The New York Times 2024-09-11 12:10:39


Middle East Crisis: Rescuers Struggle to Reach Victims After Israel Targets Militants in Tent Camp

Top News

Israel strikes a humanitarian area, and Gazan officials say at least 19 people are killed.

Israeli airstrikes slammed into a humanitarian area in southern Gaza early Tuesday, leaving large craters where Palestinians had crowded for shelter and, according to Gazan officials, killing or wounding dozens of people.

The Israeli military said in a statement that the strikes had targeted three senior Hamas militants who had been involved in the Oct. 7 Hamas-led assault on Israel.

Gaza’s Health Ministry said at least 19 people were confirmed dead and more than 60 others injured — figures that appeared likely to rise because it said that there were still victims in the area, including some buried in rubble and sand, and that ambulances had not been able to reach them. Health officials in Gaza do not distinguish between civilians and combatants when reporting casualties.

An official with Civil Defense emergency services in Gaza, Muhammad al-Mughaier, had said that 40 bodies were recovered from the site of the strike. The reason for the discrepancy was not immediately clear, although official accounts of death tolls often fluctuate in the early hours after an attack.

The Israeli military said in a statement that the figures from Civil Defense “do not align with the information” it has, but did not offer its own casualty estimate or comment on the numbers from the Health Ministry. It said it had carried out a “precise strike” and had tried to mitigate the risk to civilians, though it declined to answer questions from The Times about the specific steps it had taken.

Videos of the aftermath of the attack verified by The New York Times show craters in the southwestern part of Al-Mawasi, where satellite imagery from a week earlier showed several tents. Images taken at the scene Tuesday morning show people searching in rubble using the lights on their phones, and emergency workers from the Palestine Red Crescent Society digging with shovels.

Palestinians sheltering in Al-Mawasi said the strike came without warning around midnight or 1 a.m., with large explosions jolting their tents and filling them with smoke.

“It was like an earthquake,” said Marwan Shaath, a 57-year-old civil servant from the southern Gaza city of Rafah who has been sheltering with his family in Al-Mawasi for more than three months. “The entire area, and of course the tent, all kept shaking.”

Fatoom al-Garra, a 30-year-old widow from Rafah, said she and her children ran for safety from sounds of “horror” and a burning smell. “We couldn’t see anything as black smoke and dust were covering the area,” she said.

Another witness, Dr. Majed Jaber, said that he had been a few hundred feet away from where the strikes hit and that the massive strength of the explosions had been shocking, even for someone who had experienced 11 months of relentless bombardment.

Dr. Jaber, who has been living in Al-Mawasi after being displaced from Gaza City early in the war, said he had run to the scene to look for survivors and had found it covered in “shrapnel, the remnants of tents, the remnants of people.”

People who arrived first to the scene of the attack tried to deliver first aid with whatever materials were around them until ambulances arrived, using victims’ own clothing to stanch their bleeding and scraps of wood and metal to stabilize broken bones, Dr. Jaber said. He recalled working on one boy, about 10, whose legs had been blown off by shrapnel. He realized after several minutes that he recognized the child from around the tent camp.

“I’m still trying to process what happened,” Dr. Jaber said in a phone interview ahead of a 24-hour shift volunteering at the European Gaza Hospital. He was trying not to dwell on the scene too much, he said, “because it’s going to break me down.”

Al-Mawasi, a once sparsely populated part of southern Gaza, is now packed with tens of thousands of Palestinians who took shelter there. The Israeli military has designated the area as a humanitarian zone, but it has maintained that it will go after militants wherever it believes them to be. Israeli airstrikes also hit the area in July, in operations the military said were aimed at Hamas commanders. At the time, Gaza health officials said that strike had killed scores of people.

In its statement on Tuesday, the Israeli military said that it had conducted aerial surveillance in the hours before the strike that it said confirmed the presence of militants in the area where it struck.

Israeli has long said that Hamas embeds itself among civilians to use them as human shields. International law experts have said Israel still has a responsibility to protect civilians during its military operations. More than 40,000 people have been killed in Gaza in 11 months of war, according to the Gazan Health Ministry, whose figures do not distinguish between civilians and combatants.

The U.N. special coordinator for the Middle East peace process, Tor Wennesland, condemned the strike. “The killing of civilians must stop, and this horrific war must end,” he said.

The United Nations and other rights organizations have said that there is no safe place in Gaza. Almost the entire population of Gaza — more than two million Palestinians — has been displaced multiple times. Israel has ordered frequent evacuations and has shrunk the size of the humanitarian zone, forcing an increasing number of Palestinians to squeeze into ever tighter areas.

Ms. al-Garra said that Israel’s urgings to seek shelter in Al-Mawasi were hollow.

“What safety are they talking about?” she said. “There is no safety.”

Farnaz Fassihi, Anushka Patil, Iyad Abuheweila and Adam Rasgon contributed reporting.

Here are the latest photos from the Middle East Crisis.

2,000-pound bombs were likely used in the Mawasi strike, according to weapons experts and a Times analysis.

Large craters and a bomb fragment from an Israeli airstrike on a camp for displaced people early Tuesday provide strong evidence that Israel used 2,000-pound bombs, according to three weapons experts.

The United States has previously warned Israel that the powerful munitions can cause excessive civilian casualties in the densely populated Gaza Strip, and suspended exporting U.S.-made 2,000-pound bombs to Israel earlier this year.

Israel said it had carried out “precise strikes” aimed at Hamas militants, but has so far declined to say what sort of bombs were used. At least 19 people were killed in the blasts and more than 60 others injured, Gazan authorities said, a toll that appeared likely to rise. Health officials in Gaza do not distinguish between civilians and combatants when reporting casualties.

Video filmed after the attack and verified by The New York Times showed two enormous blast craters measuring close to 50 feet wide. Satellite imagery captured on Monday showed no craters at the location, confirming they were new.

One of the weapons experts — Chris Cobb-Smith, a former British Army artillery officer and director of Chiron Resources, a security and logistics agency told The Times that the dimensions of the craters were broadly consistent with the use of 2,000-pound munitions.

“The dimensions of the crater indicate it’s likely that this strike involved the use of a 2,000-pound aerial dropped bomb by the I.D.F.,” Mr Cobb-Smith said, referring to the Israel Defense Forces.

