or diverted.”

They added: “Disruption is now expected until 15:00.”

Thousands of unexploded Second World War bombs are found around the UK every year. Around 8,000 a year are dealt with by the private sector, while the military assists in larger operations.

Construction, dredging, and offshore projects frequently uncover unexploded ordnance, with those on land often found buried deep beneath the surface. At sea, the vast quantities of unexploded devices from both the First and Second World Wars are a significant hazard for offshore activities, including wind farms.

In 2024, a 500kg unexploded Nazi bomb was found by a man working on an extension in Plymouth. Hundreds of homes were evacuated in one of the country’s largest evacuations since the Second World War, and a military convoy was brought in to transport it through the streets. It was detonated at sea.

New CCTV released in hunt for convicted murderer after prison escape

Police have released CCTV images believed to be of a convicted murderer and a second prisoner who absconded from prison on New Year’s Day.

Avon and Somerset Police said they had received reported sightings of Matthew Armstrong and Daniel Washbourne, who absconded from HMP Leyhill, South Gloucestershire.

Armstrong, 35, was convicted of murdering someone during a robbery in Warwickshire in 2009, while Washbourne, 40, has previous convictions for violence against a person and false imprisonment.

The force said that two men matching their descriptions were pictured in Ashley Road, Bristol, at 10.35am on Saturday, and were seen walking towards the Stokes Croft area.

Then, on Sunday, between 9.35am and 9.45am, a man is seen walking along Filton Road and then Gloucester Road North in Filton, stopping at one stage to look at bus timetables, police said.

The man is wearing a burgundy coat matching the one worn by Armstrong when he left HMP Leyhill.

Police believe the man continued to walk along the same road and he is seen in the Patchway area between 11.05am and 11.15am.

The force said that neither Armstrong nor Washbourne are known to have any connection to Avon and Somerset and believes there is a “distinct possibility” that they travelled outside of the area.

Armstrong is described as a white, male, about 5ft 9in, with ginger hair, and has links to Warwickshire.

Washbourne is described as white, male, about 5ft 6in, slim, with brown hair, clean-shaven and has links to Herefordshire.

Aaron Thomas, 39, was charged with escaping the prison after being arrested in Bristol on Saturday and appeared before magistrates on Monday, Avon and Somerset Police said.

He is due to attend Bristol Crown Court next month, the force added.

Inside the living traditions of the Pyrenees of Catalonia

The Catalan Pyrenees is rightly celebrated as one of Europe’s great year-round adventure playgrounds. The region is packed with the kind of sensational ski resorts that make it one of the continent’s great winter destinations, and when the snow melts it transforms into a green, lake-dotted hikers’ idyll. What’s less well-known is that beyond the famous trails and peaks, the hills of Catalonia contain towns and villages alive with tradition, where the people enthusiastically maintain vibrant cultural practices some of which stretch for hundreds of years.

Take, for example, the Patum of Berga, a tradition that’s been celebrated annually during the feast of Corpus Christi for more than six centuries. Originally staged to teach people about the Holy Scriptures, the Patum has evolved over time into an intense and riotous carnival, which always lives up to its former name: Bullícia del Santíssim Sagrament (frenzy of the Blessed Sacrament). These days, locals crowd the streets to watch processions and performances featuring drummers and Guites (figures with a dragon’s head, giraffe’s neck, mule’s body, and horse’s tail), angels and mace-wielding demons, giants dancing to traditional Catalan melodies, and simulated battles in which the heroes always triumph. Because of the annual differences in the Easter cycle, it doesn’t have a fixed date but always takes place between the end of May and the end of June (in 2026, the main festival runs June 3rd-7th).

Summer solstice

Similarly raucous is the fiery summer Fallas festival in the high Pyrenees, which celebrates the summer solstice. The festivities take places in 17 villages, each of which has a slightly different tradition but all of which involve young people lighting two-metre-long flaming torches on high points in the mountains. They then walk towards their villages, dancing and drawing patterns with the lighted torches, guided by a local leader, until they reach a bonfire in the central square, which they light with the torch and traditional dances are performed.

Fire is a consistent theme across many of the longstanding traditions of the Catalan Pyrenees. Over in the village of Les in the Val d’Aran, Falles are quite different. The Crema de Eth Haro, which takes place on the eve of Saint John’s Day at the end of June, involves the burning of a tall fir tree trunk that was planted the year before. While the trunk burns, young people spin balls of fire called halhes (made of cherry bark and wire), the sparks of which are thought to bring the fire to every corner of the village.

Culinary traditions

The region is also home to some rich culinary traditions with long histories. Take, for example, the Carnaval de Solsona, a quirky, nine-day celebration where giant puppets parade through the streets, pranks unfold in the squares, and the whole town gathers for communal meals. Alongside the playful chaos, locals come together to share hearty winter dishes and regional specialities made from Solsonès produce, from rich stews to pork-based favourites. It’s a festival that blends satire, pageantry and food, bringing generations together around long tables in the main square to celebrate community, seasonality and the enduring flavours of the region.

