The New York Times 2024-10-19 12:10:59


Autopsy Shows Hamas Leader, Yahya Sinwar, Was Killed by a Gunshot to the Head

Pinned

Liam StackJim Tankersley and Aaron Boxerman

Here are the latest developments.

The leader of Hamas, Yahya Sinwar, was killed by a gunshot wound to the head, according to the director of Israel’s national forensic institute, Dr. Chen Kugel, who oversaw the autopsy and described its findings in an interview with The New York Times on Friday.

He said that shrapnel, possibly from either a small missile or tank shell, had earlier hit Mr. Sinwar’s arm, causing bleeding that he was trying to stanch by using an electrical cord as an impromptu tourniquet. “But it wouldn’t have worked in any case,” Mr. Kugel said. “It wasn’t strong enough, and his forearm was smashed.”

Several points remained unclear, including who fired the shot, when and with what weapon.

Hamas confirmed the killing of Mr. Sinwar in a televised eulogy on Friday by his longtime deputy, Khalil al-Hayya, who said the loss had changed nothing for the armed group or its war with Israel. The remarks by Mr. al-Hayya stood in contrast to the optimism expressed a short time earlier by President Biden, who said Mr. Sinwar’s death presented “an opportunity to seek a path to peace” in the yearlong war in Gaza.

“We are continuing Hamas’s path,” Mr. al-Hayya, who lives in exile in Qatar, said in the group’s first official comments about Mr. Sinwar’s killing by Israeli forces, adding that the slain leader’s “banner will not fall.”

Speaking to reporters in Berlin on Friday, Mr. Biden called Mr. Sinwar’s death “a moment of justice” and a chance at “a better future in Gaza without Hamas.” He plans to send Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken to Israel in the coming days to discuss securing Gaza and postwar planning, an effort to jump-start cease-fire talks that have been stalled for months.

The president spoke with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel, whose office said that both leaders had agreed there was an “opportunity to advance the release of the hostages” captured in last year’s Hamas-led attacks in Israel as part of a cease-fire deal. Dozens of hostages are still being held by Hamas and its allies in Gaza.

Mr. Sinwar orchestrated the Hamas assault on Oct. 7, 2023, that killed up to 1,200 people, captured some 250 hostages and prompted an Israeli retaliation that has killed tens of thousands of Palestinians and left much of the Gaza Strip in ruin.

He was considered the driving force behind Hamas’s refusal to surrender, and his survival made it impossible for Israel to declare victory. But after Mr. Sinwar’s killing, Mr. Netanyahu made it clear that he would continue to direct the Israeli military to pursue Hamas. “This is not the end of the war in Gaza,” he said in a video address. “It is the beginning of the end.”

Here’s what else to know:

  • Relief in Gaza: Many war-weary Palestinians in Gaza reacted to Mr. Sinwar’s death with relief on Thursday. Some in Khan Younis, his hometown, expressed hope that the war might soon end, while others blamed him for starting the conflict by organizing the Oct. 7, 2023, attacks on Israel.

  • Unlikely find: For over a year, Israel’s security establishment, backed by the United States, dedicated vast resources to its hunt for Mr. Sinwar, who was thought to be hiding in Hamas’s tunnel network under Gaza. Ultimately, a unit of trainee squad commanders unexpectedly encountered Mr. Sinwar above ground while on an operation in southern Gaza.

  • Netanyahu weighs push: Mr. Netanyahu, directing remarks on Thursday toward Palestinians in Gaza, said that the war could end “tomorrow,” if Hamas laid down its arms and returned the hostages. Hamas has survived the deaths of many previous leaders, and Mr. Netanyahu must still weigh a renewed push for a hostage deal against the priorities of his allies in government who want him to continue the war

  • Hamas’s next steps: Mr. Sinwar’s killing was a powerful blow to a violent organization that had already seen several senior leaders killed since the war in Gaza began. Though few experts expect Hamas to collapse, they said his elimination could cause a leadership vacuum and more chaos in its ranks. It remained unclear when Hamas would announce a successor.

  • Hostage families react: For the families and supporters of the hostages remaining in Gaza, the killing of Mr. Sinwar, their chief captor, brought both a moment of satisfaction and deep trepidation over the fate of the captives.

What will become of Yahya Sinwar’s body?

The death of the Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar was confirmed Thursday by Israeli authorities, but questions remain about the location of his body and what may happen to it in the future.

Mr. Sinwar was killed by a gunshot wound to the head in southern Gaza during a firefight, Dr. Chen Kugel, the director of Israel’s national forensic institute, said in an interview with The New York Times on Friday. Dr. Kugel oversaw the autopsy and, after it was complete, Mr. Sinwar’s body was handed over to the Israeli military, he said. He did not know where it was being kept.