A second expert, Trevor Ball, a former U.S. Army explosive ordnance disposal technician, identified a weapons fragment found at the scene as “the tail section of a SPICE-2000 kit,” a precision guidance kit that is used with 2,000-pound bombs.

A third expert, Patrick Senft, at the consulting firm Armament Research Services, also said that “one fragment is visually consistent with the tail section of a SPICE 2000 guidance kit, suggesting that at least one 2,000-pound bomb was employed.” He noted that the large craters also indicated the use of a heavyweight bomb.


In its campaign in Gaza, Israel has routinely used 2,000-pound bombs, which shatter into razor-sharp fragments that can kill or incapacitate people over several hundred feet.

When Washington suspended the export of U.S.-made 2,000-pound bombs in May, officials said their use could lead to wide civilian casualties and were not needed by the Israelis. Biden administration officials said at the time they were especially worried about the damage that could be done by such bombs in a crowded area with many displaced civilians.

Mr. Cobb-Smith underscored that concern, saying, “Such bombs have the technological ability to be highly accurate, but I consider the use of a munition in a densely populated area, and one designated as a ‘safe zone’ to be disproportionate.”

The area targeted in Khan Younis was part of a humanitarian zone that Gazans had been instructed to move to. Satellite imagery reviewed by The Times shows that temporary structures, including tents, began to fill the area starting in February and expanded through the year, especially following evacuation orders in the southern city of Rafah in May.

Images captured by witnesses and local journalists posted online on Tuesday morning and verified by The New York Times showed a devastating scene as emergency service workers and other residents used shovels and their hands to try to find bodies in and around the craters.

Other videos, also verified by The Times show furniture, clothes and other household items strewn around a wide area, and a car almost completely immersed under the sand. What appeared to be greenhouses situated adjacent to the strike were mostly destroyed.

In satellite imagery captured about a day before the attack, around a dozen tents and other temporary structures can be seen in the area that was directly hit. They were destroyed in the attack, as were dozens of other tents surrounding the area, which could no longer be seen in photos and videos of the aftermath.

The area was previously targeted by Israeli airstrikes, including a similar attack using 2,000-pound bombs in July targeting a top Hamas commander, Mohammed Deif, less than two miles away.

The I.C.C. prosecutor presses the court for arrest warrants for Hamas chiefs and Israeli leaders.

The chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Karim Khan, called this week for a swift decision on issuing arrest warrants for a top Hamas official in connection with the Oct. 7 Hamas-led attack on Israel and the Israeli prime minister and defense minister over Israel’s response and conduct of the war in Gaza.

“In light of the worsening situation in Palestine,” Mr. Khan said in a filing, a decision should be made with the “utmost urgency.”

Mr. Khan asked the court in May to issue arrest warrants for three Hamas leaders behind the Oct. 7 Hamas-led attack on Israel on charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity. The leaders were Yahya Sinwar, Ismail Haniyeh and Muhammad Deif. He sought the warrants for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel and his defense minister, Yoav Gallant, on the same charges, citing Israel’s prosecution of the war in Gaza after that attack.

In the latest filing, on Monday, Mr. Khan withdrew his request for a warrant for Mr. Haniyeh, citing his death. Mr. Haniyeh was assassinated in Tehran in late July. Mr. Khan said he was working on establishing the death of Mr. Deif, who the Israeli military said in August had been killed in a strike on Gaza the previous month.

Mr. Khan said in his filing that warrants for Mr. Sinwar, Mr. Deif and the two Israeli ministers were needed to “ensure that they do not obstruct or endanger the investigation or court proceedings” and to “prevent the continuing commission of the crimes alleged.”

The filing conveyed muted frustration, noting that the court had granted multiple requests for submissions and extensions by various parties, sometimes without explaining the relevance of these proposed contributions.

Mr. Khan’s request for a swift decision on the warrants comes at a precarious moment in the war in Gaza. The death toll among Palestinians is nearing 41,000, according to officials in Gaza, who do not distinguish between combatant and civilian casualties. And negotiations have stalled over a cease-fire agreement between Israel and Hamas that would secure the release of about 60 living hostages and the remains of about 35 others still being held in Gaza.

The filing also follows Israeli officials’ announcement last week that autopsies of the bodies of six hostages that the Israeli military discovered in a tunnel under Gaza showed that the hostages had been shot at close range shortly before they were found, compounding demands in Israel that Mr. Netanyahu reach an agreement with Hamas.

The Israeli military on Tuesday released a video revealing the extreme conditions in which those hostages were held before their deaths, underscoring the urgent need for an agreement. Protesters in Israel have taken to the streets repeatedly since the bodies were discovered to demand a hostage deal, and hundreds were out again in Tel Aviv on Tuesday.

Mr. Netanyahu’s office, in a statement on Tuesday, called the prosecutor’s comparison of government ministers who fight “according to the laws of war” with Mr. Sinwar of Hamas “who executes Israeli hostages in cold blood” both “antisemitic” and a “moral disgrace of the first order.”

The Israeli military details the brutal conditions six hostages endured before they were killed in a tunnel.

The Israeli military released new information on Tuesday about the six hostages whose bodies were recently discovered in a tunnel in Gaza, including video of the tunnel and details that shed light on the brutal conditions in which they were held.

The hostages appear to have spent the last weeks of their lives in a suffocatingly tight and humid tunnel that was approximately 5.5 feet tall and just 30 to 40 inches wide, Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, the military’s chief spokesman, said on Tuesday.

When a military forensic team entered the tunnel, in the Tel al-Sultan area of the southern city of Rafah, they found a harrowing scene. Video released by the military on Tuesday showed the cramped space, with bags of supplies and thin mattresses leaning on the concrete walls. Pools of dried blood could be seen on its dirt floor. The New York Times was not able to independently verify the video.

“When you see the blood in the tunnel, it is very, very hard to think also about other hostages being held in those kinds of conditions in many places in Gaza,” said Admiral Hagari. “We are obligated and committed to do everything we can, by all means, to bring back home all the hostages.”

The six hostages found earlier this month were Carmel Gat, 40; Eden Yerushalmi, 24; Hersh Goldberg-Polin, 23; Alexander Lobanov, 32; Almog Sarusi, 27; and Ori Danino, 25.

In addition to the hostages and their captors, the narrow tunnel also held mattresses, clothes and food, including energy bars and cans of tuna, and the military also found an improvised bucket toilet and multiple sacks that held bottles filled with urine, Admiral Hagari said. That led them to believe the hostages were kept in the space “for weeks, not days.”