For those looking for a rich sense of lived history, the Pyrenees of Catalonia are not just about festivals and food, the buildings are magnificent too. For an astonishing insight into life in the 12th and 13th Centuries, head to the beautifully preserved Romanesque churches in the Vall de Boí, near the border with Aragon. In all of Europe, Catalonia has perhaps the greatest collection of Romanesque murals; some of them in the National Art Museum of Catalonia in Barcelona, others in situ in these nine stunning churches. Don’t miss Sant Climent de Taüll, which was consecrated back in 1123; its atmospheric interior and beautiful tower are a portal to distant time through video mapping.

Plan your sustainable trip to the Pyrenees of Catalonia at visitpirineus.com/en

Labour drops behind Tories for first time since election ahead of crunch May vote

Labour has fallen behind the Conservatives in the polls for the first time since the general election, despite a new year relaunch for the party ahead of make-or-break elections in May.

Labour is on 17 per cent, only two points ahead of the Greens and behind the Tories, on 19 per cent, and Nigel Farage’s Reform UK, on 26 per cent, according to a YouGov poll for The Times.

The party is also just one point ahead of the Liberal Democrats, on 16 per cent, with the Greens on 15 per cent, the survey conducted on Sunday and Monday shows.

The timing is a blow to Sir Keir Starmer, who used a long interview on Sunday morning television to try to woo voters with a new campaign against the high cost of living.

In a sign of the difficulties his embattled government faces, however, he also warned rivals inside Labour not to move against him, saying that would “gift” Mr Farage the next general election, as speculation over the PM’s future mounts.

Labour faces potentially disastrous results in the local, Scottish and Welsh elections in May.

At the end of October, leading polling expert Professor Sir John Curtice warned Labour is “in severe trouble in Wales” after the by-election loss of the traditionally Labour seat of Caerphilly. There have been similar warnings over the elections to Holyrood and councils across England.

The polling will also make it harder for Sir Keir to win over his increasingly disgruntled MPs, who have forced a series of difficult U-turns on the government, most recently over the farmer inheritance tax before Christmas.

The poll was better news for the Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch, signalling the first time her party has overtaken Labour since their devastating landslide election defeat in 2024.

Sir Keir has called for cabinet discipline at the meeting of his top team and told senior ministers that their challenge for 2026 is to show “hard work, focus and determination” will help squeezed households.

As Donald Trump’s US continues to threaten Greenland, Sir Keir said: “Yes, there’s a world of uncertainty and upheaval, but tackling the cost of living remains and must remain our focus.”

He added: “At the next general election we will be judged on whether we’ve delivered on things that really matter – do people feel better off, are public services improving, for which they will look to the NHS, and do people feel more safe and secure in their own community.”

“They are the issues we will be judged on at the next general election, that is our focus.

“That will require hard work, focus and determination from all of us.

“Together, as a team, we will rise to that challenge and deliver for the whole country.”

Amorim was doomed to fail inside Man United’s broken machine

As almost everyone in football gleefully shares gossip about Manchester United, there is one detail that is provoking more intrigue. Many are asking whether Ruben Amorim was ultimately sacked over how he spoke to director of football Jason Wilcox in that now notorious Friday meeting. If so, it would seem a little over-sensitive for elite-end football.

It should be acknowledged there were sound football reasons for sacking Amorim. The football was often unwatchable and many results were unjustifiable, but league position shows this wasn’t irredeemable. And while the 1-1 against Wolves caused a shift that sparked serious discussion among the hierarchy on New Year’s Day, Friday appears to have brought the moment when an undesirable situation became “unsustainable”.

The feeling was only deepened after Amorim’s press conference at Leeds United, where some have since taken greater note of the specific managers the Portuguese referenced. “I know my name isn’t [Thomas] Tuchel, [Antonio] Conte or [Jose] Mourinho, but I’m the manager.”

Various sources now say these were the names that had been put to Amorim as an argument as to why he didn’t necessarily have the pedigree to speak in the way he had been.

One of the main triggers was nevertheless that discussion over tactics, and specifically the use of a back three. While this has primarily been put in the context of Amorim “blowing up”, the detail indicates more existential issues about the club.

It has since been reported that Wilcox favours the 4-3-3 that is central at Manchester City, even if he had previously not put it to Amorim.

Such a sentiment sums up the disconnect. As director of football, in any well-run club, it would specifically be Wilcox’s job to actually decide on team ideology.

At Manchester United? Well, who knows? There’s a strong argument that this is why Amorim was always destined to fail.

What the club really should have done in Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s first summer of 2024 was start from scratch and decide on an ideology, ensuring that dictated every single future decision – specifically recruitment in players and coaches.

They instead clumsily persevered with Erik ten Hag and then belatedly threw everything on a young coach who probably has the most fixed tactical approach in the modern game, but without the football infrastructure to support that.

It’s all the worse since Ratcliffe had actually told executives they would be taking this more holistic approach – that they would decide on style of play – before that, in February 2024. The minority owner instead immersed himself in the Amorim appointment, conducting a long one-on-one where he was said to be struck by the young coach’s personality.

It does beg the more pressing question of how major decisions at Old Trafford are made and why. Put bluntly, a club more obsessed with “identity” than any other doesn’t actually have one, at least not in the way that matters in the modern game.