Israel often holds the corpses of Palestinians, hoping to use them in a future exchange with Hamas or other militant groups, just as Hamas has done with the bodies of hostages killed on or after the Hamas-led attack in Israel. It remains to be seen whether Mr. Sinwar’s body will be held, released back to Hamas or otherwise interred.

The Israeli military did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

When asked about an exchange, experts said it is unlikely that Israeli officials would create a situation where his body would be laid to rest in a place that could become a shrine.

“What I would imagine would happen is there will be a secret dignified burial in an undisclosed place,” said Jon B. Alterman, the director of the Middle East program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, adding “when bin Laden was killed, he received a dignified Muslim funeral.”

When Osama bin Laden, the mastermind of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, was killed in 2011 by U.S. forces, he was quickly buried at sea. That was likely done to avoid the possibility of a shrine, in accordance with Muslim tradition, which requires burial within 24 hours of death.

Dr. Kugel estimated that Mr. Sinwar’s autopsy took place between 24 to 36 hours after death, but he could not specify an exact time.

Mr. Alterman said that Israeli officials likely have robust protocols in place to deal with the deaths of militants. “There will be a huge Israeli effort to make sure there is nothing left to be an object of veneration,” he said.

The burial site will likely be in Israel, he said, and Israelis will want to avoid a situation where his supporters could try to claim he was buried in Palestinian territories as a martyr.

When Hamas’s leader, Ismail Haniyeh, was assassinated in Iran in late July, Israelis did not have custody of his body. Mr. Haniyeh was buried in Qatar’s capital city, Doha, where hundreds of mourners reportedly lined the streets as his coffin, draped in a Palestinian flag, passed through the streets.

Aaron Boxerman contributed reporting.


Mentos, an expired passport and a map were some of the items Israel said it found near the slain Hamas leader.

A roll of Mentos. Nail clippers. An expired passport.

An Israeli official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the matter, shared photos of items said to have been found near the bodies of the Hamas leader, Yahya Sinwar, and two other militants killed in a firefight in southern Gaza with Israel soldiers on Wednesday.

The items range from the ordinary, including religious materials, to the operational, including firearms and a map. A number of identification documents were also found, including those of Mahmoud Hamdan, a Hamas leader the Israeli military claimed to have killed in September. The Israeli military said on Friday that this claim was inaccurate, and Mr. Hamdan was actually killed on Friday in Rafah, near where Mr. Sinwar was located.

The documents also include an expired passport for a man whose occupation was listed as “UNRWA teacher,” referring to the United Nations agency that supports Palestinian refugees.

According to the leader of UNRWA, Philippe Lazzarini, the man left Gaza for Egypt earlier this year. It was unclear why the identification documents would be near the bodies of Mr. Sinwar and the other Hamas militants.

The Times identified the locations written on a hand-drawn map that the official said was found near Mr. Sinwar. The map shows numerous locations in the Tel al-Sultan neighborhood of northern Rafah, the same area where Mr. Sinwar was killed. The house where Mr. Sinwar was killed is not included on the map.

Neil Collier contributed reporting.

West Bank violence spills into Palestinians’ crucial olive harvest.

Violence in the Israeli-occupied West Bank that has spiked during the war in Gaza is raising new alarms about an annual agricultural rite crucial to many Palestinians’ livelihoods: the olive harvest.

Jens Laerke, the spokesman for the United Nations agency for humanitarian coordination, known as OCHA, said in a briefing in Geneva on Friday that the annual harvest was becoming more perilous, noting that a woman working a grove near the city of Jenin, in the territory’s north, had been killed a day earlier.

“The olive harvest is an economic lifeline for tens of thousands of Palestinian families in the West Bank,” Mr. Laerke said, warning that Israeli settlers were increasingly endangering Palestinian farmers, land and production and that “Israeli forces have been using lethal warlike tactics” in the territory. He said that the Israeli military, as the occupying power, had a legal obligation to protect Palestinians in the territory but had at times been complicit in the increased violence.

The Palestinian Ministry of Health said on Thursday that the woman, Hanan Abd Rahman Abu Salameh, 59, was shot by Israeli military fire. The Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported that her family said she had been working in a grove about 200 yards from the Israeli-built separation barrier when a man in a military uniform shot her in the back. Haaretz and Times of Israel reported that a deputy commander had been suspended and that it had opened an investigation. In response to a query about the death, the Israeli military said it was looking into the reports.