The military also found the magazines and shells from AK-47 rifles, and an examination of the hostages’ bodies showed they were killed by two weapons, which led the military to believe two individual kidnappers killed them, he said. He did not think those kidnappers were still alive, however.

“I think there is a probability that we already killed them,” Mr. Hagari said. “When we verify it we will go the families and then verify that to the public.”

The military said it believes the hostages were killed on Thursday, Aug. 29, the day before their bodies were found. The military issued its first public statement about the finding on Saturday, Aug. 31. In the early hours of the next day, the military began to remove the bodies after inspecting the tunnel for booby traps, Admiral Hagari said.

The tunnel was approximately 20 meters underground, and the video released by the Israeli military showed that its vertical shaft opened from the floor of a room whose walls were painted with cheerful images: Mickey Mouse, Snow White, and a large red heart with the word “love” on it.

The captives were held about 120 meters from the vertical tunnel shaft, behind a heavy iron door, he said, describing it as “a passageway tunnel” with a ceiling of arched concrete that was so low the hostages could not stand up straight.

The Hostages Families Forum, which represents relatives of many of the captives, said in a statement on Monday that the families of the six hostages were briefed on the Israeli military investigation. It described the conditions as “an utterly horrific reality.”

Admiral Hagari said on Tuesday that some of the families had found their briefings to be disturbing because “it was very hard for them to see how their loved ones survived and were murdered in those conditions.”

Ephrat Livni Livni contributed reporting

Israel says its forces likely shot an American protester ‘unintentionally,’ as Blinken says killing is ‘not acceptable.’

The Israeli military said on Tuesday that it was highly likely that a slain American activist was “unintentionally” struck by Israeli gunfire last week at a protest in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, as Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken said the killing was “not acceptable.”

In the toughest criticism the United States has leveled at Israel over the death of the activist, Aysenur Eygi, Mr. Blinken said that “no one should be shot and killed for attending a protest.” He said she was the second American to be killed by Israeli security forces in recent years, after a Palestinian American journalist was fatally shot in the West Bank in 2022.

“Israeli security forces need to make some fundamental changes to the way they operate in the West Bank, including changes to their rules of engagement,” he said at a news conference in London.

The Israeli military, in a statement describing its initial inquiry into Ms. Eygi’s death last Friday, expressed regret over her killing and said that it had meant to target a person it described as a “key instigator” of the protest, which it called “a violent riot.”

But eyewitnesses vehemently disputed Israel’s justifications for opening fire, saying that the clashes had finished by the time Ms. Eygi, was shot, and that they had occurred in a separate location. They said Ms. Eygi and the other protesters were more than 200 yards away from the soldiers, who were in an elevated position, when the fatal shot was fired.

Palestinians have long said that Israel uses excessive force against them at clashes and protests in the West Bank, but the death of Ms. Eygi has shined a spotlight on the issue. An autopsy report obtained and reviewed by The Times found that a bullet hit Ms. Eygi’s head near her left ear.

The criminal investigation division of the military police has been investigating the episode and will share its findings with military prosecutors later, the Israeli military said.

On Tuesday, Ms. Eygi’s family called the military’s preliminary inquiry “wholly inadequate,” saying it was deeply offended by the suggestion that her killing “was in any way unintentional.”

“The disregard shown for human life in the inquiry is appalling,” the family said in a statement. “This cannot be misconstrued as anything except a deliberate, targeted and precise attack by the military against an unarmed civilian,” they added.

The family also demand that President Biden and other senior U.S. officials order an independent investigation into “the Israeli military’s deliberate targeting and killing of a U.S. citizen.”

Mr. Biden was asked about the Israeli statement just before boarding a helicopter outside the White House. “Apparently it was an accident, ricocheted off the ground and just got hit by accident,” he told reporters. That went beyond any explanation offered publicly by the Israeli military, and Mr. Biden did not say what it was based on.

Human rights advocates said Israel has a history of failing to take meaningful action against soldiers accused of wrongdoing in the West Bank.

“We absolutely do not expect meaningful accountability to emerge this case,” said Sarit Michaeli, a spokesman for the Israeli rights group B’Tselem. “Similar incidents occur against Palestinians all the time and they don’t lead to any real consequences for perpetrators.”

As of Tuesday afternoon, three key eyewitnesses said the military had not contacted them to collect their testimony.

The bullet, according to the autopsy conducted by forensic examiners at An-Najah National University in Nablus, penetrated Ms. Eygi’s head near her left ear, leading to major bleeding in the area. Fragments of the bullet were recovered, including one that was approximately 5 millimeters by 5 millimeters by 4 millimeters, and handed over to the office of the Palestinian Authority’s attorney general, the report said.

The autopsy said that the cause of death was “bleeding, edema, and laceration of brain matter,” adding that a CT scan of Ms. Eygi’s body did not show other injuries.

The office of the Palestinian Authority’s attorney general confirmed that it had received the fragments of the bullet and transferred them to a criminal investigations laboratory directed by the Palestinian police. The office declined to respond to further questions, saying it would not discuss other details about Ms. Eygi’s case while its investigation was ongoing.

Ms. Eygi, a Turkish American dual citizen who immigrated to the United States from Turkey as an infant and lived in Seattle, had recently arrived in the West Bank to join activists affiliated with the International Solidarity Movement, who demonstrate alongside Palestinians in the West Bank. On Friday, she joined the protest in the northern West Bank village of Beita, where residents have been demonstrating for years — sometimes violently — against a settler outpost on lands claimed by the village. The Israeli government recently said it would legalize the outpost.

The Israeli military said on Friday that soldiers had “responded with fire toward a main instigator of violent activity” who had thrown stones at Israeli forces and posed a threat.

Witnesses at the scene confirmed that some protesters had hurled rocks at Israeli troops, who responded with tear gas and gunfire, but they stressed those clashes had ended by the time Ms. Eygi was shot. “There was no stone-throwing and it was calm for a few minutes,” said Eran Maoz, an Israeli activist who was at the protest.

Jonathan Pollak, 42, a second Israeli activist, said he was roughly 50 feet away from Ms. Eygi at the protest. He said the soldiers were standing at an elevated location at least 240 yards from her, undermining the assertion that their safety was threatened.

“She was not involved in the confrontations at any point,” said Mr. Pollak. “She was taking cover next to an olive tree when an Israeli soldier shot her dead without justification.”

