Live Updates: U.S. and Qatar Say Gaza Cease-Fire Talks Will Resume, but Offer Few Details
Here are the latest developments.
Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken said Thursday that he expected negotiators to meet “in the coming days” to discuss a cease-fire in Gaza, but that it remained unclear whether Hamas was willing to re-engage in the long-stalled talks after Israel killed its leader.
Mr. Blinken spoke from Qatar, where he was meeting with senior officials from the Persian Gulf state, which has acted as an intermediary between Israel and Hamas. Qatar’s foreign minister, Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, said at a news conference alongside Mr. Blinken that Hamas’s political representatives in Doha have not so far signaled a softer position since the death of its leader, Yahya Sinwar, last week.
“We haven’t yet really determined whether Hamas is prepared to engage,” Mr. Blinken said. “The fundamental question is, is Hamas serious?”
Mr. Blinken said the United States was “looking at whether there are different options we can pursue” for a cease-fire beyond a longstanding, U.S.-backed proposal for a weekslong truce. U.S. officials said Wednesday that they were open to the possibility of a shorter cease-fire — lasting roughly a week and a half — in exchange for the release of a small number of the dozens of hostages remaining in Gaza.
U.S. officials would welcome even a short pause in the fighting to allow a surge of humanitarian aid into Gaza, where the situation is growing increasingly dire in the northern part of the territory amid a renewed Israeli military offensive. On Thursday, Palestinian Civil Defense, a local emergency service, said it had been forced to halt rescue operations in the area, calling the situation there “catastrophic.”
Here’s what else to know:
-
Lebanon: Lebanon’s military said that an Israeli attack had killed three more of its soldiers in the southern part of the country, after a new wave of airstrikes hit residential areas near Beirut overnight. The attacks came as international officials gathered for a conference about the crisis in Paris, where Lebanon’s caretaker prime minister, Najib Mikati, repeated his call for a cease-fire between Israel and Hezbollah.
-
Hospital claim: Lloyd J. Austin III, the U.S. secretary of defense, said that Washington had “not seen evidence” of Israeli claims that Hezbollah had set up a bunker complex under a hospital south of Beirut. The Israeli military has asserted that Hezbollah had stashed hundreds of millions of dollars in an underground command center beneath al-Sahel hospital. Fadi Alameh, the hospital’s director, called the claims baseless.
-
Syria strikes: Syria’s state news agency reported that one soldier was killed and seven people were wounded in Israeli strikes on the capital, Damascus, and in Homs, about 100 miles to the north. There was no immediate comment from Israel’s military, which has been targeting Iran’s network of proxies in the region. That network includes the Syrian government, which Israel has long accused of helping funnel arms to Hezbollah through its shared border with Lebanon.
-
Al Jazeera accusations: The Israeli military accused six Al Jazeera reporters based in Gaza of being fighters in the Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad militant groups. It was the latest escalation in Israel’s feud with the Arabic-language broadcaster, which is backed by Qatar. Al Jazeera strongly denied the accusations, which it said were based on “fabricated evidence.”
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken announced that the United States would provide an additional $135 million in humanitarian assistance “for Palestinians in Gaza, in the West Bank as well as in the region.” Speaking during a news conference in Qatar, he said he had been discussing “concrete ideas” for the reconstruction of Gaza during his Middle East trip.
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
“This is a moment for every country to decide what role it’s prepared to play and what contributions it could make in moving Gaza from war to peace,” he said. Since Oct. 7, 2023, the U.S. has provided a total of $1.2 billion in humanitarian assistance.
Blinken says Gaza talks will resume, but offers no sign Hamas has softened its position.
Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken said on Thursday that U.S. negotiators will return to Qatar “in the coming days” in an effort to revive cease-fire negotiations between Israel and Hamas. But Mr. Blinken and Qatar’s foreign minister, Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, signaled little reason to believe that Hamas was more willing to engage in talks since Israel killed its leader, Yahya Sinwar, last week.