There have been at least 32 settler attacks in the West Bank since the start of October that have led to casualties, property damage or both, Mr. Laerke said.

Most of those were related to the olive harvest, according to OCHA’s latest weekly update on the West Bank on Thursday. “Israeli settlers attacked Palestinians or prevented them from gaining access to their lands and damaged trees, stole crops and harvesting tools,” the report said, adding that about 600 trees and saplings were raided or vandalized, affecting farmers in about 15 communities.

The agency’s warnings followed on the heels of other, similar alarms.

The U.N.’s high commission on human rights, in a statement on Wednesday, called it “the most dangerous olive season ever” for Palestinian farmers, citing agency experts and recalling that last year’s harvest had been “marred by a sharp increase in movement restrictions and violence by Israeli forces and settlers.”

The U.N. has recorded more than 1,400 attacks by Israeli settlers against Palestinian communities since the war in the other Palestinian territory, Gaza, began last October after the Hamas-led terrorist attacks on southern Israel, and Israeli forces have conducted raids and strikes in the West Bank against what they identify as terrorists.

The British foreign secretary, David Lammy, alluded to the issue in a statement on Tuesday announcing the imposition of financial sanctions on settlers and groups identified as supporting violence against Palestinians in the West Bank. Mr. Lammy expressed concern that the rising settler violence could worsen during the harvest, which he said had “traditionally suffered spikes in violence as organized settler groups disrupt and attack Palestinians.”

And a dozen diplomatic missions in Jerusalem and Ramallah — including those from Canada, France, Germany and the European Union — released a joint statement on Monday that called on Israel to “ensure a successful olive harvest” and fulfill its obligation to protect Palestinians in the West Bank.

“It is the responsibility of Israeli security forces to actively prevent Israeli settlers from entering Palestinian olive groves to disrupt the harvest,” the statement said.

More than 2.7 million Palestinians live in the West Bank, alongside about 500,000 Jewish settlers. Israel seized control of the territory from Jordan in 1967 during a war with three Arab states. Israeli Jews have moved in since in increasing numbers, residing there with both tacit and explicit government approval. The far-right government of the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has expanded Israeli settlements in the West Bank, despite international declarations that they are illegal.

Some government ministers — including the national security minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir, and the finance minister, Bezalel Smotrich — have been explicit about implementing policies to speed up Israeli settlement in the territory to thwart the creation of a Palestinian state, emboldening extreme elements of the settler movement and increasingly blurring the line between the state and the settlers’ actions.

Lebanon issues rare criticism of Iran over ‘blatant interference.’

Lebanon’s caretaker prime minister accused Iran on Friday of meddling in the country’s affairs, opening up a rare diplomatic spat after Iran’s parliament speaker remarked that his country was ready to help negotiate terms to bring about a cease-fire between Israel and Hezbollah.

The reported remarks amounted to “a blatant interference in Lebanese affairs,” said the prime minister, Najib Mikati, who later summoned Tehran’s envoy to answer for them — a highly unusual rebuke by a top Lebanese official given the stranglehold that Iran-backed Hezbollah has on the country.

In an interview published by France’s Le Figaro newspaper a day earlier, the Iranian parliament speaker, Mohammad Baqer Ghalibaf, was quoted as saying that his government was ready to negotiate with France on the implementation of Security Council Resolution 1701, a U.N. agreement that ended the last war between Hezbollah and Israel in 2006 and is seen as a precondition for a cease-fire in Lebanon.

“The issue of negotiating to implement international resolution 1701 is being undertaken by the Lebanese state,” Mr. Mikati said in response, referring to the U.N. agreement. “Everyone is required to support it in this direction, not to seek to impose new mandates.”

The 2006 agreement called for a withdrawal of Israeli forces from Lebanon and said that only the Lebanese army and U.N. peacekeepers could operate militarily in southern Lebanon. It has widely been considered ineffective but has come into focus again during the current conflict.

Since the Hamas-led attack into Israel last year, Israel has been exchanging cross-border fire with Hezbollah, a Lebanese militant group and political party. The conflict has escalated sharply in recent weeks, leading Israel to invade southern Lebanon in a bid to destroy the group’s border infrastructure.

Although Mr. Ghalibaf’s chief adviser, Mahdi Mohammadi, later denied the remarks, it was too late to defuse the diplomatic tensions and Tehran’s envoy in Beirut was summoned to offer clarification. Lebanese officials stressed during the meeting that the country needed to preserve its sovereignty as it pursued a diplomatic solution to the conflict, according to a statement by Lebanon’s foreign ministry.