No one in the area, Mr. Pollak said, was known to be carrying firearms other than the Israeli forces.

The demonstrations around Beita began before the current war between Israel and Hamas. Israeli settlers took over a nearby hilltop in 2021, erecting an outpost known as Evyatar on land claimed by the village. That prompted months of deadly protests in which several residents of Beita were killed and scores wounded.

The outpost was illegal under Israeli law when it was established, lacking Israeli government authorization. But in June, Israel’s cabinet agreed to retroactively legalize Evyatar and four other outposts, following a demand by Bezalel Smotrich, the hard right Israeli finance minister and a settler leader.

Most of the world considers all Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank to be illegal under international law, which Israel disputes. Roughly 500,000 Israeli settlers live in the territory alongside some three million Palestinians, who live under Israeli military occupation.

Over the past several days, friends and fellow activists have mourned her death, calling her a staunch supporter of marginalized communities.

“She was passionate about helping others and every action she did was through a lens of compassion and care,” Juliette Majid, a close friend who studied with Ms. Eygi at the University of Washington, said in an interview. “It’s heartbreaking that we lost such a human being.”

Edward Wong contributed reporting from London and Aaron Boxerman and Hiba Yazbek from Jerusalem.

Polio vaccinations begin in northern Gaza after Israel detained a U.N. convoy.

United Nations officials said that health workers began vaccinating children in northern Gaza against polio on Tuesday, but noted that convoys carrying critical supplies of fuel and medicine were facing increasing obstruction and delays caused by Israeli forces.

The main U.N. aid agency operating in Gaza said that the Israeli military had detained a convoy of international and local staff members from various U.N. bodies at gunpoint for about eight hours on Monday as they traveled to northern Gaza to help roll out the polio vaccination campaign.

Stéphane Dujarric, the U.N. spokesman, told reporters at a news briefing on Tuesday that the conduct of Israeli forces had endangered the lives of the U.N. staff and ran contrary to mandated protections under international humanitarian law. He described a volatile encounter that unfolded after Israeli troops stopped the convoy at a checkpoint and said they wanted to hold two of its members for questioning.

“The situation escalated very quickly, with soldiers pointing their weapons directly towards our personnel in the convoy. The U.N. vehicles were encircled by Israeli forces and shots were fired,” he said. The convoy was then approached by Israeli tanks and a bulldozer, “which proceeded to ram the U.N. vehicles from the front and from the back, compacting the convoy with U.N. staff inside.”

Israeli forces continued to hold the convoy at gunpoint while senior U.N. officials attempted to de-escalate the situation with Israeli authorities, Mr. Dujarric said. The two staff members were interrogated and eventually released, and the convoy returned to U.N. bases without being able to complete its mission.

The Israeli military said in a statement that it had intelligence suggesting there were “Palestinian suspects” with the convoy but did not say what they were suspected of doing. In another statement on Tuesday, it said that “Israeli security forces questioned the suspects in the field and then released them.”

The episode highlighted the challenges facing humanitarian efforts like the vaccination campaign and what U.N. officials say is increasing Israeli obstruction of aid deliveries to Gaza.

The United Nations delivered the first of two doses of oral vaccine to 446,000 Gazan children in the center and south of Gaza in two operations earlier this month as part of a campaign negotiated with Israel to halt the quick-spreading polio virus. The global body aimed to vaccinate roughly 200,000 more children in the north of Gaza in the third phase, lasting through Thursday, and then to repeat the whole operation in a month’s time to deliver the second oral vaccine dose.

The Israeli military said the convoy halted on Monday was “for a U.N. personnel rotation.” UNRWA said the convoy was specifically bringing a U.N. team into the north to help roll out the vaccination campaign, and the World Health Organization said it was also bringing fuel and medical supplies to Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City.

“Unfortunately, it’s not isolated,” the W.H.O. spokesman Tarik Jasarevic said of the convoy’s detention, reporting that four attempts by the agency to deliver supplies to Al-Shifa in the last four days had failed. He added that the number of applications for aid deliveries that ended up being rejected by the Israeli authorities had more than doubled in August, compared with previous months.

The Israeli military said it was looking into the claims.

The anti-polio campaign kicked off a little more than a week ago, aiming to prevent an outbreak of the quick-spreading disease among Gaza’s children. Both Hamas and Israel agreed to staggered pauses in the fighting in certain areas to allow the vaccinations to take place.

Patrick Kingsley and Rawan Sheikh Ahmad contributed reporting.

The Bomb Shelters Are Busy. So Are the Nail Salons.

Viktoria Gulieva sat in a hot-pink armchair wearing a denim tube dress over her pregnant belly and her dark hair slicked back in a tight bun. Her white Pomeranian dog perched on her lap. A salon worker delicately painted pale pink polish onto her toenails, which were spread apart by heart-shaped foam separators.

“We do our nails because this is like emotional support for us,” said Ms. Gulieva, 30, herself a beautician. “We do something to feel better. Because of everything going on, because of the war, we are on an emotional edge. If we get our nails done, we can at least look at our hands, and say, ‘Those look good.’”

Paying attention to beauty may seem a trivial concern when the very fate of Ukraine is at stake, with Russia stepping up its bombardment of Ukraine’s cities and Moscow’s troops grinding forward on the eastern front. But for many women, it is an important ritual of daily life.

The act of keeping up appearances has also become a small way for Ukrainians to show Russia that this war has not broken them.

Even a simple act of pampering can be difficult to carry out. Power outages and air-raid sirens can make it difficult for women to have their nails done — yet many clearly make the effort. Cases in point: a surly bank teller with polished tan fingernails punctuated by glittery pale swirls, a friendly waitress with fingernails painted like blue crocodile skin, a government worker in a Kyiv suburb who once attended up to a dozen funerals a day and helped supervise the digging of mass graves but who still sports a perfect French manicure.

Since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022, Ukrainian women have adapted. They still wear long shiny dresses in Kyiv, the capital, but with practical shoes, often white tennies — making it easier to move quickly if an air raid siren goes off. They tie their hair into complicated updos when a lack of power means no hot water. A female Ukrainian soldier on the front lines posted her beauty ritual on Instagram: how she braids her long reddish-brown hair, how she does a gel manicure wearing camouflage.

The general manager of L’Oréal in Ukraine recently also described how beauty rituals boosted people’s morale, calling it the “red lipstick effect.” Even women who have taken jobs in the mines — because the men who once worked there are serving in the army — sometimes sport long red fingernails.