“We haven’t yet really determined whether Hamas is prepared to engage,” Mr. Blinken said at a joint news conference with Mr. Al Thani in Doha, the capital of Qatar. “The fundamental question is: Is Hamas serious?”
U.S. officials had seen Mr. Sinwar as a major obstacle to negotiations, and hoped that since his killing the armed group’s surviving leaders might be more open to making a deal with Israel to end the yearlong war in Gaza and release the dozens of hostages remaining there. Mr. Blinken traveled to the Middle East this week at President Biden’s request in the hope of jump-starting talks that have been frozen for months.
But during their joint news conference, neither Mr. Blinken nor Mr. Al Thani offered any sign that Hamas’s position had softened.
Mr. Al Thani said that Qatar had “re-engaged” with Hamas in the week since Mr. Sinwar’s death, via political representatives of the group who maintain an office in Doha, and sensed that Hamas maintains “the same position” as it has since the last formal negotiating proposal it offered months ago. Israel and the United States have rejected that position as unacceptable.
Mr. Al Thani added that Egypt was also playing a role in trying to revive the cease-fire talks, saying that “there are ongoing discussions between Egypt and Hamas.” He did not detail the nature of those discussions.
Mr. Blinken also did not provide details about when the new talks might start, or if the United States might propose any new positions.
For months, the Biden administration has pursued a three-phase agreement that would begin with a six-week pause in fighting during which the remaining hostages would be released from Gaza in exchange for Palestinians being held in Israeli prisons. The second phase envisions a permanent cease-fire, and the third provides for a multiyear reconstruction plan for Gaza.
U.S. officials said this week that the Biden administration was open to considering fresh proposals, potentially including a shorter pause in Israel’s offensive in exchange for the release of just some of the hostages.
Mr. Blinken, who previously visited Israel and Saudi Arabia this week, emphasized that ending the war in Gaza requires that “we continue to develop a plan for what follows, so that Israel can withdraw, so that Hamas cannot be constituted and so that the Palestinian people can rebuild their lives, rebuild their futures under Palestinian leadership.”
Mr. Blinken and Mr. Al Thani, who met for more than an hour before addressing reporters, said they had also spoken at length about how to end Israel’s offensive in Lebanon against the Iranian-backed Hezbollah militia in a way that would ensure Israel’s security.
France backs expansion of Lebanon’s army, and will give €100 million to aid displaced Lebanese, Macron says.
France will support the recruitment of thousands of extra troops for Lebanon’s military and donate around $100 million to support people who have fled their homes because of a war between Israel and the militia group Hezbollah, President Emmanuel Macron of France said Thursday at a conference on Lebanon.
Mr. Macron called for a cease-fire and said that Hezbollah, which has fired thousands of drones and missiles at Israel in the past year, should stop its attacks. He also said that Israel’s continuing invasion of Lebanon, launched this month to end Hezbollah’s aggression, was “regrettable” and he appeared to criticize the rationale for Israel’s push.
“There has been a lot of talk in recent days of a war of civilizations, or of civilizations that must be defended. I’m not sure you can defend a civilization by sowing barbarism yourself,” he said at the opening of the conference in Paris held to help raise funds for Lebanon.
Mr. Macron did not specify exactly how France would support the recruitment of additional troops for Lebanon, whose bitter sectarian divisions and weak central government have helped Hezbollah, a Shiite movement backed by Iran, to gain power.
Thursday’s meeting is the latest example of Mr. Macron’s bid to wield influence in Lebanon, a former French mandate. The historical ties, as well as the fact that French is spoken alongside English and Arabic, the official language, have long given Paris a sense of responsibility toward the country. France, for example, is one of the largest contributors of troops to the U.N. peacekeeping mission in Lebanon.
At the same time, the United States, Israel’s leading backer, remains the region’s most powerful diplomatic force. President Biden’s envoy on the Israel-Hezbollah conflict, Amos Hochstein, visited Beirut this week, and met with Lebanese officials. The State Department said it would send its deputy secretary for management, Richard Verma, to the Paris conference.