Mr. Mikati has repeatedly affirmed his government’s commitment to the full implementation of the U.N. agreement in an attempt to bring an end to the violence in Lebanon that has killed thousands and displaced over one million. However, Lebanon’s crisis-racked caretaker government is deemed largely powerless to rein in Hezbollah.

Drone Captures Moment of Defiance, Which Israel Says Was Sinwar’s Last

It was a pivotal moment of the war in Gaza and, in a surreal twist of modern warfare, Israel said it was filmed by a drone.

Hunched in an armchair, his face masked by a kaffiyeh and his body covered in dust, is a man who Israel says is Yahya Sinwar, the leader of Hamas. His right arm is gravely injured and bleeding. His fate is all but sealed.

The man, nearly motionless, watches as he is filmed, apparently recognizing the hovering Israeli drone for what it is. In his left hand he lifts a long object, possibly a stick, and puts it back down.

Then, after staring at the drone for at least 20 seconds, he defiantly throws the object at it. The video ends a few seconds later.

The Israeli military, which released the video, said it shows the last moments of Mr. Sinwar, an architect of the Oct. 7 attacks, before he was killed in Rafah on Wednesday. While the room, the man’s clothing and the arm injury broadly match other visual evidence of Mr. Sinwar’s death, The Times could not independently verify his identity in the video.

In modern warfare, militaries use drones to scope out enemy positions, and often release propaganda videos showing enemy soldiers being killed. On the battlefields in Ukraine, both sides in that conflict have released a steady stream of drone footage showing panicked soldiers moments before their deaths.

But here the drone footage shows a solitary figure remarkably close-up. In a war often seen from far away, in large explosions or wide vistas of broken buildings, the moment is remarkably personal.

There are many unknown details about the video, which was heavily edited before it was released. It does not show how the man’s arm was injured, nor does it show the moment of his death.

At the beginning of the clip, the drone enters a residential building in the Tel al-Sultan neighborhood of Rafah, in southern Gaza, through a second-story window.

Photos of the building taken later show more damage, indicating that an explosion occurred at some point after the drone footage was taken.

In another video released by the Israeli military, two tanks are positioned nearby, one of which fires on the building.

Mr. Sinwar was killed soon after the drone footage was recorded. A sniper shot him in the head, and then a tank shell flattened much of the building, the military said.

Reporting was contributed by Christiaan Triebert.

Videos show how the Israeli military destroyed parts of a Lebanese village.

The Israeli military destroyed most of a village in southern Lebanon this week with a series of explosions, according to videos verified by The New York Times and satellite images. About two dozen buildings were demolished in the village, which The Times identified as Mhaibib, just over a mile from Israel’s northern border.

In a video taken from a distance, which circulated widely online, soldiers who appear to be wearing Israeli uniforms react with exclamations in Hebrew as they watch buildings explode simultaneously.

It was not possible to determine the source of that footage. But The Times confirmed that it depicted the same demolition shown in another video, published by an Israeli radio station, in which Israeli soldiers give thumbs-up signs as they watch the destruction of the buildings on a drone controller screen.

In a series of posts on social media, the Israeli military said that its soldiers had “dismantled” a tunnel network used by Hezbollah’s elite Radwan Force on Wednesday, saying that it ran through “the heart of a village.” Accompanying the statement was aerial footage that showed several explosions and smoke rising from the village. The statement did not name the location, but The Times geolocated the video to Mhaibib. Hezbollah has made no public comment on the Israeli assertion, and the Israeli military, asked about the village on Friday, said that it was “checking.”

Satellite imagery of the village captured before and after the detonations show that only a couple of buildings are left standing after the Israeli operation, which the military’s statement said had been carried out by the 91st Division.

One of structures that appears to still be standing is an ancient shrine that has attracted pilgrims from around the region. It is dedicated to Benjamin, a son of Jacob, whom Islam regards as a prophet. It was not possible to determine from the images whether the shrine had been damaged.


Mhaibib, which sits atop a hillside overlooking the Israeli border, was the scene of heavy fighting in 2006, during a monthlong war between Israel and Hezbollah. Over the last year, it has been hit repeatedly by strikes as the Israeli military battles cross-border fire from Hezbollah, which began just after its fellow Iranian-backed militant group Hamas led the devastating Oct. 7 attacks.

Israel began a ground invasion of Lebanon almost three weeks ago.

The Israeli military campaign against Hezbollah has killed more than 2,400 people in Lebanon since last year, most of them in its recently intensified operations, including a ground invasion that began less than three weeks ago. In that time, Israel has flattened several other villages.