“Our women are unstoppable,” said Donna Todorova, manager at Kukla salon, where Ms. Gulieva had her nails painted.

Women in Ukraine have a reputation for beautiful nails, and the country’s nail professionals — called “nail masters” here — are coveted hires at salons throughout Europe. Their manicures are often not bland monochromatic nails: Every nail has long been seen as its own canvas, often detailed like a miniature painting.

But after Russia’s invasion, nails became something else. Many women decorated their nails with patriotic symbols, painted blue and yellow for the country’s flag, or with sunflowers, ubiquitous in Ukrainian fields, or red poppies, officially designated as a symbol of remembrance for the war’s dead. A salon called Mimi Miss in Kyiv still advertises on Instagram by saying, “Choose us — invest in the death of the enemies,” next to patriotic blue and yellow hearts.

Fingernails also became ways to identify the dead. A clinic employee killed by missile debris in Kyiv in July was recognized by her pink manicure with the white polka dots, the victim’s daughter said. A heating plant operator shot by Russian forces while riding her bike in the Kyiv suburb of Bucha in March 2022 was identified by her manicure: four red nails and the fifth, painted white, with a small purple heart bordered in silver.

Back then, when Russian troops pushed toward Kyiv, they took over a beauty salon in Bucha called Profi, near a major intersection and some of the worst carnage. Snipers set up in the salon window on the second floor, shooting at cars and buses, recalled the owner, Iryna Davydovych, adding that her family had stayed in the basement of their nearby home before escaping to live nearby with her mother. The Ukrainian Army then pushed the Russian invaders out.

“The Russians left behind destruction and a lot of trash,” Ms. Davydovych, 54, recalled.

In April 2022, just in time for the Easter holiday, Ms. Davydovych and her husband finished cleaning up the salon, and electricity was restored. The business reopened. Ms. Davydovych’s husband then joined the army. He’s still on the front lines.

“Sometimes you sit down and cry,” she said. “But in the morning you get up, put on lipstick, go out looking beautiful and water the flowers.”

Fifteen people now work at Profi, including four nail masters. Tetiana Kravchenko, known as Tania, is so popular that she is booked up weeks in advance. On a recent Wednesday, she painted the nails of Natalia Fomenko in designs of fluorescent green and black.

“We follow Tania around,” said Ms. Fomenko, who also brings her husband to the salon. “If she ever goes to Kyiv, we’ll follow her to Kyiv.” If Ms. Kravchenko isn’t working, Ms. Fomenko added, “it’s a catastrophe.”

“I’m always here,” Ms. Kravchenko said, bent over her work.

Now, perhaps in a nod to the third year of the war and to people’s moods, the patriotic symbols on nails are rarer. The most popular styles in Ukraine are nudes, French manicures and the occasional bright pastel, nail masters said. Ms. Kravchenko said that more women were opting for practical manicures. “Natural — it’s the new trend,” she said, waving her hands, which were manicured but not painted.

Still, at Kukla, one 21-year-old nail master — who decided on her future profession when she was in the ninth grade — likes to show off her artistic creations, in which she glues delicate butterflies onto fingernails or even pierces them with hoops.

Every customer at Kukla had a war story.

Ms. Gulieva’s family once owned their own beauty salon, on the left bank of the Dnipro River. In March 2022, a rocket destroyed the salon, shattering the panoramic windows and ruining much of its equipment for hydro peeling and permanent makeup, Ms. Gulieva recalled. She fled to Germany, along with her mother, sister and brother. But a few months later, Ms. Gulieva returned, against her mother’s wishes, to be near her husband, who had joined the army on the front line. Her mother and sister now work in German salons.

Clients sometimes call Kukla to ask about potential cancellations because of power outages or missile strikes, but that rarely happens. On July 8, when missile strikes killed more than 42 people across Ukraine, mostly in the capital Kyiv, workers and salon employees took shelter in a nearby subway station.

“When the air raid was over, the customers returned and the nail technicians continued their work,” Ms. Todorova said. “As far as I remember, nobody canceled their appointments that day.”

Dzvinka Pinchuk and Evelina Riabenko contributed reporting.

Discover The Times with our best offer: 

$0.50/week for your first year.

Sale. Don’t miss out
$0.50/week for your first 6 months year.
Billed as $2 every 4 weeks, then $12 thereafter.

Learn more

Unwilling to Be Human Shields, Some Gazans Turn Gunmen Away From Shelters

When the war forced Nasser al-Zaanin to flee his home in northern Gaza in October, he, along with his adult sons and grandchildren, moved to a school that had been turned into a shelter.

There, at the Abdul Kareem al-Aklouk school in the town of Deir al Balah, he helped set up a system of committees to improve life for families who had taken refuge. The committees oversaw food, water and medical needs, and they had one red line: No armed men were allowed in the compound.

Residents, already forced to evacuate their homes because of Israel’s intense bombardment, wanted to avoid becoming a target for Israeli forces hunting down Hamas militants. Every few days in recent weeks, Israel has hit a school building turned shelter where it has said militants are hiding, including on Saturday, when it struck two compounds in northern Gaza that it said Hamas was using as a military base.

Early in the conflict, Mr. Zaanin said, Hamas had wanted to station police officers at the shelter where he was staying. The group said it would ensure security, but he said the residents had gathered to stop that.

“All the families agreed,” said Mr. Zaanin, 56, who once worked as a civil servant for the Palestinian Authority in Gaza.

“We simply want to save all families, women and children and not let there be any potential threat against us because of the existence of police and members of the Hamas government,” he said. The police, Mr. al-Zaanin added, could stand outside the building but not inside.

Several other residents of school shelters in central Gaza recounted similar stories, though attitudes in other areas were unknown. It is hard to know how widespread the phenomenon is, and whether the armed militia are from Hamas, Islamic Jihad or other armed gangs, but these residents’ experiences suggest that at least some evacuees have blocked armed militias from moving into these shelters.

“We will quickly kick anyone who has a gun or a rifle out of this school,” said Saleh al-Kafarneh, 62, who lives at another government school in Deir al Balah and said he locked the gates at night. “We don’t allow anyone to ruin life here, or cause any strike against those civilians and families.” A third resident, Mohammed Shehda al-Obwaini, 57, said he would fight any armed men if he found them in a school shelter.