Lebanon’s caretaker prime minister, Najib Mikati, also called for a cease-fire at the conference and said that Israeli attacks had put 13 Lebanese hospitals out of service. More than 1.2 million people have fled their homes because of the conflict, the United Nations said more than two weeks ago.
Mr. Mikati said that his government could deploy additional troops to the south as part of any cease-fire deal. The military, which receives support from the United States, is not a party to the conflict and Israel has said repeatedly that it is at war with Hezbollah, not Lebanon. Still, Lebanon refers to Israel as the enemy and does not have diplomatic ties with the country.
Lebanon’s government is largely powerless to rein in Hezbollah or deploy additional troops to the southern border without Hezbollah’s consent. Lebanese officials, including, Mr. Mikati, say that Hezbollah is on board with a nearly 20-year-old U.N. resolution that would allow them to do so, but Hezbollah has not yet publicly said this.
The C.I.A.’s website said Lebanon’s military had around 73,000 active troops, but experts say it has been severely weakened by the country’s economic crisis. Israeli forces killed three Lebanese soldiers this week in southern Lebanon. Israel apologized. On Thursday, Lebanon’s military said that another Israeli attack had killed three more of its soldiers in the south.
Mr. Macron appealed to the conference to support a plan to recruit at least 6,000 additional soldiers and enable the deployment of at least 8,000 additional soldiers in the south.
This is not the first donor conference that Mr. Macron has organized for Lebanon. After a port blast devastated parts of Beirut in 2020, he toured the city before Lebanese politicians did, and held a conference that raised hundreds of millions of dollars.
Euan Ward and Ségolène Le Stradic contributed reporting
Nader Ibrahim
The Israeli military said it had struck a Hamas command center inside a compound formerly used as a school in Nuseirat, in central Gaza. Video obtained by the Reuters news agency and taken after the strike shows injured people, including children, at the compound, which has been housing displaced Palestinians.
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
Secretary Blinken’s news conference in Qatar has ended. He declined to offer details on any new Gaza cease-fire ideas the U.S. might be considering. “We haven’t yet really determined whether Hamas is prepared to engage,” he added. “The fundamental question is: Is Hamas serious?”
Arrests are made in Sri Lanka over threats against Israeli tourists.
The police in Sri Lanka have arrested three people over possible threats against tourists, specifically targeting visitors from Israel, Sri Lankan officials said on Thursday.
The people arrested, all Sri Lankan nationals, were being questioned, Vijitha Herath, a spokesman for the government, said at a news conference. “Further action will be taken based on the findings of the ongoing investigations,” he added.
The arrests came a day after both the U.S. Embassy in Sri Lanka and Israel’s National Security Council warned their citizens to avoid Arugam Bay, a popular surf destination.
The U.S. Embassy said it had “received credible information warning of an attack targeting popular tourist locations in the Arugam Bay area. Due to the serious risk posed by this threat, the Embassy imposed a travel restriction on Embassy personnel for Arugam Bay effective immediately and until further notice.”
Israel’s National Security Council told its citizens to “immediately leave Arugam Bay and the south and west coastal areas of Sri Lanka.” Israel also warned people to avoid public displays of anything that could be identified as Israeli, including clothing with Hebrew writing or religious symbols, and to avoid gathering in groups.
Britain also updated its travel advisory for Sri Lanka, citing a heightened terrorist threat. “Attacks could be indiscriminate, including in places visited by foreign nationals such as hotels, tourist sites and places of worship,” the travel advice stated.
The police in Sri Lanka had already increased security measures in Colombo, the capital, as well as in Ella and Weligama, popular destinations for Israeli tourists, a police spokesman said during an earlier news conference. One of the reasons for the heightened security, he added, was that some tourists had set up temporary prayer halls because of a Jewish holiday.
Pamodi Waravita contributed reporting from Sri Lanka.
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
In Doha, Secretary Blinken said that “what we really have to determine is whether Hamas is prepared to engage,” suggesting that crucial question remains unclear following Israel’s killing of the group’s leader, Yahya Sinwar, last week. U.S. officials have said they hope the death of Sinwar, who was seen as a chief obstacle to an agreement, might create a new opening for talks.