It was unclear whether there were any injuries or deaths in Mhaibib; many southern Lebanese border villages were already largely emptied of residents when hostilities flared last year. The village chief, Qassem Ahmed Jaber, was quoted by Anadolu, Turkey’s state-run news agency, as saying that the residents had already fled. He could not be reached for comment by The Times.

Matthew Miller, a State Department spokesman, said at a news briefing on Wednesday that he had seen the video and that U.S. officials had been in contact with the Israeli government but that he did not have any details.

“We understand that Hezbollah does operate at times from underneath civilian homes, inside civilian homes,” Mr. Miller said. “So Israel does have a right to go after those legitimate targets, but they need to do so in a way that protects civilian infrastructure, protects civilians.”

Riley Mellen, Aric Toler, Ephrat Livni and Sanjana Varghese contributed reporting.

The U.N. peacekeeping force in southern Lebanon says it will remain, rejecting Israel’s demand to withdraw.

U.N. peacekeepers in Lebanon have experienced a series of deliberate attacks by the Israeli military in recent days, but the peacekeeping force will maintain its positions along the border despite Israeli pressure to withdraw, according to a spokesman for the force, known as UNIFIL.

The UNIFIL spokesman, Andrea Tenenti, told reporters by video link from Beirut on Friday that the Israeli military had “repeatedly targeted our positions, endangering the safety of our troops.” He added that Hezbollah was also endangering the peacekeeping troops by launching rockets near their positions into Israel. UNIFIL has 10,000 troops from 50 countries occupying 29 positions close to the border between Israel and Lebanon, where they monitor the conflict and try to coordinate deliveries of humanitarian aid to the civilians remaining in southern Lebanon.

Israel has accused the U.N. peacekeepers of acting as a shield for Hezbollah and demanded that they pull out. But all the countries contributing troops to the force and the U.N. Security Council decided unanimously that the force should remain in all positions, according to Mr. Tenenti.

“I think the role of UNIFIL at the moment is more important than ever,” he said.

Mr. Teneti also said that UNIFIL had found “a trace of a possible use” of white phosphorus close to a peacekeeper position, but lacked capacity to investigate reports of wider use in Israel’s bombardment of southern Lebanon. The material can inflict serious burns and munitions using it are banned by international conventions from use against targets close to civilian population. A UNIFIL commander accused Israel last year of directly hitting a peacekeeping position with white phosphorus munitions.

Peacekeepers have come “under deliberate attack” five times as Israeli forces pursue their assault on Hezbollah in southern Lebanon, Mr. Tenenti said. Among the incidents reported since Oct. 10, an Israeli tank opened fire on a UNIFIL observation tower that Mr. Tenenti said was occupied by Serbian peacekeepers on Wednesday, damaging the tower and destroying two cameras.

In other cases in the past week, two Israeli tanks forced their way into a UNIFIL site, staying for 45 minutes, and two peacekeepers were injured six days ago when an Israeli tank fired at an observation tower at UNIFIL’s headquarters in Naqoura, on Lebanon’s southernmost Mediterranean coast.

Israel has denied targeting the U.N. peacekeepers. Mr. Tenenti insisted otherwise.

“What happened is clear deliberate targeting of peacekeepers because there was no one else around,” he said, adding that no other exchanges of fire were underway at the time.

Sinwar killed by gunshot to head, Israeli autopsy finds.

The fatal blow to the Hamas leader, Yahya Sinwar, was a gunshot wound to the head, the Israeli autopsy of his body found.

He was earlier hit in the arm during a firefight with Israeli soldiers.

On a routine operation, a unit of commanders in training encountered a group of militants on the streets of Rafah in southern Gaza. They didn’t know at the time that the group included Mr. Sinwar.

Two militants fled into one building, while a third, who would later turn out to be Mr. Sinwar, entered another, triggering an hourslong firefight, according to the Israeli military.

During the encounter, shrapnel, possibly from either a small missile or tank shell hit Mr. Sinwar on his right arm and wounded him, the director of Israel’s national forensic institute, Dr. Chen Kugel, who oversaw the autopsy and described its findings in an interview with The New York Times on Friday.

At some point, Mr. Sinwar tied an electric cable around his wounded arm, in what appears to be a makeshift tourniquet to stanch the bleeding, Dr. Kugel added. “But it wouldn’t have worked in any case,” he said. “It wasn’t strong enough, and his forearm was smashed.”

An Israeli drone that was flown into the building where Mr. Sinwar had fled captured what the Israeli military said were the “moments before his elimination.”

The video, edited and released by the military, shows a man sitting in a chair, covered in dust. The man, identified as Mr. Sinwar by the military, watches the drone for at least 20 seconds before throwing what appears to be a stick in its direction.