The residents’ testimonies also suggested that Hamas’s grip on the enclave may be weakened by the war and that ad hoc community groups are starting to operate outside the organization’s control, at least on a small scale.

The accounts, which cannot be independently confirmed, come as Israel has sharply increased the rate of its airstrikes on schools turned shelters to target what it calls Hamas command-and-control centers. It says militants have “cynically exploited” these sensitive sites to plan operations. Hamas, a militant group rather than a conventional army, has used both civilian structures and tunnels as defenses. It was not possible to confirm whether armed or unarmed militants stay in the school shelters.

“Strikes against this infrastructure are conducted in accordance with international law, with the purpose of preventing the restoration of terrorist organizations’ capabilities,” an Israeli military statement said last month. The military also says it acts using precise intelligence and takes steps to minimize civilian harm.

Hundreds of people have been killed in the attacks, according to local health officials. In one particularly deadly example on Aug. 10, the Gaza Civil Defense emergency service said that more than 90 people were killed in a strike on a school in northern Gaza. The toll could not be confirmed independently. Israel said that it had killed at least 31 Islamic Jihad and Hamas fighters and that the compound itself had not been severely damaged.

In Saturday,’s strikes, Gazan rescue services said the first had killed four people, and medics said the second had killed three and wounded 20 more.

The Israeli military has said that it has found weapons stored at schools or struck armed militants there. In some cases, the military has said that Hamas used schools as a “hiding place to direct and plan numerous attacks” against Israeli troops.

More recently, some of the military’s reports about the strikes have not mentioned weapons, and on Saturday, it did not say whether the militants targeted in the strike were armed.

The military, in recent weeks, has not explained in its statements how it arrived at its intelligence conclusions or given more details about whom it has targeted.

The United Nations, the European Union and several governments have sharply criticized Israel’s government over the strikes. Senior U.N. officials argue that to target schools — many of which are run by the United Nations — violates international law and that Israel has a duty to protect civilians caught in the war.

Formal education has been suspended in Gaza because of the war, and hundreds of schools have been turned into shelters. The shelters have played a vital role in Gaza, which has been shattered by more than 10 months of war. Almost all of the enclave’s 2.2 million residents have fled their homes, and some people say they have been forced to move as many as 10 times, often in response to Israeli warnings.

In addition, more than half of all residential buildings in the enclave have been damaged or destroyed, mainly by Israeli airstrikes, the World Bank said in January. At the same time, more than 80 percent of Gaza’s schools and all 12 of its universities have been severely damaged or destroyed, according to the United Nations.

Some people have stayed with relatives. Hundreds of thousands now live in makeshift tents. Others have decamped to overcrowded school compounds, with families living in classrooms, corridors and yards.

In the close-knit Gazan society, established families seem to have sway in the shelters.

“We are the oldest generation here,” Mr. Kafarneh said. As new people arrive, he said, “We ask about that person, their political views, just to be aware of who they are.”

“We don’t allow anyone to enter with their rifle, whether he is a militant or from a big tribe or family.”

Israel’s recent attacks on the schools have deepened the misery and sense of insecurity for civilians who live there, not least because the attacks often come without warning.

Mai Riyad al-Basyouni, 22, who lived at a government school in Deir al Balah with her husband and 3-month-old daughter, said that women and children were particularly at risk because they stayed indoors at the school, whereas men were often at the markets during the day.

She said she had been at the school for nine months and wanted to leave because of the airstrikes but could not afford to rent elsewhere. A particular worry was shrapnel, which she said she feared could pierce her tent with ease.

“Hearing the news of targeting more schools makes my daily life more miserable, stressful and traumatic,” she said.

Mohammed Shehda al-Obwaini, 57, said he used to live in a school shelter west of Deir al Balah but left after it was hit a few weeks ago and has now pitched a tent for himself and his family near a soccer field.

He described the attack on the school where he had stayed as terrifying.

“Is Israel fighting the Palestinians or Hamas?” he said. “We have had enough suffering and killing. We have enough death among us.”

Discover The Times with our best offer: 

$0.50/week for your first year.

Sale. Don’t miss out
$0.50/week for your first 6 months year.
Billed as $2 every 4 weeks, then $12 thereafter.

Learn more

Husband on Trial in Rape and Drugging Case in France Is Taken to a Hospital

A man who confessed to drugging his wife for years and bringing dozens of men into their home to join him in raping her was taken to the hospital on Tuesday just hours before he was due to testify in his trial, his lawyer said.

The condition of the man, Dominique Pelicot, 71, whose trial in Avignon, France, has shocked the country and packed two courtrooms with reporters from around the world, was not immediately clear.

His lawyer, Béatrice Zavarro, told reporters in the courthouse that Mr. Pelicot had been suffering from abdominal pain and discomfort in urinating since Friday, for which he had been excused from court on Monday.

On Tuesday, the head judge, Roger Arata, ordered Mr. Pelicot to undergo a medical examination and said that if he was admitted to the hospital, the trial would be suspended until his condition improved. Later in the afternoon, the judge announced that Mr. Pelicot’s health status did not preclude him from coming in person to the hearings, and he would return to court on Wednesday. Mr. Pelicot’s testimony, he added, would be squeezed into the schedule “in intervals” over the coming days.

Ms. Zavarro said Mr. Pelicot, who had asked to testify, still planned to take the stand before his wife and three children, who have been in the courtroom since the trial began last week and have not communicated with him since his arrest in late 2020.

“I heard things this morning in the courtroom suggesting that obviously his absence would be on purpose: No way,” Ms. Zavarro said. “Let us be very clear, Mr. Pelicot has not shied away, Mr. Pelicot will not shirk, Mr. Pelicot will be there, he will answer all the questions. But there is this medical problem for which he did not plan.”

Testifying, she added, was “for him, essential.”

Mr. Pelicot has pleaded guilty to all of the charges against him. His lawyer has said that he hopes to use the trial to explain himself to Gisèle Pelicot, who was his wife for 50 years, and to his children.

Discover The Times with our best offer: 

$0.50/week for your first year.

Sale. Don’t miss out
$0.50/week for your first 6 months year.
Billed as $2 every 4 weeks, then $12 thereafter.

Learn more

White House Is Drawn Into Dispute Over Chinese Doping

The fight between the United States and the world’s antidoping regulator over the handling of positive tests by elite Chinese swimmers has escalated in recent weeks and drawn in a powerful new player: the Biden White House.