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
Al Thani said that Qatar’s government has “re-engaged” with Hamas via the group’s political office in Doha after Sinwar’s death. “Until now there is no clarity on what will be the way forward,” he said, adding that Qatari officials sense that the group has not softened its position.
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken said he expects that U.S. and Qatari negotiators who have been seeking a Gaza cease-fire and hostage release agreement “will be getting together in the coming days.”
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
Negotiations have been stalled for months. Blinken, who was speaking at a news conference with Qatar’s foreign minister, did not immediately say whether he has seen any new reason to be hopeful about the talks. Qatar serves as an intermediary in the talks involving Israel and Hamas.
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
Qatar’s foreign minister, Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, said that negotiators from Israel will also be coming to Doha to “discuss the means for a breakthrough” in cease-fire talks. He did not say when.
Lebanon says an Israeli attack killed 3 more of its soldiers.
Lebanon’s military said Thursday that an Israeli attack had killed three more of its soldiers in the southern part of the country, hours after a new wave of airstrikes hit residential areas near Beirut overnight.
The Lebanese military said the three soldiers had been killed near the town of Yater while on an operation to evacuate wounded people from the area. It was not clear when the attack occurred.
Israel’s military said it was looking into whether its forces had “accidentally harmed” Lebanese soldiers while conducting raids in the area against Hezbollah, the Lebanese militant group. It said in a statement that it “does not intentionally target soldiers of the Lebanese army,” and added: “The incident is under review, and any lessons will be learned.”
Lebanon’s military is not a party to the conflict between Israel and Hezbollah, the powerful Iranian-backed armed group whose military assets dwarf those of the country’s government.
But Lebanese troops have increasingly been caught in the crossfire: Thursday was at least the fourth time this month that Israeli troops had killed Lebanese soldiers amid their fight against Hezbollah. This week, the Israeli military apologized over the deaths of three other Lebanese soldiers, saying that it was “not operating against the Lebanese army.”
As Israeli troops engage in a weekslong ground invasion of southern Lebanon, the Israeli military has kept up aerial bombardment across the country, in particular in the Dahiya, a densely populated urban area near Beirut where Hezbollah holds sway.
The Israeli military said Thursday that overnight strikes in the area had targeted “civilian buildings in the heart of populated areas” that Hezbollah had used to manufacture or store weapons, adding that it had issued evacuation orders for residents of the buildings.
The Lebanese television channel al-Mayadeen, which is broadly viewed as pro-Iran and pro-Hezbollah, said that one of its offices was hit. Video broadcast by the channel showed the concrete shell of a building surrounded by shattered glass and twisted metal.
Al-Mayadeen said the Israeli military had not issued a warning before striking its offices, which the channel’s employees had vacated at the start of Israel’s invasion. There were no reports of injuries. It said in a statement that it “holds the Israeli occupation responsible for targeting a well-known media office belonging to a prominent news channel.”
Gaza’s main emergency service says it has ‘completely ceased’ rescue operations in the north.
The main emergency service in Gaza has said it has ceased all rescue operations in the northern part of the territory amid a renewed Israeli offensive in the area.
Scores of Palestinians have been killed since Israel stepped up military operations in northern Gaza this month, saying it was trying to eliminate a regrouped Hamas presence there. Roughly 400,000 people remain in northern Gaza, according to the United Nations, and many have been trapped in their ruined neighborhoods by Israeli airstrikes.
Palestinian Civil Defense, the emergency service, has been responding to the scenes of attacks to treat the wounded and try to pull people from rubble. But on Wednesday night, it said its work in northern Gaza had “completely ceased.”
“The situation has become catastrophic,” it said in a statement on Telegram. “The residents there are left without humanitarian services.”
The statement said three of its rescue workers had been injured by an Israeli drone strike and that five others had been detained by Israeli forces. It added that Israeli tanks had shelled the only fire truck operating in northern Gaza.
The Israeli military did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
United Nations officials have expressed alarm about the humanitarian situation in northern Gaza, and said the Israeli authorities have denied aid workers’ requests to help find survivors in the aftermath of Israeli strikes.