The Times could not independently verify the identity of the man. Elements of the video match those of other photographs obtained by The Times showing the corpse of Mr. Sinwar.

Mr. Sinwar was later shot in the head, killing him, Dr. Kugel said. Other points remain unclear, including when the fatal shot was fired, what weapon was used and who fired it.

The following morning, his body was found in the rubble of the building, which had partially collapsed following shelling, according to Israeli officials. Soldiers at the site realized the militant bore a striking resemblance to Mr. Sinwar.

The soldiers cut off one of his fingers so that health officials could establish his identity, Dr. Kugel said. The body arrived at the national forensic institute on Thursday night for the autopsy.

The institute director said that Mr. Sinwar was relatively pale, which would make sense for someone who had spent long stretches of time in Hamas’s underground tunnel network, as is believed. He was at a healthy weight — over 150 pounds — and showed no signs of malnutrition, Dr. Kugel added.

For Dr. Kugel, the autopsy was the closing of a painful circle that began during last year’s Hamas attack on southern Israel, in which 1,200 people were killed. In its wake, an endless tide of victims flooded into Israel’s forensic institute.

Now Mr. Sinwar, the architect of the attack, lay on his table.

Dr. Kugel performed his work as he had done many times before. “It was only when I stepped outside that I internalized that this was the man responsible for more murder than anyone in the history of the country,” he said.

After the autopsy was complete, the body was handed over to the Israeli military, Dr. Kugel said. Israel holds the corpses of hundreds of Palestinians that it hopes to one day use for a future exchange with Hamas and other armed groups.

Aric Toler, Riley Mellen and Christiaan Triebert contributed reporting.

For the Israeli who once saved Sinwar’s life, there is no joy in his death.

Dr. Yuval Bitton, the Israeli dentist who helped save Yahya Sinwar’s life while the Hamas leader was in prison two decades ago, was preparing to celebrate the Jewish holiday of Sukkot when he began to hear reports that Mr. Sinwar had been killed.

Dr. Bitton said he was surprised to hear the news about Mr. Sinwar, who had evaded Israeli forces despite being the subject of an intense Israeli manhunt, but the situation quickly came into focus.

After a former colleague shared a photograph that later circulated online and that appeared to show the body of a man with facial features strongly resembling Mr. Sinwar, Dr. Bitton said he realized that it was the man he had spent years talking to, treating and analyzing.

“I spent so many years looking at his face that I didn’t need any form of identification,” he said. “I immediately recognized him.”

Since the two got to know each other in an Israeli prison in the early 2000s, their lives have been closely intertwined. Now that the Hamas leader is dead, Dr. Bitton expressed hope that a more peaceful future would descend on the Middle East — and that he would finally lose the moniker of the Israeli who saved Mr. Sinwar.

In 2004, Dr. Bitton, then a young prison dentist, came across a befuddled Mr. Sinwar in the infirmary. After a short exchange, Dr. Bitton realized that Mr. Sinwar’s life was at risk and that he needed to be taken to a hospital immediately.

At the hospital, surgeons removed an aggressive brain tumor, and Mr. Sinwar thanked Dr. Bitton for saving his life.

The two developed a unique relationship of sorts. As a dentist and later as a senior intelligence officer for the Israeli prison service, Dr. Bitton spent hours talking to Mr. Sinwar, up until the moment that Mr. Sinwar boarded a bus back to Gaza during a prisoner exchange in 2011.

“The conversations with Sinwar were not personal or emotional,” Dr. Bitton said. “They were only about Hamas.”

But the Hamas-led attack on Israel in October 2023, which prompted Israel to go to war in Gaza, did affect him personally: Dr. Bitton’s nephew Tamir Adar was taken hostage during the assault, he said. The Israeli government later told the family that intelligence suggested that Mr. Adar was injured in the attacks and had apparently died not long after being taken to Gaza.

Dr. Bitton did not take joy in the Hamas leader’s death. “In the Torah there’s a proverb, ‘Don’t rejoice when your enemy falls,’” he said.

But he did express optimism that the killing of Mr. Sinwar would help precipitate a deal to bring home the remaining hostages in Gaza and end the war there. “This is what is known as a game changer,” he said.

Dr. Bitton also said he hoped that Mr. Sinwar’s death would end a chapter in his own life. “I’m asked every day if I have regrets,” Dr. Bitton said, referring to his role in saving Mr. Sinwar’s life. “I couldn’t have acted any differently,” he added.

“Now, I think that both the public and the media will no longer have this association that he’s alive because of me,” Dr. Bitton said. “That’s it. He’s no longer alive.”