That doesn’t just mean superficialities like “wingers” and “fast play”. It is about the clarity of what you want a team to look like.

For over a decade, obvious best practice has been to decide on an ideology – be that Pep Guardiola’s positional game, German high-energy high-pressing or any similarly defined model – and take everything from that.

It brings a crucial clarity.

These very words were actually said on these pages about United back in 2019.

Far from taking what are actually “best in class” decisions to improve on the Glazers, though, Ratcliffe’s leadership seems to be making all of this worse.

Even the prospective return of Ole Gunnar Solskjaer as interim emphasises it. They’re back to “DNA”, or “vibes”, in lieu of an actual idea.

That’s also why the debate over whether United can play three at the back has always been misplaced, and almost represents magical thinking. It’s not that they’re institutionally resistant. It’s that there’s insufficient clarity under the team.

And there is now an argument that, until Ratcliffe realises this, United are constantly going to be beset by confusion.

There are too many voices, when everyone knows the only voice that matters is the one that knows the least about football.

This can be sensed in the football structure, where there’s almost a contradiction. Ratcliffe has “empowered” what looks a modern setup, from director of recruitment Christoph Vivell and Wilcox through chief executive Omar Berrada, but then his own say goes well beyond just making the final decision on the decision fed up to him.

There are multiple illustrations of how counterproductively this works. One coach interviewed in 2024 got frustrated as he found there were four different stages of the process, each involving more officials, all being cast as “decision makers”. The candidate had never experienced anything like it. The interview questions were meanwhile described as “formulaic”.

When it came to meeting the actual decision-maker in Ratcliffe – and when it looked like an offer might come – it is claimed that was delayed for three days because the billionaire was “off cycling”. Some of this might have been exaggerated for comic effect, but the point stands.

The situation is also reflective of a bigger problem in modern football, which is the co-opting of the people’s game by a billionaire class.

Many major clubs are experiencing similar, from Chelsea to Tottenham Hotspur.

And, from speaking to multiple people who have worked with Ratcliffe, a few descriptions chime.

“Meddles with everything.”

“A nightmare to work with.”

“That specific billionaire arrogance where they think being successful in one field means they’re experts on everything else.”

“It’s micromanagement. These types can never relinquish control.”

Stories already abound about Ratcliffe imparting opinions on everything from running technique to recovery.

By the same token, sources involved in the 2022 takeover of Chelsea were baffled at the manner Ratcliffe came in late on. Although it had been presumed he would then just outbid everyone, the Ineos billionaire only offered to match the Clearlake bid without outlining actual plans. The feeling from those present was that he believed he’d “successfully run Ineos so this would be easy”.

And while Dan Ashworth has obviously been reappraised this week for his caution against the Amorim appointment, that is not seen by sources as the main reason he left. It is said Ashworth made his feelings clear on Ratcliffe constantly getting involved in football.

Such an account obviously has implications for the profile of United’s current leadership. How open is Ratcliffe to alternative opinion? Would he make the same cost-cutting decisions now given anyone could have told him that such measures erode club culture for negligible financial gain?

Insiders meanwhile maintain Ratcliffe has repeatedly been frustrated with decision-making, to the point there have been so many changes in leadership. Remember Dave Brailsford?

Again, some of this would be easily solved by deciding on an actual football identity that provides guardrails for all decisions.

Instead, it’s Ratcliffe’s personality that sounds like the only guardrail. Is this really conducive to anyone making assured decisions on their own terms? Everyone always has to second-guess their boss.

It has also been noted that many of the appointments, from Wilcox to Berrada, are new to these roles. Figures at United’s rivals have been baffled by this, simply due to the amount of inexperience for key roles in a major club.

This is partly why Vivell is viewed as increasingly influential, due to his credentials in recruitment from Red Bull. Julian Nagelsmann is consequently seen as a summer candidate due to that connection, too.

The lack of a deeper identity, however, even shapes that football essential of talent ID. Insiders talk of how Ratciffe’s United seem obsessed with surveying who does things well and just trying to import that – even if they are elements that are now standard in football – when they should instead be looking to what’s next and trying to get ahead of the curve rather than playing catch-up. The latter was Ferran Soriano’s dictum at City, often using the analogy of boat races.

Instead, Ratcliffe saw that City were successful and made appointments from there, apparently overlooking how the key reason for City’s success was limitless money from Abu Dhabi ownership.

There is now said to be an overt focus on the analytics revolution at Brighton and Brentford.

That’s fine, but, again, it’s been done for years and United don’t have access to the unique data of either owner. More pressingly, United aren’t buying players to sell them on. They’re buying to win.

For United’s part, it is encouraging that they resisted some of Amorim’s transfer demands to instead sign players better suited to multiple approaches, even if it typically went against the Portuguese’s perception of his discussions with Ratcliffe.

The feelings of one candidate for the job ring out. When he previously spoke to United, the club were talking about building the best training ground in the world.

The coach found himself thinking “this is the wrong way around”. They were going for an interior decorator when they first needed to gut the house.

They next need to decide what they actually want it to look like.

Leave a Reply