Gloria Lazic, an aid worker with the U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, said on social media this week that requests by the agency to help people trapped under rubble in the northern town of Jabaliya had been “repeatedly denied by the Israeli authorities.”
Philippe Lazzarini, the head of the main U.N. agency for Palestinians, said much the same in a social media post the same day, writing that “in northern Gaza, people are just waiting to die.”
Rawan Sheikh Ahmad contributed reporting.
Catherine Porter
Reporting from Paris
At the Lebanon aid conference in Paris, President Emmanuel Macron of France announced that his government will donate 100 million euros, or about $108 million, for emergency support for displaced Lebanese people. The United Nations has said that at least a million people in Lebanon — around a fifth of the population — have fled their homes amid Israeli attacks against Hezbollah.
Michael Crowley
Reporting from Doha, Qatar
Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken has arrived in Doha, Qatar, for the third day of his Middle East swing. After meeting with Qatari leaders to discuss Gaza and other matters, he will head to London for meetings tomorrow with more Arab officials.
Matthew Mpoke Bigg
President Emmanuel Macron of France opened an international conference on Lebanon by calling for a cease-fire between Israel and Hezbollah. He said that the armed group should immediately stop its attacks toward Israel, and called Israel’s invasion of the southern part of Lebanon a matter of “regret.”
Matthew Mpoke Bigg
The French government has organized the conference in Paris to help raise financial support for Lebanon, a former colony.
Matthew Mpoke Bigg
Lebanon’s caretaker prime minister, Najib Mikati, also called for a cease-fire and said that Israeli attacks had put 13 Lebanese hospitals out of service. He said his government could deploy additional troops from the Lebanese Army — which is not a party to the Israel-Hezbollah conflict — to the southern part of the country as part of a cease-fire deal.
Israel accuses six Al Jazeera reporters of belonging to Palestinian militant groups.
The Israeli military on Wednesday accused six Al Jazeera reporters based in Gaza of being fighters in Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad, the latest escalation in Israel’s ongoing feud with the Arabic-language broadcaster backed by Qatar.
The Israeli military distributed what it said were documents seized from Gaza that showed membership lists, phone directories and salary slips for members of the Qassam Brigades and the Al-Quds Brigades, the armed wings of the two groups. The lists included names matching those of the Al Jazeera reporters.
Al Jazeera strongly denied the accusations, which it said were based on “fabricated evidence” and followed a long history of Israeli hostility toward the network. The authenticity and accuracy of the documents could not be immediately confirmed.
The accusations against the six journalists were only the latest chapter in Israel’s campaign against Al Jazeera. The organization’s Arabic-language service is widely seen in Israel as being close to Hamas, and critics have accused the network of amplifying the armed group’s perspective.
The channel’s correspondents are also some of the few remaining reporters on the ground in Gaza to document the devastating impact of Israel’s operations there. Israel has largely barred the international press from entering the enclave except on closely monitored tours accompanied by the Israeli military.
In its statement, Al Jazeera called the accusations “a blatant attempt to silence the few remaining journalists in the region, thereby obscuring the harsh realities of the war from audiences worldwide.”
Since the beginning of the war in Gaza, Israel has taken steps to crack down on Al Jazeera, including passing a new security law that it used to shutter many of the network’s operations in the country.
Press freedom advocates have criticized Israel’s measures against the news organization, calling them a serious threat to journalistic independence. They also argue that the law used to curb its activities sets a concerning precedent that could be used to prevent other international media organizations from operating in Israel.
The Committee to Protect Journalists, a press freedom monitor, said in a statement following the latest accusations that Israel had “repeatedly made similar unproven claims without producing credible evidence.”
The journalists named by Israel on Wednesday included Anas al-Sharif and Hossam Shabat, two of the last reporters in northern Gaza, where Israeli forces have launched a renewed military operation in recent days to oust what they call a Hamas insurgency. At least one of the journalists, Mr. Shabat, wrote posts on social media praising Hamas, and uploaded photos of himself wearing the green-and-white scarf of its student movement.