The regulator, the World Anti-Doping Agency, known as WADA, informed the White House last month that its officials were seeking to bar the administration’s representative from any deliberations about positive tests by Chinese athletes at the agency’s leadership meeting this week in Turkey.

The attempt to exclude the official, Dr. Rahul Gupta, who is the director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy, is seen as part of a larger effort by WADA to push back on American criticism of the agency’s handling of the doping allegations and to try to shut down an F.B.I. investigation into the matter.

WADA’s critics say the agency’s push to have Dr. Gupta barred from the discussions is meant to undercut the United States’ ability to voice concerns over how the Chinese tests were handled before the past two Summer Olympics, and to hamstring calls for more transparency and accountability in the global antidoping system.

The White House has responded forcefully, according to documents reviewed by The New York Times and interviews with government and antidoping officials. The heated back and forth is expected to come to a head on Thursday at the meeting in Turkey.

“Any attempt to impose preliminary measures will be met with strong opposition and appropriate action(s) from the United States government,” a top White House lawyer wrote to WADA in a previously undisclosed nine-page letter sent late last month and reviewed by The Times.

The disclosure about Dr. Gupta comes as WADA has continued to pressure the United States in other ways.

The antidoping agency has refused to hand over documents in response to requests from Congressional committees conducting investigations. In July, the International Olympic Committee, WADA’s biggest backer, essentially conditioned the awarding of the 2034 Winter Olympics to Salt Lake City on pledges by local officials to help curtail inquiries by the Justice Department, the F.B.I. and Congress.

According to WADA’s communications to its executive board, WADA sued the United States Anti-Doping Agency, its most vocal critic, in August in Switzerland, citing what it called “sustained defamatory comments.”

All the while, WADA has kept up a drumbeat of criticism over how the United States handles doping cases, repeatedly pointing out that most American professional sports operate beyond the reach of the global antidoping system. Internally, WADA has been conducting a leak investigation to determine who disclosed documents to The Times, which in April published an investigation that revealed how the agency handled positive tests involving about two dozen Chinese swimmers.

Dr. Gupta, the White House’s top drug official, is a member of WADA’s board, where he represents not only the United States but more than 40 countries in the Americas. Only the International Olympic Committee contributes more than the United States to WADA’s $40 million annual budget.

His potential exclusion from this week’s executive committee session in Turkey was discussed at a meeting last week among public authorities who represent five regions around the world on WADA’s board, according to two officials with direct knowledge of the conversations but who were not authorized to discuss them publicly. At that meeting, representatives from the other regions agreed to speak out against Dr. Gupta’s exclusion on Thursday.

The efforts to remove Dr. Gupta, who was celebrated by WADA at a ceremony as recently as March, have been taking place for a number of weeks and have led to a furious response from the White House.

The White House claimed in its letter to WADA that the agency’s top leaders had orchestrated the attempt to sideline Dr. Gupta through an anonymous conflict-of-interest complaint that accused him of attending meetings without disclosing his knowledge of a criminal investigation into the Chinese case.

In response to questions from The Times, a spokesman for WADA, James Fitzgerald, said that it was inaccurate to say that the agency planned to bar Dr. Gupta or to say that its top officials, its president Witold Banka and its longtime general secretary, Olivier Niggli, had concluded that the doctor had a conflict of interest.

At Thursday’s meeting, members of WADA’s executive committee will be provided with a copy of a final report into its handling of the Chinese doping cases, written by an independent prosecutor hired by the agency. The prosecutor’s interim conclusions, published before this summer’s Paris Olympics, absolved the agency of any wrongdoing.

Uneasiness between WADA, Olympic officials and the United States predates the current crisis and stems from the passing of legislation in 2020 that allows U.S. law enforcement to pursue doping cases around the world. It is those powers that most worry global antidoping officials, who have expressed growing concern about the risk of tit-for-tat laws being passed in other countries.

In June, the head of swimming’s governing body was approached by federal investigators while attending U.S. Olympic trials and subpoenaed to provide information related to the China case. The incident has made some international sports officials skittish about traveling to the United States, for fear of being drawn in to criminal cases.

‘Need to Tell a Story’: Why U.K.’s Leader Faced a Revolt Over a Retiree Benefit Cut

Nine weeks into his new job as Britain’s prime minister, Keir Starmer suffered his first big parliamentary rebellion on Tuesday, in a vote that exposed unease about his center-left government’s austere tone and focus on belt-tightening.

Although the government ultimately prevailed, more than 50 of Labour’s 404 lawmakers did not support its move to restrict payments that help retirees with winter heating costs.

Under the initiative, an annual payment of at least £200 ($261) that is currently available to anyone over the age of 66 will be subject to a means test, available only to those with the lowest incomes.

Fifty-three Labour members either abstained or were absent, and one voted against the plan.

Mr. Starmer has a majority of more than 160 lawmakers, and the plan’s passage — and therefore his victory — was never in doubt. But the number of Labour members who did not support it underscored wider disquiet over a policy that surprised many when it was announced.

“It came out of the blue and it just dropped,” said John McTernan, a political strategist who was an aide to Tony Blair when he was prime minister. The new curb could have been justified on the grounds of fairness, since many wealthy pensioners do not need the payments, Mr. McTernan said. But instead, the government focused its explanation on the need to cut spending.

By failing to sell the policy effectively to the public or his party, Mr. McTernan said, Mr. Starmer turned it into an awkward early test of his authority.“I think it was mishandled and it’s a lesson, the lesson being: Don’t make a political decision that is not backed by a political narrative and a political argument,” he added.

Labour swept to power for the first time in 14 years with a landslide victory in July’s election, and a triumphant Mr. Starmer promised that “the work of change begins immediately.”

But last month the prime minister warned that “things will get worse before they get better,” blaming a disastrous economic inheritance from the previous Conservative government and the dire state of Britain’s public services.

Some critics accuse him of substituting the tone of hope on which he campaigned with one of undiluted miserabilism.

With the taxpayer-funded National Health Service and other public services badly frayed, the mood could worsen next month when the chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves, announces her budget plans.

After coming to power, Ms. Reeves says she discovered a £22 billion ($28.77 billion) “black hole” in the government finances, prompting the move to curb winter fuel aid.

Around 11.4 million retired people currently qualify for the payments. Under the new plan, eligibility will be limited to 1.5 million people who receive other welfare support.