Yahya Sinwar was killed by a gunshot to the head, said Chen Kugel, the chief of Israel’s forensic institute, who conducted the autopsy. Sinwar was relatively pale, he added, which would make sense for someone who is believed to have spent much of his time underground. But he had a healthy weight of over 150 pounds and showed little sign of poor nutrition, Kugel said.

Israeli soldiers initially brought one of Sinwar’s fingers to begin forensic analysis to establish his identity before his body was brought to Israel on Thursday evening, Kugel said. The Hamas leader was also wounded in his arm during the battle that led to his death, Kugel added.

Iranian officials are commenting on Sinwar’s killing following Hamas’s confirmation of his death. President Masoud Pezeshkian of Iran said in a statement that Sinwar had fought and died “like a hero” but that “the martyrdom of commanders, leaders and heroes will not make a dent in the Islamic people’s fight against oppression and occupation.”

Iran’s foreign minister, Abbas Araghchi, said, “Martyrs live forever, and the cause for the liberation of Palestine from occupation is more alive than ever.”

John Kirby, the White House’s national security spokesman, said the U.S. believes Yahya Sinwar had been the chief obstacle to a Gaza cease-fire. “Now he’s gone, so we’ll see,” Kirby told reporters in Berlin. “I mean, Hamas obviously will make their own decisions about what their structure is going to look like and if and who might replace Mr. Sinwar. But yes, his death does provide a unique opportunity here.”

Kirby added, however, that he was not aware of any communication with other Hamas officials over the past day that would indicate a softening of the hard line the group took under Sinwar.

In Gaza, Yahya Sinwar’s death brings relief and glimmers of hope.

As news of Yahya Sinwar’s death spread through the Gaza Strip on Thursday night, war-weary Palestinians there expressed one emotion again and again: relief.

“The first moment I heard his death, I felt relieved that finally we will have a truce or cease-fire on the ground,” said Shorouq Abu Hammad, 22, as she was out shopping in Khan Younis, Mr. Sinwar’s hometown. Many of her neighbors felt the same way, she said, about the death of a man who “caused all this tragedy for the Gazan people.”

Mr. Sinwar, the leader of Hamas and the top target of Israel’s military, was killed in a firefight with Israeli soldiers in the southern Gaza Strip on Wednesday, Israeli officials said. He rose through Hamas’s ranks after it seized power in Gaza in 2007 and helped it to establish authoritarian rule.

And he was a key architect of Hamas’s attack on Israel last October, which left up to 1,200 dead and set off Israel’s yearlong air campaign and ground invasion of Gaza that has killed more than 42,000 Palestinians, according to local health officials, and destroyed the territory’s infrastructure.

Ms. Abu Hammad has lost one brother since the war began, she said. Another had his legs amputated because of injuries suffered in Israeli attacks, and she had been injured, too, she said.

“I hope his death will put an end to this war soon,” Ms. Abu Hammad said of the Hamas leader. “Sinwar is the one who planned all of this, and now it is a normal outcome that he be killed.”

At a makeshift roadside coffee shop near where Ms. Abu Hammad was shopping, several people shared her hopes.

Before the war, Khaled Abu Jarad, 59, worked as a taxi driver in Gaza City. He now lives in a makeshift camp outside a gas station in Khan Younis, displaced from his home like most of Gaza’s 2.2 million people. He said he thought only dyed-in-the-wool Hamas supporters would mourn Mr. Sinwar, whose brutality to his fellow Palestinians suspected of spying for Israel earned him the nickname “the butcher of Khan Younis.”

Mr. Abu Jarad expressed hope that the death of Mr. Sinwar — who was widely seen as an obstacle in cease-fire talks — would lead to a compromise between Israel and Hamas that could end the fighting and allow people to return to their homes. “It would be insane and bizarre to keep killing all of Gaza in this war,” he said.

Saher Abdul Ghafour, 19, agreed, saying that the war must end “at any cost.”

“I hope the next leader of Hamas can be a more diplomatic and wise person who can stop this war through negotiations and political channels,” he said.

Others in the coffee shop were less optimistic.

Ahmed Awad, 21, whose university studies in design were interrupted by the war, said he had “lost hope” that it would end. But he, too, said he felt “a kind of relief” when he heard Mr. Sinwar had been killed.

“Sinwar’s death may make some supporters of his sad and angry, but the majority of other people won’t feel that way because they lost everything,” Mr. Awad said. “He is gone now, and we will see what he has left behind.”

Sinwar’s Death Could Shake but Not Topple Hamas, Experts Say

Sinwar’s Death Could Shake but Not Topple Hamas, Experts Say

Analysts call the killing of several Hamas leaders, including Yahya Sinwar, a deep blow to the Palestinian militant group, but expect it to keep fighting.