On Wednesday, Mr. Shabat said in a social media post that the Israeli accusations were intended to turn him and his colleagues into “killable targets.”
In late July, Israel killed Ismail al-Ghoul, an Al Jazeera reporter in Gaza, in an airstrike, claiming that he was a member of Hamas’s military wing. Al Jazeera rejected the allegation as “baseless.” A cameraman, Rami al-Rifee, was also killed in the strike; the Israeli military did not accuse him of being a militant.
Two months later, Israeli soldiers raided the channel’s offices in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and ordered them closed for at least 45 days.
Is Afghanistan’s Most-Wanted Militant Now Its Best Hope for Change?
Christina Goldbaum
Christina Goldbaum interviewed Sirajuddin Haqqani and spoke with more than 70 experts, diplomats, Afghan officials, Taliban soldiers and others, and reviewed hundreds of pages of documents, for this story.
For the better part of two decades, one name above all others inspired fear among ordinary Afghans: Sirajuddin Haqqani.
To many, Mr. Haqqani was a boogeyman, an angel of death with the power to determine who would live and who would die during the U.S.-led war. He deployed his ranks of Taliban suicide bombers, who rained carnage on American troops and Afghan civilians alike. A ghostlike kingpin of global jihad, with deep ties to Al Qaeda and other terrorist networks, he topped the United States’ most-wanted list in Afghanistan, with a $10 million bounty on his head.
But since the Americans’ frantic withdrawal in 2021 and the Taliban’s return to power, Mr. Haqqani has portrayed himself as something else altogether: A pragmatic statesman. A reliable diplomat. And a voice of relative moderation in a government steeped in religious extremism.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
What We Learned Talking to the Taliban’s Most Fearsome Leader
For three years, there was one powerful, elusive figure I wanted to speak with in Afghanistan: Sirajuddin Haqqani.
During the U.S.-led war there, he was known as one of the Taliban’s most ruthless military strategists, deploying hundreds of suicide bombers and raining carnage on the capital, Kabul. He developed ties with terrorist groups across the region and built a mafia-like empire of illicit businesses.
After the Taliban regained control of Afghanistan in 2021, Mr. Haqqani became one of the most important figures in the government. But he remained a mystery; he had given only one interview to a Western journalist.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
On the Israel-Lebanon Border, a Town With a Past Worries for Its Future
Once a picturesque Israeli mountain resort with panoramic views into Lebanon, Metula is now off limits to civilians. Under fire for months from Hezbollah’s rockets and missiles, every other house has by now been damaged or lies in ruins. Over the past year of fighting, it has been one of the hardest-hit places in Israel.
More than a century old and a storied symbol of early pioneering Zionism, Metula, a pastoral border community and Israel’s northernmost town, juts upward like a finger into Lebanon, which surrounds it on three sides. The roughly 2,500 residents of Metula were officially evacuated a year ago, for the first time since the establishment of the Israeli state in 1948. Now, even as Israeli ground forces pursue Hezbollah’s fighters in southern Lebanon, Metula’s future is in question.
Thirty percent of the evacuees do not intend to return, whatever the outcome of the war, according to the town’s mayor, David Azulai. Those who have gone for good, he says, include many of the families with young children.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
5 Key Questions Hanging Over the Lucy Letby ‘Killer Nurse’ Case
Here are some of the concerns raised about the case:
- Statistics were misused, many experts say.
- Doubts have emerged over the ‘air embolism’ evidence.
- Insulin poisoning evidence has been questioned by clinical experts.
- Psychologists have questions about a note that was treated as a confession.
- There were longstanding concerns about the neonatal unit.
When Lucy Letby, a former nurse in a neonatal unit at a hospital in northern England, was found guilty last year of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder six others, Britain reacted with horror. She was convicted of attempting to murder another baby in a retrial of one charge earlier this year.