However, there is concern for people entitled to those benefits who fail to claim them, and critics warn of hardship for retirees whose incomes are just above the threshold. Mick Lynch, who leads the R.M.T. rail workers’ union, likened the government to the Grinch.

The opposition Conservative Party disputes claims of a £22 billion “black hole,” and argues that Ms. Reeves’s choices reflect her priorities.

While cutting the winter fuel payments, saving £1.4 billion ($1.83 billion), Ms. Reeves has also given pay raises larger than the rate of inflation to public sector workers. Labour says those pay deals were necessary to incentivize those workers, who saw their real wages fall over the past five years while the average pay of private sector workers rose.

Ahead of Tuesday’s vote, Mr. Starmer told a trade union conference that he made “no apology for the decisions we’ve had to take to change the country,” adding that he would not risk his government’s commitment to economic stability or dodge difficult decisions. “I owe you that candor,” he said.

Winter fuel payments were introduced under Mr. Blair after his election victory in 1997. When Theresa May, a Conservative former prime minister, considered curbing the payments in 2017, Labour said the plan could put thousands of lives at risk, and she retreated.

But Mr. Starmer’s supporters point out that for years Britain’s retirees have received generous financial protection under a policy known as the “triple lock,” which increases pensions annually by whichever figure is highest: 2.5 percent, the rate of inflation or earnings growth.

Labour has kept that policy and Ms. Reeves said that the basic state pension had risen by around £900 ($1,177) compared with a year ago — much more than the maximum £300 fuel payment in question.

“The winter fuel allowance came from a different time,” said Mr. McTernan, the political strategist. “We have now had 14 years of the Tories delivering a triple lock which has substantially raised the rate of the basic state pension.” Still, he argued, Mr. Starmer should have sugar coated the fuel benefit means test pill by explaining how sacrifices now would produce long-term benefits.

“If it’s going to get worse before it gets better — fine. I get the worse bit,” he said. “But what does the better bit look like or feel like? It goes back to the basics — you do need to tell a story about your politics.”

Discover The Times with our best offer: 

$0.50/week for your first year.

Sale. Don’t miss out
$0.50/week for your first 6 months year.
Billed as $2 every 4 weeks, then $12 thereafter.

Learn more

Jordan Holds Election With Domestic Issues and Gaza in Focus

Sign up for the Tilt newsletter, for Times subscribers only.  Nate Cohn, The Times’s chief political analyst, makes sense of the latest political data.

Voters went to the polls for a parliamentary election in the Arab kingdom of Jordan on Tuesday, with domestic concerns such as unemployment high on their agenda, although an Islamist party has tried to ride a wave of popular anger about Israel’s war in Gaza to challenge the pro-Western government.

The election was held under a new system introduced in 2022 that aims to promote democratization and increase the role of political parties, while reducing the influence of tribes on national politics.

Under the system, candidates for the 138 seats of the lower house may now run under national parties, rather than as individuals. (Parliament’s upper house as well as key government posts are selected by King Abdullah II.) The polls closed at 7 p.m. local time and the state news agency put turnout at around 31 percent. The results are expected overnight or early on Wednesday.

The political arm of the opposition Muslim Brotherhood, which had boycotted previous elections, used that opportunity to try to win votes, campaigning on a platform of opposition to the Gaza war, and support for an end to cooperation between Jordan and Israel on security and for establishment of a Palestinian state. Many Jordanian citizens are of Palestinian origin, and the country contains the largest proportion of Palestinian exiles anywhere.

“Gaza has given the Muslim Brotherhood an opportunity to amplify their election campaign and slogans,” said Amer Al Sabaileh, a regional security expert and university professor based in Jordan’s capital, Amman. “They exploit the concept of resistance and the entire war on Gaza to their advantage, even promoting the idea that not voting for them equates to normalization with Israel.”

But Mr. Sabaileh said that the results would likely nevertheless yield victory for tribal and pro-government parties because they are deeply entrenched in the political system and because turnout is typically higher in rural areas, their traditional base.

Jordan’s parliament has little direct power over foreign policy, which is controlled by the king under the country’s constitution. As a result many voters, even if they hold strong views about Gaza and the West Bank, would be unlikely to see their vote as a way to effect change in that area, according to Mr. Sabaileh.

Unemployment, poverty and corruption are among the top domestic concerns of voters in the country of around 11 million people, according to many Jordanians and an opinion poll published earlier this year. The unemployment rate stands at 21 percent, government figures show, but youth unemployment is far higher.

Since Oct. 7, when Hamas led the deadly attack on Israel that set off the war in Gaza, there have been several mass pro-Palestinian demonstrations.

The Jordanian government has denounced Israel’s conduct of the conflict and has reaffirmed its position that any transfer of Palestinians from the West Bank is a declaration of war. The country, however, is an important regional ally of the United States and cooperates closely with Israel.

Jordanian government officials have sought to limit expressions of opposition to Israel over the conflict, and Amnesty International reported in April that since October, at least 1,500 people, including many activists, have been arrested on charges of protesting against the war.

Jordan was also one of several countries including the United States that helped shoot down a barrage of missiles and drones that Iran fired at Israel in April. The government described its military action as that of self-defense, rather than something done directly to benefit Israel.

The state has presented the election as a chance to bolster development and democratic reform in Jordan by enhancing the role of political parties, something that appeals to the United States and other allies, Mr. Sabaileh said, adding that it is being framed “as a way to counter the influence of the Muslim Brotherhood.”

Turnout in previous parliamentary elections has been relatively low, particularly in Amman and other cities, and some voters said on Tuesday they had wrestled with the question of whether to participate and whether the Parliament would be sufficiently empowered to make a difference in their lives.

Ameen Halaseh, a retired civil engineer, 61, said that he and his wife had voted early in the morning in Amman, motivated by the chance to help establish a system that could, in time, lead to powerful political parties that could play a real role in shaping government policy.

“Most Jordanians love the king and the Hashemite family, but the legislature should be elected by the people to express what people want,” Mr. Halaseh said. “The new law that the government and the Parliament issued is really trying to plant a seed for generations to come to have real elections.”

By contrast, Shahd Fawzi, 30, a medical doctor who works in the capital, said that she did not vote because she lacked confidence that the candidates and parties who were running could institute material change. Among the changes she wanted were greater freedom of expression and more women in politics. But in the short term, she said, “I don’t see there’s any benefits from voting.”