Ben Hubbard

Reporting from Istanbul

Leer en español

He was there from the early days of Hamas, rose through the ranks to lead the organization and equipped it for the deadliest assault on Israel in its history.

And now, Yahya Sinwar is dead, depriving the militant group of a ruthless, intelligent leader and raising questions about what direction its battered remnants will take in their fight against Israel.

Mr. Sinwar’s killing was a powerful blow to a violent organization that had already been gravely damaged by a year of brutal combat with Israel. Though he was only the latest senior leader to be killed since the war began, few experts expect Hamas to collapse. Still, the men’s elimination could cause a leadership vacuum and more chaos in its ranks.

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.

In This Town, a Rape Trial Hits Painfully Close to Home

Mazan is a postcard of Provence — a small medieval village perched on a hill, surrounded by vineyards, in view of the windswept Mount Ventoux rising in the distance.

For years, it was known for its nearby cycling routes often featured in the Tour de France, and for a notorious figure from the 18th century, the Marquis de Sade, whose graceful mansion in the middle of the village has become its fanciest hotel.

Now, it is infamous as the place where Gisèle Pelicot was regularly drugged by her husband of 50 years and offered up to strange men for sex. In September, 51 men went on trial in nearby Avignon, most charged with the aggravated rape of Ms. Pelicot, 71.


Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.

Biden, in Germany, Urges Unwavering Support for Ukraine

Sidelined at home in the waning days of the campaign to succeed him, President Biden made a brief return to the global spotlight on Friday, rallying allies in support of Ukraine, and basking in praise from the German government.

Mr. Biden made a dash to Berlin that lasted barely a day, in a hastily rescheduled trip that was scuttled last week by Hurricane Milton.

The visit was focused on the war in Ukraine and a renewed push for a cease-fire in Gaza. It placed Mr. Biden in the starring role, championing western resolve against Russia in what he warned would be a “very difficult winter” for Ukraine, while calling Israel’s killing of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar “an opportunity to seek a path to peace” in the Middle East.

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.

Italian Judges Strike Down Request to Hold Migrants in Albania

Italian judges on Friday struck down a request by the government to hold a group of migrants in a detention center in Albania, ordering that they should be taken to Italy, in a major setback for Giorgia Meloni’s flagship policy of outsourcing asylum requests.

It was the first ruling on the new policy since Ms. Meloni’s right-wing government began carrying out the plan, with the Italian Navy this week bringing a group of migrants to a center built in Albania to hear asylum claims from refugees who had been bound for Italy.

The judges’ decision, which for now applied to only 12 migrants, could likely apply to others, casting doubt on the future of an approach that other nations, and even the European Commission’s president, were looking to as a model. Italy’s interior minister, Matteo Piantedosi, said the government would appeal the judges’ decision and that it was ready to take the case all the way to Italy’s highest court.

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.

Impeachment of Kenya’s Deputy President Could Signal Further Turmoil

Kenya’s Senate has voted to impeach the country’s deputy president, an unprecedented move that risks stirring a major political crisis and potential unrest in an East African nation widely viewed as a stable democracy in an increasingly volatile region.

The deputy president, Rigathi Gachagua, was impeached only months after widespread protests gripped the country over a finance bill that Kenyans feared would steeply raise the cost of living.

After that period of political and economic uncertainty, observers say the impeachment gives President William Ruto a chance to consolidate his power and rid himself of a once-powerful ally he has come to view as a liability.

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.

Sinwar’s Death Highlights Israel’s Long Quest for Deterrence

Want to stay updated on what’s happening in the Middle East? , and we’ll send our latest coverage to your inbox.

A quarter century before Israel was founded, the Zionist leader Zeev Jabotinsky articulated an idea that has come to define the way Israelis protect their country. A Jewish state, he wrote in 1923, would succeed only by projecting enough strength to force its enemies to accept it as a permanent reality.

Israel’s killing of the Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar is the newest manifestation of that century-old premise, Israeli analysts said on Friday. It reflects Israel’s decades-old policy of killing enemies in order to enact revenge, undermine its foes or establish deterrence — aims that became ever more urgent after Hamas’s devastating attack last October dented Israel’s image of strength.

“Events like the killing of Sinwar express something very deep in the Israeli psyche,” said Micha Goodman, an Israeli philosopher and writer on Israeli identity. “It highlights the longstanding Zionist view, which goes back to Jabotinsky and other early Zionist thinkers, that there will only be peace when our enemies lose hope that the Jewish state won’t exist.”

Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.