The prosecution told the jury in the two trials that she had harmed babies through a macabre range of attacks: injecting them with air, overfeeding them with milk, infusing air into their gastrointestinal tracts and poisoning them with insulin.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Lucy Letby, Former U.K. Nurse, Loses Bid to Appeal Attempted Murder Conviction
Lucy Letby, a former neonatal nurse who was convicted of the murder of seven babies and the attempted murder of seven others, was refused permission to appeal one of her convictions on Thursday.
The ruling was the latest blow to Ms. Letby’s attempts to appeal her multiple convictions, even as a growing number of statisticians and medical experts have questioned the reliability of the evidence used by the prosecution.
Ms. Letby, 34, who has always maintained her innocence, is serving 15 life sentences after she was found guilty of harming babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital in northern England between 2015 and 2016.
During two trials, the prosecution told the jury that she had harmed babies through a macabre range of attacks: injecting them with air, overfeeding them with milk, infusing air into their gastrointestinal tracts and poisoning them with insulin.
The first trial concluded in August 2023, when Ms Letby was found guilty of seven counts of murder and seven counts of attempted murder, two of which involved one baby. In May, she was denied an attempt to appeal those convictions. She was then convicted of attempting to murder another baby in a retrial of one charge in July this year.
-
On the Upper East Side, Was $800,000 Enough for a Dog-Friendly Two-Bedroom?
-
A Bazaar of Tamales, Arroz con Gandules and Fufu — on Facebook Marketplace
-
6 Takeaways From the Christopher Reeve Documentary ‘Super/Man’
Thursday’s hearing in London focused on that single attempted murder conviction, for a child known as Baby K. Lawyers for Ms. Letby said that the retrial should never have gone ahead because the intense commentary following her earlier convictions meant she could not have a fair trial.
“It’s an exceptional case with exceptional media interest,” said Ben Myers, a lawyer for Ms. Letby. He argued that the “intense hostility and the saturation” of media coverage, including public comments on her guilt from the police, prosecutors and witnesses, had prejudiced her retrial.
But prosecutors countered that Mr. Myers’s approach was misguided and would establish a problematic principle that would allow anyone convicted of a notorious crime to avoid being tried or retried for additional offenses.
Nick Johnson, a lawyer for the prosecution, argued that public comments made by the police after the first trial were accurate. “What was said by the police in the aftermath of the convictions of the first trial was reasonable,” Mr. Johnson said. “It accurately and moderately described the horrendous offenses of which this applicant had been convicted.”
The three judges at the hearing denied Ms. Letby’s bid for a full appeal. Judge William Davis, one of the three, acknowledged that the former nurse’s case “is very well known to most people in the country,” but rejected her lawyer’s argument that she could not have a fair trial.
He reminded those present in the courtroom that Thursday’s hearing had a narrow focus, saying that the other convictions or any public discussion were not relevant to the decision.
Ms. Letby had already been denied appeals in the other seven murder and seven attempted murder counts for which she is serving life sentences. She appeared by video link from the high-security prison where she is being held, wearing a green dress and looking down through much of the hearing as she listened to the legal arguments.
Last month Ms. Letby appointed a new defense lawyer, Mark McDonald, who plans to apply to Britain’s Criminal Cases Review Commission, the official body responsible for investigating alleged miscarriages of justice in the country, and the one remaining way for her other criminal convictions to be revisited.
“I can tell you now, if I was innocent and in prison, I’d rather be in the U.S. than the U.K.,” said Mr. McDonald. “It is so difficult to overturn a conviction in this country, it is almost impossible.”
Mr. McDonald said that in his application to the C.C.R.C. he would focus on the reliability of the evidence presented by the prosecution, rather than claiming that Ms. Letby’s original defense was insufficient, and plans to submit the case within weeks.
England Plans to Ban Disposable Vapes Next Year
Disposable vapes will be banned in England starting in June under a government plan announced on Thursday, a move aimed at protecting young people’s health and reducing waste.
Single-use vapes, which are often sold in brightly colored packaging, have become the “product of choice for the majority of kids vaping today,” Andrew Gwynne, the minister for public health and prevention, said in a government statement.
An estimated five million disposable vapes are discarded each week in Britain, according to the government.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.